[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | On Appeal, Cemex Loses Texas Royalties Battle | 09-04-2011
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
80°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
April 28
1943 - August Rubel, owner of Rancho Camulos, is killed when the ambulance he's driving apparently hits a German land mine in North Africa [story]


A Texas appeals court Thursday said the government is correct: Mexican national cement maker Cemex must pay the Lone Star State its due – potentially half a billion dollars or more – for mining a quarry outside of El Paso.

The appeals panel left it to the trial court to come up with an exact figure, but Texas claims it is owed $558 million in unpaid royalties dating back to the 1940s.

Cemex, which bought the 1,400-acre quarry from a predecessor in 2005, said it “will continue to vigorously defend itself against the state’s claim for royalties.”

(Cemex holds federal permits to mine 56 million tons of sand and gravel in the Soledad Canyon region of the Santa Clarita Valley. Cemex, together with Sen. Barbara Boxer and the cities of Santa Clarita and Victorville, are working on a plan to void the mining permits in exchange for a swap of land and cash. But if the deal falls through and mining commences, Cemex would be required to pay royalties to the federal government, the state of California and other jurisdictions – but not to the city of Santa Clarita, even though the city owns the surface rights to the land.)

The Texas case centers around Cemex’s operations in McKelligon Canyon, in the Franklin Mountains just north of the border city of El Paso.

The state sued the mining company for unlawful land conversion, breach of contract and trespass. In a post-ruling statement Friday, Texas Land Commissioner Jerry Patterson said the state “never authorized Cemex to take its minerals.”

He said after independence from Mexico in 1836, the Texas constitution required vacant land to remain in the public domain, and after Texas joined the Union, surface rights were gradually sold off for ranching and agricultural purposes. But the state “retained all valuable materials on, in and under the state’s lands for the benefit of public education,” he said.

“These Permanent School Fund lands in El Paso’s McKelligon Canyon were sold under the Land Sales Acts of 1895 and 1907, which expressly state all mineral wealth on the land remained property of the school fund,” he said.

He said the Texas School Fund holds about $25 billion in stocks, bonds and real estate investments. Patterson’s office leases surface acreage and charges royalties for exploitation rights to produce oil, gas and other minerals. Earnings fund K-12 education.

Cemex argued that sand and gravel aren’t “minerals” reserved to the state, and moreover, the state never pursued 60 years of past-due royalty payments before Cemex took over operations.

In Thursday’s decision, appellate Justice Guadalupe Rivera opined that under the Texas Mining Act of 1895, “title to all deposits of granite, limestone, gravel, sand and any other mineral substances of whatever kind or character having commercial value located on the McKelligon Canyon lands … are reserved to the State of Texas.”

The appeals court determined that the trial court erred because it “improperly relied upon attorney general opinions interpreting statutes inapplicable to these properties (and) ignore(d) the reservation of minerals and materials to the state” under the 1895 mining law. No public official – not even the state’s attorney general – can give away state property, the justices added.

“Cemex does not own the minerals and building materials at issue,” the court concluded.

“The gist of this case is simple,” said Patterson. “You just can’t take what’s not yours without a fight in Texas.”

