[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Judge Orders State Farm to Cut Rates, Issue Refunds | 08-09-2016
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Clear
Clear
64°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
July 29
1983 - U.S. release of "National Lampoon's Vacation;" Magic Mountain is Walley World [story]


departmentofinsurancecommissioner[Consumer Watchdog] – In a major victory for 1.7 million State Farm policyholders, an administrative law judge at the California Department of Insurance has:

* Determined that since at least July 15, 2015, State Farm’s premiums for homeowners insurance have been excessive, ordering the Company to refund policyholders at least $85 million for overcharges collected after July 15, 2015.

* Ordered that going forward, State Farm must decrease its homeowners insurance rates by 7.0%. This would save policyholders nearly $156 million per year.

California Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones, who must decide whether to approve the judge’s decision, has now ordered the judge to determine the proper amount of interest consumers should be paid for any illegal amounts State Farm collected in the past.

“In 1988, California voters passed Proposition 103 to end insurer price-gouging in California,” said lead trial counsel, Todd Foreman, of the Zohar Law Firm in Los Angeles. “Today’s ruling will put millions of dollars back into the pockets of overcharged consumers, demonstrating that consumers are only protected when insurance companies are forced to open their books and justify their rates.”

Under Proposition 103, insurance companies are barred from charging excessive auto, home and business rates. Companies are required to apply for and justify any rate changes before they take effect. The measure also authorizes consumers to request hearings to challenge illegal rates and other insurance practices, as Consumer Watchdog did here. This system has saved Californians over $100 billion since it took effect in 1989, according to a 2013 report by the Consumer Federation of America.

 

State Farm Pleads Poverty

On December 4, 2014, State Farm requested a $73 million increase, effective July 15, 2015, in its home and rental insurance rates. After analyzing the application, Consumer Watchdog concluded that State Farm’s rate increase was unjustified and that its current rates were excessive. It filed a challenge to State Farm’s request on January 1, 2015.

A hearing began before Administrative Law Judge John A. Larsen on November 16, 2015. In his 95 page ruling, Judge Larsen examined all of State Farm’s arguments, as well as evidence presented by experts from Consumer Watchdog and the Consumer Federation of California. State Farm argued that having to reduce its rates would violate its constitutional rights. In response, the consumer groups noted that State Farm had collected $12.22 billion in after-tax profits nationwide between 2010 and 2014 – in 2014 alone, State Farm raked in $4.6 billion in after-tax profits – and that cutting rates would impose no financial hardship. The groups also noted that State Farm had excluded about $105 million in investment returns made by the entire company and was improperly asking policyholders to make up this difference by paying higher rates. Judge Larsen agreed that State Farm’s rights were not violated and rejected State Farm’s proposal to hike rates; the judge criticized State Farm for failing to follow the rules governing excessive rates that all other insurers follow.

“Far from proving it deserved a rate increase, State Farm’s evidence showed that consumers are entitled to relief from the excessive rates they have had to pay for over a year,” said Jonathan Phenix, a staff attorney with Consumer Watchdog. “Simply citing to the Constitution when the evidence is against you, as State Farm did here, won’t carry the day when that evidence shows State Farm collects billions in profits every year.”

 

State Farm Tries to Hide Evidence from the Public

One of Proposition 103’s core reforms requires insurance companies to disclose to the public all the information submitted in support of an application to change their rates. Flouting this requirement, State Farm asked Judge Larsen to deviate from the formula used to calculate insurance rates and conceal from public scrutiny evidence that didn’t support State Farm’s argument. However, Judge Larsen declined to follow State Farm’s argument and found that Proposition 103’s sunshine provision guaranteed the public’s right to access to documents that support of a rate change. “[I]f cost and pricing information were required to be kept confidential as a trade secret,” Judge Larsen wrote, “little actuarial data in rate hearings would be left for the public to inspect. Such a result would undermine Proposition 103.”

“Insurance coverage is compulsory for most homeowners, so the question isn’t about whether consumers should buy insurance; it’s how much they will pay for that coverage,” said Harvey Rosenfield, the author of Proposition 103 and one of Consumer Watchdog’s lawyers in the case. “This is why the voters insisted that insurance companies and the Department of Insurance review rates in a transparent way, rather than behind closed doors like they used to. As today’s ruling recognizes, insurers must justify their rates to the public.”

 

State Farm’s History of Proposing Overcharges

This year alone, Consumer Watchdog has challenged two other excessive rate changes proposed by State Farm. In April, Consumer Watchdog challenged State Farm’s across-the-board rate hikes on small businesses after finding the insurer’s current rates for commercial property and liability insurance were excessive. And earlier this month, Consumer Watchdog alleged that State Farm will overcharge policyholders for insurance that covers dwellings occupied by tenants by as much as $100 million unless it cuts its current rates by up to 40%.

