[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: Non-Medical Medical Decisions | Commentary by Dr. Gene Dorio | 02-06-2017
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
85°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
July 25
1915 - Pioneer Juan Batista Suraco buried in a family graveyard, currently unmarked, in Bouquet Canyon near Benz Road [story]


A pediatrician decides a struggling teen with mental illness needs hospitalization to neutralize psychologic demons impacting their personal and social life.

A workers’ compensation doctor requests a neck MRI in a powerline worker with growing right arm numbness and weakness to search for potential paralyzing nerve impingement.

An orthopedist orders special testing to determine if an elder patient with right hip pain which limits walking and driving might need surgery to improve her quality of life.

Physicians are rigorously trained to make decisions in the best interest of their patients. Even after medical school and residency, doctors must follow the challenges of evidence-based medicine, standard of care, peer review, and muster the time for “continuing medical education” and certification.

Doctors are not only held accountable by their peers, but also legally, as they could be subject to lawsuits. Additionally, state licensing agencies that oversee medical professionals can discipline them, should they not practice medicine up to the standards of quality medical decision-making.

However, what if the teen’s pediatrician feels hospitalization is acutely needed for mental illness, but it is denied by the insurance company? What if the workers’ comp physician orders an MRI for the powerline worker’s ailing right arm, but it is denied? Or, if special testing to evaluate grandma’s worsening mobility and pain is turned down by the HMO? Who is held accountable?

To justify requests for specific patient care, physicians are forced to have “peer-to-peer” phone discussions with doctors employed by insurance companies, workers’ comp and HMOs. Frequently, these conversations result in denial of further care without medical justification.

A controversial question arises: Are denials by these company doctors considered medical decisions?

They are not. These decisions are considered “utilization review.” What does this mean? They are making decisions based on controlling costs, which is in the financial interest of the for-profit agencies they serve but not necessarily in the best interest of the patient.

Even though they are licensed doctors practicing medicine, their role in patient care is under the guise of “utilization review” and therefore not under the scrutiny of state licensing agencies.

What if these physicians deny care because they are incentivized to enhance personal bonuses? More so, what if some are making decisions outside the realm of their medical expertise (e.g., a urologist deciding about a diabetic)? Who holds these physicians accountable for moral transgressions or lack of judgement?

In California, we have a Medical Board that oversees licensing for all state physicians. If you report a licensed physician for making substandard medical decisions, an investigation ensues. If, though, the doctor is employed by an insurance company, workers’ comp or HMO and makes denial decisions on their behalf, it is considered “utilization review,” and they are not held accountable.

I do not pretend to understand every law and rule governing the Medical Board. But these companies have created legal barriers protecting doctors who might make substandard medical decisions.

Many physicians continue to fight for patient care rights despite frustration and helplessness of ongoing phone calls and paperwork they face. Yet substandard medical care will hamper their efforts as laws are manipulated and oversight is negligible.

Making medical decisions has never been easy. Assuring accountability makes it even harder.

 

Gene Uzawa Dorio, M.D., is a housecall geriatric physician and member of the Physicians Organizing Committee at Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital. The views expressed in this column as his alone.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

2 Comments

  1. Nancy Pitchford says:

    This is very disturbing. What can patients do to complain?

  2. Bonnie Ruiz says:

    I have worked as a Utilization Review Nurse Coordinator for a couple of large Medical Groups & know first hand how heart breaking it is to have to tell a patient that the healthplan has denied his health care request based on the medical review completed by the medical groups physician.