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
Loading...
Related Content
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Friday, Apr 28, 2017
Four Men Arrested in Underage Internet Operation in SCV
Detectives from the Los Angeles Regional Human Trafficking Taskforce arrested four individuals after conducting an undercover internet operation at a hotel in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Friday, Apr 28, 2017
Friday, Apr 28, 2017
SCV Sheriff’s Station Volunteers Thanked at Special Dinner
On Thursday evening, the SCV Sheriff's Foundation hosted a dinner for the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station Volunteers at the Child & Family Center.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Detectives from the Los Angeles Regional Human Trafficking Taskforce arrested four individuals after conducting an undercover internet operation at a hotel in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Four Men Arrested in Underage Internet Operation in SCV
Councilmember Bob Kellar was honored at the Los Angles Police Reserve Foundation on Saturday April 22, recognized 25 Reserves of the Year at their sold out gala at the Skirball Cultural Center in Los Angeles.
Kellar Honored at LAPD Reserve Foundation Gala
The one-man show Rodney King, written and performed by actor and former CalArts School of Theater faculty Roger Guenveur Smith and directed by Spike Lee, premieres on Netflix.
CalArts Faculty Member Starring in One Man Show on Netflix
On Thursday evening, the SCV Sheriff's Foundation hosted a dinner for the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station Volunteers at the Child & Family Center.
SCV Sheriff’s Station Volunteers Thanked at Special Dinner
Those ads promising seniors discounted auto insurance rates, no matter their driving record, may prove to be an auto insurance scam.
Fraud Friday:  ‘Cheap’ Auto Insurance Could Cost You Thousands
Agenda for the City Council Joint Study Session on May 3, 2017 5/3/2017 5:30 p.m. in the Century Room.
May 3: City Council Joint Study Session Agenda
Vendors specializing in areas such as printing, promotional, construction, engineering consulting and janitorial supplies, are invited to come meet various city department representatives and local public agencies.
May 16: Local Businesses Invited to City’s Vendor Outreach Event
On Thursday, May 4 at 7 p.m., The Main in Newhall is hosting the 10 by 10 Variety show. The show will have 10 different artists and entertainers perform for 10 minutes each.
May 4: The MAIN Hosts the ’10 by 10′ Variety Show
Agenda for the Parks, Recreation, and Community Services Commission Regular Meeting on May 4 at 6:00 p.m. in City Council Chambers.
May 4: Parks, Recreation, and Community Services Commission Meeting
The Planning Commission Regular Meeting scheduled for May 2, 2017 has been cancelled, as announced by the city of Santa Clarita.
Planning Commission Regular Meeting for May 2 Cancelled
Bank of Santa Clarita (BSCA) announced that it again has achieved a record level of earnings during the first quarter of 2017.
Bank of Santa Clarita Posts Record Profits
Duke Realty, an Indianapolis-based commercial real estate developer, announced that it will break ground early this summer on a two-story, 37,000-square-foot, off-campus medical office building (MOB) on 3.85 acres on the south side of Soledad Canyon Road in the Canyon Country neighborhood of Santa Clarita, which is about 33 miles northwest of Los Angeles.
CC Facey to Move Into New Building
Prices throughout Santa Clarita prices appear to have hit a plateau and remain below record highs by double-digit numbers: the March single-family home median price was 16.8 percent below the record high of $643,000, set in April 2006; and the March condominium median came in 13.1 percent below the record of $397,000, which was set in January 2006.
Median Price of Single-Family Homes Remain Below Record Highs
Homicide detectives and Los Angeles County Department of Medical Examiner-Coroner personnel have concluded a search for additional human remains and recovery efforts near Templin Highway and Old Ridge Route in unincorporated Lake Hughes.
Update: Adult Skull, Teeth Recovered in Lake Hughes
Every kid should have the chance to play. That’s the philosophy behind a brand new inclusive playground making its debut on Friday at Valley View Community School, which for the past 12 years has served the most medically fragile students in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Valley View Elementary Debuts Inclusive Playground
1943 - August Rubel, owner of Rancho Camulos, is killed when the ambulance he's driving apparently hits a German land mine in North Africa [story]
