[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Lost SCV-Related 1928 Film Reappears After Falling to Nazis, Soviets | 03-30-2014
Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
October 27
1892 - Birth of Robert E. Callahan, owner of Mission Village in L.A. and Old West Trading Post on Sierra Highway [story]

A newly rediscovered 1928 film with an “SCV connection” made its world premiere Saturday night in Los Angeles – 86 years and one day after it made its original world premiere.

The film is the Edwin Carewe version of “Ramona” starring Dolores Del Rio, and it had been lost to time until a print was discovered in 2010 in the Czech Republic.

The Santa Clarita Valley connection isn’t the film location, or even the players, but rather the story itself.

Dolores Del Rio as the title character and Warner Baxter as Alessandro in Edwin Carewe's 1928 "Ramona." Screenshot courtesy of Hugh Munro Neely.

Dolores Del Rio as the title character and Warner Baxter as Alessandro in Edwin Carewe’s 1928 “Ramona.” Screenshot courtesy of Hugh Munro Neely.

Often called the “Uncle Tom’s Cabin” of the American Indian, Helen Hunt Jackson’s 1884 “Ramona” tells the tale of a mixed-race girl who’s raised by a landed Mexican-Californio family and dares to fall in love with a Temecula Indian.

The foremost Indian rights activist of her day, Jackson called attention to the U.S. Government’s mistreatment of native Americans in her 1881 work of nonfiction, “A Century of Dishonor.” In her dramatic novel “Ramona,” she romanticized the message  in order to connect with the public in a way her nonfiction works didn’t.

And connect it did – although not necessarily in the way she envisioned.

This and other postcards of the Del Valle adobe at Rancho Camulos would have been very familiar to 1928 audiences. Click image for information.

This and other postcards of the Del Valle adobe at Rancho Camulos would have been very familiar to 1928 audiences. Click image for information.

All over the Midwest and East, Americans wanted to see the beautiful landscapes she described and the romantic characters she brought to life.

They were able to do so because the railroads were just starting to expand throughout Southern California. Thousands upon thousands of tourists came, and many stayed; the “Ramona” novel would spark the second massive westward migration of Americans after the 1849 Gold Rush.

Helen Hunt Jackson. Click image for information.

Helen Hunt Jackson. Click image for information.

Many readers didn’t realize or simply couldn’t believe Ramona, her beau Alessandro and rest of the characters were fictional.  They wanted to meet Ramona’s friends and see the “real” Home of Ramona- which meant they wanted to visit the Del Valle family’s 1853 adobe home at Rancho Camulos at the western edge of the Santa Clarita Valley, near the little town of Piru.

The novelist had visited Rancho Camulos on Jan. 23, 1882, two years before publication, and it was widely accepted that the rancho – once part of the Mexican land grant that included present-day Newhall, Saugus and Valencia – was the inspiration for a number of the make-believe locations in the novel.

So much so that in 1910, when D.W. Griffith directed the first “Ramona” film with America’s sweetheart, Mary Pickford, he shot it at Camulos and in Piru to give it the authenticity he knew his audiences would expect. It’s the earliest film known to have been shot in the Santa Clarita Valley.


ramonatitleRediscovery of the 1928 Film

Edwin Carewe directed about 58 feature films from 1914 to 1934. Of the 24 films he made in the 1920s, only three survive – including, now, “Ramona.” That’s not unusual; an estimated 75 percent of all silent films are lost.

There was no central U.S. repository for films during the silent period. Nobody knew he was making history; rarely did anyone think to keep his product for posterity. Movie houses discarded films after they ran.  When a film did make it as far as a warehouse or somebody’s garage, the nitrate film stock usually disintegrated into dust or dissolved into a toxic and highly flammable gunk.

Film historian Hugh Munro Neely leads a panel discussion at the Billy Wilder Theater after the screening. Photo: SCVTV.

Film historian Hugh Munro Neely leads a panel discussion at the Billy Wilder Theater after the screening. Photo: SCVTV.

Odd as it might seem, whenever an old, made-in (or about) Santa Clarita film did survive, it’s often thanks to the Czech National Film Archive (Národní filmový archiv, or NFA) in Prague. That’s the case, for instance, with John Ford’s “Straight Shooting” (1917) starring Saugus resident Harry Carey Sr. and shot in Placerita Canyon and Beale’s Cut.

