[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
77°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
September 24
1855 - Sanford & Cyrus Lyon establish Lyon's Station (for stagecoaches) near today's Sierra Hwy & Newhall Ave [story]


STATEMENT OF COMMISSIONER MIGNON L. CLYBURN ON AT&T/DEUTSCHE TELEKOM AG LICENSE TRANSFER PROCEEDING

 

Before discussing the concerns I have about the license transfer applications filed by AT&T Inc. and Deutsche Telekom AG this past March, I will address the procedural posture the Commission finds itself in because, on November 23, after being notified of the Commission’s intent to circulate a Hearing Designation Order, the Applicants sent an electronic filing to request withdrawal of these applications. I understand why the decision was made not to proceed with the Hearing Designation Order and I wish to express my support for today’s release of the staff Analysis and Findings. The agency has the discretion to issue such a report in this proceeding and furthermore, this action promotes federal agency transparency. Several outside parties have spent considerable time and resources to respond to the data and information requests that the FCC staff has asked them to prepare, and they deserve to see the staff’s analysis of the record evidence. In addition, the Applicants have stated that they “are continuing to pursue the sale of Deutsche Telekom’s U.S. wireless assets to AT&T.” Consequently, as they decide how best to reframe any changes to their transfer of control applications, the Applicants also deserve to have the benefit of the staff’s Analysis and Findings.

When I began to consider this license transfer application between the number two and number four (in terms of subscribers) nationwide mobile wireless service providers, I initially had concerns about the impact such a proposed merger would have for competition, innovation and investment, and customer service. I decided to keep an open mind because the Applicants offered interesting arguments why these license transfers would serve the public interest. Most notably, AT&T’s customers have complained about the problems they have with AT&T’s mobile wireless data services and the acquisition of additional spectrum could help alleviate that problem. Second, AT&T asserted that the proposed merger would result in a net gain of job openings for Americans seeking to enter the mobile wireless service industry. As is evident in the Analysis and Findings, the FCC staff engaged in a careful and thorough review of each of these issues.

As I have said before, if we want markets to be unencumbered by the cost of regulation, we need to ensure that the markets are truly competitive. My concern that the proposed merger could substantially lessen competition in the mobile wireless service market begins with what I see in the current state of the market. Increased consolidation, over the past several years, has resulted in fewer regional and rural service providers that are able to discipline the largest carriers. Voice and data roaming and other network sharing agreements would stimulate the deployment of networks to more Americans, but the denial of these agreements and those opportunities would prevent the smaller carriers from providing competitive service offerings to their subscribers, resulting in pockets of this Nation not being robustly served. In fact, the most recent 15th Mobile Services Report finds that more than seven million Americans still live in rural census blocks with two or fewer mobile service providers. In addition, more than 37 million Americans live in rural census blocks that have two or fewer choices when it comes to mobile broadband services. It may be that this current state of affairs calls for the Commission to adopt more regulation to better implement the public interest aims of the Communications Act. But, in my view, ensuring that the competitive structure of the market furthers the goals of the Act is another reason why the Commission must review license transfer applications and make its determination as to whether or not such applications serve the public interest.

Consistent with FCC precedent, the staff reviewed those aspects of the structure of the mobile services market that are relevant to this proceeding. It then determined the relevant product market to be the mobile telephony/broadband services product market. It also appropriately reviewed the impact of the merger on a local market basis and a nationwide basis. The staff’s findings suggest the applications appear to substantially lessen competition in ways that no conditions would appear to remedy. The Commission uses the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index, or HHI, to trigger when it must take a closer look at the impact of a proposed merger on a relevant geographic market. It conducts that closer scrutiny when a proposed merger would lead to market concentrations that exceed 2800 on the HHI and the change in the HHI would be 100 or the change in the HHI would be 250 or greater in a market irrespective of the total market concentration. Based on the staff analysis, 419 local markets, formally known as Cellular Market Areas, hit the HHI trigger for closer agency scrutiny.

