[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: Medical Shot-Calling | 10-05-2016
Santa Clarita CA
Mostly cloudy
Mostly cloudy
Today in
S.C.V. History
October 24
1992 - Dedication of Santa Clarita's first Metrolink station (Santa Clarita Station) [brochure]

Commentary by Gene Dorio, M.D.
| Wednesday, Oct 5, 2016

genedorioWar is being waged on behalf of American citizens against the business takeover of hospitals, yet most people don’t realize this battle exists. Surprisingly, the warriors scattered throughout our country in this fight are doctors.

Unlike recent scandalous headlines of Wells Fargo committing fraud against its customers, Mylan’s heinous price gouging for its EpiPen and oil company disasters like the Deepwater Horizon, hospitals have created a shield against criticism by using a mantra that they are “too important to fail.” Touting this defense, hospital administrators have self-aggrandized their position and covertly bestowed profits, enriching personal salaries, bonuses and golden parachutes while the public is left to suffer.

Healthcare in our country is in shambles. As a geriatric physician, I have seen my elder patients targeted, pushing them into nursing homes, onto hospice and quickly pulling the plug, declaring them brain dead. These tactics, though, are part of a wider conspiracy among business people and lawyers who 20 years ago developed a game plan to capitalize on a disarrayed system. Being at a small community non-profit hospital allowed recognition of their strategic template.

In the past decade, legal rights of the physician medical staff at Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital have been overrun, using “divide and conquer” tactics awarding favored doctor stipends for hospital directorships and signing contracts with chosen medical groups. Thereafter, MD votes on the board and certain committees were used against whistleblowing doctors who were punished or eliminated from staff. Subsequently, poor hospital performance statistics were hidden or manipulated while doctor input insuring quality care was ignored. This continues today.

Public awareness is minimal, as local media and politicians have hospital advertisement dollars and campaign funding dangled in their faces. Likewise, regulatory agencies like the Joint Commission, Department of Public Health, Medicare (CMS), and the state attorney general have succumbed to the “too important to fail” mantra with the proverbial “slap on the hand” punishment. (The same we will see with Wells Fargo, Mylan and, of course, oil companies.)

Doctors are now a profitable commodity controlled by businesses that shape physician decision-making through monetary influence or threat. Because of this, very few doctors at our hospital were willing to step forward, so former Chief of Staff Dr. Gregory Jenkins and I reached out for help.

A colleague from Let My Doctor Practice, Dr. Michael Strickland, referred us to a group in San Francisco, Physicians Organizing Committee (POC), led by Geoff Wilson. Our visit to their office earlier this year gave us insight into their 33 years of experience in this doctor struggle.

That same week, Dr. Jenkins heard the entire physician Medical Executive Committee (MEC) of Tulare Regional Medical Center was illegally ousted by the Board of Directors. In common with Henry Mayo doctors was a nonprofit hospital in a small community, building a “tower” for more patient beds, and both opened a for-profit membership gym. Coincidence or template?

Contacts were made, and the POC deftly launched a counter-offensive, legally and publicly. Rallies and community meetings pushed physician problems into the political forefront, and although the battle is ongoing, victories have been achieved.

For Dr. Jenkins and myself, this gave us hope.

Survival of our hospital is critical, as it went through bankruptcy 15 years ago, and the emotional fear still lingers. Santa Clarita is a growing community in an isolated valley, and we have only one hospital to serve us. Its loss would be detrimental to our citizens, especially elder seniors. Hospital administrators strategically remind the public and regulatory agencies of their past plight, generating fear that denudes scabs off of old wounds. Fear, though, cannot be an excuse for poor patient care.

The CEO is a recent past president of the California Hospital Association. Thus he knows the business template well and has harnessed it against the Henry Mayo physician medical staff.

As background, doctors at all hospitals in California are given the right of self-governance, legally separating them from the administration and Board of Directors. These laws are specifically made to safeguard the public from unscrupulous business people who might scheme to augment profits while providing cut-rate care. Physicians therefore cannot be employed by a hospital, preventing manipulation of medical decision-making through threats against salaries, bonuses, raises and tenure.

