[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | U.S. Supreme Court Won’t Review ‘Lexi’ Case | 01-09-2017
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Partly cloudy
Partly cloudy
47°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
January 21
1914 - Signal newspaper owner-editor Scott Newhall born in San Francisco [story]


The U.S. Supreme Court reported Monday that it will not hear the case involving a former Santa Clarita child with Native American ancestry who was removed from a foster home in Saugus and placed with relatives in Utah.

The decision puts an end to the legal tug-of-war over 6-year-old “Lexi,” which gained media attention last March when her foster parents, Rusty and Summer Page, went public in their opposition to the child’s impending placement with with her relatives, a move that had been planned in 2011 before Lexi came into the Pages’ care.

Two lower courts and the California Supreme Court denied appeals last year to keep Lexi with her foster family.

According to court documents filed with the U.S. Supreme Court by Lexi’s own court-appointed attorney, Christopher Blake, “The minor is satisfied with her current adoptive placement; it is in accord with general principles of California law and with the principles of (the Indian Child Welfare Act), both federal and California. There is simply no need for this court to intervene and upset this adoptive placement to which the minor, her tribe, the agency responsible for her care and custody and her parents, have all agreed.”

Blake also states that both the Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services and the Choctaw Tribe of Oklahoma, in which is Lexi is eligible for enrollment, have chosen Lexi’s relatives in Utah, “and that selection was made before (the Pages) ever assumed any care for the minor, and they were always aware of that fact,” adding that state law “strongly favors relative placement and placement with siblings for dependent minors.”

In a statement released Monday on the “Save Lexi” Facebook page, the Page family wrote: “To say we are heartbroken is an understatement. … We will continue to advocate on Lexi’s behalf. We are her parents and will never give up on her. Our home will always be her home, and we know that one day we will be able to hold her in our arms again. One day she will know how many people fought for her. Lexi, we love you forever and ever.”

“The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to hear the appeal in Lexi’s case. This means the former foster parents have exhausted their appeals, and Lexi can now remain permanently with her sister in the home of their extended family,” said DCFS Public Affairs Director Armand Montiel. “We are satisfied with the Supreme Court’s decision.”

An article by Charlie D. Clark of the Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma, published Jan. 11 in Native Times, states: “The Choctaw Nation is pleased that this lengthy and unnecessary litigation has been brought to an end by the U.S. Supreme Court. Lexi can remain where she belongs, with extended family that will raise her and a sister in the Choctaw tradition. The attorneys who brought the case to the high court made clear from the beginning their goal was not only to remove Lexi from her Utah family, but to overturn the Indian Child Welfare Act. They failed to do so, and the ICWA will continue to protect Native American children’s rights to family and cultural connections.”

Statements from other parties involved in the case will be added to this article as they become available.

Attached are briefs submitted to the U.S. Supreme Court by all parties:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

7 Comments

  1. Star says:

    Lexi, is exactly where she needs to be, where she legally belongs. The interests of this child were met. Lexi is free to blossom without the unnecessary petty vindictiveness of that foster family who used her as a prop to win sympathy from the duped masses of ignorant people living in SCV.

  2. goooey says:

    http://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/archive/B252999.PDF

    “By the time Alexandria was placed with the P.s in December 2011, her extended family in Utah, the R.s, were aware of dependency proceeding and had spoken to representatives of the tribe about their interest in adopting Alexandria. The tribe agreed to initial foster placement with the P.s because it was close to father at a time when he was working on reunification. If reunification services were terminated, the tribe recommended placement with the R.s in Utah.”

    The Utah Family referred to as the R’s were always the first choice for placement if reunification with the biological father failed.

    “On October 4, 2012, the court terminated father’s reunification services and scheduled a hearing for termination of parental rights under Welfare and Institutions Code section 366.26. At the Department’s request on November 16, 2012, the court issued a request for expedited placement, identifying the R.s in Utah as the planned placement under the ICPC.”

    As early as November 16, 2012 a request for expedited placement was issued.

    “On January 17, 2013, while the ICPC request was still in process, Alexandria’s guardian ad litem and court-appointed attorney requested a “Do Not Remove” order to prevent Alexandria from being moved out of state without a court order. ”

    By January 2013, the Page’s blocked the placement of Lexi with the intended adoptive family in Utah. During the 2yrs that lexi was under foster care with the Pages, the Pages was reminded that the child was under ICWA jurisdiction, that the foster placement was _temporary_, that the R’s were the intended adoptive placement family.

