[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | L.A. County Stormwater Runoff Lawsuit Takes Another Turn | 11-01-2016
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
79°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
April 26
1906 - Bobby Batugo, World Champion Mixologist in the 1970s, born in The Philippines [story]


storm_drain[CN] – The Ninth Circuit on Monday reversed dismissal of environmental groups’ challenge to how Los Angeles County discharges polluted storm water, because the county has not made it “‘absolutely clear’ that no violation will occur in the future.”

The long-running dispute started in 2008, when the Natural Resources Defense Council claimed that L.A. County and its Flood Control District violated their 2001 National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit by discharging water that was more heavily polluted than allowed.

The county took out a new permit in 2012, which was more complicated, and included deadlines for achieving water quality in polluted areas. The county has begun setting up programs to cover all of its watershed areas and has obtained approval for some of them. So, the county argued, it was in compliance with the 2012 permit and the environmentalists’ requests for civil penalties and injunctive relief were moot. The district court agreed with the county regarding and dismissed.

The Ninth Circuit panel unanimously reversed on Monday.

“The plaintiffs’ claims for injunctive relief are not moot because the county defendants are still subject to receiving water limitations, which are substantially the same as the limitations in the 2001 permit,” Ninth Circuit Judge Milan D. Smith wrote. “Although the county defendants are significantly less likely to violate those limitations under the 2012 Permit, because of the delay and partial exemption afforded by the safe harbor of WMPs and EWMPs, it is not ‘absolutely clear’ that their violations will not recur.”

The county argued that the 2012 permit’s compliance requirements superseded those of the 2001 permit. But Judge Smith found that the baseline limitations are almost the same and the onus is on the county to maintain compliance.

“Because compliance is conditional on the success of these programs, the county defendants bear the burden of demonstrating that it is ‘absolutely clear’ the violations will not recur, either through the use of the safe harbor of the WMPs [watershed management programs] and EWMPs [enhanced watershed management programs] or through actual pollution reduction measures.”

The district court also agreed with the county’s argument that that there was no evidence that the county would not comply with the 2012 permit. But this erroneously shifted the burden of proof to the plaintiffs, to demonstrate that future violations would occur. The county did not provide evidence that continued compliance was likely, as since the safe harbor program may violate the Clean Water Act and the watershed management programs will be costly and complicated.

The 2012 permit created a safe harbor program that allowed permit-holders to “initiate, develop, revise, and implement a voluntary watershed management program … or enhanced watershed management program,” Smith wrote.

“Until the county defendants have finished the process of financing and implementing the WMPs, there is a significant likelihood that they will be subject to and violate the baseline receiving water limitations. Initiation of a reform process cannot, standing alone, make it ‘absolutely’ clear’ that the reformation will last.”

Steve Fleischli, the council’s water director and senior attorney praised the ruling.

“We’re pleased that the court has confirmed our right to seek injunctive relief,” Fleischli said. “I think it’s important that the country stick to their obligation to clean up their storm water pollution.”

Polluted storm water is a major problem in many urban areas, he said, where it can get into local rivers and lakes and harm wildlife. In Los Angeles, the polluted water is shunted into the oceans and has an adverse impact on the beaches, an area of great economic import to Southern California, making it all the more important for the county to fix this problem.

“The way we view that, the county has an obligation to do all that now, and they’ve been dragging their feet on that,” Fleischli said.

Aaron Colangelo, the council’s co-litigation director, argued the case.

Joining Smith on the panel were Ninth Circuit Judge Harry Pregerson and U.S. Senior District Judge H. Russel Holland, from the District of Alaska, sitting by designation.