Leave a Comment


Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Related Content
RECENT COMMENTARY
Thursday, Jul 20, 2017
Much of the dramatic decline of the yellow-billed cuckoo in California has been directly attributed to breeding habitat loss and degradation from lands being converted to agricultural and other urban uses.
Wednesday, Jul 19, 2017
The Newhall Ranch project will create nearly 74,000 permanent jobs within the region and an estimated 130,000 construction jobs over the decades it will take to build the project, and it will provide a variety of housing types from apartments and starter homes to places to raise a family, from affordable housing to executive housing.
Friday, Jul 14, 2017
Medicare covers a variety of heath care services that you can get in the comfort and privacy of your home. These include intermittent skilled nursing care, physical therapy, speech-language pathology services, and occupational therapy.
Tuesday, Jul 11, 2017
In their attempt to usurp the Division of State Architect's role in the reopening of Acton School, the Acton-Agua Dulce school board has exposed itself to possible penalties being levied against the district, or civil lawsuits against individual board members.
Sunday, Jul 9, 2017
Python hunters work in pairs. One is the puller and one is the “hole guy.” The hole guy crawls into the hole to face the python head-on. When he’s bitten and the snake is holding on tight, the puller pulls out the hole guy, and the snake comes out with him.
Wednesday, Jul 5, 2017
As the temperatures go up this week, a great way to cool off is to head to one of the City’s six pools, says Santa Clarita City Manager Ken Striplin.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
For 42 years Soroptimist International of Valencia has been committed to the Live Your Dream program awarding cash grants to disadvantaged women.
Aug. 1: Summer “Wine” Down to Raise Funds for Disadvantaged Women
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, A bear sighting was reported in Newhall Tuesday morning. Plus, the Child & Family Center and Domestic Violence Center of Santa Clarita Valley are going forces and planning to merge. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Tuesday, July 25, 2017
The California State University (CSU) has partnered with the Los Angeles Cleantech Incubator (LACI) to develop the next generation of clean energy entrepreneurs.
CSU Receives Grant; Will Fund Workshops for Clean Energy Entrepreneurs
The largest-ever concert series devoted entirely to the music of renowned composer John Luther Adams (Music BFA 73) takes place this week (July 26-July 30). Hosted by SFJAZZ, the festival takes place in several venues in San Francisco, including the Miner Auditorium, Grace Cathedral and the Sutro Baths at Lands End in the Golden Gate National Recreation Area.
Concert Series Devoted Entirely to CalARTS Alum
The Child & Family Center and Domestic Violence Center of Santa Clarita Valley have announced their intention to join forces and merge into a single organization to better serve the needs of the growing Santa Clarita community.
DVC Merging Into Child & Family Center
Local artist Chrystal Walker presents a one-woman show at FastFrame Valencia, located at 24204 Valencia Blvd., during September.
Sept. 1: One-Woman Show on Printmaking by Local Artist
Santa Clarita deputies are investigating a report of a bank robbery at the Logix location on McBean Parkway.
Report of Bank Robbery at Logix Valencia; Deputies on Scene
Santa Clarita’s night-time commuters might notice some slowing on the freeway in the coming weeks, due to some road construction projects, officials said Tuesday.
Officials Issue Travel Alert for LAX Commuters
Knowing that up to 70 percent of residential water is used for landscaping, it’s no surprise that conscientious homeowners are looking for efficient irrigation methods to minimize water waste, and lower household water bills.
Aug. 19: CSUN-al Offering Class on Water-Saving Methods for Home and Garden
CHP officers and Fish and Wildlife officials were unable to locate a bear reported near Calgrove Boulevard and Wiley Canyon Road, in Newhall on Tuesday morning.
Bear Sighting in Newhall
Despite robust closed escrow sales in June, California pending home sales slipped for the sixth consecutive month, suggesting an impending slowdown in the state's housing market as the peak homebuying season winds down, the CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® (C.A.R.) said today.
State Sees Downward Trend in June Home Sales
On Saturday, August 19, 2017, test your strength, stamina, and endurance at the 12th Annual Plane Pull fundraiser at the Long Beach Airport.
Aug. 19: Annual Plane Pull Benefiting Local Non-Profit
Trey Killian tossed seven shutout innings to lead the Lancaster JetHawks to a 3-0 win over the Rancho Cucamonga Quakes on Monday night at LoanMart Field
Killian Gets 7th Win; Throws for Seven Shutout Innings
