[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | L.A. County Stormwater Runoff Lawsuit Takes Another Turn | 11-01-2016
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
72°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
August 17
1920 - Actress Maureen O'Hara born in Ireland; 1961 "Parent Trap" uses Disney Golden Oak Ranch [story]


storm_drain[CN] – The Ninth Circuit on Monday reversed dismissal of environmental groups’ challenge to how Los Angeles County discharges polluted storm water, because the county has not made it “‘absolutely clear’ that no violation will occur in the future.”

The long-running dispute started in 2008, when the Natural Resources Defense Council claimed that L.A. County and its Flood Control District violated their 2001 National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit by discharging water that was more heavily polluted than allowed.

The county took out a new permit in 2012, which was more complicated, and included deadlines for achieving water quality in polluted areas. The county has begun setting up programs to cover all of its watershed areas and has obtained approval for some of them. So, the county argued, it was in compliance with the 2012 permit and the environmentalists’ requests for civil penalties and injunctive relief were moot. The district court agreed with the county regarding and dismissed.

The Ninth Circuit panel unanimously reversed on Monday.

“The plaintiffs’ claims for injunctive relief are not moot because the county defendants are still subject to receiving water limitations, which are substantially the same as the limitations in the 2001 permit,” Ninth Circuit Judge Milan D. Smith wrote. “Although the county defendants are significantly less likely to violate those limitations under the 2012 Permit, because of the delay and partial exemption afforded by the safe harbor of WMPs and EWMPs, it is not ‘absolutely clear’ that their violations will not recur.”

The county argued that the 2012 permit’s compliance requirements superseded those of the 2001 permit. But Judge Smith found that the baseline limitations are almost the same and the onus is on the county to maintain compliance.

“Because compliance is conditional on the success of these programs, the county defendants bear the burden of demonstrating that it is ‘absolutely clear’ the violations will not recur, either through the use of the safe harbor of the WMPs [watershed management programs] and EWMPs [enhanced watershed management programs] or through actual pollution reduction measures.”

The district court also agreed with the county’s argument that that there was no evidence that the county would not comply with the 2012 permit. But this erroneously shifted the burden of proof to the plaintiffs, to demonstrate that future violations would occur. The county did not provide evidence that continued compliance was likely, as since the safe harbor program may violate the Clean Water Act and the watershed management programs will be costly and complicated.

The 2012 permit created a safe harbor program that allowed permit-holders to “initiate, develop, revise, and implement a voluntary watershed management program … or enhanced watershed management program,” Smith wrote.

“Until the county defendants have finished the process of financing and implementing the WMPs, there is a significant likelihood that they will be subject to and violate the baseline receiving water limitations. Initiation of a reform process cannot, standing alone, make it ‘absolutely’ clear’ that the reformation will last.”

Steve Fleischli, the council’s water director and senior attorney praised the ruling.

“We’re pleased that the court has confirmed our right to seek injunctive relief,” Fleischli said. “I think it’s important that the country stick to their obligation to clean up their storm water pollution.”

Polluted storm water is a major problem in many urban areas, he said, where it can get into local rivers and lakes and harm wildlife. In Los Angeles, the polluted water is shunted into the oceans and has an adverse impact on the beaches, an area of great economic import to Southern California, making it all the more important for the county to fix this problem.

“The way we view that, the county has an obligation to do all that now, and they’ve been dragging their feet on that,” Fleischli said.

Aaron Colangelo, the council’s co-litigation director, argued the case.

Joining Smith on the panel were Ninth Circuit Judge Harry Pregerson and U.S. Senior District Judge H. Russel Holland, from the District of Alaska, sitting by designation.