When it subjects a proposed merger to heightened competitive review, the Commission considers whether the proposed merger would create incentives for the merged entity and other competitors, such that they would likely engage in unilateral or coordinated action that would harm competition. Said another way, we ask whether by removing T-Mobile, AT&T and competitors would be more likely to raise prices. After a detailed analysis of these issues, the staff concluded that the removal of T-Mobile as a competitor would create these incentives for AT&T and other competitors because these two companies compete with each other for customers and respond to each other’s competitive strategies. The staff also considered the Applicants’ argument that the merger would not result in these competitive harms because smaller regional mobile wireless carriers are available to effectively compete. The staff was not persuaded by this argument because these smaller mobile wireless carriers do not have the resources to replace T-Mobile’s competitive strength in the market. These smaller carriers have considerably less spectrum, smaller service footprints, lower Average Revenue Per Unit and, as I implied earlier, have difficulties obtaining roaming agreements. Furthermore, it appears the proposed merger would make it even more difficult for these smaller carriers to compete because the merged entity would make it more difficult for them to acquire the more advanced and popular handsets and acquire the backhaul services. For these and additional reasons, the staff report finds that the proposed merger would substantially lessen competition in the market for mobile telephony/broadband services.

I am concerned about the impact that policies and market structure have on innovation and investment in the mobile wireless services market. Innovation is why we have seen mobile wireless handsets change from being about the size of a brick with limited coverage and offering only voice service, to including the advanced technologies in smart phones, tablets and other portable devices that operate at broadband speeds. As the National Broadband Plan stated, greater deployment and adoption of mobile broadband services will drive innovation throughout our Nation’s economy. With regard to the impact of the proposed merger on innovation in the industry, the staff Analysis and Findings also finds harm because by removing T-Mobile, the proposed merger would remove a disruptive force in the mobile wireless services market. T-Mobile exerts that disruptive force by engaging in both price and technical innovation. For example, the staff Analysis explains that, T-Mobile was the first nationwide provider to offer the following innovative pricing plans: month-to-month postpaid plans; plans that allow customers to pay for new phones over four monthly interest free installments; and soft data cap plans that allow customers to exceed their monthly maximum in data service without incurring expensive overage fees. T-Mobile also acted disruptively by being the first to invest in and deploy HSPA+ technology through its network. That strategy led AT&T to respond by accelerating its deployment of the same technology. T-Mobile was a founding member of the Open Handset Alliance which spurred the deployment of Android devices to the market. It was also the first provider to offer an Android smart phone. According to the staff reports, the Applicants have not shown how the innovation in pricing and technology, which T-Mobile had the resources and market power to introduce to the market, would continue after this proposed merger.

Also of concern is that the staff found that the proposed merger could adversely impact customer service. The staff found that AT&T’s documents show that the cost savings from the proposed merger would result from the elimination of most T-Mobile customer service representatives and the complementary infrastructure. In recent years, T-Mobile has received high ratings for its customer service. So, this causes me to question how current customers would be impacted.

As I implied earlier, I was intrigued by the Applicants’ assertions that the proposed transactions would result in the following merger specific benefits: (1) network efficiencies that would allow them to meet the challenges caused by the explosion of data traffic on their networks; and (2) the creation of more jobs for Americans than would occur without the merger. The Applicants submitted several documents to support the network efficiency claim including economic and engineering models. The staff report reviewed these models and, in some instances, agreed with some of the assertions the Applicants made. The staff’s overall assessment of these models and documents, however, is that they fall far short of being persuasive because “the models provided are abstract, [are] not robust to more reasonable assumptions, [are] not consistent with each other or, in many cases, [with] the Applicants’ internal documents and have no demonstrated predictive value.”

The staff also stated that they were not persuaded by the Applicants’ contention that the proposed merger would result in the creation of more jobs. That is due to the staff’s calculation that, in order to reach the dollar amount of synergies the Applicants assert would result from the merger, this would necessarily mean the elimination of jobs. The staff found that this is consistent with AT&T’s own statements in the record that “jobs serving redundant functions” would be eliminated to reduce costs. Furthermore, staff examined the history of AT&T’s management decisions following recent mergers. The staff found that “in 2002, there were 70,000 employees at AT&T Mobility and its predecessor companies. Since then, AT&T merged with Cingular, Dobson, and Centennial. Today, there are 67,000 employees at AT&T Mobility.” After reviewing this evidence, the staff found that, even if AT&T follows through with its commitment to not terminate any call center jobs in the United States, there is “no dispute that the proposed transaction will result in fewer total direct jobs across the business.”The staff Analysis and Findings concludes that the proposed merger would substantially lessen competition whether reviewed at the local market or national market level, and there are substantial questions whether the claimed public interest benefits would occur.