State Farm has a long history of proposing rates that later turned out to be unjustifiable. Since 2006, including the savings from today’s decision, Consumer Watchdog has saved California renters and homeowners with State Farm insurance more than $749 million by challenging State Farm’s excessive rate proposals.

History of State Farm’s Rate Changes in Homeowners Insurance

Year

Rate Changes Proposed (Overall)

Rate Changes Implemented (Overall)

Savings to State Farm Policyholders

2006

0%

-20%

$266 million

2011

0%

-12.6%

$157 million

2013

6.9%

-1.2%

$86 million

2016

6.9%

-7.0%

$235 million

In the current proceeding involving State Farm’s homeowners rates, Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones has asked that Judge Larsen consider how much interest, if any, consumers should get along with their refunds. Once Judge Larsen makes this finding, Commissioner Jones will then decide whether to approve the ruling issued by Judge Larsen. State Farm has already said it will appeal an adverse ruling.

Read the Administrative Law Judge’s decision and the Commissioner’s August 8, 2016 order regarding calculation of interest rates on the refunds:http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/resources/noticeofnonadoptionofpd.pdf

Read Consumer Watchdog’s April 11, 2016 brief in support of rate refunds and decreases for State Farm’s customers: http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/resources/4-11-16cwdopeningbriefpublicredacted.pdf

Read more about Proposition 103: http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/focusarea/prop-103-california-insurance-reform

 

About Consumer Watchdog and Zohar Law Firm, P.C.

Consumer Watchdog is a non-profit non-partisan organization.  It has invoked the public participation process under Proposition 103 to save auto, home and medical malpractice insurance policyholders over $3 billion since 2003.

Consumer Watchdog’s trial counsel in this proceeding are Todd Foreman and Daniel Y. Zohar of the Zohar Law Firm, P.C. in Los Angeles. The Zohar Law Firm has achieved landmark successes in prior rate hearings, saving consumers hundreds of millions of dollars, and also handles business and entertainment litigation throughoutCalifornia.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

9 Comments

  1. Theresa McGrath Cowdray

  2. chuck dimes says:

    Don’t mess with the Zohar

  3. Dee says:

    When will I get our refund plus interest!

Leave a Comment


LOCAL BUSINESS LINKS
LOCAL BUSINESS HEADLINES
FINANCIALS OF LOCAL INTEREST
MARKETS & METALS
NASDAQ6374.6768  chart -0.12%
S&P 5002472.10  chart -0.13%
STOCKS OF LOCAL INTEREST
Bank Santa Clarita15.72  chart +0.00%
Biosolar, Inc.0.0399  chart -9.32%
Sierra Bancorp26.65  chart -0.74%
Cu Bancorp (ca)36.70  chart -0.94%
Enable Ipc Corp0.001  chart +0.00%
Flex Ltd. - Ordinary Shares16.29  chart -4.68%
Linn Energy Llc Unit Repstg Ltd0.096  chart +0.00%
Linn Co Llc Com Shs Repstg Ltd 0.0431  chart +0.00%
Mannkind Corporation1.32  chart +3.12%
Mission Vly Bcp Ca13.86  chart -1.00%
Quest Diagnostics Incorporated109.51  chart +0.48%
Tejon Ranch Co20.99  chart -0.52%
Us Energy Initiative0.0004  chart +0.00%
Wesco Aircraft Holdings, Inc.10.65  chart +1.91%