    The Page’s most likely acted out of a misguided attempt at safeguarding Lexi’s welfare. but the irony is that they probably ended up causing the most damage by delaying Lexi’s prompt placement for _3 years_

  3. Coastal Sage says:

    Here’s a link to the resume of the appellate lawyer for the foster parents who appealed the California courts’ decisions all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. Now no one in Santa Clarita will ever find out why she took the case. http://wilkinsonwalsh.com/who-we-are/lori-alvino-mcgill/

    Now we’ll never find out what the Goldwater Institute wanted to accomplish by filing an amicus brief in the case in support of the foster parents.

    The U.S. Supreme Court’s docket page for this case tells us that on January 6, 2017 the Justices sat down and discussed a bunch of cases to decide which ones they wanted to hear. It’s pretty bone chilling from the point of view of the foster parents and the little girl involved to think of the U.S. Supreme Court Justices sitting around a table and deciding, in effect “Off with their heads”.

    With my kids, looking back at ancestors who would make up a 1/64th blood line we would have to go all the way back before the Revolutionary War. I bet the same holds true for most families in the USA.

    The upshot of the refusal of the U.S. Supreme Court to hear this case is that if your children are 1/64th Native American, or more, you need to keep your mouth shut about that fact, because if those children are ever involved in a custody lawsuit some Native American tribe can muscle their way in, claim that your child is a Native American and a defacto member of their tribe and dictate who gets custody, regardless of what the judge thinks is right. No I am not kidding.

    • Lina says:

      @Coastal Sage: “Here’s a link to the resume of the appellate lawyer for the foster parents who appealed the California courts’ decisions all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. Now no one in Santa Clarita will ever find out why she took the case.”

      She took it because she is a part of a group that wants to abolish a federal law. Also because no respectable attorney would take such a case, and she was the only one desperate enough for it.

      “Now we’ll never find out what the Goldwater Institute wanted to accomplish by filing an amicus brief in the case in support of the foster parents.”

      The Goldwater Institute wants to destroy it’s founder’s reputation, and so they want to abolish the federal law that the founder was in favour of.
      Also, there is money involved in finalizing adoptions, so people with a financial interest in that will try to create more opportunities to make money whenever they can.

      “The U.S. Supreme Court’s docket page for this case tells us that on January 6, 2017 the Justices sat down and discussed a bunch of cases to decide which ones they wanted to hear. It’s pretty bone chilling from the point of view of the foster parents and the little girl involved to think of the U.S. Supreme Court Justices sitting around a table and deciding, in effect “Off with their heads”.”

      Why are you including the girl in that? She wants to stay in Utah, with her baby sister and her family. She does not want her former fosters.
      And the former fosters have done absolutely nothing to earn sympathy points. They made their bed when they prevented Lexi from going home almost four years ago now. They knew it would come to this moment and they did not care how their actions would affect Lexi.
      THAT is bone chilling.

      “With my kids, looking back at ancestors who would make up a 1/64th blood line we would have to go all the way back before the Revolutionary War. I bet the same holds true for most families in the USA.”

      Then rest assured that it has nothing to do with that. That ancestor is simply the enrolled ancestor who guaranteed his children enrollement, his children guaranteed their children enrollement, etc.
      Lexi’s father is an enrolled member of the Choctaw Nation. So was her grandmother. So are both of her sisters. Lexi’s membership in the tribe is because her father is a member.
      And just because they got their eligibility through that one ancestor does not mean it’s the only Native ancestor of that family just because it’s his line on their CDIB.

      “The upshot of the refusal of the U.S. Supreme Court to hear this case is that if your children are 1/64th Native American, or more, you need to keep your mouth shut about that fact, because if those children are ever involved in a custody lawsuit some Native American tribe can muscle their way in, claim that your child is a Native American and a defacto member of their tribe and dictate who gets custody, regardless of what the judge thinks is right. No I am not kidding.”

      You may not be kidding, but you are absolutely mistaken.
      Lexi is an enrolled member of the Choctaw Nation, and her father requested a placement with family members, the tribe simply approved his request.
      Also, if your children are 1/64 Native American, that does not mean they are eligible for enrollment in federally recognized tribe. ICWA only applies to children who are members of a federally reconized tribe or eligible for enrollment in such. And even then, they do not ignore the parents’ wishes.
      There’s actually one case where both parents of an Indian child wanted their child to be adopted to strangers. The tribe did not fight that, since both parents wanted it, and simply made the condition that the girl be enrolled in the tribe before the adoption, which was the girl’s right.

