[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: Chartering a Way Forward | Commentary by Mark Distaso | 08-30-2016
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Clear
Clear
60°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
March 30
1993 - Federal govt. declares coastal California gnatcatcher (bird) a threatened species [story]


markdistasoThis article is written in response to the commentary of Aug. 22 by Ken Pfalzgraf on SCVNews.com in regard to the Acton Agua Dulce Unified School District and its charter schools.

Pfalzgraf laid out a series of facts to support his apparent disagreement with the district’s charter school efforts; however, in doing so, he left out a number of significant facts in an apparent attempt to justify his opposition to the district’s direction. When all of the facts are included, a much different picture appears.

In his commentary, Pfalzgraf described AADUSD’s operation of charter schools as not yet being “legally or legislatively validated,” which belies the actual facts. As of today, the legal issue has been legally resolved, since the district ultimately prevailed in the courts at both the trial and appellate level (Newhall School District v. AADUSD re: the Albert Einstein Academy).

As for the legislative perspective, the Legislature is divided on the issue of existing charter school law, as it comes under immense pressure from traditional school districts that are threatened by the existence of charter schools. It has become a complicated political issue on a number of levels that seem to have perplexed the Legislature – and this dynamic does not lend itself to a simplified black-and-white issue that Pfalzgraf would have the reader believe.

Pfalzgraf addressed that the Joint Legislative Audit Committee considered an audit of three school districts that authorize charter schools, one of those being AADUSD, and he intimated that with the hundreds of school districts in the state, AADUSD must be doing something wrong to undergo an audit. Again, the audit committee’s effort is part of that complicated political issue underway in the state as it relates to charter schools.

There are two points of interest for the reader to know: First, the audit committee voted 7 to 6 to approve that the audit process take place – with the split vote on the matter serving as a reflection of the divide within the Legislature and the pressure the lawmakers are under. Second, Assurance Learning Academy, an authorized charter of the district, is one of the schools targeted by the audit – the claim being that ALA does not meet the academic progress of its students under the Education Code.

However, what Pfalzgraf either does not know or failed to mention is that the ALA charter school was specifically designed to target at-risk youth who have dropped out of high school (including those incarcerated or previously incarcerated) in an effort to provide them with an avenue to recover academic credits. Because of its target population, ALA does not operate under the standard accountability model within the Education Code. Instead, it operates under the Alternative Schools Accountability Model. ASAM was designed by none other than by the California Department of Education to service this at-risk youth population and is enumerated under sections 52051.5 through 52052.9 of the Education Code, with emphasis under section 52052(g).

In developing ASAM, the CDE recognized that this at-risk youth population attending an alternative education program could not be compared to a traditional comprehensive high school program or traditional standardized test scores. With this said, it stands to reason that an at-risk youth population would have lower standardized test scores than a regular high school accountability model. While ALA certainly serves a population outside of the Acton-Agua Dulce area, it also serves as a valuable resource for numerous local youth living in our town. The district is confident the state audit will be favorable to ALA.

It is Pfalzgraf’s claim that the district operates on the “outer fringe of the charter school game,” and he insinuates that the district is making up for lost state funding by “taking a cut” off of the charters it sponsors. However, he makes no mention of why the district has authorized its charter schools beyond some perceived money grab.

Let’s place this matter into perspective: The AADUSD school board initiated our charter school efforts in part because a sizable number of parents in Acton-Agua Dulce were demanding a charter school alternative within our district boundaries.

With all of the talk about district-authorized charters far away from our borders, let us not forget that we provide an entire school campus locally for the Albert Einstein Academy to operate. We as a district demonstrated the courage to authorize a local charter school in order to provide choice to our students and parents – courage that other districts have failed to show.

In addition, several years ago, when the state introduced its new funding formula (Local Control Funding Formula or LCFF), it significantly reduced funding to all school districts in the state. AADUSD alone lost approximately $500,000 in the first year of LCFF. In addition to this new state funding model containing funding reductions, the model itself was not fully capitalized. To this day, it is only at 90 percent of what should be funded.

Add to this fact the recent California Supreme Court decision leaving in place an appellate court ruling under Robles-Wong v. State of California that the California Constitution does not guarantee the right to an adequate level of education in terms of funding or quality, and you are left with school districts up and down the state struggling to provide quality education programming to their students.

Instead of the district operating on the “outer fringe” as described by Pfalzgraf, I characterize the district as operating on the “cutting edge” of educational practice. The district and its charter school partners are looking at an unprecedented model of cooperation to share and leverage scarce fiscal and physical infrastructure resources so we can enhance the level of education that otherwise could not be experienced by the children of Acton-Agua Dulce while attending a small school district.