Apple Inc.149.50  chart -0.70%
At&t Inc.39.00  chart -1.04%
Autonation, Inc.42.65  chart +0.90%
Best Buy Co., Inc.57.64  chart +1.03%
Big Lots, Inc.50.43  chart +0.34%
Barnes & Noble, Inc.8.20  chart +0.61%
Brady Corporation33.15  chart -0.75%
Boston Scientific Corporation27.01  chart -0.15%
N/a24  chart +0.00%
Cbre Group Inc Class A37.63  chart -0.16%
Carnival Corporation66.40  chart +0.09%
Comcast Corporation39.52  chart +0.23%
Costco Wholesale Corporation152.89  chart +0.24%
Curtiss-wright Corporation98.26  chart +1.07%
Cvs Health Corporation79.75  chart +1.05%
Cemex, S.a.b. De C.v. Sponsored9.61  chart +0.21%
D.r. Horton, Inc.35.85  chart -0.61%
Walt Disney Company (the)109.96  chart -0.04%
Edison International78.25  chart -1.22%
Hyatt Hotels Corporation Class 55.43  chart +0.45%
Home Depot, Inc. (the)148.08  chart +0.24%
Kb Home23.04  chart -0.43%
Kroger Company (the)24.28  chart +1.38%
Lennar Corporation Class A52.43  chart -1.13%
Laboratory Corporation Of Ameri160.07  chart -0.02%
Linn Energy Llc Unit Repstg Ltd0.096  chart +0.00%
Linn Co Llc Com Shs Repstg Ltd 0.0431  chart +0.00%
Lowe's Companies, Inc.76.48  chart -0.68%
Marriott International103.34  chart -0.69%
Mcdonald's Corporation155.85  chart -0.70%
Mitsubishi Ufj Financial Group,6.30  chart +0.00%
Netflix, Inc.184.04  chart +0.74%
Office Depot, Inc.5.76  chart -2.04%
Rite Aid Corporation2.28  chart -1.72%
Rexford Industrial Realty, Inc.28.19  chart +0.14%
Regal Entertainment Group Class19.26  chart +0.05%
Ross Stores, Inc.54.87  chart -0.45%
Republic Services, Inc.64.30  chart -1.68%
N/aN/A  chartN/A
Starbucks Corporation54.00  chart -9.24%
Smart & Final Stores, Inc.8.75  chart +0.57%
Sears Holdings Corporation9.21  chart -0.97%
Six Flags Entertainment Corpora57.99  chart +1.75%
Sonova N156.10  chart -0.13%
Staples, Inc.10.14  chart -0.39%
Sunpower Corporation11.35  chart +2.90%
Target Corporation56.11  chart +0.11%
Time Warner Cable Inc209.56  chart -0.21%
Ulta Beauty, Inc.248.60  chart -0.33%
Walgreens Boots Alliance, Inc.79.62  chart +1.07%
Waste Connections, Inc.65.06  chart -1.15%
Whole Foods Market, Inc.41.82  chart +0.10%
Waste Management, Inc.74.80  chart -0.86%
Wal-mart Stores, Inc.79.81  chart +0.04%
Woodward, Inc.70.27  chart -0.23%
CURRENCY CONVERTER

