[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Mountain Bikers, Naturalists at Odds Over Forest Lands | 06-07-2012
Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
August 19
1879 - Newhall civic leader Charles Henry Kingsburry born in Missouri [story]

Read an update to this story here => http://scvnews.com/?p=32325


One man’s wilderness is another man’s playground.

Thus begins the battle for the future of some of Southern California’s last remaining roadless natural areas.

Local residents have until Monday, June 11, to tell the Forest Service whether mountain bikes and other non-motorized vehicles – and for that matter, motorized vehicles – should be formally banned from a canyon north of Castaic Lake and other federal lands in Southern California.

It’s the latest development in a legal feud between the state and federal governments that dates back several years.

– – –

On Feb. 28, 2008, California Resources Sec. Mike Chrisman and then-Attorney Gen. Edmund G. “Jerry” Brown Jr. filed a complaint in federal court, accusing the U.S. Forest Service of disregardingCalifornia’s land management plans for the Angeles, Cleveland, Los Padres and San Bernardino National Forests and thus putting these areas at increased risk.

“Time and again we have tried to hold the Forest Service to their word on the roadless policy. Time and again they have failed to live up to their promises,” Chrisman said at the time. “Following months of trying to work with them and establish what we believe to be reasonable management plans for Southern California’s forests, we were afforded no alternative but to file suit.”

“Plaintiffs alleged violations of several federal laws including the National Forest Management Act, National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and Administrative Procedure Act,” said Justin Seastrand, environmental coordinator for the Angeles National Forest.

The lawsuit followed nearly three years of ill-feeling between the Forest Service and California’s environmental groups and elected officials.

In January 2005, the California Resources Agency wrote a letter to Jack A. Blackwell, regional U.S. Forester, noting that the Forest Service’s interim directive regarding the inventoried roadless areas (IRAs) would expire the following year. The state asked the feds to reevaluate its land management plans, specifically requesting that the Forest Service update its area maps to reflect the true condition of the IRAs, allow access to native American tribes en route to sacred sites within the forests, provide appropriate access to fire fighting crews, and reexamine whether the roads in those areas should be decommissioned or further maintained.

Chrisman’s letter stated, “We believe that California’s best interests are served when truly roadless areas remain roadless. However, unlike wilderness areas, a multitude of activities are allowed in roadless areas so long as new roads are not created for such activities.”

Blackwell’s response was encouraging. He agreed with all of Chrisman’s propositions, and in 2006 the Forest Service withdrew its original land management plans for the four Southland forests.

However, in a letter of March 15, 2006, to Bernard Weingardt, the Pacific Southwest Region’s forester, Chrisman had to reiterate his request to address the designations in the four forests.

At stake was a combined managed area of more than 4 million acres of Southern California forest, hundreds of thousands of which the state and the environmental groups fought to keep pristine. That is a big bounty for anyone.

So they launched a legal war.

Then-Gov. Schwarzenegger wrote to U.S. Agriculture Sec. Mike Johanns, saying he wished Johanns would realize California wasn’t about to give up the fight for its wilderness areas.

“Frankly, it is not too much to ask the Forest Service to do the right thing and live up to its own assurances,” Schwarzenegger’s letter stated.

The response from the Forest Service was cordial but vague. While the feds pledged their commitment to the “4.4 million acres of inventoried roadless areas in the state of California,” they also stopped short of committing to their complete protection.

“I believe the best way to resolve concerns over the protection of California’s inventoried roadless area is through cooperatively developed state-specific rule making,” Johann wrote. However, he said he believed the department’s 2005 rule was “properly promulgated” and would “assure conservation and management of inventoried roadless areas.”

“Accordingly,” Johann wrote, “we are pursuing an appeal to the ruling of the District Court.”

So it snowballed.

Between the 2008 court filing and 2011 when the settlement was finalized, the various litigants were fighting tooth and nail for what they thought the people wanted: On one hand, the 4×4, OHV and mountain biking communities argued that the national forests were created for multiple uses, ergo they had just as much right to be on the trails as the “foot people.” On the other side were the hikers, naturalists and conservationists pursuing an age-old goal: keep nature natural.

– – –

“Wilderness has to be land that is exceptional and not trammeled by man,” says Dianne Erskine-Hellrigel, executive director and president of Santa Clarita’s Community Hiking Club. “In other words, if man has left scars behind, it is most probably not suitable.”

“I hike because I enjoy the solitude,” she said. “This is why I appreciate wilderness. These areas that are recommended for wilderness provide that peace that I seek. Wilderness also brings us better quality water and air.”

