[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: Two-Tiered Healthcare System | 08-08-2016
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
78°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
March 28
1934 - Bouquet Canyon Reservoir, replacement for ill-fated St. Francis Dam & reservoir, begins to fill with water [story]


Commentary by Gene Dorio, M.D.
| Monday, Aug 8, 2016

genedorioBorn in Canada, our mother came to the United States after World War II and blended into the Greatest Generation. Raising a family in the second half of the 20th Century saw her contribute to a thriving American society then maintain retirement health on Medicare. But in her early 90s, this tranquility was threatened when her HMO hospital tried to kill her.

She went to the emergency room with symptoms of the stomach flu and was rapidly placed on palliative care with an erroneous diagnosis of end-stage liver cancer. Fortunately, after a long ordeal and because of our medical background, we thwarted hospital personnel’s efforts and got her back home, healthy.

Because healthcare spending is 17.5 percent of the nation’s Gross Domestic Product – by far the highest in the world – legislators have focused on lowering this figure. Some of the financial assault has come against Medicare, creating a two-tiered system endangering the health of the Greatest Generation.

As a primary care physician, I have seen this onslaught perpetrated against elder senior patients who are admitted to the hospital.

In the Medicare tier, patient reimbursement has been legislatively lowered, and therefore hospital admissions have been statistically scrutinized. “Length of stay” is a common term that business-oriented hospital administrators use to bully primary care physicians hurriedly to discharge still-ill patients to nursing homes. Multiple case managers and discharge coordinators are employed to hover over doctors expediting “drive-thru” medical care.

Some patients, though, are extremely ill, and hospitals have maneuvered and exploited end-of-life hospice laws. Unlike our mother, many patients do not have physician family members guiding them through this ordeal.

In the second tier, patients who have private insurance and are under 65 do not come under the same scrutiny Medicare patients undergo. There are no delegated in-hospital oversight personnel, and I rarely receive phone calls from insurance companies to discharge the patient. Patients stay longer, leave healthier, and there is never a length-of-stay statistical report generated to coerce their primary care physician.

So those elder senior patients – our parents and grandparents who fought in wars and defended our nation, made it through the Great Depression and established vested interest in the future of our nation – are swooshed into and out of the hospital in a legally sanctioned attempt to minimize their medical care.

Shouldn’t legislators be more responsible? Of course. But the caveat to this scheme is that the members of Congress who make these laws don’t go on Medicare like the rest of us. They have health insurance outside of the Medicare system. This undermines our ideals of equality, as the legislators who make the laws don’t live under the laws.

Not fair? We have moved forward on many issues, and most of us now believe the Constitution should read, “all men and women are created equal.” The same should be said for healthcare. Let’s get rid of the two-tiered system of hospital care and find a better way to provide Medicare to the Greatest Generation.

For a start, demand that all members of Congress go on Medicare at age 65. They will then have vested interest in their future, as well as ours.

 

 

Gene Uzawa Dorio, M.D., is a housecall geriatric physician on staff at Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital and has been engaged as an advocate in many community activities. The views expressed in this column as his alone.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

3 Comments

  1. Mbb says:

    THANKS for the article – hope it scares families into making sure that anyone in their family receiving Medicare has a loud and educated (to the above) advocate. My older sister in St. Louis was in the same position til I stepped in at great expense.

    Don’t let it happen to you, either – plan ahead!!

  2. S.Smith says:

    I respectfully disagree with your assertion of a two-tiered system based upon age and being a Medicare recepient. Young people are also subject to scrutiny, approvals and authorizations by their insurance plans, especially HMO plans. Even more at risk are those with no insurance, for which there is no private nor government payer. And what about our veterans who have received inadequate care at some VA hospitals.
    I don’t believe every, nor most, physicians, hospitals, or health plans are as “slanted” as your portray.
    I’d like to present an alternate portrait of an experience with an elderly family member where the physician wanted to admit my family member to the hospital for multiple minor medical issues that arose. I don’t think the physician was a bad physician. I don’t think they wanted to spend the additional time managing my family member at home. Advocating for care aligned with the family member’s desires and values, we switched our family member to a practice with a Physician’s Assistant who was willing and capapble of managing care that prevented hospitalizations and kept our family member at home.
    I appreciate commentary and Op Ed pieces as long as they are accurate. I don’t find this one completely accurate and recommend SCVnews.com find another contributor.

  3. Gene Uzawa Dorio, M.D. says:

    In response to S. Smith:

    In the article, traditional Medicare is being compared to those using private insurance in a hospital setting.

    HMO Medicare (briefly alluded to in the posting as it applied to my mother) is one of several insurances reimbursing hospitals for medical care including Medi-Cal (federally it is Medicaid), Affordable Care Act (known by the public as Obamacare), and the Veterans Affairs (usually at their government set-up hospitals).

