header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
March 28
1934 - Bouquet Canyon Reservoir, replacement for ill-fated St. Francis Dam & reservoir, begins to fill with water [story]
Bouquet Reservoir


departmentofinsurancecommissioner[Consumer Watchdog] – In a major victory for 1.7 million State Farm policyholders, an administrative law judge at the California Department of Insurance has:

* Determined that since at least July 15, 2015, State Farm’s premiums for homeowners insurance have been excessive, ordering the Company to refund policyholders at least $85 million for overcharges collected after July 15, 2015.

* Ordered that going forward, State Farm must decrease its homeowners insurance rates by 7.0%. This would save policyholders nearly $156 million per year.

California Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones, who must decide whether to approve the judge’s decision, has now ordered the judge to determine the proper amount of interest consumers should be paid for any illegal amounts State Farm collected in the past.

“In 1988, California voters passed Proposition 103 to end insurer price-gouging in California,” said lead trial counsel, Todd Foreman, of the Zohar Law Firm in Los Angeles. “Today’s ruling will put millions of dollars back into the pockets of overcharged consumers, demonstrating that consumers are only protected when insurance companies are forced to open their books and justify their rates.”

Under Proposition 103, insurance companies are barred from charging excessive auto, home and business rates. Companies are required to apply for and justify any rate changes before they take effect. The measure also authorizes consumers to request hearings to challenge illegal rates and other insurance practices, as Consumer Watchdog did here. This system has saved Californians over $100 billion since it took effect in 1989, according to a 2013 report by the Consumer Federation of America.

 

State Farm Pleads Poverty

On December 4, 2014, State Farm requested a $73 million increase, effective July 15, 2015, in its home and rental insurance rates. After analyzing the application, Consumer Watchdog concluded that State Farm’s rate increase was unjustified and that its current rates were excessive. It filed a challenge to State Farm’s request on January 1, 2015.

A hearing began before Administrative Law Judge John A. Larsen on November 16, 2015. In his 95 page ruling, Judge Larsen examined all of State Farm’s arguments, as well as evidence presented by experts from Consumer Watchdog and the Consumer Federation of California. State Farm argued that having to reduce its rates would violate its constitutional rights. In response, the consumer groups noted that State Farm had collected $12.22 billion in after-tax profits nationwide between 2010 and 2014 – in 2014 alone, State Farm raked in $4.6 billion in after-tax profits – and that cutting rates would impose no financial hardship. The groups also noted that State Farm had excluded about $105 million in investment returns made by the entire company and was improperly asking policyholders to make up this difference by paying higher rates. Judge Larsen agreed that State Farm’s rights were not violated and rejected State Farm’s proposal to hike rates; the judge criticized State Farm for failing to follow the rules governing excessive rates that all other insurers follow.

“Far from proving it deserved a rate increase, State Farm’s evidence showed that consumers are entitled to relief from the excessive rates they have had to pay for over a year,” said Jonathan Phenix, a staff attorney with Consumer Watchdog. “Simply citing to the Constitution when the evidence is against you, as State Farm did here, won’t carry the day when that evidence shows State Farm collects billions in profits every year.”

 

State Farm Tries to Hide Evidence from the Public

One of Proposition 103’s core reforms requires insurance companies to disclose to the public all the information submitted in support of an application to change their rates. Flouting this requirement, State Farm asked Judge Larsen to deviate from the formula used to calculate insurance rates and conceal from public scrutiny evidence that didn’t support State Farm’s argument. However, Judge Larsen declined to follow State Farm’s argument and found that Proposition 103’s sunshine provision guaranteed the public’s right to access to documents that support of a rate change. “[I]f cost and pricing information were required to be kept confidential as a trade secret,” Judge Larsen wrote, “little actuarial data in rate hearings would be left for the public to inspect. Such a result would undermine Proposition 103.”

“Insurance coverage is compulsory for most homeowners, so the question isn’t about whether consumers should buy insurance; it’s how much they will pay for that coverage,” said Harvey Rosenfield, the author of Proposition 103 and one of Consumer Watchdog’s lawyers in the case. “This is why the voters insisted that insurance companies and the Department of Insurance review rates in a transparent way, rather than behind closed doors like they used to. As today’s ruling recognizes, insurers must justify their rates to the public.”