The NFA was founded in 1943 to protect films from the ravages of World War II.

Now enter Hugh Munro Neely. Longtime (now former) curator of the Mary Pickford Institute of Film Education, Neely was no stranger to “Ramona”; the Griffith-Pickford version is one of its centerpieces.

In 2010, Neely learned of the existence of a lone print of Carewe’s “Ramona” in the NFA. Together with colleagues Joanna Hearne, an authority on early native American representations in cinema, and Dydia DeLyser – author of the book, “Ramona Memories,” which explores the myths, settings and historical impacts of Jackson’s novel – Neely traveled to Prague.

“Over the next several years,” Neely writes, “we were able to help coordinate the return of this print to the United States where it was preserved by the Library of Congress.”

The story of the print itself has the makings of a Hollywood thriller.

Phil Brigandi, longtime historian of the Ramona Pageant in Hemet. Photo: SCVTV.

Phil Brigandi, longtime historian of the Ramona Pageant in Hemet. Photo: SCVTV.

The Nazis confiscated a copy of “Ramona” in the former Czechoslovakia, which they occupied in 1939, and brought it (and countless other films) to Berlin. Next, when the Soviet Union liberated Berlin, “Ramona” was removed to the Soviet film archive, Gosfilmofond, outside of Moscow. Then, after the fall of the Soviet Union, Czech archivist Myrtil Frida found it in Gosfilmofond (now the State Film Fund of the Russian Federation) and carried “Ramona” back to Prague.

For a unique print that survived not only test of time but also the ravages of two Central European armies, it’s in remarkably good shape. Neely said the Library of Congress didn’t need to enhance the images; it merely needed to insert new title cards for English-speaking audiences.

"Ramona" expert Dydia DeLyser. Photo: SCVTV.

“Ramona” expert Dydia DeLyser. Photo: SCVTV.

“Phil Brigandi and Dydia DeLyser joined Klara Molacek and me for the purpose of creating a historically sensitive translation of the film’s titles from the Czech language back into English,” writes Neely. Brigandi is a leading Orange County historian and author with longtime ties to the annual Ramona Pageant in Hemet; Molacek, now in L.A., hails from Plzen in the Czech Republic.

“The Library of Congress’ team of preservationists created new titles for the film using artistic and period-appropriate type fonts,” Neely writes. “The result is a beautiful, photochemically restored film from the height of the silent era that tells one of the most famous stories to ever be set in our state.”


Edwin Carewe. Photo courtesy of Marc Wanamaker.

Edwin Carewe. Photo courtesy of Marc Wanamaker.

Carewe’s Version

Edwin Carewe is possibly unique among silent filmmakers in that he was native American. Of Chickasaw descent, he was born March 5, 1883, as Jay Fox in Gainesville, Texas, and changed his legal name to his stage name, which combined actor Edwin Booth’s first name with Carewe, a character Booth portrayed.

As such, Carewe’s reinterpretation of Jackson’s novel about the plight of the Indians is quite different from other versions.

In a panel discussion that followed the premiere in Westwood, Brigandi noted there are no sympathetic “white” characters in the film. A gang of white cattle rustlers raid an Indian encampment – filmed at what is now Forest Lawn’s Hollywood Cemetery, according to historian Marc Wanamaker – and are particularly brutal as they mercilessly gun down every last Indian – men, women and babes in arms.

Del Rio as Ramona and Roland Drew as Felipe.

Del Rio as Ramona and Roland Drew as Felipe.

All, that is, except Ramona and Alessandro, who flee in time to watch from a distance as the marauders burn their Western-style home and encircle it precisely as other filmmakers depicted Indians encircling Westerners’ wagons.

And as the panelists noted, the title cards identified the Indians as “unarmed.”

When Ramona and Alessandro escape to start their life together and raise a baby girl, Carewe chooses to use Utah’s Zion National Park as a backdrop. Panelist James D’Arc of the Brigham Young University Film Archive in Provo theorized that Carewe placed them in the towering mountains to add visual majesty to their pure and wholesome love.

The 1928 movie poster plays to romantic notions of Old California by showing the characters of Ramona and Feilpe - but it doesn't show Alessandro or any other Indian.