    Those unfortunate patients who still have no health insurance (about 20 million in the US) are the most victimized, but were not discussed in this posting.

    I agree with you, younger patients in regular HMO (as well as older Medicare HMO) are clearly under the scrutiny of management, as their administrators are there to make a profit. Because of this motivation though, some physicians, hospitals, and health plans are “slanted” when they provide care. This was also not discussed in the article.

    Even as a physician, I find these areas complex. Still, I stand by the accuracy of my commentary.

    Gene Uzawa Dorio, M.D.

Leave a Comment


Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Related Content
RECENT COMMENTARY
Friday, Mar 24, 2017
The ACA woes are long-standing and obvious, and addressing them is long overdue. Both political parties need to face reality and unite for corrections. Democrats offer nothing but criticism and fright, while some recalcitrant Republicans obsess with killing the ACA immediately. Both are foolish.
Thursday, Mar 23, 2017
Many flowers are pollinated by insects, so there is nothing unusual there for the poppies, which are indeed fertilized by insects. What is more unusual is the kind of insects that play an important part in doing this job. It seems the actual pollinator is...
Wednesday, Mar 22, 2017
Despite Trump’s lies, tens of millions will lose insurance, huge premium spikes will hit older and middle-class Americans hard, and low-income children and the disabled will have their health care taken away.
Friday, Mar 17, 2017
Fifteen California community colleges have the option to offer bachelor’s degrees as part of a pilot program created in 2014 by Senate Bill 850, which sought to provide more educational options to help high school graduates get the training required to enter a competitive job market. Senate Bill 769 by Sen. Jerry Hill would expand the pilot program and allow community colleges to offer multiple bachelor’s degree programs in areas where the CSU system is unable to meet the need.
Thursday, Mar 16, 2017
One of my favorite destinations in Death Valley National Park is located in Wildrose Canyon, where you will find what are believed to be the best known surviving examples of charcoal kilns in the western states - plus a great hiking trail and campground.
Wednesday, Mar 15, 2017
Having practiced pharmacy for many years, I often find myself talking to people about their Medicare prescription drug, or Part D, plans. A first step to correcting problems is always to contact your drug plan. If that doesn’t work, you can file a complaint.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
For the past four months, Trinity Classical Academy and the Imago Dei School’s fourth grade classes have been preparing for the annual Medieval Times and Renaissance Faire, happening this Friday, March 31 from 9:00 a.m. – 11:30 a.m. in the Celebration Center at Trinity Classical Academy.
March 31: Trinity Classical Academy Medieval Times, Renaissance Faire
Beginning April 1, 2017, sales of lead-acid batteries will be subject to two $1 fees. Manufacturers will pay a $1 fee for every lead-acid battery sold to a retailer, wholesaler, distributor or other person for retail sale in California. Consumers will pay a $1 fee on each purchase of a replacement lead-acid battery.
April 1: Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act Fees Go into Effect
1934 - Bouquet Canyon Reservoir, replacement for ill-fated St. Francis Dam & reservoir, begins to fill with water [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, an early morning barricade situation ended peacefully on Sunday. Plus, local kids got artsy over the weekend. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Monday, March 27, 2017
FivePoint Management, formerly Newhall Land, is expected to present the Net Zero Newhall initiative at the next Valley Industry Association meeting in April.
April 18: FivePoint to Present NetZero Newhall Initiative at VIA Meeting
A rape suspect accused of faking his illness to avoid trial pleaded guilty Monday in court.
Man Pleads Guilty to Valencia Parking Lot Rape
With the College of the Canyons spring semester in full swing, registration is underway for late start classes to help students meet their academic goals.
COC Adds More Spring Classes
As One Story One City 2017 comes to a close, the Santa Clarita Public Library invites the community to participate in the final events.
Final Week of Events for ‘One Story, One City’
William S. Hart Union High School District is holding its regular Governing Board meeting on Wednesday March 29 at 6 p.m.
March 29: William S. Hart Union H.S.D. Governing Board Meeting
Parents searching for innovative summer programs can now register their children for a creative, fun and unforgettable learning experiences at California State University, Northridge.
CSUN’s Summer Camps Offer Kids a Chance to Play, Learn, Have Fun
The city of Santa Clarita’s Thursdays@Newhall series will head into April with an exciting lineup of Samba dancing, free live performances, an off-road car show, a Best in the West block party and more.
Thursdays@Newhall Continues on Main Street in April
Financial industry giant Milton Berlinski, reality TV trailblazer Mike Darnell and science and technology leader Patricia Maloney are the recipients of CSUN’s 2017 Distinguished Alumni Awards and will be honored at the 19th annual gala event at the Four Seasons Hotel in Westlake Village.