I would like to thank Renata Hesse, Austin Schlick, Rick Kaplan, Paul De Sa and the staff members from their respective Bureaus and Offices who worked tirelessly to finish the review of these applications before 180 days. I commend them for presenting us with a sound analysis of the relevant issues in the proceeding.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

1 Comment

  1. Michael Van Tol says:

    Elimination of more jobs… great. I’m looking for a customer service job, but not in a call center. I need to work from home. Anyone know of a good source? I’ve tried craigslist, but no luck. Anyone heard of PajamaJobs.com ? They have a lot of jobs listed but I can’t tell if they’re legit…

Leave a Comment


LOCAL BUSINESS LINKS
LOCAL BUSINESS HEADLINES
FINANCIALS OF LOCAL INTEREST
MARKETS & METALS
STOCKS OF LOCAL INTEREST
Bank Santa Clarita17.25  chart -1.15%
Biosolar, Inc.0.0427  chart +13.26%
Sierra Bancorp25.76  chart -0.39%
Cu Bancorp (ca)37.55  chart +0.13%
Flex Ltd. - Ordinary Shares16.66  chart -0.54%
Mission Vly Bcp Ca14.15  chart +0.00%
Quest Diagnostics Incorporated102.11  chart +0.55%
Tejon Ranch Co21.21  chart -1.03%
Us Energy Initiative0.0007  chart -12.50%
Wesco Aircraft Holdings, Inc.9.35  chart +1.63%

Apple Inc.151.89  chart -0.98%
At&t Inc.38.59  chart +0.97%
Autonation, Inc.47.36  chart +0.89%
Best Buy Co., Inc.53.90  chart -0.09%
Big Lots, Inc.49.51  chart +0.43%
Barnes & Noble, Inc.7.25  chart +3.57%
Brady Corporation36.80  chart +0.96%
Boston Scientific Corporation28.85  chart +0.31%
Brookfield Asset Management Inc40.64  chart -0.17%
Cbre Group Inc Class A37.18  chart -0.03%
Carnival Corporation64.33  chart -0.19%
Comcast Corporation38.10  chart +1.68%
Costco Wholesale Corporation161.29  chart -0.12%
Curtiss-wright Corporation104.34  chart +0.61%
Cvs Health Corporation79.63  chart +0.09%
Cemex, S.a.b. De C.v. Sponsored9.35  chart +0.11%
D.r. Horton, Inc.36.90  chart +0.11%
Walt Disney Company (the)98.60  chart -0.29%
Edison International78.28  chart -0.48%
Hyatt Hotels Corporation Class 61.29  chart +0.15%
Home Depot, Inc. (the)159.97  chart +0.49%
Kb Home20.88  chart +0.48%
Kroger Company (the)20.15  chart -0.35%
Lennar Corporation Class A50.28  chart -0.42%
Laboratory Corporation Of Ameri155.07  chart +0.77%
Lowe's Companies, Inc.78.23  chart +0.24%
Mannkind Corporation1.98  chart +2.06%
Marriott International107.88  chart +0.29%
Mcdonald's Corporation158.91  chart -0.08%
Mitsubishi Ufj Financial Group,6.48  chart +0.62%
Netflix, Inc.187.35  chart -0.76%
Office Depot, Inc.4.37  chart +1.86%
Rite Aid Corporation2.39  chart -1.24%
Rexford Industrial Realty, Inc.29.51  chart -1.57%
Regal Entertainment Group Class16.61  chart +2.22%
Ross Stores, Inc.60.89  chart -0.03%
Republic Services, Inc.66.26  chart +0.17%
Starbucks Corporation55.09  chart +0.15%
Smart & Final Stores, Inc.7.30  chart +2.10%
Sears Holdings Corporation7.11  chart +0.85%
Six Flags Entertainment Corpora58.96  chart +1.97%
Sonova N164.00  chart -0.30%
Staples, Inc.10.25  chart +0.10%
Sunpower Corporation7.64  chart +3.66%
Target Corporation58.99  chart +1.13%
Time Warner Cable Inc209.56  chart -0.21%
Ulta Beauty, Inc.219.17  chart -0.26%
Walgreens Boots Alliance, Inc.78.41  chart +0.27%
Waste Connections, Inc.69.86  chart -0.20%
Whole Foods Market, Inc.41.99  chart +0.00%
Waste Management, Inc.78.20  chart -0.10%
Wal-mart Stores, Inc.79.53  chart -0.60%
Woodward, Inc.75.95  chart +1.56%
CURRENCY CONVERTER

