[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: Don’t Let Plambeck Fool You | 07-22-2016
Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
September 30
1955 - Actor James Dean, 24, drives through Castaic Junction en route to his final resting place [watch]

Commentary by Thomas Campbell, CLWA
| Friday, Jul 22, 2016

tom_campbellA recent opinion piece by Newhall County Water District Director Lynne Plambeck made some serious – but patently untrue – allegations regarding Castaic Lake Water Agency that demand correction and clarification.

The spread of such misinformation is an attempt to block a move toward cooperative water management in the Santa Clarita Valley, on the flawed theory that doing so will undermine city and county land use decisions.

CLWA is a wholesaler of State Water Project and other imported water supplies and owns and operates one retail water supplier, the Santa Clarita Water Division, and recently purchased the stock of another, the Valencia Water Co. In addition, CLWA and Newhall County Water District are discussing a merger of their operations to take advantage of economies of scale, mitigate future rate increases and, most importantly, advance water supply security and reliability in the region.

Plambeck, who is president of SCOPE (Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment), has been a vocal opponent of the merger, which she has falsely labeled a takeover. She should know it isn’t, since her fellow Newhall County Water District Board members all support exploration of the idea. Her June 26 commentary on SCVNews.com is another attempt to discredit CLWA, confuse the public, and lobby for her position.

In fact, Plambeck has an apparent conflict of interest since she sits in on NCWD board’s closed sessions regarding the merger and is actively subverting her board’s desired path in a desperate attempt to backstop SCOPE’s losing lawsuit challenging CLWA’s purchase of Valencia Water Co.

In 2012, CLWA purchased the stock of Valencia Water Co. from The Newhall Land and Farming Co.

Contrary to Plambeck’s rhetoric, Valencia’s quarterly dividend has remained unchanged since the company’s stock was acquired by CLWA. But instead of going to a private company, the money is benefiting the public. The funds are used for CLWA’s wholesale operation, which in turn keeps costs down for customers throughout our service area.

Some of the programs funded in CLWA’s wholesale operating budget include conservation assistance to water ratepayers throughout the area, including those within the Valencia Water Co., Newhall County Water District, L.A. County Waterworks District 36 and Santa Clarita Water Division service areas.

Furthermore, Valencia’s board of directors – not CLWA – makes all decisions regarding rates, which are the lowest in the Santa Clarita Valley.

There is no attempt to hide any of this information. Valencia publishes a notice and materials about proposed rates and CLWA’s board receives the company’s financial reports, which are a public record.

Plambeck has raised some issues regarding our finances. To clarify, interfund transfers are a legitimate way to allocate and track funds so that they are properly accounted for and reimbursed.

And defeasance, to which she refers, means pre-paying debt. One of the benefits of this strategy is that it reduces the need for a significant rate increase to meet revenue-to-debt coverage ratios during a severe sales drop, like we experienced during the drought.

CLWA’s financials are published regularly, audited annually and subject to significant review by the major credit rating agencies. CLWA maintains a AAA/AA-plus credit rating on its debt.

CLWA has issued debt that has financed critical water supply assets, including two major water filtration plants, storage facilities and about 45 miles of large-diameter pipeline.

All of this work helps CLWA fulfill its mission to deliver reliable, quality water at a reasonable cost to the Santa Clarita Valley.

And lastly, no one is talking about taking over anyone else. CLWA and NCWD are mutually exploring the idea of merging into one new entity that would provide more efficient and cheaper water service.

Isn’t that what responsible government officials are supposed to do?

Don’t be fooled by Plambeck’s baseless arguments, which are driven by her self-serving agenda to undermine proper and prudent water management in support of her misguided efforts to dictate land use in the valley.


Thomas Campbell is president of the board of the Castaic Lake Water Agency.


Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


  1. Mbb says:

    or is it just fear that Lynne will lose her spot on the board if NCWD and CLWA merge?