The 1928 movie poster seeks to attract American audiences by playing to the romantic notions of Old California as embodied in the characters of Ramona and Felipe. It doesn’t show Alessandro or any other Indian character.

Carewe doesn’t attempt to portray the Jackson’s entire 490-page book scene-for-scene on the screen; nobody would – although one previous director did so. That was Donald Crisp, in 1915 (released in 1916). His version ran more than 3 hours – even longer than Griffith’s 1915 “The Birth of a Nation.” Just one reel of Crisp’s “Ramona” exists.

Perhaps ironically, Griffith’s 1910 “Ramona” runs just 17 minutes. Carewe’s version, produced by his own Inspiration Pictures Inc. and distributed by United Artists, runs 77 minutes.

Original audience reactions to Carewe’s “Ramona” are unknown, although the panelists noted that Variety and The New York Times gave it good reviews and predicted its success.

Also, DeLyser said birth records show that many babies born in 1928, when the film debuted, were given the name Ramona – but when she contacted a number of them, all said they were named for the song “Ramona,” which came out in 1927 and was intended to accompany the silent film.

ramonaovertureFor the premiere, Rodney Sauer and his Mont-Alto Motion Picture Orchestra performed “Ramona” as an overture but didn’t play it during the film itself because, Sauer said, a popular tune tends to distract audiences from the story unfolding on the screen. Moreover, a sweet waltz might not have meshed well with Carewe’s sometimes harsh portrayal of an unquestionably sad story.

The “Ramona” sheet music issued in 1928 shows film star Dolores Del Rio on the cover.

Carewe had discovered Del Rio in Mexico and featured her in all seven of the feature films he made between 1925 and 1929, the latter five occurrences as leading lady. She played the title role not only in “Ramona” but also the following year in Carewe’s “Evangeline,” based on the Henry Wadsworth Longfellow poem.

While the little blonde Mary Pickford might have been America’s sweetheart, the dark-haired Del Rio was for men what Rudolph Valentino was for women: She was considered the most beautiful woman on the screen.


Photo: SCVTV

Photo: SCVTV

The New Premiere

It’s somewhat unusual for the UCLA Film & Television Archive  to premiere a film that it didn’t restore itself, but such was the case Saturday at the sold-out, 285-seat Billy Wilder Theater at the Armand Hammer Museum.

Support for the special viewing came from Carewe’s granddaughter, Diane Allen, who treated guests, including representatives of the Rancho Camulos Museum, to a pre-event reception at her Brentwood estate.

With the rediscovery of “Ramona,” Allen and other family members have launched an effort to “promote and preserve the legacy of our Grandfather Edwin Carewe.”

It’s a worthy goal. Carewe was an A-lister who “made medium to high-budget films that were released by First National, a company that focused its efforts on ‘A features,'” Neely said. “He then switched to United Artists, Paramount and Fox.” In some respects it’s a wonder his name is so little known.

Film historian Marc Wanamaker participates from the audience. Photo: SCVTV.

Film historian Marc Wanamaker participates from the audience. Photo: SCVTV.

“As an actor, director, producer and writer,” his family states, “Edwin was one of Hollywood’s most illustrious and talented trailblazers in the silent era of motion pictures. We know, as his grandchildren, that he would be most honored by this tribute to preserve his legacy for future generations and film aficionados worldwide.”

And if Carewe was like other filmmakers of the era who used Placerita Canyon and Vasquez Rocks as backdrops, his heirs are likely to come across more “Santa Clarita Valley connections” in his body of work.

Let’s hope “Ramona” is but the first of many to reappear after all these years.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