Joining the Natural Resources Defense Council as plaintiff/appellant is Santa Monica Baykeeper.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


Related Content
LOS ANGELES COUNTY HEADLINES
Tuesday, Apr 25, 2017
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra today called out the U.S. Department of Education for abdicating its responsibility to millions of student loan borrowers and their families across the country.
Tuesday, Apr 25, 2017
Senator Scott Wilk, R-Antelope Valley, Monday urged Governor Jerry Brown to reconsider his support of legislation hiking the gas tax and veto Senate Bill 1.
Monday, Apr 24, 2017
Laura Zucker announced her plans to leave her position as Executive Director of the Los Angeles County Arts Commission on July 31, 2017.
Thursday, Apr 20, 2017
Attorney General Xavier Becerra today announced a $9.8 million settlement with Walgreens, one of the largest drugstore chains in the United States.
Thursday, Apr 20, 2017
California’s state wildlife and transportation departments signed a credit agreement on an innovative pilot project to create advanced mitigation credits for wildlife highway crossings.
Keep Up With Our Facebook
-->
Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station needs the public's help in identifying individuals wanted for questioning about a theft that occurred at a Magic Mountain Parkway business.
SCV Sheriffs Need Public’s Help in Identifying Two Wanted for Questioning
1906 - Bobby Batugo, World Champion Mixologist in the 1970s, born in The Philippines [story]
In a press conference held at the Henry Mayo Center on Tuesday, speakers including Henry Mayo Emergency Room Dr. Tracy Lawrence and Cary Quashen, executive director of Behavioral Health and Henry Mayo and director of Action Family Counseling, discuss the recent spike in drug overdoses across the Santa Clarita Valley.
Press Conf.: Officials Discuss Spike in Drug Overdoses (Video)
California State University, Northridge will confer honorary doctorates on financial journalist William C. Griffeth and substance-abuse educator Michael Watanabe, president and CEO of Asian American Drug Abuse Program (AADAP).
CSUN Giving Honorary Doctorates to Substance-Abuse Educator, Business News Anchor
Careless motorists as well as riders get special scrutiny as the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department aims to improve motorcycle safety.
LASD Looking to Improve Motorcycle Safety
The FDA is warning consumers to beware of products claiming to cure cancer on websites or social media platforms, such as Facebook and Instagram.
FDA Warns Consumers to Beware of Fake Cancer ‘Cures’
The College of the Canyons women’s volleyball program invites boys and girls ages 9-14 to participate in the 2017 COC Volleyball Camp, with two sessions running in July.
COC Athletics to Host 2017 Volleyball Summer Camp
America’s Job Center of California invites residents to connect with new employers, find a new career path or get back into the workforce by attending the Hiring Fest on Friday, April 28, 2017, from 9:00 to 11:00 a.m. at the College of the Canyons University Center, located at 26455 Rockwell Canyon Road.
April 28: Get Hired at the AJCC Hiring Fest
With warmer weather on the way, motorcycle riders will be gearing up and taking to California’s roadways.
CHP, OTS Promoting Motorcycle Safety Throughout May
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra today called out the U.S. Department of Education for abdicating its responsibility to millions of student loan borrowers and their families across the country.
A.G. Becerra Discusses Student Loan Serving Reforms
Senator Scott Wilk, R-Antelope Valley, Monday urged Governor Jerry Brown to reconsider his support of legislation hiking the gas tax and veto Senate Bill 1.
Wilk Urging Governor to Veto Transportation Legislation
The College of the Canyons men’s basketball program invites boys and girls ages 6 to 14 to participate in the 2017 Howard Fisher Cougar Basketball Camp, with two sessions running this summer.
COC Athletic Department to Host 2017 Cougar Basketball Summer Camp
Bridge to Home, SCV homeless service provider, gave a Humanitarian Award to Yaniv Rokah, Director of the internationally acclaimed documentary movie "Queen Mimi" at the Cowboy Breakfast Fundraiser in Newhall on Saturday.
Bridge to Home Gives Humanitarian Award to Film Director
Canyon Country Crime Information and Public Safety Report for the Week of April 10-16, 2017
Crime Blotter: Grand Theft Auto, Aggravated Assault in Canyon Country