  2. Allan Cameron says:

    A note to correct a common misconception regarding “conflict of interest” committed by an elected public official. Appropriately, a “conflict of interest” by an elected or appointed public official is any action that either advances or harms a financial investment or asset held by a public official. All Americans fully retain their rights of free expression, whether or not they hold elective office. Ms. Plambeck has every right to express any opinion she may have. SCOPE is a non profit organization, with no paid staff, or any assets of any kind. (I am its co founder). She may criticize as she wishes. Of course, she may expect criticism in return. However, there is absolutely no conflect of interest in evidence here, despite assertions to the contrary.

    • treehugger says:

      Knowing Ms. Plambeck for over 30+ years I have NEVER know her to say or do anything for personal gains. However that may not be said for CLWA board members and their staff. Ms. Plambeck has been the local voice that has helped shape our community into the oak tree shaded village we all know and love. No Ms. Plambeck can’t be bought out, Mr. Campbell, can you say the same?

  3. waterwatcher says:

    Whew – maybe Campbell should go back and re-read the article that Plambeck wrote. What is he talking about increasing the dividend? The problem is that CLWA is increasing rates on Valencia Water Company customers while those same customers are paying CLWA 199,000 a quarter, totally some 2.4 million to date (2.6 if the July payment has been made), in dividends for stock that CLWA is not allowed to own under state law. Here’s the link to the first article where SCV news posted all the Valencia Water Dividend payments to CLWA. http://scvnews.com/2016/06/26/enron-accounting-at-clwa-commentary-by-lynne-plambeck/

    I guess when the other person is right and has the documents to prove it, Mr. Campbell’s tactic is to call them names and try to impugn their reputation. Sorry, I don’t buy it and neither should anyone else.

  4. waterwatcher says:

    “Furthermore, Valencia’s board of directors – not CLWA – makes all decisions regarding rates, which are the lowest in the Santa Clarita Valley.”

    Oops – one more thing. Oh silly you, Mr. Campbell – Who is Valencia’s Board of Directors? At the last rate hearing, three of the five members were CLWA employees – which means CLWA controls the Board. You know that! Although, it might be hard for the public to know this since CLWA refuses to allow Board meetings to be publicly held, does not publish any agendas or minutes and refuses to release any financial information. You claim Valencia Water is is private except when you want to raise our rates and then suddenly you are a public water company subject to 218. You can’t have it both ways, at least not legally.

  5. Sheryl says:

    I totally agree with Allan. I also believe the CLWA has no business being in the water retail business. They are a wholesaler not a retailer. Being in the retail business is a conflict of interest. The City of Santa Clarita should look into having its own city water company as Burbank and Glendale have. CLWA is out of control and in the pockets of the developers.

  6. scvdontfoolme says:

    Oh I don’t think Lynne Plambeck tries to fool anyone. Lynne is very brave to come forward and I think we ALL know why.

    Since when is a conflicting view, a conflict of interest? What you seem to be saying is that if she doesn’t agree with the rest of the board, then there is some conflict. I guess CLWA doesn’t believe in, or think very much of, democracy?

    When will the merger be agendized on NCWD as well as CLWA? When will the public get to vote on this? Has Pavley agreed to carry any legislation? What does the governance look like? Is this the fox guarding the hen house again, like with the Valencia Water illegal purchase where a sitting board member asked if they could be held “personally liable” for any law breaking?

    We thought you learned your lesson when the courts told you NOT to repeat the same technique you used with the purchase of Santa Clarita Water. Guess Not.

    And this “exploring” was a year in the making without anyone from the public knowing a thing about it, and all BEHIND closed doors in closed meetings. How could Lynne have a conflict of interest by NOT wanting a 60 year old voting district gobbled up by CLWA? I guess you can only “explore” something if you are all for it?

    Doesn’t NCWD have a lawsuit again CLWA for the illegal purchase of Valencia Water, which they have refused to dismiss? And didn’t NCWD just win 2 other lawsuits again CLWA for Brown Act violations, and unfair rates?