According to the South Coast Air Quality Management District, air quality will be unhealthy for sensitive individuals in Santa Clarita Valley Tuesday.
Air Quality Advisory for Sensitive Individuals in SCV
Rep. Steve Knight’s (CA-25) bill, H.R. 2333, Small Business Investment Opportunity (SBIO) Act of 2017, passed the House Monday with unanimous support.
Knight Bill to Improve Small Business Investments Unanimously Passes House
1915 - Pioneer Juan Batista Suraco buried in a family graveyard, currently unmarked, in Bouquet Canyon near Benz Road [story]
The Los Angeles Dodgers Monday reinstated left-handed pitcher Hyun-Jin Ryu from the 10-day disabled list, put Clayton Kershaw on the DL with low back strain, among other roster moves.
Dodgers Roster Moves: Kershaw & McCarthy on DL, Ryu Reinstated
Sierra Bancorp, parent of Bank of the Sierra, today announced its unaudited financial results for the three- and six-month periods ended June 30, 2017.
Sierra Bancorp Reports Earnings for First Half of 2017
Marston's restaurant in Valencia will donate 20 percent of patrons' bills for breakfast, lunch or dinner to the fundraising effort for the new Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center on Tuesday, July 25.
July 25: Dine at Marston’s, Benefit New SCV Senior Center
The county of Los Angeles seeks to block reopening of the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage field until an earthquake analysis is completed.
L.A. County Moves to Block Aliso Gas Field Reopening
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, COC's MakerSpaces received a grant to enhance their centers on both campuses. Plus, the L.A. SummerFEST needs your help. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Monday, July 24, 2017
Here's a preview of Santa Clarita arts-related events for July 26-28, 2017.
July 26-28: Santa Clarita Arts Calendar
Alfredo Manzano is the new head coach of the Saugus boys basketball program, Saugus High School Principal Vince Ferry announced today.
Manzano Named New Saugus Boys Basketball Coach
College of the Canyons has been awarded a $311,432 grant to enhance its MakerSpace centers at both COC campuses with additional equipment, courses, training and internships.
COC ‘MakerSpace’ Centers Awarded $311,432 Grant
Organizers of the non-profit Santa Clarita Festival are seeking the community's help to cover a funding shortfall for the the ninth annual L.A. SummerFEST, a cultural festival featuring free performances of Shakespeare’s plays.
L.A. SummerFEST Seeks Donations to Keep Shakespeare Onstage
The city of Santa Clarita’s New Heights Artist Development Series offers free local workshops, panel discussions and lectures designed specifically with the creative individual in mind.
New Heights Artist Development Series Fosters Creative Growth
Wolf Creek Brewery will host a "Pints & Paws" fundraiser at Wolf Creek Brewery to benefit the SCV Education Foundation on Tuesday, July 25 starting at 4 p.m.
July 25: Pints & Paws Fundraiser for SCV Education Foundation
A GoFundMe crowdfunding page has been set up to help cover funeral expenses for a mother and two of her children killed in a rollover crash on Highway 14 in Acton Thursday.
Funeral Expenses Fund Set Up for 3 Dead in Acton Rollover Crash
Mylz Jones, Collin Ferguson and Yonathan Daza each delivered four hits to help lift the JetHawks over the Lake Elsinore Storm, 14-8, on Sunday evening at The Hangar.
JetHawks Power Through Storm 14-8 Sunday
The Lancaster JetHawks combined for 13 runs in the fourth and fifth innings and cruised to a 14-3 victory over the Lake Elsinore Storm on Saturday night at The Hangar.
Two Huge Innings Lift JetHawks to Blowout Win Saturday
Garrett Hampson delivered three hits and drove in four to lead the Lancaster JetHawks over the Lake Elsinore Storm, 10-7, on Friday night at The Hangar.
Hampson Helps ‘Hawks Weather Storm, Even Series Friday
Here is the Saugus (Zone 4) Public Safety and Crime Prevention Information for the week of 07/10/17 – 07/16/17:
Crime Blotter: Grand Theft Auto, Vehicle Burglary in Saugus
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has awarded more than $12 million to California and 22 more states plus the District of Columbia to support their responses to the opioid overdose epidemic.
CDC Awards $12 Million to California, 22 More States to Fight Opioid Epidemic
Here is the Stevenson Ranch: Zone 3 Public Safety and Crime Prevention Information for 07/03/17 through 07/16/17:
Crime Blotter: Petty Theft, Vehicle Burglary, Assault in Stevenson Ranch
The California Department of Water Resources is seeking validation of $11 billion in bonds to fund Gov. Jerry Brown’s Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta tunnel project, California Water Fix, which cleared its final environmental hurdle on Friday.
California Sues to Validate Bonds to Fund Delta Tunnels Project
The Castaic Lake Water Agency's Planning and Engineering Committee has scheduled a meeting for Tuesday, August 1 starting at 5:30 p.m.
August 1: CLWA Planning & Engineering Meeting