1891 - President Benjamin Harrison stops at Saugus Depot, dines at Tolfree's Saugus Eating House [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, we look back at the 2017 Cowboy Festival. Plus, the first Measure E bonds have been sold. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Monday, April 24, 2017
As part of National Volunteer Week, which runs from April 23 to 29, 2017, the city of Santa Clarita thanks the thousands of volunteers who dedicate their time and energy to the community.
City of Santa Clarita Thanks Volunteers during National Volunteer Week
Join HandsOn Santa Clarita for a night of poker, prizes, a silent auction and great food all while supporting this organization on Friday, May 5 at The Paseo Club.
May 5: Cinco de Mayo Charity Poker Tournament for HandsOn Santa Clarita
Last month (March 2017), Welcome to My Life won an NYICFF (New York Children's Film Festival) Audience Award for children (between 12 and 17 years old).
CalArts Animator Wins NYICFF Audience Award
Laura Zucker announced her plans to leave her position as Executive Director of the Los Angeles County Arts Commission on July 31, 2017.
LA County Arts Commission Exec. Director to Leave Position
The first bonds from Measure E, the Santa Clarita Community College District $230 million general obligation bonds approved by voters in June 2016, were sold on April 12, yielding $50 million to assist in funding a new parking structure at the college’s Valencia campus and two new buildings at its Canyon Country campus.
First Measure E Bonds Sold, Yield $50 Million
Upcoming arts and culture events in the Santa Clarita Valley.
SCV Arts Upcoming Events
Detectives from the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department’s Missing Persons Detail are working together with South Pasadena Police Department in seeking the public’s assistance to locate a missing critical child, Andressian, Aramazd Jr.
LASD, SCV Search and Rescue Looking for Missing Boy
As part of National Bike Month, the city of Santa Clarita will host a week of bicycle-focused events and activities leading up to and after the world-class cycling race, Amgen Tour of California, presented by AEG.
City Hosting Free Bike Week Events Leading to Amgen Tour
Agenda for the City Council Committee Development Committee Meeting on April 25 at 4:00 p.m. in the City Hall, Mural Room.
April 25: City Council Development Committee Meeting
The Rotary Club of Santa Clarita and The Newhall Rotary Foundation graciously donated $2,700 to assist with the cost of re-flooring the Val Verde Samuel Dixon Family Health Center.
Rotary Club, Newhall Rotary Foundation Join Efforts to Remodel Val Verde Health Center
Sam Hilliard delivered a game-tying double in the ninth inning, but for the second straight day, the Lake Elsinore Storm won in walk-off fashion, 7-6, in 10 innings on Sunday afternoon at The Diamond.
Jethawks Force Extra Innings, Fall in the 10th
Valencia Crime Information and Public Safety Report for the Week of April 10-16, 2017
Crime Blotter: Grand Theft, Burglary in Valencia
Saugus Crime Information and Public Safety Report for the Week of April 10-16, 2017
Crime Blotter: Assault with a Deadly Weapon, Grand Theft Auto in Saugus
Castaic/ Val Verde Crime Information and Public Safety Report for the Week of April 10-16, 2017
Crime Blotter: Domestic Dispute, Grand Theft Auto in Castaic, Val Verde
1962 - SCV residents vote to connect to State Water Project, creating CLWA [story]
1986 - COC board votes to allow Argentine cliff swallows to nest forever on sides of buildings [story]
1974 - Gov. Ronald Reagan speaks at dedication of COC's first permanent building, the William G. Bonelli Instructional Resource Center [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, a social media post by a Valencia High School student sparked alarm. Plus, we round-up some great events happening in Santa Clarita this weekend. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, April 21, 2017
The Santa Clarita Public Library has recently named Matthew Hortt as City Librarian. Matthew Hortt will be working with the city of Santa Clarita overseeing programming and operations for the Santa Clarita Public Library’s three branches in Canyon Country, Newhall and Valencia.
Santa Clarita Public Library Welcomes New City Librarian
In an off-market transaction, Colliers International has negotiated the $69.5 million sale of Gateway Village Shopping Center in Santa Clarita.
Valencia L.A. Fitness Shopping Center Sells for $69.5 Mil.