    Is it me, or does Lynne make total sense, and YOU are the one with the conflict, but with HER, not the merger. I think I know who to trust on this issue, and it’s not the ones trying to vilify a whistleblower.

  7. Bart Joseph says:

    So we elected a watchdog to a board of trustees abd the other trustees dont want the environmentalist to talk about internal issues..
    What a shock. Schilling is illegal, and now that we know they cant sell retail, when do we get our refund of their profit?

  8. Lee Jenkinson says:

    I am disturbed when the city council apparently sits back and lets all of this happen without any comment. I am also disappointed with the Signal for not making what appears to be a developer end run around the citizens a news story. It all seems so Machiavellian to me, and the Signal should be explaining this to us so that we understand what is going on. Frankly, between the chloride issue and this ongoing CLWA consolidation of Santa Clarita’s water, I am losing faith in the ability of our city council to stay objectively on top of things.

    • SCVNews.com says:

      the city council is no more involved with the water system than, say, the school boards. It’s not within their purview; the council has nothing to say about it. There are probably quite a few people in this town who would object to the idea of expanding the powers of the city council.

  9. scvdontfoolme says:

    I was watching a City Council meeting on TV where Bob Kellar wanted to send a support letter. I nearly fell out of my chair. I will have to review the video clips, but YES HE SUPPORTS IT. Marsha, bless her heart, asked for the council to SLOW DOWN, and to review everything before sending a letter of support. She mentioned that she liked having her water company separate and governed by the board that she and her neighbors voted on. Marsha a a smart lady.

