[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Pot Heads Still Can’t Own Guns, Court Says | 08-31-2016
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Clear
Clear
67°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
October 1
1842 - New York Observer (newspaper) reports on Placerita gold discovery, proving that the Americans knew about it 6 years before Sutter's Mill [story]


[CN] – Medicinal marijuana is legal in Nevada, but that doesn’t negate federal guidelines banning drug addicts from owning guns, the Ninth Circuit ruled Wednesday.

S. Rowan Wilson had hoped the federal appeals court would revive her constitutional challenge to the federal firearms provision keeping her unarmed.

When Wilson had tried to buy a gun in Moundhouse, Nevada, she was a card-carrying member of the Nevada marijuana registry.

Moundhouse is a small community, and the owner of the gunsmith where Wilson was shopping on Oct. 4, 2011, knew she had gotten her medical card just five months earlier.

He also knew that the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives was trying to coordinate its regulations with the spread of medical-marijuana laws around the country.

In September 2011, the ATF published an open letter that marijuana addicts are considered prohibited firearms buyers, regardless of their state’s medicinal marijuana laws.

The owner of the gun store Wilson visited received this letter three days before her visit. Wilson claimed in her federal complaint against the government that its letter was to blame for her not getting a gun that day.

A federal judge dismissed the lawsuit, however, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed Wednesday.

Senior U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff wrote the ruling for the circuit’s three-judge panel, sitting by designation from Manhattan.

The 30-page opinion cites several issues with Wilson’s complaint.

“Wilson has not alleged that she is an unlawful drug user or that she is addicted to any controlled substance,” Rakoff wrote. “Nor has she alleged that she possessed or received a firearm. Accordingly, Wilson has not alleged that § 922(g)(3) has injured her in any way.”

Though Wilson argued that the ban unconstitutionally burdens her right to bear arms, Rakoff said the regulations at issue had no bearing on her ability to buy guns before getting her medical card.

“Wilson could have amassed legal firearms before acquiring a registry card … and the Open Letter would not impede her right to keep her firearms or to use them to protect herself and her home,” Rakoff wrote. “In addition, Wilson could acquire firearms and exercise her right to self-defense at any time by surrendering her registry card, thereby demonstrating to a firearms dealer that there is no reasonable cause to believe she is an unlawful drug user.”

Wilson also failed to show that the ban violates her First Amendment free-speech rights.

Even though her acquisition of the card is definitely a protected speech act, Rakoff said strict scrutiny of the law and the open letter does not apply because the ban does not target anyone’s speech rights — Wilson’s claims of a government crackdown on medical marijuana notwithstanding.

“The production, distribution, and use of medical marijuana are not protected by the First Amendment, and efforts by the Government to impede—or even eliminate altogether—the production, distribution, and use of medical marijuana are not evidence of any conspiracy against free speech,” Rakoff wrote.

The Justice Department declined to comment. DOJ attorney Abby Wright argued this appeal for the government.

Las Vegas attorney Charles Rainey represented Wilson. He said that he was pleased the circuit gave the case its sufficient attention. Though Rainey would have preferred an alternate outcome, he said the case will press on.

“We are going to litigate this, exhaust whatever remedies we have,” he said.

Rainey also said the he believes the real thrust of the case is the First Amendment.

“When this letter was issued, it was issued as part of a deliberate attempt by the DOJ to quell a political movement,” Rainey said.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

3 Comments

  1. Harvey says:

    Puff puff, pass over your GUN RIGHTS.