April 29: CSUN Honoring Distinguished Alumni
The 13th annual Santa Clarita Valley Mayor's Prayer Breakfast will focus on the topic of loving god and surviving Hollywood with this years keynote speaker, actor and author Sam Sorbo.
May 4: Mayor’s Prayer Breakfast to Feature Sam Sorbo
The 2017 Santa Clarita Cowboy Festival, presented by Heritage Sierra Medical Group, will offer a wide variety of rocking musical genres to the wildest Western event of the season.
Official Lineup for the 2017 Cowboy Festival
Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department Special Enforcement Bureau Special Weapons Teams responded to an armed barricaded suspect on Sunday.
LASD Responds to Barricaded Suspect, Ends Peacefully
1847 - Probable birth date of Pico Canyon oil driller Charles Alexander Mentry [story]
The 5th Annual SCV Charity Chili Cookoff attracted a capacity crowd to Wolf Creek Brewery on Thursday to raise funds for SRD-Straightening Reins and Spotlight Arts Center.
Chowing Down for Charity
1821 - SCV (with the rest of Alta Calif.) becomes territory of Mexico during war for Mexican independence from Spain [story]
1889 - Castaic School District established [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, an anonymous tipster helped lead deputies to a stolen vehicle arrest. Plus, some junior high students got to try their hand at welding. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, March 24, 2017
The New Heights panel for May will discuss how to build a home studio at a free panel discussion on Wednesday, May 3, 2017 from 7 p.m. to 9 p.m. at The Centre.
May 3: New Heights to Discuss Setting Up a Home Studio
As Tax Day nears, many seniors may get calls or emails from people identifying themselves as Internal Revenue Service or Franchise Tax Board agents – but, in reality, they are crooks looking to make a quick buck.
Seniors Beware: That’s Not the Taxman on The Phone
An anonymous tip to L.A. Crime Stoppers led to a stolen vehicle arrest Thursday night, deputies said.
Anonymous Tip Leads to Arrest of Stolen Vehicle Suspect
California Credit Union has partnered with four school districts in the Santa Clarita Valley in a new “4th Grade Book Buy Program” aimed at encouraging young readers. Through the program, California Credit Union donated 900 books to 36 public elementary schools in the Castaic Union School District, Newhall School District, Saugus Union School District, and Sulphur Springs School District.
California Credit Union, SCV School Districts Partner for 4th Grade Book Buy Program
The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department is very proud of one of LASD's own, Ms. Sandra R. Enslow, our Graphic Arts Coordinator and Lead Forensic Artist.
LASD Employee Wins American Academy of Forensic Sciences Field Award
More than 2 million poisonings are reported each year to poison centers across the United States, according to the American Association of Poison Control Centers. Half of those calls involve children under 6 years old.
Five Ways to Protect your Child from Household Poisons
“Dust,” a collection of Western-themed large scale paintings by contemporary, figurative painter Jorin Bossen, will be on display in the gallery at The MAIN in Old Town Newhall starting Tuesday, April 4, 2017.
‘Dust,’ a Western Themed Art Exhibit, Comes to Old Town Newhall
Castaic/Val Verde Crime Report: Week of March 13, 2017- March 19, 2017
Crime Blotter: Petty Theft, Vehicle Theft in Castaic, Val Verde
Stevenson Ranch Crime Report: Week of 03/13/17 to 03/19/17
Crime Blotter: Vehicle Burglary in Stevenson Ranch
The ACA woes are long-standing and obvious, and addressing them is long overdue. Both political parties need to face reality and unite for corrections. Democrats offer nothing but criticism and fright, while some recalcitrant Republicans obsess with killing the ACA immediately. Both are foolish.
ObamaScare | Commentary by Betty Arenson
1922 - Wyatt Earp's wife thanks William S. Hart for defending her husband's honor [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, a Castaic man accused of domestic violence and murder against his wife has pleaded guilty.. Plus, Castaic Union School District is looking for new members for the Measure QS Citizens Oversight Committee.. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, March 23, 2017
At this New Heights Workshop, digital market expert, Sheri Candler, will walk filmmakers through the important process of audience identification with emphasis on where to find an audience (both online and offline) and the key tools available to filmmakers to capture their audience’s attention and compel that audience to watch their film.
April 12: New Heights Workshop to Focus on Marketing Tips for Indie Filmmakers
Castaic resident Amy Juico had the lucky ticket Wednesday night that won her a brand new 2017 Chevy Cruze LT from AutoNation Chevrolet Valencia.
Castaic Woman Wins ‘WiSH’ Car from AutoNation
Retirees ages 62 and older or those looking to retire soon, are invited by the American Family Funding, a division of American Pacific Mortgage Corporation, to dine and be apart of a workshop where they can learn how a reverse mortgage can provide access to home equity without the monthly payments.
Discovering Reverse Mortgage for Homes of Retirees