 

State Farm’s History of Proposing Overcharges

This year alone, Consumer Watchdog has challenged two other excessive rate changes proposed by State Farm. In April, Consumer Watchdog challenged State Farm’s across-the-board rate hikes on small businesses after finding the insurer’s current rates for commercial property and liability insurance were excessive. And earlier this month, Consumer Watchdog alleged that State Farm will overcharge policyholders for insurance that covers dwellings occupied by tenants by as much as $100 million unless it cuts its current rates by up to 40%.

State Farm has a long history of proposing rates that later turned out to be unjustifiable. Since 2006, including the savings from today’s decision, Consumer Watchdog has saved California renters and homeowners with State Farm insurance more than $749 million by challenging State Farm’s excessive rate proposals.

History of State Farm’s Rate Changes in Homeowners Insurance

Year

Rate Changes Proposed (Overall)

Rate Changes Implemented (Overall)

Savings to State Farm Policyholders

2006

0%

-20%

$266 million

2011

0%

-12.6%

$157 million

2013

6.9%

-1.2%

$86 million

2016

6.9%

-7.0%

$235 million

In the current proceeding involving State Farm’s homeowners rates, Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones has asked that Judge Larsen consider how much interest, if any, consumers should get along with their refunds. Once Judge Larsen makes this finding, Commissioner Jones will then decide whether to approve the ruling issued by Judge Larsen. State Farm has already said it will appeal an adverse ruling.

Read the Administrative Law Judge’s decision and the Commissioner’s August 8, 2016 order regarding calculation of interest rates on the refunds:http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/resources/noticeofnonadoptionofpd.pdf

Read Consumer Watchdog’s April 11, 2016 brief in support of rate refunds and decreases for State Farm’s customers: http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/resources/4-11-16cwdopeningbriefpublicredacted.pdf

Read more about Proposition 103: http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/focusarea/prop-103-california-insurance-reform

 

About Consumer Watchdog and Zohar Law Firm, P.C.

Consumer Watchdog is a non-profit non-partisan organization.  It has invoked the public participation process under Proposition 103 to save auto, home and medical malpractice insurance policyholders over $3 billion since 2003.

Consumer Watchdog’s trial counsel in this proceeding are Todd Foreman and Daniel Y. Zohar of the Zohar Law Firm, P.C. in Los Angeles. The Zohar Law Firm has achieved landmark successes in prior rate hearings, saving consumers hundreds of millions of dollars, and also handles business and entertainment litigation throughoutCalifornia.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

9 Comments

  1. Theresa McGrath Cowdray

  2. chuck dimes says:

    Don’t mess with the Zohar

  3. Dee says:

    When will I get our refund plus interest!

