[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: Non-Medical Medical Decisions | Commentary by Dr. Gene Dorio | 02-06-2017
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
92°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
May 23
1941 - SCV's first real movie house, the American Theater, dedicated in Newhall [story]


A pediatrician decides a struggling teen with mental illness needs hospitalization to neutralize psychologic demons impacting their personal and social life.

A workers’ compensation doctor requests a neck MRI in a powerline worker with growing right arm numbness and weakness to search for potential paralyzing nerve impingement.

An orthopedist orders special testing to determine if an elder patient with right hip pain which limits walking and driving might need surgery to improve her quality of life.

Physicians are rigorously trained to make decisions in the best interest of their patients. Even after medical school and residency, doctors must follow the challenges of evidence-based medicine, standard of care, peer review, and muster the time for “continuing medical education” and certification.

Doctors are not only held accountable by their peers, but also legally, as they could be subject to lawsuits. Additionally, state licensing agencies that oversee medical professionals can discipline them, should they not practice medicine up to the standards of quality medical decision-making.

However, what if the teen’s pediatrician feels hospitalization is acutely needed for mental illness, but it is denied by the insurance company? What if the workers’ comp physician orders an MRI for the powerline worker’s ailing right arm, but it is denied? Or, if special testing to evaluate grandma’s worsening mobility and pain is turned down by the HMO? Who is held accountable?

To justify requests for specific patient care, physicians are forced to have “peer-to-peer” phone discussions with doctors employed by insurance companies, workers’ comp and HMOs. Frequently, these conversations result in denial of further care without medical justification.

A controversial question arises: Are denials by these company doctors considered medical decisions?

They are not. These decisions are considered “utilization review.” What does this mean? They are making decisions based on controlling costs, which is in the financial interest of the for-profit agencies they serve but not necessarily in the best interest of the patient.

Even though they are licensed doctors practicing medicine, their role in patient care is under the guise of “utilization review” and therefore not under the scrutiny of state licensing agencies.

What if these physicians deny care because they are incentivized to enhance personal bonuses? More so, what if some are making decisions outside the realm of their medical expertise (e.g., a urologist deciding about a diabetic)? Who holds these physicians accountable for moral transgressions or lack of judgement?

In California, we have a Medical Board that oversees licensing for all state physicians. If you report a licensed physician for making substandard medical decisions, an investigation ensues. If, though, the doctor is employed by an insurance company, workers’ comp or HMO and makes denial decisions on their behalf, it is considered “utilization review,” and they are not held accountable.

I do not pretend to understand every law and rule governing the Medical Board. But these companies have created legal barriers protecting doctors who might make substandard medical decisions.

Many physicians continue to fight for patient care rights despite frustration and helplessness of ongoing phone calls and paperwork they face. Yet substandard medical care will hamper their efforts as laws are manipulated and oversight is negligible.

Making medical decisions has never been easy. Assuring accountability makes it even harder.

 

Gene Uzawa Dorio, M.D., is a housecall geriatric physician and member of the Physicians Organizing Committee at Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital. The views expressed in this column as his alone.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

2 Comments

  1. Nancy Pitchford says:

    This is very disturbing. What can patients do to complain?

  2. Bonnie Ruiz says:

    I have worked as a Utilization Review Nurse Coordinator for a couple of large Medical Groups & know first hand how heart breaking it is to have to tell a patient that the healthplan has denied his health care request based on the medical review completed by the medical groups physician.