At the close of his commentary, Pfalzgraf suggests the district needs to refocus on its own children. Since he does attend board meetings often, I’m mystified as to why Pfalzgraf has not picked up on the following programs and efforts that have enhanced the educational experience for our local children:

* The school board recently implemented a five-year plan that includes the introduction of a fully articulated STEAM (Science-Technology-Arts-Engineering-Math) education program funded in part by our charter schools.

* As part of the district’s effort to introduce a STEAM curriculum through virtually all grade levels, the school board also directed a reduction in class size to an intermediate goal ratio of 1 teacher to 28 students, with a the ultimate goal of 1:24 (as the state will require in five years). This is an expensive proposition, since it includes the need to create more classrooms and additional teachers, and it could not be realized without funding from our charter schools.

* The district has introduced a transitional kindergarten program that is supported by Community Collaborative Charter School through its covering of the cost of the teacher.

* In partnership with Assurance Learning Academy, the district is able to provide summer school for our high school students in need of credit recovery. The district has historically provided summer credit recovery, but can it now do so at significantly less cost after partnering with ALA.

* As of this past summer, thanks to a partnership with Community Collaborative, the district was able to resurrect its K-8 summer school program – a program that was cut years ago due to state budget cuts.

* Prior to our collaboration with Assurance Learning Academy, when the district had a rare occasion to expel students for severe behavioral issues, we had to outcast them to another school district. Today, we have the option of placing them with ALA, allowing the district to keep closer tabs on these students in order to insure compliance with our behavior contract and reevaluate them in one year for suitability to be readmitted back into our schools.

* In partnership with ALA, Community Collaborative and Pathways charter schools, the district is on the cusp of introducing a vocational track education program at Vasquez High School for our students who are not drawn to attending a university. While vocational and skills training were removed from high schools in California decades ago due to a lack of funding, it is AADUSD, with one of the smallest high schools in the region, which is taking the initiative to reinstitute such an educational option. Why? Because parents and students have been asking for such a program. This is an effort that will benefit our students and one that can be realized only through partnership with our charter schools.

As to the sustainability of the district’s budget, any inference that the district has failed to consider its sustainability if any portion of charter school funding is lost would be false. As with any responsible budget development process, the district has a strategy to expand or contract services, depending on available funding resources. In addition, the district is working on leveraging available federal dollars to support and maintain our enhanced educational efforts – specifically as they apply to our vocational track education initiative.

In closing, I urge all three candidates who are seeking a vacant seat on the AADUSD Board of Governors to ensure they include all facts and represent them accurately if they use any set of facts to support a position or opinion. While all citizens, including candidates for office, have a welcomed right to express dissenting opinions on the solutions, direction and policies currently in place by the district, I again urge all the candidates who take a dissenting viewpoint please to offer a specific set of alternative solutions, direction and policies to replace those they disagree with.

The voting public is owed that much.

 

Mark Distaso is president of the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District Governing Board. His statements reflect his own opinions and are not intended to represent those of other school board members.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

1 Comment

  1. Tracy Costan says:

    So refreshing to read a coherent, accurate article vs. the ramblings of someone’s personal platform with no plan or solution. Thank you to AADUSD for giving the community a choice in schools and a vision for the future.