The mountain biking community couldn’t agree more. Their issue is not with the existing  – and arguably plentiful – wilderness areas of the Southland, which they enjoy as much as the hikers or equestrians do, but rather with the reasoning behind the restrictions of the new land management plan.

“I’m not in favor of the federal policy of prohibiting all mountain biking in all federal wilderness areas,” said Santa Clarita resident Ed Pongracz. “These are public lands, and I and my fellow mountain bikers have as much right to explore these lands on my non-motorized bicycle as does someone else with their horse or hiking boots and trekking poles.”

“Studies show that the impacts from mountain biking are similar to hiking,” Pongracz said. “Both are much less severe than the impact on the trails by equestrians.”

There is also Mother Nature to consider. In a recent KCET interview, biologist Ileene Anderson of the Tucson-based Center for Biological Diversity – one of the parties to the original lawsuit – said the connection between roadless areas and non-threatening habitats of endangered species is obvious. She cited the classic example of the arroyo toad, whose riparian habitat is all but gone due to unrelenting development.

Erskine-Hellrigel agrees.

“Southern California chaparral is the fastest disappearing habitat in California. If we continue to let it slip away to developments, there will be nothing left. We have protected very little of this habitat, as can be seen by bear, cougar and other animals wandering into populated neighborhoods in search of food and water.

“We need the animal corridors open to guarantee them safe passage,” Erskine-Hellrigel said. “I see roadkill on a daily basis in our area, including a bear and a cougar over the last few years. If we keep this frantic pace of development, we won’t have any chaparral, nor will we have any animals to live in it. There are a lot of endangered species and rare species in these IRAs, which is reason enough to protect them.”

– – –

One of the requirements of the 2011 settlement agreement was for the Forest Service to prepare a supplemental environmental impact statement (EIS) for an amendment to the land management plans for the Angeles, Cleveland, Los Padres, and San Bernardino forests.

“The Forest Service proposes to amend the land management plans to change land use zone allocations within select inventoried roadless areas in the four Southern California National Forests,” according to its April 27 notice of intent. “The amendment also proposes to change the land management plan monitoring protocols for the four forests. This joint planning process will maintain the consistent management direction and format across the four forests. One supplemental environmental impact statement will be prepared with a Record of Decision for each land management plan.”

To help make sense of the cumbersome process and give communities a chance to weigh in, the Forest Service is conducting a series of public meetings in the ranger districts of the four national forests.

“Thus far, the Angeles National Forest has participated with the other three Southern California forests in complying with the settlement agreement,” said Seastrand. “We have assigned staff like myself to be on the interdisciplinary team.

“We have completed one key portion of the agreement by participating in a collaborative process to prioritize decommissioning of roads and trails within roadless areas,” he said. “We have reviewed the zoning of our roadless areas and defined the proposed action for the Angeles.”

Seastrand said his agency is in the scoping phase of the environmental process – defining possible alternatives to banning roads, studying the environmental effects of the ban and inviting public comment.

– – –

Within the Angeles, a bundle of hills and valleys northeast of Castaic Lake are to be combined into the recommended 40,000-acre Fish Canyon wilderness area.

“Our proposed action for the Fish Canyon and Salt Creek roadless areas, as well as a small piece of land between them, is to zone them as ‘recommended wilderness,’” Seastrand said, “and manage them according to that designation if it is adopted.”

And this is where the communities around the proposed wilderness re-zoning areas come into play: All interested environmental and recreational groups and individuals are invited to share their views on the amendments.

The public comments period closes Monday, June 11 – and every opinion counts.

“The information gathered through public scoping is used to define these alternatives based on issues the public identifies,” Seastrand said. “The legal requirement is that we provide a “reasonable range” of alternatives.

“You can think of it this way: We are required to think about and involve the public in coming up with different ways to meet the same objective, more specifically, ways that may create less impact on the environment.”

Written comments may be emailed to socal_nf_lmp_amendment@fs.fed.us or sent to: Cleveland National Forest, 10845 Rancho Bernardo Road Ste. 200, San Diego, CA 92127-2107, ATTN: LMP Amendment.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


  1. Bicycles should not be allowed in any natural area. They are inanimate objects and have no rights. There is also no right to mountain bike. That was settled in federal court in 1994: http://mjvande.nfshost.com/mtb10.htm . It’s dishonest of mountain bikers to say that they don’t have access to trails closed to bikes. They have EXACTLY the same access as everyone else — ON FOOT! Why isn’t that good enough for mountain bikers? They are all capable of walking….