  2. Heisenberg says:

    “Potheads”, “addicts”, the author tips their hand a little too much. ATF is a federal agency and where in the U.S. Constitution does it claim that the government has the authority to dictate what people put in their bodies or to suspend other constitutional rights because of what people put in their bodies.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
Loading...
Related Content
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Friday, Sep 30, 2016
SCVi Charter Dedicates New Flag Courtyard
The flags fly proudly each day at SCVi Charter School — and now they fly in a brand new landscaped flag courtyard created as a patriotic tribute by a soon-to-be Eagle Scout who coordinated more than 850 volunteer hours to make it happen.
Friday, Sep 30, 2016
Jail is a Scary Place: Haunted Jailhouse Returns Oct. 30
Deputies are inviting the public to stop by the 27th Annual Haunted Jailhouse and Community Open House event on Sunday, Oct. 30, from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. and help them look for ghosts and goblins spotted in and around the station jail.
Friday, Sep 30, 2016
Brown Signs Runner-Sponsored Bill to Help Disabled Veterans
Gov. Jerry Brown has signed legislation sponsored by Board of Equalization Member George Runner and authored by Sen. Patricia Bates, R-Laguna Niguel, that expands eligibility for the state's property tax exemption to disabled military veterans who were discharged under "other than honorable conditions."
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
College of the Canyons will play its fifth regular season game as the Cougars host the Grossmont College Griffins at Cougar Stadium. Saturday's game is a non-conference contest. All players, coaches and cheerleaders associated with a Santa Clarita Valley youth sports league or cheer organization are invited to attend Saturday's game free of charge.
Saturday: No. 11 COC Hosts No. 8 Grossmont College
The Master’s University volleyball team survived a five-set dogfight Thursday night against Hope International University.
Volleyball: Lady Mustangs Scrap for Win Over Hope Int’l
1842 - New York Observer (newspaper) reports on Placerita gold discovery, proving that the Americans knew about it 6 years before Sutter's Mill [story]
Traffic investigators from the Lancaster Sheriff’s Station are investigating the circumstances of a fatal traffic collision involving a pedestrian, who was a Southern California Edison worker, and a vehicle. The collision occurred on Avenue K west of 20th Street East, in the City of Lancaster.
Motorist Hits, Kills Edison Worker in Lancaster
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, check out our top headlines from this past week and upcoming weekend events. Plus, COC hosts a human trafficking awareness event and Forge Ahead Arts host the She Bytes exhibition. Check out these stories tonight on SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, September 30, 2016
Assemblyman Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, presented a $5,000 Education Grant from the Barona Band of Mission Indians to Mint Canyon Community School on Friday to assist in the purchase of 67 MobyMax tablets to aid students learning math and language arts.
Barona Indians Give $5K to Mint Canyon School for Tablets
The Newhall Community Center recently opened its doors for pickleball play on two newly lined courts in the multipurpose room. Pickleball courts are also available at the Sports Complex Gymnasium and Bouquet Canyon Park.
Pickleball Now Available at Newhall Community Center
All 23 California State University campuses will begin accepting applications on Oct. 1 for admission to the fall 2017 term.
Oct. 1: Application Period Opens for Fall 2017 at All CSU’s
NYT Best-Selling Author Stephen Mansfield is best known for his groundbreaking books on religion, history and contemporary culture. He will speak at the Trinity Classical Academy campus about "Recovering a Christian View of History" on Monday, Oct. 10, at 7 p.m.
Oct. 10: Christian History Author to Speak at Trinity School
The Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk is in need of pollworkers across Los Angeles County for the upcoming Nov. 8 Presidential General Election.
800 More Pollworkers Needed for Nov. 8 Election
The flags fly proudly each day at SCVi Charter School — and now they fly in a brand new landscaped flag courtyard created as a patriotic tribute by a soon-to-be Eagle Scout who coordinated more than 850 volunteer hours to make it happen.
SCVi Charter Dedicates New Flag Courtyard
The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department Metrolink Bureau partnered with several law enforcement agencies in September to enforce traffic laws at railroad grade crossings in several Southern California Counties used by commuter rail.
119 Tickets Issues at Rail Crossings During Special Operation
The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, cordially invites you to come and enjoy the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department “Fun In the Sun” Chili Cook Off on Saturday, Oct. 15, from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. at the Jack Bones Equestrian Center in Castaic.
Oct. 15: ‘Fun in the Sun’ Chili Cookoff in Castaic for Special Olympics
Deputies are inviting the public to stop by the 27th Annual Haunted Jailhouse and Community Open House event on Sunday, Oct. 30, from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. and help them look for ghosts and goblins spotted in and around the station jail.
Jail is a Scary Place: Haunted Jailhouse Returns Oct. 30
