[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Antonovich Seeks Inquiry Into Chiquita Landfill Odors | 10-31-2016
Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
December 3
1887 - Prohibitionist Henry Needham purchases land in Newhall, attempts to establish "dry" colony [story]

UPDATE: The board approved the motion Tuesday, directing county staff to investigate the complaints of odors emanating from the Chiquita Canyon Landfill. Scroll down for Chiquita’s response.


Chiquita-Web-Image-006The Board of Supervisors will consider a motion Tuesday by 5th District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich to investigate ongoing  complaints of odors emanating from the Chiquita Canyon Landfill.

The South Coast Air Quality Management District has received 107 complaints about the landfill this year and 233 complaints last year, according to Antonovich’s motion. The AQMD has issued the landfill one notice “for violating health and air quality codes that prohibit public nuisance.”

Following the issuance of the notice, Antonovich’s motion states, “the Department of Public Works has worked closely with the operator in an effort to control and reduce odors from the landfill.”

“However,” the motion states, “the community continues to report landfill odors to this day.”

Consideration of the motion is expected to follow a report from the county’s interim director of public health and the director of regional planning on a similar investigation into Sunshine Canyon Landfill that was made Oct. 4.

“It is important that the county investigate these complaints and review the conditional use permit for the landfill and identify any and all conditions of approval and enforcement tools to eliminate landfill odors migrating beyond the property boundary and impacting the community of Val Verde,” according to the motion.

If the motion is approved, the county’s departments of regional planning, public works and public health will need to report back to the Board of Supervisors in 30 days with their findings.

Chiquita Canyon Landfill is operating under a conditional use permit issued in the late 1990s. The facility reached its approved capacity earlier this year and was issued a waiver by the county planning director so it could continue operating until a new permit can work its way through the approval process.


Supervisor Antonovich released the following statement after Tuesday’s meeting:

In light of public odor complaints and air quality violation notices, the Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a motion by Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich calling for a comprehensive investigation into the Sunshine Canyon and Chiquita Canyon landfills, their Conditional Use Permits and available enforcement tools to mitigate the landfill emissions that are negatively impacting residents living in surrounding communities.

In November, 2008, the Sunshine Canyon landfill began to generate odor complaints from residents in Granada Hills and Sylmar – which resulted in the Supervisor requesting that AQMD investigate the complaints and ultimately issue multiple Notices of Violation.  Supervisor Antonovich also expedited permits for the landfill’s gas-to-energy facility hoping it would reduce odors, but it had a minimal impact. The Supervisor also worked with the Department of Public Works to approve a new synthetic daily cover hoping it would reduce odors, but that failed too.

“The landfill operator has had more than ample opportunity to correct this odor problem. This has been going on for years now and every device or technique they propose to solve the odor problem fails,” said Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich.

Supervisor Antonovich has also heard from residents in Val Verde that the Chiquita Canyon Landfill is emitting noxious odors as well. The Supervisor directed the Department of Public Health, in consultation with County Counsel and the Departments of Public Works and Regional Planning, to review both landfills’ Conditional Use Permit and examine Conditions of Approval to bring the operators into compliance and alleviate the odor nuisance impacting the surrounding communities.  The Departments will report back to the Board in two weeks with findings and recommendations.


Chiquita made the following statement at Tuesday’s meeting of the Board of Supervisors:

“Good afternoon, Chair Solis, members of the Board. My name is John Musella and I am here this afternoon representing Chiquita Canyon Landfill regarding Agenda Item 27 in which Supervisor Antonovich has asked the Director of Planning, in consultation with County Counsel and the Director of Public Works to review the landfill’s Conditional Use Permit regarding odors.

Chiquita Canyon welcomes the opportunity to work with the County of Los Angeles regarding this important issue as we take very seriously the safe operations of our landfill. As such, there has been only one Notice of Violation issued to Chiquita Canyon by the South Coast AQMD in nearly 10 years.

Compare that to the 180 Notices of Violation issued to Sunshine Canyon landfill in just the past 8 years.

Last year, on its own initiative, Chiquita Canyon hired a nationally recognized firm specializing in odor analysis to conduct an independent Odor Survey at Chiquita Canyon. That firm concluded Chiquita does not create significant odor impacts to the surrounding community.

Three trained odor specialists collected 2,025 sampling data points over a 25-day period in the community surrounding the landfill. Only 5 of the 2,025 data points (only 0.2%) were potentially associated with landfill odors in Val Verde. These findings support the records of the SCAQMD which has record of only 3 verified odor complaints in a 5-year period between August 2007 and July 2012.

No verified odor complaint has ever been associated with landfill gas emissions from Chiquita Canyon.

During the past 14 years, under the current management, Chiquita Canyon Landfill has consistently been proactive in addressing potential odors. Chiquita focuses on preventing problems before they occur while Sunshine Canyon only reacts to problems after they occur.

Many of the proactive control measures put in place at Chiquita Canyon have set the standard for measures at Sunshine Canyon that were directed by the regulatory agencies in response to their problems.

