[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Man On a Mission: Soldier’s ‘Avoidable’ Death Spurs Gold Star Dad to Action | 12-07-2011
Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
November 28
1950 - CalArts grad Ed Harris ("A Beautiful Mind," "Apollo 13," "The Abyss") born in New Jersey [timeline]

Rudy Acosta was a Santa Clarita boy through and through. Born at Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital, he attended Santa Clarita Christian School and enlisted in the Army as a medic. He wanted to save lives and become a surgeon.

He shipped off to Afghanistan in the summer of 2010. When he came back home for a visit in January, he came back a man.

Two months later he was dead.

He didn’t step on a land mine. He didn’t get shot by a sniper. He didn’t fall in a firefight.

Rudy and his fellow soldiers were back at their base – safely, by all rights, inside the wire. They were preparing for a mission, cleaning their guns, when an Afghan insurgent masquerading as a protector opened fire on the troops he was hired to guard.

Rudy may have saved one last life as he fell. Reports suggest he may have stepped into a bullet intended for another solider – a woman who credits Rudy for the fact that she is alive today to raise her own family.

Dante Acosta is a man on a mission.

Santa Clarita’s newest Gold Star father has a message for military leaders:

Stop hiring independent contractors for U.S. force protection. Don’t entrust soldiers’ lives to private security firms that hire native residents in an active war zone. Don’t hand an AK-47 to someone who hasn’t been properly vetted.

As it turns out, the Afghan infiltrator had been hired just 10 days earlier and was a security team leader, Dante Acosta said.

Dante Acosta discusses his son's death on "SCV Newsmaker of the Week"

“This was totally avoidable,” Dante said in an “SCV Newsmaker of the Week” interview Tuesday on SCVTV.

While Dante’s message might sound simple and even sensible, his quest for action hasn’t been nearly so simple. Not during troop reductions. Not when the military is shaving $465 billion from its budget over the next 10 years. Not when a congressional supercommittee can’t come to terms and stave off further cuts that could render the U.S. incapable of operating simultaneously in two theaters.

Much has changed in the seven decades since Pearl Harbor. Even in Korea and Vietnam, Navy Seabees cleared most of the airstrips and the Army Corps of Engineers built the bridges and paved the highways. Today, more and more of the functions once performed exclusively by members of the U.S. armed forces are farmed out to private contractors.

Usually that’s because it is more cost-effective to hire contractors. In Afghanistan the situation is more complex. It’s a NATO command, and cost containment isn’t supposed to be the overriding factor in Afghanistan. Instead, U.S. and international forces are supposed to be training Afghans to take over more of the peacekeeping responsibilities.

For Rudy Acosta, the reason for farming out force protection didn’t matter.

Dante Acosta thinks it is worth neither the risk nor the cost.

“We’re penny wise and pound foolish,” he said, letting his experience as a senior financial advisor with UnionBanc Investment Services kick in. Pennies saved on force protection are outnumbered by the dollars lost with the death not only of two trained soldiers – Rudy, 19, and Cpl. Donald R. Mickler Jr., 29, of Ohio – but of two people who would have gone on to become productive, tax-paying members of society.

Dante has taken his message to the chairman of the House Armed Services Committee – his own Santa Clarita congressman, Buck McKeon.

McKeon invited Dante to testify in Washington about native security forces in Afghanistan. Dante came away feeling unfulfilled. He said the discussion centered on the Afghan National Army and Afghan border police – “which are not the same thing. Those are actually Afghan governmental agencies.”

Rudy’s case involves “civilians hired by an Afghan subsidiary of a Canadian firm (that) hires local Afghans to guard our soldiers,” Dante said. “I haven’t been successful in having a hearing specifically about this issue.”

At the Sept. 22 hearing, McKeon formally submitted 10 questions on behalf of Dante and his wife, Carolyn Acosta, to Defense Undersecretary Michele Flournoy.