      Also, all judges involved in this case have ruled in favour of Lexi’s family and against the former fosters. Lexi’s move to her family was right for her, and all professionals and her family members approved it. The only ones who didn’t like it are the former fosters, and they never had any rights to the child AND the child does not want to be with them anyway.

      • SCVNews.com says:

        Also, if you remove ancestry from the equation altogether, what you’re left with is some non-relatives trying to prevent a child from reuniting with her competent relatives, which they knew would happen from the very beginning, and dragging it out in court for years, to the potential detriment of the child’s emotional well being.

  4. Nadiya Littlewarrior says:

    Thank you SCOTUS!

  5. Jo says:

    It is amazing that here in the article are all of the documents given the court. I can’t believe that anyone who actually reads through them would come to the conclusion that the child’s best interest was not served.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
Loading...
Related Content
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Friday, Jan 20, 2017
Human Remains Found in Agua Dulce Identified
Medical examiners identified a man whose body was found on Christmas Day near Agua Dulce.
Friday, Jan 20, 2017
Plane Crash Victim Identified
Coroner’s officials identified the sole victim of a Lake Hughes plane crash Friday.
Friday, Jan 20, 2017
County Closes Some Canyon Roads Due to Storm
In anticipation of a more severe storm on Sunday, Bouquet Canyon Road is scheduled to be closed between the gates at 5 p.m. on Sunday, January 22, until conditions and inspection allow.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1914 - Signal newspaper owner-editor Scott Newhall born in San Francisco [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, an overnight and early morning storm caused flooding, downed trees, and accidents throughout SCV Friday. Plus, the sole victim of a plane crash in Lake Hughes has been identified. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, January 20, 2017
News and views from College of the Canyons.
News from COC: The Bottom Line, Winter 2016/17
A series of storms is sweeping through Los Angeles County, with the final and strongest one predicted to affect the area late Saturday night through Monday. The combined rainfall totals for all three storms could be 3.00-6.00” for coastal and valley areas, with up to 9.00” possible in some foothill and mountain areas. Potential impacts include flash flooding and debris flows for recent burn areas, rock and mudslides along canyon roads, urban and small stream flooding, significant travel delays, isolated power outages, and dangerous driving conditions.
L.A. County Braces for a Series of Storms
Medical examiners identified a man whose body was found on Christmas Day near Agua Dulce.
Human Remains Found in Agua Dulce Identified
Parents and students will be offered information about healthy study habits and managing mental health at the William S. Hart Union High School District’s Parent and Student Empowerment (PASE) Information Night.
Hart District to Discuss Mental Health, Study Habits
Coroner’s officials identified the sole victim of a Lake Hughes plane crash Friday.
Plane Crash Victim Identified
10 Things to Expect at Thursdays @ Newhall
10 Things to Expect at Thursdays @ Newhall
On Tuesday, February 7 at 7:00 P.M, Trinity Classical Academy’s Speaker Series welcomes Dr. Hugh Ross, PhD, astronomer, best-selling author, and Founder of Reason To Believe.
Feb. 7: Trinity Classical Academy’s Speaker Series
The Board of Supervisors has appointed Dr. Christopher Rogers to the position of Acting Chief Medical Examiner-Coroner, effective Friday.
County Names New Chief Medical Examiner-Coroner
The California High-Speed Rail Authority will be hosting five community open house meetings in the Bakersfield to Palmdale Project Section starting next Saturday, January 28 in Rosamond.
California High-Speed Rail Authority to Host Public Meetings
Valencia High School students take honors at 2017 Socal Career Development Conference.
VHS Students Take Honors at Socal Career Development Conference
Princess Cruises received top honors in USA TODAY’s 10Best Readers’ Choice travel awards, being named “Best Ocean Cruise Line” after the cruise line was nominated by cruise industry experts and ultimately voted on by USA TODAY readers. In addition, Princess Cruises was recognized for “Best Cruise Ship Entertainment,” “Best Cruise Ship Dining” and “Best Cruise Ship for Families.”
Princess Cruises Named in USA TODAY’s 10Best Readers’ Choice
Assemblyman Dante Acosta, R-Santa Clarita, has announced his committee appointments including his selection to serve as Vice Chair of the Committee on Natural Resources.
Acosta Named to Several Committees
Two senior al-Qaida operatives were killed recently in separate U.S. airstrikes in Syria, Pentagon Press Secretary Peter Cook said in two statements.
Two al-Qaida Operatives Killed in Syria