Leave a Comment


Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Los Angeles County Public Works is updating the Los Angeles County Bicycle Master Plan.
April 16:  County Bicycle Master Plan Virtual Community Meeting
College of the Canyons mens golf got back on track during its return to conference play on Monday, carding a five-man score of 370 to top the eight-team field at Brookside Golf Course and maintain its unblemished conference mark.
Cougars Win Again, Keep Conference Streak
Los Angeles County Treasurer and Tax Collector, reminds property owners that the second installment of the 2023-24 Annual Secured Property Taxes becomes  delinquent if not received by 5 p.m. Pacific Time or United States Postal Service postmarked on or before Wednesday, April 10, 2024.
County Treasurer Reminds Property Owners of April 10 Due Date
Local nonprofit Fostering Youth Independence is seeking “Allies” to support Santa Clarita youth who are aging out of the L.A. County foster care system.
April 16: FYI Seeks Volunteers To Pair With Local Foster Youth
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health today unveiled the latest L.A. County Health Survey, which gathers vital data on health behaviors, conditions, neighborhood settings, and the needs of L.A .County residents, informing future public health policies and programs.
Public Health Unveils the 2023 L.A. County Health Survey Findings
Due to the projected rain forecast, Eggstravaganza will now be held indoors at the Canyon Country Community Center beginning promptly at 10 a.m. on March 30.
March 30: Eggstravaganza Now Being Held Indoors at Canyon Country Community Center
To support the mental health of California's young people, the California Department of Public Health awarded $25 million to 28 tribal and community-based organizations across the state.
California Announces $25 Million in Awards for Youth Mental Health
The College of the Canyons Athletic Department will host a dedication ceremony to unveil the Michele Jenkins Softball Team Room in honor of the longtime board member and ardent softball program supporter’s nearly 40 years of service to the district.
April 16: COC to Host Michele Jenkins Team Room Dedication Ceremony
PFLAG Santa Clarita has announced the establishment of the Peggy and Jeff Stabile PFLAG SCV Scholarship. The scholarship will provide financial assistance to LGBTQIA+ students pursuing higher education and committed to advocating for LGBTQIA+ rights and promoting diversity and inclusion.
PFLAG SCV Announces Stabile PFLAG Scholarship
1934 - Bouquet Canyon Reservoir, replacement for ill-fated St. Francis Dam & reservoir, begins to fill with water [story]
Bouquet Reservoir
The California Department of Public Health launched the “Never a Bother” campaign, a youth suicide prevention public awareness and outreach campaign for youth, young adults, and their parents, caregivers, and allies.
California Launches New Youth Suicide Prevention Campaign
The Santa Clarita Master Chorale invites the community to "Let the Sunshine In," a delightful evening of food, wine and song at the annual Cabaret & Cabernet fundraising benefit.
April 20: Santa Clarita Master Chorale’s Cabaret, Cabernet Fundraiser
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health cautions residents who are planning to visit the below Los Angeles County beaches to avoid swimming, surfing, and playing in ocean waters:
March 27 Ocean Water Warning
As an integral ingredient necessary to help the Santa Clarita Valley to flourish, feedback from the business community is the secret sauce for achieving great things.
SCVEDC Asks For the Business Community’s Opinion on Santa Clarita
Raise your heart rate while raising funds for the Santa Clarita Sister Cities Dollars-for-Desks campaign to provide school desks for students in Sariaya, Santa Clarita's Sister City in the Philippines.
April 13: Sister Cities Zumba-thon Fundraiser
Remo, Inc. is is the world's leading manufacturer and developer of synthetic drumheads and shells. They’ve been in business for 60 years
SCVEDC Company Spotlight: Drumming Up Big Business with Remo, Inc.
California State Assemblywoman Pilar Schiavo (D-Chatsworth) and Assemblyman James Ramos (D-Highland) have introduced AB 3074 the "School or athletic team names: California Racial Mascots Act."
Schiavo Introduces Bill to Prohibit ‘Derogatory’ School Mascot Names
Los Angeles County’s Justice, Care and Opportunities Department  in collaboration with Local Initiatives Support Corporation Los Angeles is proud to announce the 2nd Annual Pitch Competition for the cohorts of JCOD's Incubation Academy.
March 28: JCOD Incubation Academy Helps Grassroots Non-Profits For the Second Year
Children’s Bureau is seeking foster families and now offers two virtual ways for individuals and/or couples to learn how to help children in foster care while reunifying with birth families or how to provide legal permanency by adoption.
April 18: Children’s Bureau Hosts Virtual Orientation
The Sunburst track was constructed in 1887 by the Southern Pacific Railroad and was a part of the main line running between San Francisco and Los Angeles.
Enjoy Spring With a Ride On The Sunburst Track
California State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond hosted a Personal Finance Summit today where he announced his support for Assembly Bill 2927 (McCarty), legislation that would require a personal finance education course for California high school graduation.
State Superintendent Announces Support for Personal Finance Graduation Requirement
1847 - Probable birth date of Pico Canyon oil driller Charles Alexander Mentry [story]
C.A. Mentry
The first Music Jam Session at The MAIN was held on Thursday, Feb. 22 and was a hit. Come out and join in for the next one on Thursday, March 28 7 p.m.-9 p.m.
March 28: The MAIN to Host Musicians’ Jam Session
SCVNews.com