But hospitals have lawyers always looking for loopholes, so because they cannot directly hire doctors, they instead appoint them to paid hospital positions as directors; sign contracts with medical groups; or provide “loan” money to open and sustain a practice. These physicians become subservient to the hospital board and administration and succumb to the same manipulations self-governance should protect. Loophole.

The Henry Mayo Hospital Board of Directors has been financially conflicted by the administration, so their influenced vote is used to encroach physician self-governance. Here are some examples:

Recently the administration made a false claim against the MEC of impeding approval of physician assistants (PAs). In violation of state law, the board independently approved PAs who were allowed to care for critically ill patients throughout the hospital. Some PAs approved by the board were found not to be qualified to practice in our hospital, exposing extremely ill patients to subordinate care.

The administration-run Palliative Care Committee created a policy allowing non-physicians to consult the team. This is a medical decision that should be made only by doctors, as the consequence of this determination may lead to end-of-life hospice care. Allowing arbitrary medical decision-making forced vulnerable patients out of the hospital, inflating profits.

The Board of Directors enabled administrators to change the hospital Sentinel Event Policy, likely contributing to the death of a patient. When someone dies or is severely injured, some of these cases should be investigated. Originally, the policy directed the physician chief of staff to make the determination designating the case a “sentinel event,” launching an inquiry. But instead, administrators changed the policy and removed physician authority to make this decision, putting it into the hands of – guess who? – the administration.

There have been many more assaults encroaching on physician self-governance against the MEC, medical staff, and individual doctors. So far, we have seen only superficial corrections ordered by regulatory agencies. Why? For fear it might close or bankrupt the hospital?

Freeing hospitals from accountability when patients die or their lives are put in jeopardy only allows the problem to perpetuate. More dangerous in this business world, hospitals have joined Wells Fargo, Mylan and oil companies in their scandalous attempt to deceive the public.

Warfare must be sustained through proactive doctor groups like the Physicians Organizing Committee and the rising voices being heard through online blogs. Healthcare may be in shambles, but doctors and the public need to organize and coalesce in addressing this threat. There is hope, so we can’t give up the fight.

I’m not an historian and will be happy to be corrected, but an inspirational fact that stood out from high school history class is Gen. George Washington fought nine major battles during the Revolution. He lost seven … but still won the war.


Gene Uzawa Dorio, M.D., is a housecall geriatric physician and member of the Physicians Organizing Committee at Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital. The views expressed in this column as his alone. This commentary appears in the Fall edition of New Diagnosis .


Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

1 Comment

  1. Elaine Hanson says:

    Wow, this is an important war on healthcare in our country. I’m glad to hear there are some physicians to whom quality of care and the human side of patient care still matters. I have know a hospital administrator or two and when talking with them – they always came across as self-serving and full of bull. Never a definitive answer but fear mongering always ended the conversation. The fear mongering seemed to float down to their closest staff also, ie messages along the line of if you keep questioning…. Not saying all hospital administrators are like that, just the ones I’ve encountered.