Leave a Comment

Commentary Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Related Content
Friday, Sep 30, 2016
One can legitimately ask if Steve and Cokie Roberts' story falls into Hillary’s list of tales about being under gunfire in Bosnia, Chelsea’s danger in being near ground zero on 9/11, and Hillary’s claim of being named after Sir Edmund Hillary – who did not become famous until six years after Hillary’s birth.
Thursday, Sep 29, 2016
Walking across my property the other morning around 7:30, I saw something move suddenly at my feet. It actually struck at me, and it was a good thing I didn’t step on it. It was in fact a night snake. I was thrilled.
Tuesday, Sep 27, 2016
Social justice warriors at the University of Kansas screamed obscenities at white students who didn’t feel the need for "safe spaces." Imagine that. The self-proclaimed warriors of civility and equality respond to what was supposed to be an open conversation by shouting them down, using foul language, and screaming in the faces of students with a different viewpoint.
Sunday, Sep 25, 2016
I have taken many walks on the plains of Tanzania with Masai body guards armed with spears and occasionally rifles. It is rather unnerving to think at any moment, you could become prey to a lion, cheetah or another apex predator.
Thursday, Sep 22, 2016
If you find yourself traveling east on Interstate 40 to Needles or beyond, you might want to consider a short side trip to explore Amboy Crater National Natural Landmark. It’s located just off of National Trails Highway (Historic Route 66) about 28 miles east of the town of Ludlow.
Tuesday, Sep 20, 2016
Medicare’s annual open enrollment season begins Oct. 15 and runs through Dec. 7. This is the time every year when you can sign up for a new Medicare drug or health plan, or switch the one you have now.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
One can legitimately ask if Steve and Cokie Roberts' story falls into Hillary’s list of tales about being under gunfire in Bosnia, Chelsea’s danger in being near ground zero on 9/11, and Hillary’s claim of being named after Sir Edmund Hillary – who did not become famous until six years after Hillary’s birth.
Selective Memory | Commentary by Betty Arenson
1955 - Actor James Dean, 24, drives through Castaic Junction en route to his final resting place [watch]
On Saturday, The Master’s University’s cross country teams will toe the line at their fifth-annual home race, The Mustang Challenge, at Santa Clarita’s Central Park.
Oct. 1: TMU Hosts XC Race at Santa Clarita Central Park
The Golden State Athletic Conference has announced that Michael Sciarra has been named the Cross Country Runner of the Month for September. This is Sciarra’s first time receiving this honor.
TMU’s Sciarra Named Conference Runner of Month
Twelfth-ranked Biola used a splendid bicycle kick 4:59 into overtime to eke out a 1-0 victory over the Mustangs Wednesday night in La Mirada.
Men’s Soccer: Mustangs Fall to Biola 1-0 in Overtime
The College of the Canyons men's soccer team claimed its biggest win of the season on Tuesday, coming in the form of a physical 2-1 victory over Santa Barbara City College at Cougar Stadium.
Men’s Soccer: COC Gets Physical with Santa Barbara, Wins 2-1
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, the annual Hate Crimes report was released by the Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations and reports a 24 percent increase this past year. Plus, Halloween is around the corner and this local farm will help you get in the spirit of the season. Check out these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, September 29, 2016
The burned-out and blighted Greens pub and putting course on McBean Parkway could be redeveloped into a 5-story hotel and 4,000-square-foot restaurant if the Santa Clarita Planning Commission shouts "FORE!" on Tuesday to a proposal that's working its way through the city approval process.
City Planners to Consider New Hotel, Restaurant for ‘Greens’ Property
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson announced today that the U.S. Department of Education has awarded California $49.9 million in start-up funds to assist in the launch and development of high-quality charter schools over the next three years.
Feds Providing $50 Mil. for Calif. Charter School Start-Ups
During the month of October on every Saturday, residents can partake in a variety of happenings throughout the city of Santa Clarita to celebrate the arts. All events are free and open to the public.
Santa Clarita Celebrates National Arts, Humanities Month
The Matador Report is the official e-newsletter of Matador Athletics.
CSUN Athletics: Matador Report for Thursday, Sept. 29, 2016
Lots of fun learning activities are in store at the Santa Clarita Public Libraries in October.
October at the Santa Clarita Libraries
Education is power. Come learn about the new laws which will affect your business and employees, and discuss the steps you can take to help ensure compliance and avoid costly fines or litigation.
Dec. 2: Employment Law Update at COC Chancellor’s Circle Breakfast
Parents, educators, students, and employers are invited to take part in the "STREAM Kids Expo," an event that engages students in real-world issues through exciting hands-on activities facilitated by industry experts such as NASA, Lockheed Martin, Gantom Lighting & Controls, Wells Fargo, BMW, and Solar City.
Oct. 22: ‘STREAM Kids Expo’ to Engage Students in Real World Issues