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
It has been a year since Energy Transfer Partners bulldozed the sacred burial grounds just beyond the borders of the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation to clear a path for the Dakota Access Pipeline – and about 10 months since I hightailed it over there. I want my friends to know what I know, and I want to be able to look back and remember some details before time wipes them away.
Standing Rock: Why I Went | Commentary by Leon Worden
1855 - Sanford & Cyrus Lyon establish Lyon's Station (for stagecoaches) near today's Sierra Hwy & Newhall Ave [story]
1948 - Agua Dulce Women's Club organized [timeline]
The governing boards of College of the Canyons and the William S. Hart Union School District are scheduled to discuss plans for a new Academy of the Canyons-style campus at the future Castaic High School when they sit down for their annual joint meeting Sept. 27.
COC, Hart Planning ‘North Academy’ at Castaic High School
The League of California Cities, with representatives from cities statewide including Santa Clarita, is calling for Gov. Jerry Brown to veto SB 649, which if enacted would allow the wireless industry to install new 5G equipment with little input from local jurisdictions.
League of California Cities Urges Governor to Veto 5G Wireless Equipment Bill
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, an off-duty LAPD officer and Canyon Country resident, died Thursday evening after a collision in Porter Ranch. Plus, check out all the exciting events happening this weekend. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, September 22, 2017
The new pedestrian bridge crossing McBean Parkway is expected to be open in time for weekend foot traffic.
New Pedestrian Bridge on McBean Parkway Set to Reopen Saturday
The Child and Family Center will begin providing outpatient substance use treatment services for adolescents and young adults with primary substance use disorders under the California Drug MediCal Program starting Tuesday, October 3.
Oct. 3: Child and Family Center Begins Outpatient Substance Abuse Treatment
College of the Canyons and the Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center will host a caregivers' workshop at the Senior Center in Newhall on Saturday, September 30 from 9 a.m. to 11:30 a.m.
Sept. 30: COC, Senior Center Host Caregiver Workshop
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors is strongly opposing the proposed Graham-Cassidy healthcare legislation, saying it would undermine the well-being of the county’s most vulnerable populations and burden taxpayers with heavier costs for years to come.
Supes Say Graham-Cassidy Bill Threatens Health of Millions of LA County Residents
The intersection of Soledad Canyon Road and Bouquet Canyon Road will be under construction from 7 p.m. to 5 a.m. on Friday night, September 29 and Saturday morning, September 30.
Sept. 29-30: Soledad and Bouquet Canyon Repaving
College of the Canyons launched its First-Year Promise program this fall, and to ensure the future of the FYP program, which offers full-time freshman students waived tuition and fees during their first year of study, the COC Foundation has committed to fundraising $500,000 over the next two years.
COC Foundation Launches ‘First-Year Promise’ Fundraising Campaign
Road rehab on major arterial roads and intersections in the city of Santa Clarita continues into October.
Santa Clarita Road Rehab Drives into October
More than 60 Air Force senior leaders convened on Friday to discuss the Air Force’s aircrew crisis, which has left the service more than 1,500 pilots short of its requirements.
Short by 1,500 Pilots, Air Force Leaders Address Aircrew Crisis
The Santa Clarita Valley has five major industry clusters and the SCV Economic Development Corporation targets its economic development efforts to support and expand them.
Five Growing Industry Clusters in the Santa Clarita Valley
In the aftermath of Hurricanes Irma and Maria, the Veterans Affairs Department VA announced Friday that it continues to provide vital health care and other support to displaced Veterans in Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands.
VA Aids Veterans in Puerto Rico, Virgin Islands After Hurricanes Irma and Maria
Gatorade made misleading “anti-water statements” while pushing the benefits of its sports drinks in a video game marketed to teenagers, according to a settlement announced Thursday by California’s attorney general.