Joining the Natural Resources Defense Council as plaintiff/appellant is Santa Monica Baykeeper.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


Related Content
LOS ANGELES COUNTY HEADLINES
Wednesday, Aug 16, 2017
The Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations released a statement Wednesday morning, condemning the violence and mourning a death in Charlottesville.
Tuesday, Aug 15, 2017
On a motion by Supervisors Kathryn Barger and Janice Hahn, the Board of Supervisors voted 3-0, with Supervisor Mark Ridley-Thomas abstaining, to establish a “Blue Ribbon Commission on Public Safety” to explore innovative solutions to criminal justice challenges resulting from statewide reform
Tuesday, Aug 15, 2017
In recent weeks, the Greater Los Angeles County Vector Control District (GLACVCD) has seen a marked increase in West Nile virus (WNV) activity across its jurisdiction.
Monday, Aug 14, 2017
Purposeful Aging Los Angeles launched a landmark survey today to gather feedback from county and city of Los Angeles residents that will guide the development of an Age-Friendly Action Plan for 2018-2021 for the region.
Friday, Aug 11, 2017
Two labor groups have sued Los Angeles County Sheriff Jim McDonnell seeking a court order to release communications between his department and the Trump administration about California’s sanctuary bill.
Keep Up With Our Facebook
-->
Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
San Francisquito Road was reduced to one lane for a couple of hours Wednesday night when a car traveling northbound, at a high-rate of speed, collided with a vehicle traveling the opposite direction, according to a police report released by the California Highway Patrol.
San Francisquito Road Collision Leads to Major Injuries, Road Closures
1920 - Actress Maureen O'Hara born in Ireland; 1961 "Parent Trap" uses Disney Golden Oak Ranch [story]
Farmers and environmentalists are lining up to battle the $16.7 billion California WaterFix tunnels project proposed for the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta.
Farmers, Environmentalists Join to Fight California ‘WaterFix’ Project
There's a new Grizzly at Golden Valley High School as Matt Sorensen has been named the school's new head baseball coach.
Matt Sorenson New Head Baseball Coach at Golden Valley
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Sheriff’s deputies are continuing to conduct burglary suppression operations in our valley. Plus, Representative Steve Knight sat down with local law enforcement to discuss the current state and future role of policing in the SCV. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, August 16, 2017
The Saugus Union School Board is establishing a committee to advise on the development of policies and procedures for the sale or lease of surplus real property owned by the District.
Saugus Board Creates Surplus Property Advisory Committee
The SCV Sanitation Board has provided an update in its efforts to comply with the state-mandated chloride limit, including finalizing the Recirculated EIR released for public comment in May.
SCV Sanitation Board Finalizing EIR Due August 18
"Music, Volume 1," the latest album by platinum recording artist and CalArts' School of Music namesake Herb Alpert, recently reached the No. 1 spot on the Billboard Contemporary Jazz Albums chart.
Herb Alpert’s Latest Album Tops Billboard Jazz Chart
The Castaic Union School District's Governing Board will hold a special meeting on Thursday, August 17 at 5 p.m.
August 17: Castaic Schools Governing Board Special Meeting
MannKind Corp. is moving its corporate headquarters to Westlake Village, after nearly 17 years in Valencia, according to the latest quarterly report it filed with the SEC.
MannKind Corp. Moving from Valencia to Westlake Village
CalArts grads Mark Bradford and Sharon Lockhart headline the Un-Private Collection artist talk at the Orpheum Wednesday night, presented by the Broad museum of contemporary art.
August 16: CalArtians Mark Bradford, Sharon Lockhart at Broad in L.A.
Santa Clarita Valley International School has hired veteran coach Ken Erenberg as athletic director, the school announced today.
Ken Erenberg Named SCVi Athletic Director
The Los Angeles Dodgers took the first of the two-game Interleague series with a 6-1 victory over the White Sox at Dodger Stadium Tuesday night.
Dodgers Soil White Sox 6-1 Tuesday
40 oz. to Freedom arrives in Santa Clarita as part of its anniversary tour at Concerts in the Park at Central Park on Saturday, August 19, with showtime at 7 p.m.
August 19: 40 Oz. to Freedom Rocks Central Park