A plan to divide the lot on the Northpark Community Church property, which houses Trinity Classical Academy, is set to go before the Santa Clarita Planning Commission on Tuesday.
Planners to Consider Northpark Church-Trinity Academy Lot Split
Gov. Jerry Brown has signed legislation sponsored by Board of Equalization Member George Runner and authored by Sen. Patricia Bates, R-Laguna Niguel, that expands eligibility for the state's property tax exemption to disabled military veterans who were discharged under "other than honorable conditions."
Brown Signs Runner-Sponsored Bill to Help Disabled Veterans
Witches, zombies, ghosts and fairies alike are all invited to attend this spook-tacular day that will be held at the LIMS Movie Studio in Castaic.
Oct. 23: Family-Oriented Halloween Event at Castaic Movie Studio
One can legitimately ask if Steve and Cokie Roberts' story falls into Hillary’s list of tales about being under gunfire in Bosnia, Chelsea’s danger in being near ground zero on 9/11, and Hillary’s claim of being named after Sir Edmund Hillary – who did not become famous until six years after Hillary’s birth.
Selective Memory
1955 - Actor James Dean, 24, drives through Castaic Junction en route to his final resting place [watch]
On Saturday, The Master’s University’s cross country teams will toe the line at their fifth-annual home race, The Mustang Challenge, at Santa Clarita’s Central Park.
Oct. 1: TMU Hosts XC Race at Santa Clarita Central Park
The Golden State Athletic Conference has announced that Michael Sciarra has been named the Cross Country Runner of the Month for September. This is Sciarra’s first time receiving this honor.
TMU’s Sciarra Named Conference Runner of Month
Twelfth-ranked Biola used a splendid bicycle kick 4:59 into overtime to eke out a 1-0 victory over the Mustangs Wednesday night in La Mirada.
Men’s Soccer: Mustangs Fall to Biola 1-0 in Overtime
The College of the Canyons men's soccer team claimed its biggest win of the season on Tuesday, coming in the form of a physical 2-1 victory over Santa Barbara City College at Cougar Stadium.
Men’s Soccer: COC Gets Physical with Santa Barbara, Wins 2-1
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, the annual Hate Crimes report was released by the Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations and reports a 24 percent increase this past year. Plus, Halloween is around the corner and this local farm will help you get in the spirit of the season. Check out these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, September 29, 2016
The burned-out and blighted Greens pub and putting course on McBean Parkway could be redeveloped into a 5-story hotel and 4,000-square-foot restaurant if the Santa Clarita Planning Commission shouts "FORE!" on Tuesday to a proposal that's working its way through the city approval process.
City Planners to Consider New Hotel, Restaurant for ‘Greens’ Property
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson announced today that the U.S. Department of Education has awarded California $49.9 million in start-up funds to assist in the launch and development of high-quality charter schools over the next three years.
Feds Providing $50 Mil. for Calif. Charter School Start-Ups
During the month of October on every Saturday, residents can partake in a variety of happenings throughout the city of Santa Clarita to celebrate the arts. All events are free and open to the public.
Santa Clarita Celebrates National Arts, Humanities Month
The Matador Report is the official e-newsletter of Matador Athletics.
CSUN Athletics: Matador Report for Thursday, Sept. 29, 2016
Lots of fun learning activities are in store at the Santa Clarita Public Libraries in October.
October at the Santa Clarita Libraries
Education is power. Come learn about the new laws which will affect your business and employees, and discuss the steps you can take to help ensure compliance and avoid costly fines or litigation.
Dec. 2: Employment Law Update at COC Chancellor’s Circle Breakfast
Parents, educators, students, and employers are invited to take part in the "STREAM Kids Expo," an event that engages students in real-world issues through exciting hands-on activities facilitated by industry experts such as NASA, Lockheed Martin, Gantom Lighting & Controls, Wells Fargo, BMW, and Solar City.
Oct. 22: ‘STREAM Kids Expo’ to Engage Students in Real World Issues
A bill cosponsored by Representative Steve Knight (CA-25) that would buy time for small businesses and other entities to comply with an impending federal regulation passed the House of Representatives Wednesday night.
Knight Bill Aiming to Delay Mandate Affecting Business Passes House
A total 32 rabid bats have been found in Los Angeles County, with 11 of them being found in the Santa Clarita Valley, in 2016 as of September 27.
Three More Rabid Bats Found in SCV, Brings Total to 11
At Tuesday’s meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, 5th District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich presented Bailey, a 3-month-old spayed female chihuahua mix, ready to be adopted.
Antonovich Pet of the Week (9-27-2016): Bailey
The Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations has released its annual account of hate crimes reported throughout Los Angeles County in 2015.
Hate Crimes Rise in L.A. County for the First Time in Seven Years
Gov. Jerry Brown signed into law Santa Clarita Assemblyman Scott Wilk’s AB 1322, which permits salons and barbershops to serve a single complimentary alcoholic beverage to clients ages 21 and over without requiring a license or permit, provided no extra fees are charged for the beverage.
Brown Signs Wilk Bill Allowing Alcoholic Beverages to be Served at Salons