[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | L.A. County Stormwater Runoff Lawsuit Takes Another Turn | 11-01-2016
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Clear
Clear
67°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
June 22
1932 - Larry Thornton, Hart High band director 1969-89, born in Kern County [story]


storm_drain[CN] – The Ninth Circuit on Monday reversed dismissal of environmental groups’ challenge to how Los Angeles County discharges polluted storm water, because the county has not made it “‘absolutely clear’ that no violation will occur in the future.”

The long-running dispute started in 2008, when the Natural Resources Defense Council claimed that L.A. County and its Flood Control District violated their 2001 National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit by discharging water that was more heavily polluted than allowed.

The county took out a new permit in 2012, which was more complicated, and included deadlines for achieving water quality in polluted areas. The county has begun setting up programs to cover all of its watershed areas and has obtained approval for some of them. So, the county argued, it was in compliance with the 2012 permit and the environmentalists’ requests for civil penalties and injunctive relief were moot. The district court agreed with the county regarding and dismissed.

The Ninth Circuit panel unanimously reversed on Monday.

“The plaintiffs’ claims for injunctive relief are not moot because the county defendants are still subject to receiving water limitations, which are substantially the same as the limitations in the 2001 permit,” Ninth Circuit Judge Milan D. Smith wrote. “Although the county defendants are significantly less likely to violate those limitations under the 2012 Permit, because of the delay and partial exemption afforded by the safe harbor of WMPs and EWMPs, it is not ‘absolutely clear’ that their violations will not recur.”

The county argued that the 2012 permit’s compliance requirements superseded those of the 2001 permit. But Judge Smith found that the baseline limitations are almost the same and the onus is on the county to maintain compliance.

“Because compliance is conditional on the success of these programs, the county defendants bear the burden of demonstrating that it is ‘absolutely clear’ the violations will not recur, either through the use of the safe harbor of the WMPs [watershed management programs] and EWMPs [enhanced watershed management programs] or through actual pollution reduction measures.”

The district court also agreed with the county’s argument that that there was no evidence that the county would not comply with the 2012 permit. But this erroneously shifted the burden of proof to the plaintiffs, to demonstrate that future violations would occur. The county did not provide evidence that continued compliance was likely, as since the safe harbor program may violate the Clean Water Act and the watershed management programs will be costly and complicated.

The 2012 permit created a safe harbor program that allowed permit-holders to “initiate, develop, revise, and implement a voluntary watershed management program … or enhanced watershed management program,” Smith wrote.

“Until the county defendants have finished the process of financing and implementing the WMPs, there is a significant likelihood that they will be subject to and violate the baseline receiving water limitations. Initiation of a reform process cannot, standing alone, make it ‘absolutely’ clear’ that the reformation will last.”

Steve Fleischli, the council’s water director and senior attorney praised the ruling.

“We’re pleased that the court has confirmed our right to seek injunctive relief,” Fleischli said. “I think it’s important that the country stick to their obligation to clean up their storm water pollution.”

Polluted storm water is a major problem in many urban areas, he said, where it can get into local rivers and lakes and harm wildlife. In Los Angeles, the polluted water is shunted into the oceans and has an adverse impact on the beaches, an area of great economic import to Southern California, making it all the more important for the county to fix this problem.

“The way we view that, the county has an obligation to do all that now, and they’ve been dragging their feet on that,” Fleischli said.

Aaron Colangelo, the council’s co-litigation director, argued the case.

Joining Smith on the panel were Ninth Circuit Judge Harry Pregerson and U.S. Senior District Judge H. Russel Holland, from the District of Alaska, sitting by designation.