Leave a Comment


Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Related Content
RECENT COMMENTARY
Friday, Mar 24, 2017
The ACA woes are long-standing and obvious, and addressing them is long overdue. Both political parties need to face reality and unite for corrections. Democrats offer nothing but criticism and fright, while some recalcitrant Republicans obsess with killing the ACA immediately. Both are foolish.
Thursday, Mar 23, 2017
Many flowers are pollinated by insects, so there is nothing unusual there for the poppies, which are indeed fertilized by insects. What is more unusual is the kind of insects that play an important part in doing this job. It seems the actual pollinator is...
Wednesday, Mar 22, 2017
Despite Trump’s lies, tens of millions will lose insurance, huge premium spikes will hit older and middle-class Americans hard, and low-income children and the disabled will have their health care taken away.
Friday, Mar 17, 2017
Fifteen California community colleges have the option to offer bachelor’s degrees as part of a pilot program created in 2014 by Senate Bill 850, which sought to provide more educational options to help high school graduates get the training required to enter a competitive job market. Senate Bill 769 by Sen. Jerry Hill would expand the pilot program and allow community colleges to offer multiple bachelor’s degree programs in areas where the CSU system is unable to meet the need.
Thursday, Mar 16, 2017
One of my favorite destinations in Death Valley National Park is located in Wildrose Canyon, where you will find what are believed to be the best known surviving examples of charcoal kilns in the western states - plus a great hiking trail and campground.
Wednesday, Mar 15, 2017
Having practiced pharmacy for many years, I often find myself talking to people about their Medicare prescription drug, or Part D, plans. A first step to correcting problems is always to contact your drug plan. If that doesn’t work, you can file a complaint.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1993 - Federal govt. declares coastal California gnatcatcher (bird) a threatened species [story]
Cherise Moore was selected Wednesday night to fill a vacant seat on the William S. Hart Union High School District governing board. In a 3-1 vote, board members made the selection after hearing from five candidates who applied for the position.
Hart Board Picks Educator to Fill Vacancy
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, City Council endorsed a bill that would completely reorganize how resident's buy water. Plus, a look inside the Gibbon Conservation Center. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, March 29, 2017
Novelist Antoine Wilson has been named the recipient of California State University, Northridge’s inaugural San Fernando Valley Award for Fiction.
CSUN’s Oviatt Library Awards Inaugural Fiction Award to Antoine Wilson
A Santa Clarita City Council discussion about SB 634, which would completely reorganize how residents buy water, led to more than three hours of discussion, and ultimately, an endorsement.
Council Backs Water Merger After Long Discussion
Commander Roosevelt Johnson of the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station announced at Tuesday's City Council meeting that his last station “patrol” will be Saturday.
SCV Sheriff’s Station Captain Announces Final ‘Patrol’
Al-Umma Center of Santa Clarita Valley, the Islamic Center of Santa Clarita Valley, and the Santa Clarita Valley Interfaith Council invite the community of the Santa Clarita Valley, and all other interested citizens, to a Santa Clarita Community Forum: “Building Strength through Diversity.”
April 15: Community Forum to Discuss ‘Building Strength through Diversity’
Actor and CalArts alumna Condola Rashad (Theater BFA 08) joins Laurie Metcalf, Chris Cooper and Jayne Houdyshell onstage for a Broadway production of Lucas Hnath's A Doll's House, Part 2, with previews starting on March 30 at John Golden Theatre in New York.
CalArts Alum in Broadway Production of A Doll’s House, Part 2
Princess Cruises has announced the newest additions to the Encounters with Discovery at Sea speaker series program.
Princess Cruises Reveals 2017 Encounters with Discovery at Sea Program
Since his debut in 2014, Jason Karkenny has been known more for his right arm than anything else. Along the way he's thrown a perfect game and become the winningest pitcher in program history.
Corralling The Herd
The County of Los Angeles Department of Consumer and Business Affairs (DCBA) will be hosting a Business Connections event on Thursday, March 30 at the Centre on Centre Pointe Parkway from 8 a.m. to noon.
March 30: Grow Business, Network with Contractors at Business Connections Event
The College of the Canyons football program has released its 2017 spring football practice schedule with sessions set to begin on Monday, April 10.
Canyons Football Announces 2017 Spring Practice Schedule
College of the Canyons Chancellor Dr. Dianne G. Van Hook has been named as the National Pacesetter of the Year by the National Council for Marketing and Public Relations (NCMPR).
Dr. Dianne G. Van Hook Named National Pacesetter of the Year
Supervisor Kathryn Barger is hosting her first State of the County luncheon with Santa Clarita Valley business and community leaders on Thursday, May 11 at the Hyatt Regency Valencia.
May 11: Barger Holds First State of the County Luncheon
Representative Steve Knight (CA-25) joined a bipartisan effort Tuesday to urge the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) to investigate and address ongoing problems with the Veterans Crisis Line program.
Knight Calls on VA to Fix Veterans Crisis Hotline