Answers were supposed to come in 60 days. The deadline passed two weeks ago. McKeon – and the Acosta family – still await a formal Defense Department reply to the questions, which appear below.

Also awaited are the results of an investigation McKeon requested March 28, 2011, nine days after Rudy’s death.

McKeon wrote to then-NATO ISAF Commander Gen. David Petraeus seeking his “personal assurances that your command will spare no effort to determine the root causes for this and other similar attacks by Afghans employed by the U.S. directly or hired by U.S. funded contractors.”

Also March 28, McKeon wrote to Army Secretary John McHugh, asking him to assess whether U.S. troops were adequately prepared to “detect and possibly prevent attacks by host nation personnel hired by the U.S. Army in support of counterinsurgency operations.”

And in a same-day letter to then-Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates, McKeon requested “a review to ensure that the Department of Defense and all the combatant commands have in place processes and procedures to assess the reliability of host nation personnel … who are contracted, utilized or employed by U.S. military forces.”

Army Spc. Rudy Acosta

“As Dante and Rudy Acosta’s representative,” McKeon told SCVTV in a statement, “it is my duty to make sure that the issues and concerns of my constituents are echoed in Washington.

“As Chairman of the Armed Services Committee, there is no matter I take more seriously than the safety of our service men and women.  There is no greater loss than the loss of a soldier, and as a father I can only imagine the grief that their loved ones bear.

“I share Mr. Acosta’s concerns to ensure the safety of our nation’s sons and daughters who bravely and selflessly answer their country’s call to duty.  I look forward to Mr. Acosta’s continued partnership in our pursuit to best serve the troops who serve our great country.”

Dante Acosta knows it takes time and tenacity to effect change, and he’s determined to commit both to his cause.

“I don’t know that I can rest knowing that we have soldiers over there still in theater (who are) not allowed to protect themselves,” he said. “They’re asked to stand by while there are 90 or so Afghans with AK-47s on our posts, on our bases, and they’re tasked with guarding our troops – to sometimes tragic results.”

“When we had bad body armor going over there, that got changed because the public demanded it,” Dante said. “When the public demands no more foreign nationals guarding our troops as they sleep and eat on their bases, then it will change.”


Dante Acota’s “SCV Newsmaker of the Week” appearance will be televised Thursday, Dec. 8, at 9 p.m. and Sunday, Dec. 11, at 8:30 a.m. on SCVTV (Time Warner Cable Channel 20, AT&T U-verse Channel 99, SCVTV.com live stream, with an archived copy on demand at SCVNewsmaker.com).


Questions submitted Sept. 22, 2011, by U.S. Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon on behalf of Dante and Carolyn Acosta to Michele Flournoy, Under Secretary of Defense for Policy:

1. Why do we trust non Americans to guard our troops in a war zone?

2. What are the other options to having contractors like Tundra Security assigned to protecting our troops in wartime and in foreign lands?

3. Who is directly responsible for approving these contracts and implementing this policy?

4. What ties to any US government or foreign governments does Tundra have?

5. What criteria must be met by a contractor to be awarded a contract such as this?

6. Now or in the past have former employees ever worked for any agency of the US Government?

7. Why are these guards allowed on base with loaded weapons?

8. Where is the threat to them or the convoys they escort on the base?

9. What kind of supervision are these guards under?

10. How are the guards trained and who trains them?


Army Spc. Rudy Acosta in Afghanistan

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

Comments are closed.