Senator Scott Wilk, R- Antelope Valley, today submitted a letter to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation during a public comment period regarding proposed regulations that could lead to the early release of dangerous "nonviolent" inmates and diminish victim rights.
Wilk Urges Public Safety When Releasing ‘Non-Violent’ Felons
The Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations released a statement Wednesday morning, condemning the violence and mourning a death in Charlottesville.
County Commission Mourns Death of Charlottesville Protester
Garrett Hampson, the Cal League’s reigning Player of the Week, slugged a two-run home run to lead the Lancaster JetHawks to a 5-3 win over the San Jose Giants on Tuesday night at Municipal Stadium.
Hampson Stays Hot, Lifts ‘Hawks Over Giants
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station deputies arrested three suspects and seized drugs and weapons in a recent burglary suppression operation.
SCV Deputies Arrest 3, Seize Drugs, Weapons
1947 - Newhall Hardware opens on Spruce Street, now called Main Street [story]
Representative Steve Knight, R-Palmdale, sat down with Santa Clarita law enforcement officials to discuss the current state and future role of policing in the SCV.
Knight, Law Enforcement Officials Hold Roundtable Discussion
From the Facebook page of Shirley Miller, public information officer, social media manager at Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station: LASD Carjacker Captured (with some help).
Community Member Tackles Suspected Carjacker
A funeral service for William Clinton Cloyd Sr., a renowned architect and home builder in the Santa Clarita Valley, is being held Wednesday, August 16 in Eternal Valley’s Upper Chapel.
Funeral Services Wednesday for SCV Homebuilder, Architect William Cloyd Sr.
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, deputies are looking for a hit-and-run suspect. Plus, county supervisors have approved a motion to a establish a Blue Ribbon Commission on public safety.. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Tuesday, August 15, 2017
To kick-start its celebration of the 10th Anniversary of the revival of TMU Theatre Arts, the school is bringing back a favorite.
TMU Celebrates 10th Anniversary Revival of Theater Arts
College of the Canyons is hosting 2017 Professional Development Week — a week of seminars, lectures, and workshops concerning student development and teaching.
COC Professional Development Week Underway
In the fall, College of the Canyons will offer several Associate Degrees for Transfer (AD-T) at the Canyon Country campus, including Business Administration, Psychology, and Sociology.
COC Will Now Offer “Degrees With a Guarantee”
On a motion by Supervisors Kathryn Barger and Janice Hahn, the Board of Supervisors voted 3-0, with Supervisor Mark Ridley-Thomas abstaining, to establish a “Blue Ribbon Commission on Public Safety” to explore innovative solutions to criminal justice challenges resulting from statewide reform
Supes Approve Blue Ribbon Commission on Public Safety
If left uncontrolled, diabetes can lead to some really bad outcomes, including kidney problems, glaucoma and other eye disorders, foot ulcers, amputation of feet or legs, stroke, diabetic coma, and even death.
Medicare and Your Diabetes | Commentary by Greg Dill
In recent weeks, the Greater Los Angeles County Vector Control District (GLACVCD) has seen a marked increase in West Nile virus (WNV) activity across its jurisdiction.
County Seeing Increase in West Nile Virus Activity
Arroyo Seco Junior High School will be celebrating its 50th Anniversary on Friday, September 1, with a midday ceremony and festivities.
Sept. 1: Arroyo Seco Junior High Celebrates 50th Anniversary
A veteran investigator of sex crimes in Santa Clarita discussed concerns created by coverage and social media, as part an ongoing KHTS News series.
Social Media Poses New Concerns for Sex Crimes Investigations
On Friday, August 18th, 2017, the California Highway Patrol Newhall Area Office will be conducting a sobriety checkpoint in the unincorporated area of Los Angeles County.
DUI Checkpoint Scheduled for Friday
Communication With All Life University and founder Joan Ranquet to present upcoming workshops in learning animal communication, energy healing techniques for animals, and death & the art of dying.
Oct. 6-15: Animal Communication Workshops
Join the VIA Education Foundation and the Valley Industry Association in mentoring today's high school students to prepare them for their future.
VIA School Program Looking for Facilitators to Mentor Students
The city of Santa Clarita will host the 23rd Annual River Rally Cleanup and Environmental Expo on Saturday, September 23, 2017 from 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 a.m.
Sept. 22-23: Registration Deadline, Annual River Rally Cleanup