Chiquita Canyon can be proactive in addressing issues because its on-site management is empowered by the company to address potential odor problems immediately, in order to stay “ahead of the game.” They have full authority to do whatever is needed when there is a need.

In addition to Chiquita Canyon’s independent odor analysis, the Val Verde Community Advisory Committee paid for their own independent third-party air quality testing and review of our CUP and permits. Val Verde’s own consultants also concluded there were no issues related to air quality in Val Verde from the landfill. Their report also concluded Chiquita Canyon was operating in compliance with our operations permits.

Thank you for your time this afternoon and we look forward to working with the County on this very important issue.”

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


  1. Steve says:

    They are operating under a Clean Hands Waiver, at this time they are in violation of the contract. They take in more daily tonnage then was stated in the contract and have exceeded the limit they were to be allowed before closing. Contracts are only for the rich, this is just an attempt to make it look like the county cares about Val Verde before they shove the next 30 years of landfill down Val Verde’s throat.

  2. lighttech says:

    what 5th District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich!

    should be working on is closing this place!

    They meet the FULL limit of the what the contract that they agreed to was, and now with the help of LA council they (the dump) want to ONE SIDED change that contract. The elected officials ‘washed’ their hands on this….why?
    because they are still getting nice free dump fee’s and taxes to spend way down in LA city and not here!

  3. waterwatcher says:

    Will this is great. Then why did he allow the landfill to be expanded by 25% with a back room deal that no one in the community was told about? Is this some kind of game he is playing to cover up the “clean hands” waiver?

  4. Tessa Lucero says:

    They need an inquiry to confirm that the dump smells? Really?

  5. C.R. says:

    Let’s re-name it “The Michael D. Antonovich Memorial Dump” and give credit where credit is due.

  6. Richard Hood says:

    A total game, no intent to solve the problem or follow the will of the people who elected him. A show to make it look like they are good guys trying to do the right thing as opposed to the wrong thing – taking money from the landfill to use on his never ending campaigning/meal ticket on the government dole, and then claiming it has no effect on how he votes!
    Consider the track record – he has all the facts at his disposal, and does nothing instead of closing it down and abiding by the contract. Forget him and the county. Move forward with the law, and with publicity towards his appointed heir. Hit them hard from day one of the signing in with reporters and cameras and recall ultimatums. Demand their promise of a closure in public.

  7. Richard Hood says:

    Thank you SCV news for covering this – I am boycotting the Signal as they refused articles on this fiasco. I fear the worst about our so-called 4th estate – more like a 5th column, in their case.

