[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | L.A. County Stormwater Runoff Lawsuit Takes Another Turn | 11-01-2016
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
56°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
February 23
1998 - Worst day of record-setting 1997-98 El Nino storm season [story]


storm_drain[CN] – The Ninth Circuit on Monday reversed dismissal of environmental groups’ challenge to how Los Angeles County discharges polluted storm water, because the county has not made it “‘absolutely clear’ that no violation will occur in the future.”

The long-running dispute started in 2008, when the Natural Resources Defense Council claimed that L.A. County and its Flood Control District violated their 2001 National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit by discharging water that was more heavily polluted than allowed.

The county took out a new permit in 2012, which was more complicated, and included deadlines for achieving water quality in polluted areas. The county has begun setting up programs to cover all of its watershed areas and has obtained approval for some of them. So, the county argued, it was in compliance with the 2012 permit and the environmentalists’ requests for civil penalties and injunctive relief were moot. The district court agreed with the county regarding and dismissed.

The Ninth Circuit panel unanimously reversed on Monday.

“The plaintiffs’ claims for injunctive relief are not moot because the county defendants are still subject to receiving water limitations, which are substantially the same as the limitations in the 2001 permit,” Ninth Circuit Judge Milan D. Smith wrote. “Although the county defendants are significantly less likely to violate those limitations under the 2012 Permit, because of the delay and partial exemption afforded by the safe harbor of WMPs and EWMPs, it is not ‘absolutely clear’ that their violations will not recur.”

The county argued that the 2012 permit’s compliance requirements superseded those of the 2001 permit. But Judge Smith found that the baseline limitations are almost the same and the onus is on the county to maintain compliance.

“Because compliance is conditional on the success of these programs, the county defendants bear the burden of demonstrating that it is ‘absolutely clear’ the violations will not recur, either through the use of the safe harbor of the WMPs [watershed management programs] and EWMPs [enhanced watershed management programs] or through actual pollution reduction measures.”

The district court also agreed with the county’s argument that that there was no evidence that the county would not comply with the 2012 permit. But this erroneously shifted the burden of proof to the plaintiffs, to demonstrate that future violations would occur. The county did not provide evidence that continued compliance was likely, as since the safe harbor program may violate the Clean Water Act and the watershed management programs will be costly and complicated.

The 2012 permit created a safe harbor program that allowed permit-holders to “initiate, develop, revise, and implement a voluntary watershed management program … or enhanced watershed management program,” Smith wrote.

“Until the county defendants have finished the process of financing and implementing the WMPs, there is a significant likelihood that they will be subject to and violate the baseline receiving water limitations. Initiation of a reform process cannot, standing alone, make it ‘absolutely’ clear’ that the reformation will last.”

Steve Fleischli, the council’s water director and senior attorney praised the ruling.

“We’re pleased that the court has confirmed our right to seek injunctive relief,” Fleischli said. “I think it’s important that the country stick to their obligation to clean up their storm water pollution.”

Polluted storm water is a major problem in many urban areas, he said, where it can get into local rivers and lakes and harm wildlife. In Los Angeles, the polluted water is shunted into the oceans and has an adverse impact on the beaches, an area of great economic import to Southern California, making it all the more important for the county to fix this problem.

“The way we view that, the county has an obligation to do all that now, and they’ve been dragging their feet on that,” Fleischli said.

Aaron Colangelo, the council’s co-litigation director, argued the case.

Joining Smith on the panel were Ninth Circuit Judge Harry Pregerson and U.S. Senior District Judge H. Russel Holland, from the District of Alaska, sitting by designation.

Joining the Natural Resources Defense Council as plaintiff/appellant is Santa Monica Baykeeper.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