In anticipation of a more severe storm on Sunday, Bouquet Canyon Road is scheduled to be closed between the gates at 5 p.m. on Sunday, January 22, until conditions and inspection allow.
County Closes Some Canyon Roads Due to Storm
The County Interim Health Officer is extending a Cold Weather Alert due to the National Weather Service’s forecast for low temperatures. Wind chill temperatures are expected to be below 32 degrees Fahrenheit. Affected areas include:
Jan. 20- 24: Cold Weather Alert Issued
The California Transportation Commission (CTC) has adopted 49 projects, valued at more than $127 million, to support needed upkeep on California’s aging roads and bridges, make upgrades to transit and rail systems and encourage use of alternative forms of transportation, including biking and walking.
Caltrans Adopts 49 Projects Worth $127 Million
It finally happened. The Ringling Brothers Barnum and Bailey Circus is closing very shortly.  There's nothing to fear over losing this circus because another is actively swelling to massive proportions. Hysteria and annihilation are the main attractions. It's the Left's Circus over the duly elected Donald J. Trump as the 45th President of the United States of America.
The new circus in town
Twelve Golden Valley High School students and two teachers made the trip to Washington D.C. to watch the inauguration of Donald Trump as the United States of America’s 45th President.
GVHS Students in D.C. to Witness Inauguration
A flash flood warning has been issued for the Santa Clarita Valley. Residents living in recent burn areas, especially the Sand Fire burn area, take precautions to avoid mudslides and flooding.
Jan. 20: Flash Flood Warning In Effect for SCV
Newhall Crime and Public Safety Report for Week of 01/09/17- 01/15/17
Crime Blotter: Petty Theft, Grand Theft in Newhall
The Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station will host the fifteenth Sheriff’s Community Academy beginning February 28, 2017.
Submit Application to Upcoming SCV Sheriff Community Academy
Newhall Crime and Public Safety Report for Week of 01/09/17- 01/15/17
Crime Blotter: Grand Theft, Petty Theft in Newhall
1993 - Hart High grad Dee Dee Myers (1979) becomes first female White House press secretary [story]
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Supervisor Kathryn Barger is proposing a motion to establish a $20,000 reward for information about the suspect responsible for a fatal hit-and-run. Plus, a new event for the 2017 Cowboy Festival lineup. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, January 19, 2017
The Board of Supervisors will be asked to approve a motion by Supervisor Kathryn Barger establishing a $20,0000 reward for information leading to the arrest and/or conviction of a suspect or suspects responsible for the hit-and-run death of a 15 year-old girl in Canyon Country.
Reward Offered in Hit-And-Run Death of Canyon Country Girl
The public is invited to participate in a stakeholder forum to learn about the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act and provide input regarding the formation of a Groundwater Sustainability Agency for the Santa Clara River Valley East Subbasin, which underlies most of the Santa Clarita Valley.
Jan. 24: Sustainable Groundwater Management Act Meeting
With the interest being generated by the 2017 Presidential Inauguration, the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department has committed resources to ensuring a state of readiness and preparedness. Although we anticipate many will express their views and opinions of the democratic process, we DO NOT have any specific or credible information indicating that any areas of Los Angeles County will substantially affected or disrupted.
Sheriff Ready for Inauguration Day Protests
Officials with the Coroner’s Office have released the identity of a woman killed in a fatal crash off Kelly Johnson Parkway.
Victim of Fatal Crash Near Walmart Identified
As the council wanted to appoint someone anyway, why not appoint the candidate who came in next place in the election?
Human Nature 101
The 2017 USA Swimming Open Water National Championships (featuring stand-alone Junior National Championships for the first time) are slated for May 19 through 21 at Castaic Lake.
May 19-21: Open Water Nationals Returns to Castaic Lake
VIA is hosting its 2017 Employment Law Update, presented by Brian Koegle and David Poole of Poole & Shaffery, LLP on Tuesday, February 21.
Feb. 21: 2017 Employment Law Update
The Los Angeles County Arts Commission is accepting applications from organizations seeking support for music programming at their facility or designated location.
March 1: Submit Application for ‘Free Concerts in Public Sites’ Program
Hart Regiment is now offering a simple way to contribute to its organization and help support the Regiment as it continues to work towards excellence.
Hart Regiment Offering Simple Way to Support Organization
Local Realtors during 2016 assisted 2,493 sales of existing single-family homes throughout the Santa Clarita Valley while the annual price rose 6.3 percent, the Southland Regional Association of Realtors reported today.
SCV 2016 Home Sales Increase, Annual Prices Rise