Los Angeles County Sheriff's Homicide detectives are investigating the discovery of possible human remains found at Templin Highway and Old Ridge Route, in unincorporated Lake Hughes.
Detectives Investigating Possible Human Remains in Lake Hughes
After two years of being held to strict drought-inspired conservation laws, California’s over 400 water suppliers are free to sell as much water as their customers will buy.
California Lifts Drought Restrictions on Water Suppliers
Historian and author Robin D.G. Kelley will speak to California State University, Northridge students, faculty and the community about ethnic studies’ origins, at 2 p.m. on Monday, May 1, in the University Student Union’s Lake View Terrace Room.
Historian to Explore Ethnic Studies’ Roots in CSUN Lecture
Valencia High School’s Vocal Jazz Program, which features the group Two N’ Four, has been named the No. 1 Vocal Jazz Program in the nation by Downbeat Magazine.
Valencia HS Vocal Jazz Named Number One in Nation by Downbeat
LA artist Sart is bringing his gallery, "Climate Change," to The MAIN gallery space from May 1 to 31.
May 1-31: The MAIN Gallery Space Showcasing ‘Climate Change’ Exhibit
The Senate Committee on Governance and Finance approved Senate Bill 792, authored by Senator Scott Wilk, R-Antelope Valley, in a 7-0 vote.
Measure B Oversight Legislation Clears Another Hurdle in Sacramento
The Senate Committee on Governance and Finance approved Senate Bill 634, authored by Senator Scott Wilk, R-Antelope Valley, in a 6-0 vote.
New SCV Water District Legislation Moves Forward
Triumph Foundation, a nonprofit organization working to improve the lives of people living with disabilities, will host its 6th Annual Wheelchair Sports Festival on Saturday, April 29, 2017 and Sunday, April 30, 2017 at the Santa Clarita Sports Complex, featuring ten adaptive recreational sports that are open to the general public to participate.
Push the Limits of Your Ability at the Wheelchair Sports Festival
Flair Cleaners, Southern California’s leading eco-friendly dry cleaners, will host the second annual Flair Cares Spring Food Drive, May 1 through 31, at its Valencia location, 27011 McBean Parkway, benefitting the Santa Clarita Valley Food Pantry.
‘Flair Cares’ Spring Food Drive Benefitting SCV Food Pantry
Caltrans commemorated the passing of three more of its employees today during its 27th Annual Workers Memorial at the State Capitol.
Caltrans Memorial Honors 187 Fallen Highway Workers
Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital's Volunteer Service Department is hosting a Bear Collection Day on Saturday April 29 from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., where community members are invited to help bring comfort to a sick or injured child by donating a brand new nine to 12 inch teddy bear of stuffed animal friend.
April 29: Henry Mayo Collecting Teddy Bears for Children in ER
The Michael Hoefflin Foundation for Children's Cancer 'Evening Under the Stars' is back this year on September 16 at Mann Biomedical Park.
Sept. 16: 24th Annual ‘Evening Under the Stars’
California’s state auditor on Tuesday slammed University of California President Janet Napolitano, finding her office has $175 million in reserves they failed to disclose to stakeholders – and obstructed the audit besides.
University of California President Slammed for Hoarding Money
Deputies arrested a burglary suspect Wednesday in downtown Newhall after deputies talked him down from a rooftop.
Newhall Burglary Suspect Arrested After Standoff
The Castaic Lake Water Agency Water Resources Committee is scheduled to meet on Thursday, May 4 at 5:30 p.m. at the Santa Clarita Water Division.
May 4: CLWA Water Resources Committee Meeting
For decades, the search for life on other planets has captivated the imaginations of writers, filmmakers, artists, and scientists.
May 5: COC Canyon Country Campus to Hold Star Party
The Castaic Lake Water Agency Planning and Engineering Committee is scheduled to meet on Tuesday, May 2 at 5:30 p.m. in the Training Room at the Rio Vista Water Treatment Plant.
May 2: CLWA Planning & Engineering Committee Meeting
Crane flies look like giant, fragile, super-huge mosquitos with balance problems. Right now you see them everywhere during the day and in the evening, especially around your porch lights. I even had one go inside my dryer, presumably attracted by the light. I left the door open, and it left again with a goofy flight, bouncing left and right.
Harmless Drunk Flyers | Commentary by Evelyne Vandersande
1971 - Tejon Ranch Co. torches the run-down Hotel Lebec [story]