Related Content
LOS ANGELES COUNTY HEADLINES
Wednesday, Feb 22, 2017
The California State Archives launched a new online exhibit celebrating the 50 year anniversary and history of the California Legislative Black Caucus (CLBC). In 2006, the CLBC submitted their historical materials to the State Archives for lasting preservation. This exhibit provides highlights of the CLBC’s collection, profiles trailblazers and chronicles milestones in the caucus’ history.
Wednesday, Feb 22, 2017
California State Parks’ Office of Grants and Local Services announced that it is accepting applications for the Outdoor Environmental Education Facilities Grant Program. The application due date is Friday, Sept. 1, 2017.
Wednesday, Feb 22, 2017
By age 21, one in three girls in foster care will give birth. These alarming numbers are proof that targeted education is necessary to overcome the stigma and challenges relating to early and unplanned pregnancy prevention. In response, the Board of Supervisors passed a motion, co-authored by Supervisor Hilda L. Solis and Supervisor Sheila Kuehl, to implement the “California’s Plan for the Prevention of Unintended Pregnancies for Youth and Non-Minor Dependents,” better known as “The Plan.”
Tuesday, Feb 21, 2017
In the wake of the shooting death of Officer Keith Boyer, a 27-year veteran of the Whittier Police Department, a motion by Supervisor Kathryn Barger, co-authored by Supervisor Janice Hahn, calls for a full investigation into the suspect’s involvement with the state parole system and county probation supervision.
Tuesday, Feb 21, 2017
Senator Scott Wilk, R - Antelope Valley, announces the introduction of Senate Bill 792 (SB 792), a measure which will bring accountability and fairness to the distribution of Los Angeles County's trauma funding, saying to L.A. County: "Antelope Valley lives matter too".
Keep Up With Our Facebook
-->
Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Santa Clarita Water (SCWD), a division of Castaic Lake Water Agency (CLWA), received the Distinguished Budget Presentation Award presented by the Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA) of the United States and Canada and the California Society of Municipal Finance Officers (CSMFO) Operating Budget Excellence Award for its FY 2016/17 Budget.
Santa Clarita Water Receives GFOA Distinguished Budget Presentation Award
In a continued effort to reduce college costs, College of the Canyons will launch the First Year Promise (FYP) program, a pathway that will provide increased opportunities for new full-time college students to achieve their educational goals, through a $667,000 grant from the California Community Colleges Chancellor’s Office (CCCCO).
COC Receives $667,000 Grant for First Year Promise Program
There is no way you can provide the balanced diet the animals will find in the wild, so do not try to feed any wildlife - even if they look sooo cute.
Animal Rescuing | Commentary by Evelyne Vandersande
1998 - Worst day of record-setting 1997-98 El Nino storm season [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, L.A County Fire Air Ops rescued a stranded hiker Wednesday morning . Plus, have you seen Katy Perry's newest music video? You might notice a familiar place. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, February 22, 2017
Fifth graders from Castaic Elementary School, Live Oak Elementary, Germain Charter Academy, Plum Canyon Elementary, and Dr. J. Michael McGrath Elementary are attending the Blue Ribbon Children's Festival at the Music Center/Performing Arts Center of Los Angeles County.
Fifth Graders from SCV Schools Heading to Blue Ribbon Children’s Festival
Los Angeles County Fire Department Air Operations located and rescued an adult male trapped on a cliff in Placerita Canyon Natural Area late in the night on Wednesday.
Man Rescued in Placerita Canyon Natural Area
The Saugus Union School District Measure EE Committee meeting is scheduled for Thursday, Feb. 23, 2017 at 6 p.m. in the Caulfield Room at the SUSD District Office. Agenda topics include approval of minutes, a hearing session and a Measure EE update from staff.
Feb. 23: SUSD Measure EE Oversight Meeting
SCV Sheriff's traffic investigators are seeking information on a fatal Valencia traffic collision that led to the death of one woman.
Valencia Traffic Collision Kills One, Information Needed
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson and the California Student Aid Commission (CSAC) announced that applications for the California Dream Act are down significantly and urged all eligible students to apply for the program, which allows undocumented students to receive state financial aid for college.
California Dream Act Applications Available
New work by James Welling (Art BFA 72, MFA 74) is on display at S.M.A.K., the Museum of Contemporary Art, in Ghent, Belgium from Jan. 28 through April 16.
CalArts Alumni’s Photography on Display in Belgium
Kirsten Lepore (Film/Video MFA 12) co-directed an animated video with actress Lena Dunham for Planned Parenthood's centennial. The short educational video, which has tallied more than 3 million views on Facebook since its Jan. 16 release, combines stop motion animation, illustration, and archival photos and audio to document the nonprofit organization's past 100 years.
CalArts Alumni Co-Directs Planned Parenthood’s Centennial Animated Video
REGULAR MEETING of the GOVERNING BOARD Sulphur Springs Union SD February 22, 2017 7:00PM Sulphur Springs Union School District District Administrative Offices 27000 Weyerhaeuser Way Santa Clarita, CA 91351 661-252-5131
Feb. 22: Sulphur Springs School District Governing Board Meeting
Gabe Woodward, bronze medalist in the 4x100 meter freestyle at the 2004 Olympics, All-American swimmer and 2001 graduate of USC, joins The Master’s University to launch their first ever swimming and diving program for the Fall 2017 season.
Olympic Medalist to Launch TMU Aquatics Program
No. 13 College of the Canyons dropped its first game of the season to Santa Barbara City College on Tuesday, as the Vaqueros scored three runs in the seventh to down the Cougars 7-4 at Whitten Field.
No. 13 Canyons Drops First Game of Season 7-4 to Santa Barbara
College of the Canyons took a 1-1 tie into the seventh inning vs. Fullerton College on Tuesday, before allowing six runs in a decisive eighth inning that gave the Hornets an eventual 7-1 victory.
Big Inning Costs Canyons in 7-1 Loss to Fullerton