Leave a Comment


Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Related Content
RECENT COMMENTARY
Monday, May 22, 2017
At its root, leftism despises this redeeming nature and also the deity of the Judeo-Christian moral system, and so rejects such possible redemption. This, despite leftists’ insistence that others treat them according to the immovable objective standard of that moral code, and despite that code allowing them the type of life they demand.
Thursday, May 18, 2017
History shows us that presidents have used the Antiquities Act to protect important and special places on our federal lands only after local residents, businesses, tribes and others have made it clear to the president that an overwhelming majority of them want and support such a designation.
Tuesday, May 16, 2017
The gentleman working the fruit stand asked what I do for a living. When I told him I work for Medicare, he said he was having difficulty paying for his prescription drugs. So we talked for a while about ways he might be able to reduce his drug costs.
Thursday, May 11, 2017
The expense of college often stands as an insurmountable obstacle to students’ academic achievement. At College of the Canyons, we have launched a number of initiatives designed to bridge that gap and ensure financial need does not prevent students from achieving their full potential.
Saturday, May 6, 2017
Why is the Legislature seeking to eliminate any kind of local voter control over existing ground water agencies and prohibiting them access to laws that would allow the public to reconstitute water governance to their liking?
Tuesday, May 2, 2017
Spring has sprung in Santa Clarita. And what a beautiful time of year it is. Thanks to the onslaught of rain we got in the last few months, our hillsides are blankets of fresh green spotted with wildflowers. The spring season has long been hailed as fresh and new – and here in Santa Clarita there are a lot of new and exciting things happening this month.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Tuesday, Representative Steve Knight’s (CA-25) bill, No Hero Left Untreated Act, passed unanimously from the House of Representatives and now heads to the Senate for consideration.
Knight’s ‘No Hero Left Untreated Act’ Unanimously Passes House
The COC SBDC is hosting a local pitch competition on June 1, as part of InnovateHER 2017. The SBA National competition with cash prizes totaling $70,000 in the final round is scheduled for September 2017.
June 1: COC SBDC Hosts InnovateHER Pitch Competition
According to the South Coast Air Quality Management District, air quality will be unhealthy for sensitive individuals in Santa Clarita Valley on Wednesday, May 24.
Air Quality Advisory Issued for Santa Clarita Valley
The median price of single-family homes in the Santa Clarita Valley that closed escrow during April was $555,000, up 3.1 percent from April 2017 and 3.7 percent higher than March.
Median Price of Single Family Homes Up 3.1 Percent
The SCV Senior Center is offering a new class that will teach attendees the art of crochet and jewelry making.
SCV Senior Center Offering New Class on Crochet, Jewelry Making
Get ready for the sounds of live Jazz and Blues bands to once again fill Town Center Drive in Valencia. Established 18 years ago, the series will once again feature regional, national and international entertainers in a quaint street party setting while offering interactive activities for adults and children.
2017 Valencia Jazz and Blues Concert Series Announced
Attorney General Xavier Becerra announced Tuesday a record $18.5 million multi-state settlement with Target, in response to allegations that over 40 million customers had their payment card information compromised during the 2013 holiday season after the company failed to provide reasonable data security.
Becerra Announces $18.5 Million Multi-State Settlement with Target
An injury crash reported at approximately 5:15 a.m. involving a truck and an LAPD motorcycle shut down all lanes of southbound traffic on I-5 near Lyons Avenue, and LAPD and CHP officers are reportedly on scene investigating. By 8:45 a.m., all lanes had reopened, but CHP officials remained on scene near the Lyons Ave. off-ramp.
Early Morning I-5 Collision Injures LAPD Officer
College of the Canyons music student Justin Horwitz is one step close to his goal of becoming a music director thanks to a $21,000 transfer scholarship to Rider University in New Jersey.
COC Graduating Music Student Receives $21,000 Scholarship
Detectives with the Sheriff’s Station’s Narcotics Unit arrested five suspects Tuesday morning in connection a raid on a suspected drug house.
Arrests Made at Suspected Canyon Country Drug House
Craig Schlitter’s run of seven-straight quality starts came to an end as the Lancaster JetHawks fell to the Inland Empire 66ers, 6-1, on Monday night at San Manuel Stadium.
JetHawks Lose 6-1 to 66ers
Memorial Day weekend is the traditional start of summer and a time when many families and travelers will be on the go. California Highway Patrol (CHP) officers will take to the roads throughout the holiday weekend and will be working to save lives through seat belt education and enforcement.
Seat Belt Safety Never Takes a Holiday
The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department will be conducting a specialized Motorcycle Safety Enforcement Operation on May 24, 2017 in an effort to lower deaths and injuries.
May 24: LASD Conducting Motorcycle Safety Enforcement Operation