Leave a Comment

Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Related Content
Sunday, Oct 23, 2016
In the spring, I see an increase of people exercising, getting ready for bathing suit weather. Now it’s autumn, and thoughts go to cuddling up on the couch in front of the TV and drinking hot cocoa. But exercise should be an everyday activity, not just in the spring.
Thursday, Oct 20, 2016
The experience of other states such as Colorado and Washington suggests that when medical sales are tax-free, nearly all marijuana users suddenly become patients, even if they are not. The significant loopholes in Proposition 64 mean revenue projections could fall far short of expectations.
Thursday, Oct 20, 2016
This is the time of the year when you should slow down on Placerita Canyon Road, on Sand Canyon and the adjacent roads, as well. Be aware that a buck is not going to pay much attention to traffic if it has located a receptive doe.
Monday, Oct 17, 2016
Every day, we all face challenges, but we can’t just throw our hands in the air and call it quits because we don’t agree with someone. And we can’t sit idly by while watching group after group get bullied, attacked and insulted by the big kid with high ratings.
Monday, Oct 17, 2016
Without having met me, someone from the medical field, let’s say a psychiatrist, would probably diagnose me as clinically depressed simply by reading my mail.
Sunday, Oct 16, 2016
I love autumn. It just might be the very best season of the year. It's a time for soups and stews and homemade breads that make my house smell sweet and inviting; for spiced apple cider and maybe a fire in the hearth and an apple pie browning in the oven.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
College of the Canyons has been ranked among the top 15 (out of 381) best community and career colleges by salary potential in PayScale’s 2016-2017 College Salary Report.
COC in Top 15 Nationally for Students’ Salary Potential
Community: Valencia Crime Report for the week of October 10, 2016
Crime Blotter: Multiple Burglaries, Vehicles Stolen in Valencia
Castaic/Val Verde Crime Report for the week of October 10, 2016
Crime Blotter: Gasoline Stolen from Trailer in Castaic
1992 - Dedication of Santa Clarita's first Metrolink station (Santa Clarita Station) [brochure]
In the spring, I see an increase of people exercising, getting ready for bathing suit weather. Now it’s autumn, and thoughts go to cuddling up on the couch in front of the TV and drinking hot cocoa. But exercise should be an everyday activity, not just in the spring.
Hey, Couch Potato
1888 - 8:15 a.m.: Newhall's luxurious Southern Hotel burns to the ground [story]
The Master’s University volleyball team beat the San Diego Christian Hawks in three sets (25-17, 25-12, 25-23) Saturday night in El Cajon.
Volleyball: Lady Mustangs Soar Past Hawks, Improve to 18-9 (10-2)
The men of TMU took care of business Saturday with a 3-0 romp over Menlo, but the Lady Mustangs ended up on the wrong side of a shutout of their own.
Soccer: 2 Shutouts as Menlo Takes on The Master’s
1898 - Birth of Mary S. Ruiz, eldest child of Enrique & Rosaria Ruiz of San Francisquito Canyon; all died in 1928 dam disaster [cemetery census]
Both the men's and women's cross-country teams from The Master’s University earned second-place finishes at the Titan Invitational in Fullerton on Friday.
TMU Men, Women Run to 2nd-Place Finishes in XC Invitational
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Hart District bans clown costumes and the voter registration deadline is almost here. Check out these stories and more tonight on SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, October 21, 2016
Six new human infections of West Nile Virus have been reported in the county, including one in Valencia, according to the weekly Los Angeles County Epidemiology Report.
Valencia Resident Tests Positive for West Nile Virus
A master plan for trails in the Castaic area is set to go before the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors on Tuesday.
Castaic Multi-Use Trails Plan to Go Before County
Southern California Gas Co. (SoCalGas) is performing annual maintenance work at the Honor Rancho Storage Facility in Santa Clarita. As part of this work, which includes a valve replacement and upgrades to dehydration plants and meters, SoCalGas crews will occasionally release natural gas.
Smell Something at Castaic Junction? Gas Co. Working on Local Storage Facility
The William S. Hart Union High School District has banned clown costumes on school campuses for Halloween due to recent social media scares in the community.
Clown Scare Prompts Costume Ban in Hart District Schools
The California Highway Patrol recognizes Red Ribbon Week, October 23-31, as an excellent opportunity for families to have lifesaving conversations with their children about drug use.
Oct 23-31: Red Ribbon Week Shines Spotlight on Drug Abuse
NASA’s Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter has identified new markings on the surface of the Red Planet that are believed to be related to the European Space Agency's ExoMars Schiaparelli entry, descent and landing technology demonstrator module.
European Mars Lander’s Crash Site Located
2007 - Buckweed fire chars 38,000 acres, destroys 21 homes in Canyon Country and Agua Dulce [story]