Joining the Natural Resources Defense Council as plaintiff/appellant is Santa Monica Baykeeper.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


Related Content
LOS ANGELES COUNTY HEADLINES
Thursday, Jun 22, 2017
Los Angeles County supervisors have scheduled a special meeting on Monday, June 26, to consider final approval of the county's $30 million-plus 2017-18 budget.
Wednesday, Jun 21, 2017
On a 4-1 vote with Supervisor Kathryn Barger opposing, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors Tuesday authorized a $3 million agreement to provide legal defense for illegal immigrants facing deportation.
Friday, Jun 16, 2017
Warm weather is here, bringing with it outdoor fun and, unfortunately, mosquitoes and disease risks.
Friday, Jun 16, 2017
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health (Public Health) has identified the first case of human West Nile virus (WNV) infection in Los Angeles County for the 2017 season (excluding Long Beach and Pasadena as cases identified in those cities are reported by their local health departments).
Friday, Jun 16, 2017
Board of Equalization Vice Chair George Runner issued a statement Thursday in response to legislation passed by the State Senate and Assembly that would strip the Board of its authority to hear taxpayer appeals as well as other regulatory functions.
Keep Up With Our Facebook
-->
Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
June 30 is the deadline for Santa Clarita residents to submit entries to the city's quarterly photo contest.
June 30: Last Day to Enter City’s Summer Photo Contest
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, a road rage incident is caught on camera. Plus, local deputies work on a crime suppression operation. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, June 22, 2017
Olympian Alysia Montaño, a graduate of Canyon High School and a seven-time national champion, is competing in the 2017 USATF Outdoor Championships as she did in 2014 -- while pregnant.
Olympian Alysia Montaño Races Pregnant for a Second Time
A road rage incident on Highway 14 near Newhall Avenue Wednesday morning resulted in a two-car crash and a motorcyclist who remains at large, according to CHP officials.
CHP Seeks Motorcyclist in Road Rage Crash
While Mark Bradford and Sharon Lockhart represent the United States and Poland, respectively, in the prestigious Venice Bienniale (La Biennale di Venezia), two other CalArtians' work is also on view there.
CalArtians Danz and Rosero in 57th Biennale International Art Exhibition
CalArts has named Dimitri Chamblas, former artistic director of the Paris Opera’s creative digital platform 3rd Scene, as the new Dean of The Sharon Disney Lund School of Dance.
CalArts Names Dimitri Chamblas Dean of Lund School of Dance
Los Angeles County supervisors have scheduled a special meeting on Monday, June 26, to consider final approval of the county's $30 million-plus 2017-18 budget.
June 26: County Weighs Budget, Expecting State and Federal Cuts
Bond oversight legislation authored by California State Senator Scott Wilk (R-Antelope Valley) has been given the thumbs-up by the Assembly Education Committee.
Wilk School Bond Oversight Bill Clears Assembly Policy Committee
Air quality will be unhealthy for all individuals in the Santa Clarita Valley and for sensitive individuals in the East San Gabriel Valley and San Gabriel Mountains tomorrow, June 23.
SCV Air Quality Bad on Friday
Castaic residents attending a Town Council meeting expressed their anger over a Taco Bell fast-food restaurant on The Old Road that already has a foundation.
Castaic Locals Angry About New Taco Bell on The Old Road
Responding to a spike in drug overdoses in the Santa Clarita Valley, Bob Sharits of The Way Out Recovery brought together a group of treatment providers to address mental health and addiction treatment during a meeting on Thursday.
Addiction Recovery Providers Meet at Way Out Recovery to Discuss SCV Overdoses
The U.S. House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology today unanimously approved H.R. 2763, the Small Business Innovation Research and Small Business Technology Transfer Improvements Act of 2017, sponsored by U.S. Rep. Steve Knight (R-Calif.).
Knight Small Business Bills Clear Key House Committee
Palmdale Mayor Jim Ledford has been charged with illegally receiving more than $60,000 a year from local consultants and failing to publicly disclose the income on economic statements
Palmdale Mayor, Consultants Charged in Corruption Case
You are cordially invited to the SCV Senior Center's Building Party.
June 22: Building Party to Help Build New SCV Senior Center; Special Guest Appearance by Adam Tunney