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1983 - U.S. release of "National Lampoon's Vacation;" Magic Mountain is Walley World [story]
Vendor applications are now available for the city of Santa Clarita’s 26th Annual Fine Craft Show outdoors at Old Orchard Park in Valencia on Saturday and Sunday, November 18-19.
Fine Craft Show Vendor Sign-Ups Now Available
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Public Health is reporting that several rabid bats have been found in Santa Clarita recently. Plus, check out some of these weekend events. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, July 28, 2017
A new front in Los Angeles County’s battle against homelessness was launched today with an innovative program aimed at encouraging cities to join forces more strongly in confronting this escalating humanitarian crisis.
New County Program Enlists Cities in Homelessness Fight
A few tickets are left for the Friends of Hart Park's exciting and entertaining “Silents Under the Stars” fundraiser at William S. Hart Park in Newhall on Saturday, July 29 starting at 6 p.m.
July 29: Hart’s 1919 ‘Wagon Tracks’ Screens on ‘Silents Under the Stars’
Lisa Hamblen Jaserie, a former Top 10 recording artist, horse breeder, music company CEO and longtime Friends of Hart Park board member, died at her home in Friendly Valley Tuesday morning, surrounded by members of her large family. She was 79.
Lisa Hamblen Jaserie, Longtime Friend of Hart Park, Dead at 79
Los Angeles County Sheriff Jim McDonnell, Tulare County Sheriff Mike Boudreaux and California Attorney General Xavier Becerra held a news conference today to announce breakup of a major West Coast human trafficking ring.
Attorney General, Sheriffs Break Up Major Human Trafficking Case
Blues-rock singer and guitar slinger Jim Gibson headlines the Valencia Jazz & Blues concert on the street outside the Hyatt Regency Valencia tonight starting at 7 p.m.
July 28: Jim Gibson at Valencia Jazz & Blues
The city of Santa Clarita’s Thursdays@Newhall series cruises into August with a lineup of fun, entertaining and interactive events.
Hot August Nights Ahead on Thursdays@Newhall
CalArts Provost Emeritus Beverly O'Neill passed away on Sunday, July 16, after a long illness.
CalArts Provost Emeritus Beverly O’Neill Dies
California State Parks is offering the public tips on how to access the Golden State’s new reservation system, ReserveCalifornia, starting Tuesday, August 1.
August 1: State Launches New Parks Reservation System
County Supervisor Kathryn Barger blasted a Superior Court judge for denying the county's request Friday for a temporary restraining order to block gas reinjection at the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage facility.
Barger Blasts Judge for Denying Aliso Canyon TRO
Air quality will be unhealthy for sensitive individuals in the Santa Clarita Valley on Saturday, according to an alert from the South Coast Air Quality Management District.
SCV Air Quality Unhealthy Saturday
The Castaic Lake Water Agency's Water Resources Committee is scheduled to meet Wednesday, August 2, 2017 at 5:30 p.m. in the Training Room at the Santa Clarita Water Division, 26521 Summitt Circle, Santa Clarita 91350.
August 2: CLWA Water Resources Committee Meeting
A jury is now deliberating the innocence or guilt of a Newhall man charged with murdering his wife in 2015.
Jury Deliberating Fate of Newhall Man Charged with Murdering Wife
The number of rabid bats in Los Angeles County has grown by 50 percent from July 18, when there were 12 reported for the year to the current count of 18, 12 of them in the Santa Clarita Valley.
SCV Rabid Bat Reports Increase in 2017
Collin Ferguson continued his hot hitting in his short time with the JetHawks, but Lancaster dropped the series opener to the San Jose Giants, 7-3, on Thursday night at The Hangar.
Ferguson Stays Hot, But JetHawks Drop Opener Thursday
The city of Santa Clarita has canceled the Planning Commission Regular Meeting scheduled for Tuesday, August 1, according to a memo from the office of Jason Crawford, city planning manager.
Planning Commission Cancels August 1 Meeting
The FDA announced a new comprehensive plan for tobacco and nicotine regulation that will serve as a multi-year roadmap to better protect kids and significantly reduce tobacco-related disease and death.
FDA Targets Nicotine in Fighting Tobacco-Related Disease
1938 - Newhall Tunnel cut away, replaced by Sierra Highway [story]
After nearly a decade, a performing arts center is in sight for students at Saugus High School.
Saugus High School Performing Arts Center Nearing its Completion
The Los Angeles County Metro Board of Directors unanimously approved a motion by Supervisor Kathryn Barger and co-authored by Director Ara Najarian to conduct an in-depth study of the northern segment of the Metrolink Antelope Valley Line.
Supes Approve In-Depth Study of Metrolink AV Line
Come to the 8th annual Burrito Bowl on August 22nd at the top of Town Center Drive to cheer for your favorite local high school Football team - and support them by purchasing a raffle ticket prior to the event.
Aug. 22: Annual Burrito Bowl to Benefit Local Student Groups
In 2015, according to the US Census, there were 47.7 million Americans ages 65 and older.
SCV Seniors Needing Financial Help Will Soon Get Their Wish
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, deputies arrested a teenage girl on suspicion of attempted murder Wednesday afternoon. Plus, get a sneak peek at Saugus High School's Performing Arts Center. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, July 27, 2017
On Friday, August 4, the City of Santa Clarita will begin installation of a new pre-fabricated steel truss pedestrian bridge across McBean Parkway between Gamble House Court and Arroyo Park Drive.
Aug. 4: New Pedestrian Bridge McBean Parkway; Expect Delays
Drowning is one of the major causes of accidents resulting in serious injury and death in children.
Summer Safety Tips from SCV Sheriff’s Station
LA County Library, along with Acton Agua Dulce Library, will join more than 1,000 libraries across the country, to celebrate the celestial event of the century, the August 21, 2017 Solar Eclipse.
Acton Agua Dulce Library to Take Part in Solar Eclipse 2017 Event
Longtime Santa Clarita resident Steve Hanauer - the “Steve” in Steve’s Valencia Florist - died Wednesday night from complications stemming from a fall he sustained the previous day.
Steve Hanauer, Longtime SCV Florist, Dies at 76
The Lancaster JetHawks dropped the rubber game of a three-game series to the Rancho Cucamonga Quakes, 3-2, on a walk-off single in the ninth inning on Wednesday night at LoanMart Field.
JetHawks Drop Rubber Game on Walk-Off Single
For College of the Canyons students grappling with mental health issues, immediate support is now just a text away.
Crisis Text Line Now Available for Students Struggling With Mental Health Issues
The William S. Hart Union High School District announces its policy to serve nutritious meals every school day under the National School Lunch Program and/or School Breakfast Program.
Hart Releases Fees For Free and Reduced-Price Food Program
Four College of the Canyons programs have been ranked by California Community Colleges (CCC) as Strong Workforce Stars, a new annual commendation for career education programs whose students show significant gains in social mobility and earning power.
Several COC Programs Make “Strong Workforce Stars” List
You may know Fargo and you may even know The Music Man, but do you know Don’t Hug Me?
July 29-Aug. 26: Musical Written by Local Playwright Comes to Santa Clarita
Deputies arrested a teenage girl for attempted murder Wednesday afternoon in the Shadow Pines neighborhood of Canyon Country.
Teenager Arrested on Suspicion of Attempted Murder
Here is the Valencia ( Zone 5) Public Safety and Crime Prevention Information for 07/03/2017 to 07/16/2017:
Crime Blotter: Grand Theft Auto, Arson, Attempted Residential Burglary in Valencia