    A favorite myth of mountain bikers is that mountain biking is no more harmful to wildlife, people, and the environment than hiking, and that science supports that view. Of course, it’s not true. To settle the matter once and for all, I read all of the research they cited, and wrote a review of the research on mountain biking impacts (see http://mjvande.nfshost.com/scb7.htm ). I found that of the seven studies they cited, (1) all were written by mountain bikers, and (2) in every case, the authors misinterpreted their own data, in order to come to the conclusion that they favored. They also studiously avoided mentioning another scientific study (Wisdom et al) which did not favor mountain biking, and came to the opposite conclusions.

    Those were all experimental studies. Two other studies (by White et al and by Jeff Marion) used a survey design, which is inherently incapable of answering that question (comparing hiking with mountain biking). I only mention them because mountain bikers often cite them, but scientifically, they are worthless.

    Mountain biking accelerates erosion, creates V-shaped ruts, kills small animals and plants on and next to the trail, drives wildlife and other trail users out of the area, and, worst of all, teaches kids that the rough treatment of nature is okay (it’s NOT!). What’s good about THAT?

    For more information: http://mjvande.nfshost.com/mtbfaq.htm .

  2. Truth-speaker says:

    Mike Vandeman is a convicted criminal who has repeatedly assaulted other people on trails.

    Mike is currently banned from trails in his community by a court order, as a direct result of his criminal actions.