Leave a Comment

SCV NewsBreak
Related Content
Friday, Dec 2, 2016
LACoFD Battle 2 Brush Fires, Both Now Under Control
Santa Clarita Valley firefighters handled a pair of brush fires Friday, officials said, leaving none injured and no structures threatened.
Friday, Dec 2, 2016
Crime Blotter: Burglary, Petty Theft in Stevenson Ranch
Stevenson Ranch Crime Report: November 21, 2016 - November 27, 2016
Thursday, Dec 1, 2016
Motorcyclist Sustains Major Injuries in Hit-and-Run Crash
A 23-year-old woman was arrested after she attempted to flee the scene of a hit-and-run crash that left one man in the hospital with major injuries.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1887 - Prohibitionist Henry Needham purchases land in Newhall, attempts to establish "dry" colony [story]
The Latino Business Alliance will be hosting a "Posada Breakfast" on December 6, which will be an opportunity to network with others in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Dec. 6: Network with Fellow Business Owners at the Posada Breakfast
Court Appointed Special Advocates of Los Angeles, or CASA/LA, a non-profit organization that drastically improves the lives of abused and neglected foster children in LA County through trained volunteer advocates, will be hosting its first CASA Book Fair in collaboration with Barnes & Noble of Valencia December 8.
Dec. 8: CASA/LA Book Fair Fundraiser to be Held at Barnes & Noble in Valencia
The County Interim Health Officer is issuing a Cold Weather Alert due to the National Weather Service’s forecast for low temperatures.
Cold Weather Alert for Antelope Valley, L.A. County Mountain Areas
Just as people plan for retirement, the California Highway Patrol (CHP) urges them to plan for changing needs and abilities in their driving as they age.
CHP Recommends Planning for Senior Drivers
Here it is the end of the year and the culmination of a lot of programs, services and projects for us at the city
Message from the City Manager
Santa Clarita Valley firefighters handled a pair of brush fires Friday, officials said, leaving none injured and no structures threatened.
LACoFD Battle 2 Brush Fires, Both Now Under Control
Stevenson Ranch Crime Report: November 21, 2016 - November 27, 2016
Crime Blotter: Burglary, Petty Theft in Stevenson Ranch
1972 - Five wounded in Vagos biker gang shooting at Curtis & JoAnne Darcy's Acton '49er Saloon [story]
A 23-year-old woman was arrested after she attempted to flee the scene of a hit-and-run crash that left one man in the hospital with major injuries.
Motorcyclist Sustains Major Injuries in Hit-and-Run Crash
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Princess Cruises has agreed to plead guilty to seven charges stemming from its deliberate pollution of the seas and intentional acts to cover it up. Plus, retiring L.A. County Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich shares some inspiring words about achieving your dreams and moving forward. See these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, December 1, 2016
Pocock Brewing Co. will host their 1st Anniversary Beer Festival benefiting the Castaic and SCV Education Foundations this month.
Pocock Brewing to Host Fundraiser for Castaic, SCV Education Foundations
The Valley Industry Association will review and close the 2016 year, and formally install the 2017 Valley Industry Association Board of Directors at their upcoming meeting.
Dec. 20: VIA to Install New Board of Directors
The ALDI grocery store chain is coming to Santa Clarita this month.
Dec. 15: ALDI Grocery Store to Open in Santa Clarita
The Santa Clarita Public Libraries are providing families with plenty of occasions to embrace the spirit of the holidays through the month of December.
Santa Clarita Libraries Embrace Holiday Spirit with Family-friendly Events
The Transportation Research Board announced Thursday that Caltrans Director Malcolm Dougherty will become chair of its Executive Committee, effective January 12, 2017.
Caltrans Appoints Chair of Executive Committee
An artist named "Six" is hosting an opening reception for the installation piece "Ghost Band."
‘Ghost Band’ Art Installation Comes to ARTree
The 16 Santa Clarita Valley LDS congregations of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints are inviting the public to attend their annual Community Christmas Concert.
SCV Latter-day Saints Congregations Host ‘When Love Was Born’ Performance
The Southern California Football Association has announced its 2016 All-League Teams and seven players from College of the Canyons are included among the honorees from the National Division, Northern League.
SCFA Honors Seven COC Football Players
A Valencia man got the chance to participate in as a featured “Trader” in an attempt to avoid “Zonks” and win a sensational selection of prizes on the game show "Lets Make A Deal".
Valencia Man to Appear on ‘Lets Make A Deal’
Bakkavor Foods USA, Inc. is voluntarily recalling Trader Joe’s Mediterranean Hummus and Trader Joe’s White Bean & Basil Hummus with “USE BY” date codes up through and including "12/15/2016," because these products have the potential to be contaminated with Listeria monocytogenes.
Recall: Two Types of Trader Joe’s Hummus Potentially Contaminated by Listeria
The death occurred in a middle-aged man, from the northern part of Los Angeles County, who had significant pre-existing medical conditions.
First Flu Death in LA County Confirmed
Princess Cruises has announced a settlement Friday, after a three-year Department of Justice investigation to a charge the company broke environmental laws by discharging sewage illegally.
Princess Cruises to Pay Fine for Illegally Dumping Sewage
Winter holidays are a time for families and friends to get together, but that also means a greater risk for fire.
Steps to a Fire-Safe Holiday
It has been my honor to serve as your Mayor this year. The city of Santa Clarita is one of California’s best cities and it just keeps getting better and better.
Monthly Message from Mayor Bob Kellar
1929 - Saugus train robber "Buffalo" Tom Vernon apprehended in Pawnee, Okla. [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, we see how friends and family are remembering actor, Paul Walker. Plus, a firefighters and local dignitaries celebrated Fire Station 143 in Castaic today. See those stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, November 30, 2016
Two years ago, I took the oath to lead the nation’s largest Sheriff’s Department in a manner that put public trust at the core of what we do. I also made a promise to the 18,000 men and women at the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department (LASD) that this could, and would, be done by focusing on our future together and closing the door on the divisiveness and factions that once threatened this great organization.
Sheriff Jim McDonnell Announces New Executive Team
Valencia Marketplace officials are inviting families and community members to a tree lighting ceremony this Thursday.
Dec. 1: Valencia Marketplace Tree Lighting Ceremony
Henry Mayo hosts training program to help community become more aware of the signs of suicide and how to help.
Henry Mayo Hosts SafeTALK to Prevent Suicide, Create Awareness
California State University, Northridge’s Valley Performing Arts Center has hosted several world-renowned artists since opening its doors in 2011.
CSUN VPAC Celebrates Five Years of World-Renowned Artists
Princess Cruises has won four awards from the readers of Porthole Cruise Magazine, receiving Best Central America Itineraries, Best South Pacific Itineraries, Best Onboard Shopping and Best Signature Cocktail in the magazine’s 18th annual Readers’ Choice Awards.
Princess Cruises Wins Four Awards from Porthole Cruise Magazine
[District Attorney] A 72-year-old convicted rapist was sentenced Wednesday to 520 years to life in state prison for sexually assaulting a 9-year-old girl under his care in Canyon Country.
Canyon Country Man Gets 520 Years to Life for Sexual Assaults
An Agua Dulce man pleaded no contest to gross vehicular manslaughter and driving under the influence Tuesday.
Agua Dulce Man Pleads Not Contest to DUI, Vehicular Manslaughter
Associated Students Sustainability and Recycling Services at California State University, Northridge recently hosted its annual America Recycles Day.
Students at CSUN Participate in America Recycles Day
American Indian tribes from around the United States gathered at California State University, Northridge for a day of celebration at the 33rd annual Powwow.
CSUN Hosts American Indian Tribes for 33rd Powwow