California Fines Gatorade $300K for ‘Anti-Water’ Ad Campaign
John Gasparyan, an off-duty Los Angeles Police Department officer and Canyon Country resident, died when his motorcycle crashed in Porter Ranch around 6:50 p.m. Thursday.
LAPD Officer from Canyon Country Dead in Motorcycle Crash
A former Los Angeles County probation officer was sentenced after pleading guilty to inappropriately touching two girls at a youth camp, the county District Attorney’s Office has announced.
Ex-Probation Officer Gets 364 Days for Sexual Assault
1969 - College of the Canyons opens with first class of students in temporary quarters at Hart High School [story]
The most prestigious recognition for government assessment agencies has been awarded to the Office of the Assessor in Los Angeles County.
County Awarded Prestigious Government Assessment Award
The Dodgers, who have clinched a postseason berth for the fifth consecutive year, return home tomorrow to open their final homestand of the regular season against the San Francisco Giants (Sept. 22-24) and San Diego Padres (Sept. 25-27).
Dodgers Back Home Friday; Last Homestand of 2017 Season
Auditions for the the upcoming Canyon Theater Guild's production of A Christmas Story are just around the corner.
Sept. 30-Oct. 1: Christmas Story Auditions at CTG
Now that the formerly great state of California is a sanctuary, I’ve got to compare that action with the actions in the early 1860s of the Confederate States of America. They decided what laws they wanted to follow and what ones they didn’t.
No Home for Me | Commentary by Darryl Manzer
Santa Clarita Valley residents have known the family-owned Italian restaurant, Sisley Kitchen, since 1993 when their doors first opened at the top of Valencia Town Center Drive in Westfield Valencia.
Renovations Complete at Sisley Kitchen
The Women's Soccer team will be finishing up their non-conference matches this weekend.
Sept. 22-24: CSUN Athletics Roundup
David Wolfram will demonstrate pastel-over-watercolor painting at the Santa Clarita Artists Association (SCAA) meeting on Monday evening, Nov. 20 at 6:30 pm. This event is free, open to the public and meets at Barnes & Noble, 23630 Valencia Blvd.
Nov. 20: Pastel-Over-Watercolor Demonstration at SCAA Meeting
Beginning October 1, all 23 California State University (CSU) campuses will accept applications for admission to the fall 2018 term.
Oct. 1: CSU Accepting Fall 2018 Applications
College of the Canyons launched its First-Year Promise (FYP) program this fall, and to ensure the future of the FYP program, which offers full-time freshman students waived tuition and fees during their first year of study, the COC Foundation has committed to fundraising $500,000 over the next two years
COC First-Year Promise Fundraising Campaign Underway
The city of Santa Clarita is inviting our younger residents to take part in the 30th anniversary celebration.
City Launches ’30 Things for 30 Years’ Contest; Students Invited to Take Part
California State University, Northridge’s Friends of the Oviatt Library welcomes members of the community to nominate their favorite stories about the San Fernando Valley for consideration of the San Fernando Valley Award for Non-Fiction.
CSUN Library Group Invites Community to Nominate Favorite San Fernando Valley Story
The Los Angeles Dodgers today announced sellouts for all seven potential postseason home games in the Division Series and League Championship Series just hours after tickets went on sale to the public at 10:00 a.m. It’s believed to be the quickest that the club has sold out of postseason tickets in Dodger Stadium history.
Dodgers NLDS, NLCS Tickets Already Sold Out
Sales of existing single-family homes increased 7.4 percent throughout Santa Clarita during August while the median price of homes that changed owners rose 6.6 percent, the Southland Regional Association of REALTORS® reported today.
Increase in SCV August Home Sales, Prices
Mountainview Elementary School parents were greeted with a voicemail Thursday morning informing them of a break-in on campus believed to have occurred the night before.
Vandals Trash Library, Computers, Classrooms at Mountainview
Hans' family did not know too much about his childhood or the country he had grown up in. About all the family knew was that Hans and his wife were born in Germany but had lived in this small Minnesota town for the last 60 years or more.
Lesson from History | Commentary by John Windsor