SCV NewsBreak
Related Content
Saturday, Nov 28, 2015
Memorial Service Scheduled For SCV Leader Duane Harte
The memorial service date has been announced for the longtime Santa Clarita resident and leader, Duane Harte, who Nov. 23 at the age of 68.
Thursday, Nov 26, 2015
Update: Victims of Single-Vehicle Crash Near Agua Dulce ID’d
Emergency officials responded to a fatal single-vehicle traffic collision near Agua Dulce on Thursday morning.
Wednesday, Nov 25, 2015
Family, Santa Clarita Community Mourn Duane Harte
Duane Harte, longtime Santa Clarita community activist and noted volunteer, died early Monday in Valencia from a massive heart attack. He was 68.
Follow Us @scvtv20

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Prayer Angels for the Military and the Valencia Library hosted a care package creation event, to send much needed supplies to people in service overseas.
Volunteers Make Care Packages For SCV Nonprofit
The memorial service date has been announced for the longtime Santa Clarita resident and leader, Duane Harte, who Nov. 23 at the age of 68.
Memorial Service Scheduled For SCV Leader Duane Harte
1950 - CalArts grad Ed Harris ("A Beautiful Mind," "Apollo 13," "The Abyss") born in New Jersey [timeline]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, an elderly couple that was killed in a fiery crash has been identified. Plus, two Hart District schools won coveted marching band titles. Click the link to see those stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, November 27, 2015
Two marching bands from the William S. Hart Union High School District won state titles at the Southern California School Band and Orchestra Association Championship.
Hart Marching Bands Win State Championship Titles
1941 - Funeral for "our" Remi Nadeau, whose Canyon Country deer park became North Oaks [story]
Emergency officials responded to a fatal single-vehicle traffic collision near Agua Dulce on Thursday morning.
Update: Victims of Single-Vehicle Crash Near Agua Dulce ID’d
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, locals are lining up to get a head start on Black Friday shopping. Plus, find out how residents spent the morning outside to continue a Thanksgiving tradition. Click the link to see those stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, November 26, 2015
Deputy Bertola and Princess Cruises were both recognized during Tuesday's city council meeting.
Local Business, Deputy Honored at City Council
Last year while driving around, I noticed an unusual plant growing on the roadsides in Acton. It looked just like hops. I asked people what this plant might be. It was stunning and seemed to be a member of the chaparral group. But no one was able to answer my question.
Four-winged Salt Bush
1916 - A score of Wobblies bust up Newhall Jail after commandeering SP freight train [story]
Duane Harte, longtime Santa Clarita community activist and noted volunteer, died early Monday in Valencia from a massive heart attack. He was 68.
Family, Santa Clarita Community Mourn Duane Harte
When Nola Aronson of Advanced Audiology tells people she has a unique answer for hearing loss, she means it.
SCV Audiologist Presenting a ‘Unique’ Solution for Hearing Loss
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Vasquez Canyon Road acquired a permanent fence, but it isn't exactly keeping people out. Plus, a hot prowl break in occurred in Canyon Country last week. Click the link to see those stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, November 25, 2015
Legacy Christian Academy was honored by state and national representatives as the only Los Angeles County private school to be named a National Blue Ribbon School Award recipient.
Legacy Christian Recipient of  Blue Ribbon School Award
A total of 205 single-family homes and 93 condominiums changed owners during October throughout the Santa Clarita Valley, the Southland Regional Association of Realtors reported today.
SCV October Home Sales Up 7% as Seasonal Trends Appear
The California Department of Transportation will close the north and southbound 101 off-ramps at Cahuenga Boulevard, Sunday, Nov. 29, from 3 p.m. to 10 p.m. for an event.
101 to be Closed Sunday Afternoon for Event
The Santa Clarita City Council unanimously voted to establish the speed limit along the recently opened Golden Valley Road extension at its meeting on Tuesday night.
City Council Votes for 50 MPH Speed Limit for Golden Valley Extension
Two California Highway Patrol officers suffered minor injuries Wednesday when their patrol vehicle was struck by another vehicle that lost control on the I-5 south just north of Balboa Boulevard.
Car Crashes into CHP Officers on I-5 Near Balboa
Every Christmas season, Triumph goes to hospitals all over Southern California to visit people who've recently become paralyzed to deliver care baskets full of resources, have a party and bring a message of hope.
Triumph Foundation Seeks Volunteers for Care Basket Delivery