The Castaic Lake Water Agency Planning and Engineering Committee is having a meeting on April 4, 2017 at 5:30 p.m. in the Training Room at the Rio Vista Water Treatment Plant.
April 4: CLWA Planning, Engineering Committee Meeting
California Film Commission Newsletter for Spring 2017.
CA Film Commission News: Santa Clarita Featured, Tax Credit, More
The County of Los Angeles is home to millions of pet loving families who are against animal abuse and suffering. In support of our furry constituents, Supervisors Hilda L. Solis, Sheila Kuehl, Janice Hahn, and Kathryn Barger passed a motion to advocate for the fair treatment of animals and oppose China’s Yulin Dog Meat Festival.
Supes Say ‘No’ on Animal Cruelty and Abuse
It’s springtime, and 14 member artists of the Santa Clarita Artists Association will be featured at a fine art exhibition in Westfield Valencia Patios this coming Saturday April 1, from 12 to 5:30 p.m.
April 1: SCAA Exhibition at Westfield Valencia Patios
1928 - Little dam victim, thought unidentified & buried in SCV, actually ID'd & buried in Chatsworth [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, five out of seven candidates are left in seeking a seat on the Hart District governing board. Plus, wondering what TV shows and movies are filming in SCV this week? Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Tuesday, March 28, 2017
Southern California may lose two-thirds of its beaches to rising sea levels by the end of this century, according to a report released Monday by the U.S. Geological Survey.
SoCal Could Lose Two-thirds of Beaches to Rising Sea Levels
After having Tuesday's series opener postponed due to inclement weather, No. 16 College of the Canyons defeated host Victor Valley College 7-0 on Thursday, behind eight scoreless innings from freshman lefty Jacob Lopez.
No. 16 Canyons Gets 7-0 Road Win vs. Victor Valley
Sophomores Jasmine Hall and Samiyah Hawkins each won a pair of events on the women's side and freshman Delon Buncio leaped his way to a first place finish for the men's squad, as the College of the Canyons track & field teams finished second and fourth, respectively, at the Bakersfield College Relays on Saturday.
Canyons Track & Field Continues Strong Run at Bakersfield Relays
No. 16 College of the Canyons finished its season sweep of conference opponent Victor Valley College, winning 4-0 and 17-5 to take both games of Friday's home doubleheader at Cougar Field.
No. 16 Canyons Sweeps Doubleheader, Season Series vs. Victor Valley
Deeply respected filmmaker and School of Film/Video Nina Menkes often refers to the sorcery of her work that evokes meaning and truth outside of traditional narrative cinema.
CalArts Filmmaker Talks ‘The Shock of the Real’ at ‘dffb’ Symposium
With the announcement that the United States will begin to dismantle the Clean Power Plan, California Governor Edmund G. Brown Jr. and New York Governor Andrew M. Cuomo today issued the following statement reaffirming their ongoing commitment to exceed the targets of the Clean Power Plan and curb carbon pollution.
California, New York Governors Continue Commitment to Clean Power Plan
The Knoxville, Tennessee-based Big Ears Festival curates a world-class lineup of musicians and filmmakers. This year, the festival runs from March 23-26 with several CalArtians screening their works, including School of Theater faculty Janie Geiser and alumni Manuela De Laborde (Film/Video MFA 16), Christina Nguyen (Film/Video MFA 16) and Mike Stotlz (Film/Video MFA 14).
CalArtians Screen Works at Big Ears Festival in Knoxville, Tenn.
On Saturday, members of The Master’s University women’s track & field program posted outstanding marks at the at the 2017 Westmont Classic w/ Jim Klein Multis on the campus of Westmont College in Santa Barbara.
Lady Mustangs Track & Field Storm Westmont Classic
Last week, members of The Master’s University men’s track & field program had made history at the 2017 Westmont Classic w/ Jim Klein Multis on the campus of Westmont College in Santa Barbara.
Mustangs Track & Field Make History at Westmont Classic
The Newhall Post Office opened its doors for the first time Monday after six months of delay.
Newhall Post Office Now Open After Delays
Tragedy struck a family of six from Santa Clarita in January when 18-year-old Kaeli Edmonds lost control of the car she was driving on Vasquez Canyon Road and Sierra Highway, causing it to strike a mountain and flip three times.
Car Crash Leaves Teen Paralyzed
Ryan Bricker bunted in the go-ahead run in the opener and walked with the bases loaded to provide the winner in the nightcap while Scott Savage pitched his way to a save and a win as The Master's University swept Arizona Christian 8-7 and 11-9 Saturday afternoon.
TMU Baseball Triumphant Over Arizona Christian
Five out of seven candidates are left in seeking the Hart District governing board seat vacated by Robert Hall. The remaining four members scheduled a public meeting Wednesday, March 29, 2017, to interview all applicants, publicly debate about those applicants, and they’re expected to make their decision Wednesday night, from the five residents from District No. 3 boundaries for the William S. Hart Union High School District.
March 29: Hart District to Choose New Board Member
The Academy is now accepting entries for its 2017 Student Academy Awards competition. All Student Academy Award winners become eligible for Oscars consideration. The entry deadline for submissions is Thursday, June 1.
June 1: Deadline for 2017 Student Academy Awards Competition
The Santa Clarita City Council will have a special meeting on March 28 at 5:30 p.m.in City Council Chambers.
March 28: Agenda for Special Meeting of City Council