Caltrans has scheduled workshops in Los Angeles and Sacramento for June 26 and June 27 respectively to allow Californians to help shape how planning grants will be allocated under Senate Bill 1, The Road Repair and Accountability Act of 2017.
June 26-27: Caltrans Planning Grants Workshops
As a heat wave gripped the Santa Clarita Valley, Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station deputies on Tuesday helped rescue another dog locked in a car in a local parking lot.
SCV Deputies Rescue Another Hot Dog from Car in Parking Lot
Three people charged with murder, including the step-sister of a woman whose body was found in Gorman, were back in court Wednesday for a hearing in connection with the death.
Murder Suspects Back in Court
The Castaic Lake Water Agency's Water Resources Committee meeting originally scheduled for Thursday, July 6 has been rescheduled to Wednesday, July 12 at 5:30 p.m.
CLWA Reschedules Water Resources Meeting to July 12
Hooded orioles must be the most beautiful birds you can see in your backyard. They will be here until the third week of August, so catch a glimpse while you can.
A Sugar Addict | Commentary by Evelyne Vandersande
1932 - Larry Thornton, Hart High band director 1969-89, born in Kern County [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, a dog was rescued Wednesday afternoon by the Santa Clarita Valley’s Sheriff’s Station. Plus, arraignment continues for suspects involved in a murder kidnapping case that occurred last August. Also your weather report. Click the link to see these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, June 21, 2017
Didik Nini Thowok, master dancer from Yogyakarta, Indonesia, held a two-week artist residency at CalArts from April 24 to May 5, 2017.
CalArts Dance: A Turn with Didik Nini Thowok and Ratri Anindyajati
This weekend's musical lineup at the Roy and Edna Disney/CalArts Theater (REDCAT), CalArts' downtown Los Angeles performance space, features the Grammy award-winning ensemble Partch.
June 23-24: Partch Ensemble Performs 1958 Arthouse Film Score at REDCAT
Providence Holy Cross Medical Center is seeking the public’s help in identifying a patient who was critically injured Saturday night when he was hit by a vehicle in North Hollywood.
Hospital Asks Public’s Help to ID Injured Pedestrian
June is Men's Health Month. Do you know what the top health risks are for men? According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, they include heart disease, stroke, cancer and respiratory diseases.
June is Men’s Health Month
[Blank] My Life, a surreal, comedic YouTube webseries follows Susan, a millennial struggling to make it as an artist in New York City.
CalArts Alumni Collaborate on YouTube Series
Runners of all ages will have the opportunity to support the College of the Canyons cross country and track & field programs by participating in the 44th Annual Cross Country Summer Series on Thursday evenings from July 6 to Aug. 17.
July 6-Aug. 17: 44th Annual Cross Country Summer Series
In a year marked by team championships and personal milestones, The Master’s University finished among the top 15% of NAIA athletic programs on the final Learfield Director's Cup standings (38 of 248 current members).
TMU Athletics Year in Review
The Master’s University volleyball program’s 2017 schedule has been released.
TMU 2017 Volleyball Schedule Announced
The Master’s University men’s soccer team’s 2017 schedule has been released.
TMU Men’s 2017 Soccer Schedule Announced
The Master’s University women’s soccer team’s 2017 schedule has been released.
Lady Mustang 2017 Soccer Schedule Released
To make parents' experiences easier when hiring a babysitter, Los Angeles County Sheriff's Deputy Jodi Wolfe offers a few important safety tips
Hiring a Babysitter? Use Sheriff’s Safety Checklist
Princess Cruises has launched a thirst-quenching deal with its “Sip & Sail” cruise promotion, offering free all-inclusive beverages plus an early booking bonus offer
Princess Cruises Serves Up Thirst-Quenching ‘Sip & Sail’ Promo
Camp Power Up Santa Clarita, a free American Diabetes Association summer diabetes prevention camp for youth, is set for the weekend of July 15-16 at the Boys & Girls Club of Santa Clarita Valley's Newhall clubhouse.
July 15-16: Diabetes Prevention Camp for SCV Youth
The city of Santa Clarita continues its summer rehab of city streets this week, with maintenance crews and paving contractors repairing potholes and spreading slurry seal on street surfaces
June 20-29: Santa Clarita Street Rehab
Santa Clarita Regional Theatre will stage live performances of Disney's "The Little Mermaid" at the Santa Clarita Performing Arts Center at College of the Canyons in July and August.
July 22: ‘The Little Mermaid’ Staged by Santa Clarita Regional Theatre