Leave a Comment

Wednesday, Oct 26, 2016
Thursdays@Newhall’s 10 by 10 variety show continues to amuse and entertain attendees month after month and November should be no exception.
Wednesday, Oct 26, 2016
Santa Clarita resident, Justice Enlow, has been chosen to represent North Los Angeles in the upcoming state pageant to be held December 2-4, 2016 in Long Beach.
Wednesday, Oct 26, 2016
Former Santa Clarita resident and renowned songwriter, Julia Michaels, recently signed a solo deal with Republic Records.
Monday, Oct 24, 2016
Based on her’ influential Animation History class at CalArts, Maureen Furniss' "A New History of Animation" is the first textbook to chronicle the history of the field. It is also a must-read reference for fans and scholars.
Monday, Oct 24, 2016
Several features, TV shows and a student production are filming in Santa Clarita this week.
Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
I retired in 2012 and started hiking and biking into the mountains. I kept running into strange, fenced-in sites, usually located at the top of cul-de-sacs. Each consisted of a pit that ended at a concrete wall. Close to the wall, a strange perforated silo would rise up. What were these things?
Mud Catchers | Commentary by Mike Summe
1892 - Birth of Robert E. Callahan, owner of Mission Village in L.A. and Old West Trading Post on Sierra Highway [story]
Santa Clarita-based Princess Cruises has promoted SCV resident Marsha Patrick to the role of sales director for the western region, succeeding Stephanie Brennan who recently retired after 39 years of service. In her new role, Patrick will lead a team of 15 business development managers promoting the Princess Cruises and Cunard Line brands to travel consultants in the western United States and Canada.
Princess Names New SCV-Based Sales Director for Western Region
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, a local congressman addressed the Department of the Interior about a local mine. Plus, impatient drivers are causing problems on some Canyon Country roads. See what's happening on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, October 26, 2016
Tons of exciting news from the College of the Canyons Foundation.
COC Foundation News, 10-26-2016
Free spooktacular events will be brewing at local Santa Clarita Public Library branches on Monday, Oct. 31.
Oct. 31: Free Halloween Activities at Santa Clarita Libraries
Thursdays@Newhall’s 10 by 10 variety show continues to amuse and entertain attendees month after month and November should be no exception.
Nov. 3: 10-by-10 Variety Night Stacked with Talent
A 26-year-old Santa Clarita Valley resident and Marine was killed in a single-vehicle motorcycle crash last month on Ortega Highway in an Orange County.
Marine from SCV Killed in Motorcycle Crash
The Master’s University men’s soccer team posted two goals in the second half of Wednesday’s match against Westmont College, but couldn’t rally past the Warriors, resulting in a 3-2 loss.
Soccer: Mustangs Fall Short Despite Late Rally
Mission Valley Bancorp's President & CEO Tamara Gurney has announced the year to date net income of $2,190,000 for the period ended Sept. 30, 2016 – the strongest 3rd quarter in the history of the company.
Mission Valley Bank Posts 25% Higher Year-Over-Year Profits
California Pizza Kitchen is hosting a fundraiser for the Michael Hoefflin Foundation for Children's Cancer on Wednesday, Nov. 2, 2016.
California Pizza Kitchen Hosts Michael Hoefflin Foundation Fundraiser
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health reminds individuals to take precautions to reduce lead exposure to children during National Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Week. Lead poisoning can cause serious health effects and developmental problems in young children.
Public Should Take Precautions Against Lead Poisoning
Four Santa Clarita Valley homes will be decked out in true holiday splendor during Henry Mayo’s 36th Annual Home Tour this December.
Dec. 3: Henry Mayo Presents Annual Holiday Home Tour
Santa Clarita resident, Justice Enlow, has been chosen to represent North Los Angeles in the upcoming state pageant to be held December 2-4, 2016 in Long Beach.
SCV Resident Chosen to Represent North LA in Miss California USA Pageant
The College of the Canyons Canyon Country campus will host a pair of family-friendly events with its annual movie night and garden walk activities returning to campus on Nov. 4 and 5.
Nov. 4-5: COC to Host Garden Walk, Movie Night at Canyon Country Campus
The Valley Industry Association is pleased to host Bill Bellows as keynote speaker for the November luncheon meeting.
Nov. 15: VIA to Host Bill Bellows as Keynote Speaker
Former Santa Clarita resident and renowned songwriter, Julia Michaels, recently signed a solo deal with Republic Records.
Songwriter from SCV Signs Record Contract
The 5th Annual Bowling for Kids Charity Event is back again on Sunday, Dec. 4 with 100 percent of the proceeds benefiting the Children’s Hospital of Los Angeles.