Caltrans has adopted California’s first statewide bicycle and pedestrian plan, Toward an Active California, which lays out policies and actions to support active modes of transportation.
Caltrans Adopts State Bicycle, Pedestrian Plan
The Castaic Lake Water Agency Planning and Engineering Committee is scheduled to meet on Tuesday, May 30 at 5:30 p.m. in the Training Room at the Rio Vista Water Treatment Plant.
May 30: CLWA Planning & Engineering Committee Meeting
Santa Clarita residents can learn CPR at Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital during a special county-wide event on Thursday, June 1 in front of the hospital’s main building and at the Jo Anne Darcy Library in Canyon Country.
June 1: Sidewalk CPR Day at Henry Mayo
Valencia Crime/Public Safety Report, May 8-14
Crime Blotter: Domestic Violence, Grand Theft in Valencia
1941 - SCV's first real movie house, the American Theater, dedicated in Newhall [story]
The regular meeting for the Sulphur Spring Union School District Governing Board will be held on May 24 at 7 p.m.
May 24: SSUSD Governing Board Regular Meeting
Einstein Academy officials were dealt another blow Monday, when their ex parte hearing was denied in a Los Angeles County Superior courtroom.
Superior Court Judge Denies Hearing for Einstein Academy
A Los Angeles County judge dismissed the charges last week against one of three people accused of human trafficking in Santa Clarita.
Charges Dismissed Against One of Three People in Human Trafficking Case
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, a brush fire broke out in the vicinity of Sierra Highway and Hillfield Lane on Monday. Plus, celebrate the newest art exhibit to take over the Town Center Art Space. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Monday, May 22, 2017
City, county and law enforcement officials cleaned up the Santa Clara River wash, aiming to remove illegal encampments and improve residents’ safety, officials said Monday.
Bridge to Home, Law Enforcement, Government Officials Clear Homeless Encampments
A Ventura County lawmaker is proposing an overhaul of the state’s community college placement system, and College of the Canyons is one of the “models” for the program.
Lawmaker Uses COC As Model for Community College Placement System
The popularity of Netflix show “13 Reasons Why” is concerning mental health experts who are seeing copycat behaviors in Santa Clarita from the “revenge suicide” show.
Local Mental Health Experts Concerned About Netflix Show
Santa Clarita City Council agenda for May 23, 2017
May 23: City Council Regular Meeting
The city of Santa Clarita will once again host its annual Summer Bash celebration for Santa Clarita Valley residents and visitors.
June 23: City Hosts Annual Summer Bash
On Friday, May 19, the Herb Alpert Foundation and CalArts award the 23rd Annual Herb Alpert Award in the Arts (HAAIA) to five exceptional mid-career artists. The awards recognize past performance and future promise, and each artist receives an unrestricted prize of $75,000.
Herb Alpert Foundation, CalArts Host 23rd Annual Herb Alpert Award in the Arts
In a postseason dominated by a prolific offense, The Master's University tossed in a gutsy pitching performance by senior Jason Karkenny Wednesday afternoon to beat Georgia Gwinnett 9-1 and punch its ticket to the NAIA World Series for the second consecutive year.
TMU Baseball Heads to NAIA World Series
Based on excellent performances in the classroom, TMU's Joshua Delo and Samuel Eisenhuth have been named 2017 Men's Golf NAIA Scholar-Athletes.
Two TMU Athletes Named 2017 Men’s Golf NAIA Scholar-Athletes
The North County Transportation Coalition is encouraging area residents to weigh in on the guidelines under development by Los Angeles County Metro (Metro) for Measure M by submitting their comments at www.theplan.metro.net until May 26.
North County Transportation Coalition Wants Resident to Weigh in on Metro Guidelines
The College of the Canyons track and field program sent a combined 14 student-athletes to compete in 13 events at the 2017 California Community College Athletic Association (CCCAA) State Championship meet hosted by American River College May 19-20.
COC Track & Field Compete in CCCAA State Champs
Hitting its way deeper into the postseason, The Master's University scored early and often and then held on to defeat Webber International 14-12 Tuesday afternoon in a winners' bracket game at the NAIA National Championship Opening Round.
TMU Baseball Defeats Webber International 14-12
It used to be that graduate students were often pegged as scholars so entombed in their studies and their campus libraries, they rarely saw the light of the day. There was usually not time for a family or children or even a social life. Now imagine having two young children and managing four track & field and two cross country programs and the student-athletes that entails all while pursuing a master’s degree with your spouse.
CSUN Track Coaches Among 2017 Grads
The California Transportation Commission has adopted a plan to immediately begin implementation of programs established by Senate Bill 1 – The Road Repair and Accountability Act of 2017.
State Transportation Commission Approves Road Repair, Accountability Act
At its root, leftism despises this redeeming nature and also the deity of the Judeo-Christian moral system, and so rejects such possible redemption. This, despite leftists’ insistence that others treat them according to the immovable objective standard of that moral code, and despite that code allowing them the type of life they demand.
Wrongists, Unite | Commentary by Richard Hood