The experience of other states such as Colorado and Washington suggests that when medical sales are tax-free, nearly all marijuana users suddenly become patients, even if they are not. The significant loopholes in Proposition 64 mean revenue projections could fall far short of expectations.
Loopholes Could Sink Pot Tax
The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board unanimously approved a contract Wednesday night to begin the construction of Castaic High School.
District Awards Contract to Build Castaic High School
The Teacher Curriculum Center (TCC) in California State University, Northridge’s Delmar T. Oviatt Library has long served as a resource center for teachers throughout the region. Last month, the center was renamed after the late Karin J. Duran, who served as the center’s director for 32 years before passing away in 2010.
CSUN Names K-12 Teacher Section of Library for Late Director
The days are getting shorter, the nights are getting cooler, and failure to perform annual maintenance on gas appliances may result in higher gas bills and possible exposure to carbon monoxide, which can cause negative health effects like nausea, drowsiness, flu-like symptoms, and even death.
Ready for Winter? Check Your Furnace Early
The Saugus Union School District announced the appointment of Isa De Armas, Ed.D. to the position of Assistant Superintendent, Curriculum and Instruction. De Armas, who has been in education for more than 30 years, has worked in the district for 20 years as a teacher, principal and – most recently – as Director of Curriculum and Instruction.
Asst. Superintendent of Instruction Named for Saugus Schools
Carousel Ranch is pleased to announce its annual Carousel Corral-After Auction Exclusives auction. This auction is the final step of the ranch’s Heart of the West fundraising, selling items that came in post deadline, etc.
Bid Now on 2nd Chance Items to Help Carousel Ranch
The Santa Clarita Environmental Education Consortium is a sustainable, public-private initiative sponsored by College of the Canyons, Lockheed Martin, Sempra Energy, SCV Family of Water Suppliers, and other community stakeholders that promotes environmental literacy in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Local Coalition Earns Prize for Environmental Education
It’s officially Halloween time at Children’s Hospital Los Angeles. The hospital is inviting supporters and friends in the community to take part in "treating" its young patients by going to CHLA.org/Halloween now through Oct. 31 and creating a special greeting card for the Halloween holiday.
Don’t Trick, Just ‘Treat’ a Children’s Hospital Patient
Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk Dean C. Logan reminds eligible Los Angeles County voters that the deadline to register to vote is Monday, Oct. 24.
Monday is Voter Registration Deadline
In a continued effort to modernize the elections process for the November 8th Presidential General Election, the Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk will be leveraging geospatial technologies and Snapchat to improve elections operations and promote voter participation.
Registrar Using Mobile Apps to Improve Voter Experience
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, a brush fire near Sierra Highway charred one acre before being extinguished. Plus, the William S. Hart District Governing Board awarded a contract to begin the construction of Castaic High School. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, October 20, 2016
Santa Clarita City Council agenda for Tuesday, Oct. 25, 2016.
Council Tuesday: City Eyeing Princessa Property
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health is reminding everyone six months of age and older to get an annual flu vaccine. Influenza (the flu) vaccinations will be available at no-cost to residents at Public Health Centers, LA County libraries and more than 100 community vaccination events throughout the county.
R U Over 6 Months Old? Get a Flu Shot
Longtime Santa Clarita resident Joy Burkhard, founder and chair of the National Coalition for Maternal Mental Health and founder, executive director and board chair of 2020 Mom was honored Thursday by the U.S. Office of Health & Human Services’ Office of Women’s Health with the 2016 Women’s Health Emerging Leader Award.
SCV-Resident Founder of Nat’l Maternal Mental Health Coalition Honored by HHS
With the start of the 2016-17 season less than a month away, Matador fans will have the opportunity to meet this year's Women's and Men's Basketball teams at the annual Matador Madness event set for Friday, Oct. 21, at 6:30 p.m at The Matadome.
Oct. 21: Meet CSUN Basketball Teams at Matador Madness
On Election Day, California voters will decide on Proposition 64, a ballot initiative that would legalize recreational marijuana use in the state for adults at least 21 years old and tax the production and sale of cannabis.
Voters on Both Coasts to Decide on Recreational Pot
The Master’s University volleyball team beat Arizona Christian University in three sets (25-23, 25-20, 25-10) Thursday evening.
Volleyball: TMU Douses Firestorm in 3 Sets
TMU’s fourth shutout of the season commenced when freshman forward Hannah Bahr (Santa Clarita, CA) scored an unassisted goal from 30 yards out at the 32:51 mark.
Soccer: Lady Mustangs Improve to 8-4-3 with 3-0 Shutout