Dec. 4: Bowling for Kids Returns to Valencia Lanes
On Thursday, Nov. 10 the SCV Senior Center Silvertone Singers will present an audible feast of all-time musical favorites to put you in the mood for holiday culinary indulgences.
Nov. 10: SCV Senior Center to Feature Feasting Melodies
The College of the Canyons women's golf team competed at Western State Conference Tournament No. 8 on Monday, with two Lady Cougars finishing in the top-15.
Golf: Individual Lady Cougars Finish 8th, 14th in Conference Play
With the win, TMU’s 2016 record improved to 19-9 and 11-2 in Golden State Athletic Conference play. Currently, TMU sits just two matches behind the No. 1 nationally ranked Westmont College Warriors.
Volleyball: Lady Mustangs Get Past Vanguard in 3
1992 - Newspaper editor Scott Newhall (SF Chronicle, Newhall Signal, SCV Citizen) dies at 78 in Valencia hospital [story]
An elite helicopter tour of Los Angeles and an all-inclusive visit to Taliesin West, Frank Lloyd Wright's home in Arizona, are among the unique items that will be on the auction block at Zonta's 2016 Tribute to Women sponsored by Zonta Club of SCV.
Nov. 4: Unusual Items to be Auctioned at Zonta Tribute
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, a 9 year old girl was struck and killed in Newhall Monday evening. Plus, pirates and beer will take over this local golf course. Check out these stories and more on tonight's SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Tuesday, October 25, 2016
Rain or Shine! The 28th Annual Haunted Jailhouse & Community Open House event will be held this Sunday, Oct. 30, 2016 from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. at the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station located at 23740 Magic Mountain Parkway, Santa Clarita.
Haunted Jailhouse Coming Sunday, Rain or Shine
At Tuesday’s meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, 5th District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich presented Mighy, an 8-month-old shorthaired Chihuahua, and Miss Inky, a 2-month-old domestic shorthair, ready to be adopted.
Antonovich Pets of the Week (10-25-2016): Miss Inky, Mighty
With extensive input from the community, the Board of Supervisors today approved a comprehensive trails master plan intended to guide future multi-use trail development in the Castaic area, announced Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich.
Board OK’s Multi-Use Trails Plan for Castaic Area
Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder County Clerk Dean C. Logan announced the results Tuesday of the friendly voter registration competition between crosstown rivals USC and UCLA.
USC-UCLA: One Registers 10,109 New Voters, The Other Just 411
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors today approved plans to turn the former Puente Hills Landfill into a regional park that will offer natural open space and a host of recreational programs for area residents.
Supes OK Park Plan for Ex-Puente Hills Landfill Site
Santa Clarita-based Princess Cruises revealed its new livery as Royal Princess made her U.S. debut on arrival into Ft. Lauderdale on Oct. 22. The ship is the first to sail with the new hull design featuring the iconic brand mark, which was added during a recent dry dock in Civitavecchia, Italy.
New Princess Cruises Livery Makes First Appearance in U.S. Waters
Halloween can be a fun and exciting night, but according to the Center for Disease Control, due to increased foot traffic and Trick-or-Treaters out at night, the potential for automobile related accidents with young pedestrians increase four times on this night.
Safety Tips: Don’t Get Tricked on Halloween
Street sweeping will take place every week following trash pickup days between the hours of 7 a.m. and 5 p.m. to help keep streets, and particularly gutters, clean and free of falling leaves and debris.
Expect More City Street Sweeping This Time of Year
After a week of tense anticipation, a federal judge on Tuesday granted final approval of Volkswagen's $15 billion settlement with VW and Audi owners regarding the automaker's emissions cheating scandal - perhaps the largest payout of its kind in U.S. history.
Judge OK’s Car Maker’s $15 Bil. Settlement with VW, Audi Owners
Minutes away from upsetting No. 11 Westmont, the Mustangs watched the Warriors come out of a scrum in front of the net to score the game-tying goal that eventually led to a 1-1 double-overtime draw.
Soccer: Lady Mustangs Battle to 1-1 Draw in Double OT
The Master’s University golf team wrapped up its time at the CSUSM Fall Classic by placing 12th out of a field of 17 teams with a collective score of 935 (308-300-327).
Golf: Downey Leads Mustangs as Fall Season Ends
A 9-year-old girl died Monday, after she was hit by a car in Newhall while crossing the street after getting off a city bus, officials said.
9-Year-Old Girl Struck, Killed After Getting Off Bus