The Lady Cougars finished the 2016-17 season in winning fashion by recording a convincing 68-48 victory over visiting West L.A. College despite finish the game with just four players on the floor.
Lady Cougars Close Season With 68-48 Win vs. West L.A.
College of the Canyons finished its season with a 71-66 loss to West L.A. College in a game that saw the Cougars play to an eight-point halftime lead before giving way to mistakes down the stretch.
Canyons Concludes Season With 71-66 Loss to West L.A.
The Castaic Lake Water Agency received the Operating Budget Excellence Award from the California Society of Municipal Finance Officers (CSMFO) for its FY 2016/17 Budget. This is the tenth consecutive year in which the Agency has received this award.
CLWA Receives Operating Budget Excellence Award
Crossroads Community Church is hosting a city-wide Easter Service at College of the Canyons Cougar Field on Sunday, April 16, 2017. For the sixth year, this non-denominational Easter Service is open to the public.
April 16: Crossroads Community Church Hosts Easter Service at COC
Are the needs of grandparents and other relatives who care for children truly being met in Los Angeles County? Researchers at California State University, Northridge have received a $165,756 grant from the Eisner Foundation to answer that question and others, as they take a serious look at the programs offered by one of the county’s largest providers of services to grandparents and other family caregivers, the nonprofit Grandparent as Parents (GAP). Once completed, the researchers will use their study as a catalyst for a conference on understanding the needs of this underserved and growing population.
CSUN Researchers Receive Grant Studying Services Provided to Grandparents, Family Caregivers
The California State Archives launched a new online exhibit celebrating the 50 year anniversary and history of the California Legislative Black Caucus (CLBC). In 2006, the CLBC submitted their historical materials to the State Archives for lasting preservation. This exhibit provides highlights of the CLBC’s collection, profiles trailblazers and chronicles milestones in the caucus’ history.
State Archives Launches California Legislative Black Caucus Exhibit
California State Parks’ Office of Grants and Local Services announced that it is accepting applications for the Outdoor Environmental Education Facilities Grant Program. The application due date is Friday, Sept. 1, 2017.
State Accepting Applications for Outdoor Environmental Education Facilities Grant Program
By age 21, one in three girls in foster care will give birth. These alarming numbers are proof that targeted education is necessary to overcome the stigma and challenges relating to early and unplanned pregnancy prevention. In response, the Board of Supervisors passed a motion, co-authored by Supervisor Hilda L. Solis and Supervisor Sheila Kuehl, to implement the “California’s Plan for the Prevention of Unintended Pregnancies for Youth and Non-Minor Dependents,” better known as “The Plan.”
County Supes Implement Plan for Prevention of Unintended Pregnancies
Instagram and photography lovers, this one is for you: there is a free exhibit featuring Instagram photos taken by community members on display at the Newhall Community Center.
Instagram Exhibit Showcases Creativity in Social Media
The Castaic Lake Water Agency Retail Operations Committee meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, Feb. 28, 2017 at 5:30 p.m. at the Santa Clarita Water Division Training Room. Agenda topics include the Water Production Report, finance and budget report, and more.
Feb. 28: CLWA Retail Operations Committee Meeting
Canyon Country (West) Crime Report: Week of February 6-12
Crime Blotter: Residential Burglary, Commercial Burglary in West Canyon Country
1983 - Armed robber taken out at Alpha Beta supermarket on Lyons [story]
In the wake of the shooting death of Officer Keith Boyer, a 27-year veteran of the Whittier Police Department, a motion by Supervisor Kathryn Barger, co-authored by Supervisor Janice Hahn, calls for a full investigation into the suspect’s involvement with the state parole system and county probation supervision.
Barger Requests Investigation into Felon Suspected of Killing Whittier Officer
The County Interim Health Officer is issuing a Cold Weather Alert due to the National Weather Service’s forecast for low temperatures. Wind chill temperatures are expected to be below 32 degrees Fahrenheit.
Cold Weather Alert for SCV, A.V., Mountain Areas
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Homicide detectives still need your help in finding 58 year old William Cierzan, a missing man from Valencia who disappeared more than a month ago. Plus, photography and Instagram lovers can see Instagram photos from the community and have the chance to see their own works on display as well. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Tuesday, February 21, 2017
Senator Scott Wilk, R - Antelope Valley, announces the introduction of Senate Bill 792 (SB 792), a measure which will bring accountability and fairness to the distribution of Los Angeles County's trauma funding, saying to L.A. County: "Antelope Valley lives matter too".
Wilk Measure Brings Sunshine to Trauma Funding in Antelope Valley
See what's coming from the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce.
Upcoming SCV Chamber of Commerce Events
The current political climate in the United States has sparked fears of new anti-immigration laws and a potential culture war, prompting scholarly discussions about the necessity of ethnic studies and cultural awareness. A landmark of these discussions is the two-volume anthology “White” Washing American Education: The New Culture Wars in Ethnic Studies — a collaboration from California State University, Northridge ethnic studies professors.
CSUN Professors Collaborate on Anthology Exploring Ethnic Studies Education
The city of Santa Clarita strongly encourages residents and business owners who have been impacted by the recent storm to report damages to their homes, properties and businesses by completing the Los Angeles County’s Damage Assessment Survey located online at www.211la.org/damage-assessment-survey.
City Encouraging Residents, Businesses Owners to Report Storm Damages
Effective 8 a.m. this Thursday, February 23, Lake Oroville State Recreation Area (SRA) partially reopens. Areas surrounding the Thermalito Diversion Pool (Burma Day Use and Lakeland Day Use) and Spillway Launch Ramp will remain closed.
California State Parks Partially Opens Lake Oroville State Recreation Area