A bill cosponsored by Representative Steve Knight (CA-25) that would buy time for small businesses and other entities to comply with an impending federal regulation passed the House of Representatives Wednesday night.
Knight Bill Aiming to Delay Mandate Affecting Business Passes House
A total 32 rabid bats have been found in Los Angeles County, with 11 of them being found in the Santa Clarita Valley, in 2016 as of September 27.
Three More Rabid Bats Found in SCV, Brings Total to 11
At Tuesday’s meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, 5th District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich presented Bailey, a 3-month-old spayed female chihuahua mix, ready to be adopted.
Antonovich Pet of the Week (9-27-2016): Bailey
The Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations has released its annual account of hate crimes reported throughout Los Angeles County in 2015.
Hate Crimes Rise in L.A. County for the First Time in Seven Years
Gov. Jerry Brown signed into law Santa Clarita Assemblyman Scott Wilk’s AB 1322, which permits salons and barbershops to serve a single complimentary alcoholic beverage to clients ages 21 and over without requiring a license or permit, provided no extra fees are charged for the beverage.
Brown Signs Wilk Bill Allowing Alcoholic Beverages to be Served at Salons
The Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk has begun mailing over 5 million Sample Ballot Booklets to voters for the Nov. 8th Presidential General Election.
Sample Ballet Booklets Mailed to More Than 5 Mil. Voters
The Welcome Back Barbecue for Hart Regiment Alumni and parents will again be held at the 33rd annual Rampage Field Show Competition on Oct. 29, 2016 at College of the Canyons.
Oct. 29: Hart Regiment Alumni and Parents Welcome Back BBQ
The California Retail Survey, which compares retail sales activity for each of California’s 58 counties and 480 cities, ranked the city of Santa Clarita 21st in retail sales in the recently released 2016 California Retail Survey.
Out of 480 Cities, City Ranks 21st in Retail
The Santa Clarita Valley will never forget the sacrifices of those who have laid down their lives to protect this community. That’s the overriding message behind a coordinated effort to refresh and rejuvenate a memorial to four California Highway Patrol officers who were killed in the line of duty during a 1970 shootout that became known as The Newhall Incident.
CHP, Stay Green and Eternal Valley Honor Fallen Officers
Gov. Jerry Brown on Wednesday signed two bills vigorously opposed by law enforcement, allowing thousands of felons serving time in county jails to vote and reforming California's gang database.
Brown Signs Legislation Allowing More Felons to Vote
The class is for teens between 15-19 years old. If they are about to get their permits, have just gotten them or are new to driving in general, this class is for them. We will discuss DUI, speeding, seatbelts and distracted driving.
Oct. 22: Newhall CHP Hosts ‘Start Smart’ Driving Class for Teens
The U.S. military successfully struck two al-Qaida targets in central Yemen in the past week, killing four al-Qaida operatives.
U.S. Military Takes Out 4 al-Qaida Operatives in Yemen
CU Bancorp, the parent company of wholly owned California United Bank, which serves the Santa Clarita, San Fernando and Conejo valleys, announced Thursday that it has been named to Fortune’s annual Top 100 Fastest-Growing Companies list.
Cal United Bank Among 100 Fastest Growning Companies
Walking across my property the other morning around 7:30, I saw something move suddenly at my feet. It actually struck at me, and it was a good thing I didn’t step on it. It was in fact a night snake. I was thrilled.
Night Snakes
1907 - Actor & Placerita movie ranch owner Orvon Gene Autry born in Texas [story]
Support Hart Cheer and buy a raffle ticket for $10 to win 12 VIP tickets plus parking to see the LA Kings take on the Vancouver Canucks at the Staples Center on Saturday, Oct. 22.
Help Hart Cheer: Enter to Win Kings VIP Tix, $6,000 Value
Join expert archivists who work in the entertainment industry in celebrating the 14th annual International Home Movie Day on Saturday, Oct. 15, from noon to 4 p.m. at the Valencia Public Library.
Oct. 15: Share Your Old Home Movie at Valencia Library
Los Angeles County Supervisor Don Knabe is proud to announce that the County’s Safe Surrender Program celebrated success for the fifth time this year with the report of a safely surrendered newborn baby boy. This most recent Safe Surrender occurred on Monday, Sept. 27m at a hospital in Montebello.
Baby Boy Safely Surrendered in L.A. County
The City of Santa Clarita’s March-through-October Thursdays@Newhall series comes to a close with an interactive dance night, one-of-kind car show, a zombie outbreak, interesting speakers and more on Main Street in Old Town Newhall.
From Zydeco to Zombies: Thursdays in Newhall in October
Former Los Angeles County Sheriff Leroy Baca says he will not get a fair trial on charges he obstructed an investigation into jailhouse abuses because a federal judge is already convinced of his guilt and media coverage has prejudiced him.
Baca Wants New Judge, Prosecutor, Trial Location
The Master’s University’s women’s soccer team’s 2016 record moved to 4-4-2 (0-2 GSAC) after falling to Biola University 4-0 Tuesday night.
Soccer: Biola Shuts Door on Lady Mustangs
Morgan Koch paced the Lady Mustangs with eight kills, while Tate followed with seven. Kayla Sims tallied 27 assists, while Emily Clark notched 12 digs. Stevens finished the evening with four blocks and six kills.
Volleyball: Lady Mustangs Improve to 13-5 with Win Over Warriors