Leave a Comment

SCV NewsBreak
Related Content
Friday, Aug 18, 2017
Environmental Groups File Complaint Against Newhall Ranch Water Plan
Two local environmental groups filed a complaint in L.A. Superior Court Thursday regarding the approved plan to provide water to the Newhall Ranch development, set to break ground in 2018.
Friday, Aug 18, 2017
SCV Sheriff’s Station Student Worker, LASD Dad Top Mt. Whitney
Ashley Olivier, a student worker at the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station, summited Mt. Whitney with her dad, a lieutenant at LASD's Monterey Park station.
Friday, Aug 18, 2017
New Report Details Rail Role in State Economy
Caltrans has released "Rail and the California Economy," a research report investigating how the state’s vast passenger and freight rail system contribute to California’s economy, as well as an overview of opportunities for rail to address the state’s needs and challenges in the future.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1879 - Newhall civic leader Charles Henry Kingsburry born in Missouri [story]
40 oz. to Freedom arrives in Santa Clarita as part of its anniversary tour at Concerts in the Park at Central Park on Saturday, August 19, with showtime at 7 p.m.
August 19: 40 Oz. to Freedom Rocks Central Park
Two local environmental groups filed a complaint in L.A. Superior Court Thursday regarding the approved plan to provide water to the Newhall Ranch development, set to break ground in 2018.
Environmental Groups File Complaint Against Newhall Ranch Water Plan
County Supervisor Kathryn Barger has provided $143,000 in funding to extend the season of youth and adult swim programs offered at the Castaic Aquatic Center through October 31.
Castaic Aquatic Center Programs Extended to October 31
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Los Angeles County firefighters and government leaders welcomed back the Super Scoopers Friday morning. Plus, the Old Town Newhall Library helped get the community ready for it as well by handing out free eclipse viewing glasses. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, August 18, 2017
CalArts alumna Audrey Chan (Art MFA 07) will host a free, all-ages interactive arts workshop in Little Tokyo on Saturday and Sunday, August 19 and 20, as part of the Japanese American Cultural & Community Center’s 2017 Nisei Week activities.
August 19-20: Nisei Week Arts Workshop with CalArts Alum Audrey Chan
Western singer and songwriter John Zipperer headlines the next episode of "SCVTV Presents The OutWest Concert Series" at The MAIN in Old Town Newhall the evening of Friday, August 25.
August 25: John Zipperer Toplines ‘SCVTV Presents The OutWest Concert Series’
Habitat for Humanity SFV/SCV is honored to have received a $25,000 grant from the Disabled Veterans National Foundation, which will fund trauma workshops.
Habitat for Humanity Receives $25K Grant from Disabled Veterans
Here are agenda highlights for the next meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, set for Tuesday, August 22, starting at 9:30 a.m..
August 22: Board of Supervisors Meeting Agenda
Ashley Olivier, a student worker at the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station, summited Mt. Whitney with her dad, a lieutenant at LASD's Monterey Park station.
SCV Sheriff’s Station Student Worker, LASD Dad Top Mt. Whitney
Looking to enter the win column for the first time in 2017 on day two of the Summer Slam volleyball tournament, the TMU Mustangs squared off against 11th-ranked Eastern Oregon but lost in straight sets.
Mountaineers Spike Mustangs at Summer Slam
Caltrans has released "Rail and the California Economy," a research report investigating how the state’s vast passenger and freight rail system contribute to California’s economy, as well as an overview of opportunities for rail to address the state’s needs and challenges in the future.
New Report Details Rail Role in State Economy
The Master’s University women’s soccer team soared to a 7-0 victory over the visiting Eagles from Sierra Nevada College Thursday.
Lady Mustangs Soccer Win Opener 7-0
The Master’s University women's volleyball team concluded their first day of HIU Summer Slam tournament play with a five-set thriller against the Southern Oregon University Raiders on Wednesday evening, dropping the fifth set 15-9.
Lady Mustangs Fall in 5 to Raiders at HIU
A federal judge on Wednesday ruled against claims by a state workers’ union that California’s pension system unfairly changed the terms of a pre-existing collective bargaining agreement.
Court Upholds Increase in CalPERS Retirement Age
Friday's alert from the South Coast Air Quality Management District that air quality will be unhealthy for sensitive individuals in the Santa Clarita Valley has been extended through Saturday.
Updated: SCV Air Quality Unhealthy Saturday
Four annual crime reports, which provide law enforcement agencies and the public with statewide data on crime statistics, were released Friday by California's Attorney General.
AG Releases 4 California Crime Reports for 2016
The Master’s University women’s volleyball team lost their 2017 season opener Wednesday at the HIU Summer Slam in straight sets against the Warriors from national powerhouse Corban University (OR).
Warriors Drop TMU Lady Mustangs in Straight Sets
Here's the Castaic/Val Verde (Zone 2) Crime Information and Public Safety Report from the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station for the week of August 7 to August 13.
Crime Blotter: Assault, Theft in Castaic-Val Verde
Two Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station employees will be recognized at the City Council meeting to be held on August 22 at 6 p.m.
City Council to Honor 2 SCV Sheriff’s Station Employees
The Santa Clarita Public Library invites residents to celebrate the upcoming total solar eclipse on Monday, August 21 with two free events at the Old Town Newhall Library.
August 18 & 21: Solar Eclipse Events at Newhall Library
The city of Santa Clarita’s Youth Sports program has seen measured success thus far in 2017.
Santa Clarita Youth Sports Sees Spike in Participation
The Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center’s new building campaign now only has $1.3 million remaining to raise before groundbreaking on the site can begin.
New SCV Senior Center Needs $1.3M to Break Ground
Sacramento County sued the California Department of Water Resources on Thursday over DWR's certification of the California 'WaterFix' delta tunnels project’s “dizzying” and “shifting” environmental review.
Sacramento County Sues to Freeze California ‘WaterFix’
1946 - Pioneering Placerita Canyon movie producer Trem Carr dies in San Diego [story]
' style=
The storewide remodel of the Walmart Supercenter at 26471 Carl Boyer Drive is complete and, in addition to the many physical changes inside, Santa Clarita residents now have access to Online Grocery Pickup.
Walmart on Carl Boyer Drive Celebrates Grand Reopening Friday
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, two people have been hospitalized after a major collision. Plus, an acquisition of land near the 14. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday August 17, 2017
Le Chene French Cuisine, a long-time Santa Clarita local favorite restaurant along Sierra Highway, has announced that they will be hosting a thrilling Murder Mystery Dinner on Saturday, November 4th, 2017.
Nov. 4: Le Chene Murder Mystery Dinner
Senator Scott Wilk, R- Antelope Valley, today announces that he is one of the 2017 inductees into the Antelope Valley High School Alumni Hall of Fame.
Sept. 22: Wilk to be Inducted into AV High School Hall of Fame
Signups are under way for the Santa Clarita Walk to End Alzheimer’s, which offers participants an opportunity to take a healthy stroll, experience outstanding live entertainment, honor loved ones who have been affected by Alzheimer’s and raise funds to battle the debilitating disease.
Oct. 7: Walk to End Alzheimer’s; Signups Under Way
Trammell Crow Company (TCC) andand Clarion Partners are pleased to announce the acquisition of 54 acres of land for the development of The Center at Needham Ranch, a state-of-the-art business park in the city of Santa Clarita, CA.
TCC, Clarion Partners Acquire More Than 50 Acres of SCV Real Estate
The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration is hosting what will be a highly educational and informative (and free) Tax Seminar for Nonprofits and Exempt Organizations.
Sept. 6: Tax Seminar for Non-Profits and Exempt Organizations
For the first time in 99 years, a total eclipse of the sun will pass over the continental United States on August 21, and Princess Cruises guests sailing on six cruise ships in Alaska will be invited to special viewing parties as part of the cruise line’s exclusive Stargazing with Discovery at Sea program.
Princess Cruises to Host On-Board Viewing Parties for Solar Eclipse
Two people have been hospitalized with major injuries after a collision on San Francisquito Wednesday night.
San Francisquito Road Collision Leads to Major Injuries