[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
57°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
December 15
1987 - Incorporation: Santa Clarita officially becomes a city [story]


In a unanimous decision Thursday, the California Supreme Court ruled that the William S. Hart Union High School District bears a measure of responsibility for alleged sexual molestation incidents involving a female guidance counselor and a male student at Golden Valley High School five years ago.

The case pertains to Roselyn Hubbell, a school counselor who was arrested in June 2008 in connection with the ongoing molestation of a 15-year-old boy from January to September 2007.

According to court papers filed by attorneys for the boy, Hubbell drove the victim home from school “and spent long hours with (him) on and off the high school premises. The guidance counselor performed a variety of sexual acts on (the victim) and required him to perform a number of sexual acts on her.”

Hubbell’s charges were ultimately reduced to one misdemeanor count of annoying or molesting a minor. In April 2009 she pleaded no contest to that charge and was placed on three year’s probation. A “no contest” plea cannot be used as an admission of guilt in a civil court.

Attorneys for the victim’s family filed a civil lawsuit against the school district, alleging the district knew Hubbell had a history of child molestation before it hired her and did nothing to warn people about it or prevent it from happening in the future.

The Hart District won at the trial court level and the Appeals Court upheld the decision. According to court documents, the appellate court ruled that even if the district knew about Hubbell’s history before it hired her, the district can’t be held laible if she did it again.

The question for the California Supreme Court was whether the appellate court decision was correct. It said no.

The specific issue for the high court was this:

“When a school district’s employees hire, retain or supervise a school guidance counselor they know or have reason to know has a history of child molestation, can the school district be vicariously liable for that negligent hiring, retention or supervision under Government Code section 820 if that counselor molests a student entrusted to her – or is the molested student unable to sue the school district because there is no separate statute imposing direct liability on the district for that conduct, as the Court of Appeal majority held in its published opinion in this case?”

Writing for the Supreme Court, Justice Kathryn Mickle Werdegar said, “We conclude plaintiff’s theory of vicarious liability for negligent hiring, retention and supervision is a legally viable one. Ample case authority establishes that school personnel owe students under their supervision a protective duty of ordinary care, for breach of which the school district may be held vicariously liable.”

In other words, yes, a school district can be sued for damages if it knew or should have known about an employee’s history of child molestation.

Which is well and good from a theoretical standpoint.

But the underlying question remains:

Before she was hired into the William S. Hart Union High School District, did Roselyn Hubbell have a history of child molestation that the district knew or should have known about?

The Supreme Court assumed she did.

But that “fact” has never been proved in a court of law.

When the plaintiffs initially sued the Hart District, the school district filed a demurrer, alleging the court lacked statutory authority to hear the case because the Hart District (thought it) couldn’t be held liable. The trial court agreed, and the facts of the case – Did Hubbell have a history or not? – were not argued.

Plaintiffs appealed the trial court’s decision to uphold the demurrer, meaning the appellate court only ruled on whether the Hart District could be sued. It didn’t delve into Hubbell’s history.

At the Supreme Court level, Hubbell’s history was not open to debate. The only question was whether a school district could be held liable IF it knew an employee had a history.

In a statement Thursday from the law firm handling the matter for the Hart District – whose costs were covered under the school district’s insurance policy – attorney Steve Harber of McCune & Harber said the case is in the “allegations stage. It is one thing to make allegations; it is another to establish facts.”

At this point, the idea that Hubbell had a history of child molestation is merely an allegation – as is the idea that she molested the boy at Golden Valley, from the court’s standpoint. Because Hubbell’s “no contest” plea in the criminal court can’t be used as an admission of guilt in a civil court, the “fact” that she molested the boy at Golden Valley hasn’t been established in the civil case against the Hart District.

Hubbell was a Hart District employee from August 2002 to June 2008. When she was hired, state law required school district employees to be fingerprinted for background checks. Hart District administrators were not immediately able to give details about Hubbell’s background check Thursday – and aren’t likely to do so because it’s a matter of pending litigation – but if she was cleared in the background check, she might not have had a criminal history.

“When the true facts come out, they will show that the (school) district appropriately screens its teachers and counselors,” Harber’s statement said. “The alleged perpetrator here was found out, arrested and prosecuted because of the district’s vigilance.”

The public is likely to find out whether Hubbell had a prior history of child molestation – and whether the Hart District knew or should have known about it. That’s because Thursday’s Supreme Court decision opens the door for the victim’s attorneys to bring the case back to the trial court and argue the facts for the first time.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

No Comments

    Leave a Comment


    LOCAL SCHOOL LINKS
    Related Content
    LATEST SCHOOL NEWS
    Thursday, Dec 14, 2017
    The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board has approved naming Dr. Collyn Nielsen as Chief Administrative Officer and Jan Hayes-Rennels as Director of Special Programs and Staff Development.
    Thursday, Dec 14, 2017
    The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board held it’s annual reorganizational meeting Wednesday night, naming Steve Sturgeon as Board President.
    Thursday, Dec 14, 2017
    Castaic Elementary School is collecting gently used children's clothing and toys for the victims of the Creek Fire in Sylmar.
    Wednesday, Dec 13, 2017
    During October, 15 junior high and high school campuses in Santa Clarita hosted a toiletries drive as part of their annual DFY in SCV community campaign.
    Wednesday, Dec 13, 2017
    The nonprofit WiSH Education Foundation is out to raise $100,000 to fund improvements in Hart District school libraries.

    Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
    1987 - Incorporation: Santa Clarita officially becomes a city [story]
    With an offense that challenged the program’s single-season goals record, The Master’s University women’s soccer team was almost almost never out of any game it played: The Mustangs were always within striking range.
    Lady Mustangs Within Range of Directors’ Cup Top Spots
    When Ed Jackiewicz met Tera Trujillo in spring 2015, she was studying at a desk she’d carried to the corner of the California State University, Northridge soccer field, in a “time out” of sorts, unable to practice because she’d just earned a D in an economics class.
    CSUN’s “Under Armour Faculty” Promotes Academic Success in Student-Athletes
    When Rafael Munoz recalls his time at the Layer 8 Computer Security Club at California State University, Northridge, he feels proud and thankful.
    CSUN’s Tech Education Makes Top 10 List
    The city of Santa Clarita Arts and Events division is currently seeking proposals for solo exhibits for 2018 in the gallery space at The MAIN, the City’s newest arts venue in Old Town Newhall.
    City Seeking Artists for 2018 Solo Exhibits
    NORTHRIDGE, Calif.---CSUN Men's Basketball returns to the road for the final time in the non-conference season this weekend.
    CSUN to Face-Off Against Formal Rival Eastern Washington
    Here is a list of Santa Clarita arts-related events for Friday:
    Dec. 15: Santa Clarita Arts Calendar
    This Friday and Saturday (Dec. 15-16), The Sharon Disney Lund School of Dance brings their annual Winter Dance Concert to the REDCAT stage.
    Dec. 15, 16: Sharon Disney Lund School of Dance Concert at REDCAT
    The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board has approved naming Dr. Collyn Nielsen as Chief Administrative Officer and Jan Hayes-Rennels as Director of Special Programs and Staff Development.
    Hart Appoints Nielsen, Hayes-Rennels to District Office Positions
    NORTHRIDGE, Calif. - The CSUN men's volleyball team was picked to finish third in the inaugural Big West Men's Volleyball Preseason Coaches Poll announced Thursday.
    Big West Pre-Season Coaches Poll Puts Matadors Volleyball at No. 3
    A 44-year-old transient was arrested by SCV Sheriff's Station deputies Wednesday afternoon after he allegedly tried to pick up his 8-year-old niece from a school in Santa Clarita.
    Suspect Arrested in Attempted Kidnapping
    It was a night to honor exceptional mentors at California State University, Northridge, but the five recipients of the 2017 Don Dorsey Excellence in Mentoring Awards just wanted to talk about their students.
    CSUN Pays Tribute to Mentors Who Have Made a Difference
    The words leapt right off the page and hung in the air, heavy, encircling the audience. Their creator stood, offering his gifts of verse — shared in a powerful baritone voice.
    Literary Star Power Comes to CSUN
    While critical fire conditions continue through Friday, the final numbers for the Rye Fire have been released.
    Officials Release Final Numbers on Rye Fire
    The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board held it’s annual reorganizational meeting Wednesday night, naming Steve Sturgeon as Board President.
    Steve Sturgeon Named 2018 Hart Board President
    Castaic Elementary School is collecting gently used children's clothing and toys for the victims of the Creek Fire in Sylmar.
    Local School Collecting Clothes, Toys for Creek Fire Victims
    Gusty Santa Ana winds fanned the Thomas Fire's eastern flank Thursday, prompting officials to call for mandatory evacuations for areas near Fillmore.
    Officials Issue Evacuation Orders for Fillmore Residents
    SACRAMENTO – California Attorney General Xavier Becerra issued the following statement in response to the Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) decision to repeal net neutrality rules instituted in 2015. These rules protect consumers' access to online content without interference or manipulation by an internet service provider:
    Becerra Condemns FCC’s Net Neutrality Ruling
    Washington—Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) released the following statement Thursday on the fifth anniversary of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting:
    Feinstein Issues Statement on Five Year Anniversary of Sandy Hook
    SACRAMENTO – California Attorney General Xavier Becerra today filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Department of Education and its Secretary, Betsy DeVos, for refusing to process debt relief claims submitted by tens of thousands of students who took out federal student loans to attend Corinthian Colleges, Inc. (Corinthian).
    Becerra Lawsuit Alleges Devos, Education Department Refusing to Process Debt Relief Claims
    CAL FIRE has released a statement on its Facebook page regarding the death of one of their own:
    CAL FIRE Engineer Killed Battling Thomas Fire
    1931 - Season's first major storm deposits 9 inches of snow in Newhall, 10 in Saugus [story]
    The Sheriff’s Department and CHP will participate in a special year-end "Drive Sober or Get Pulled Over" enforcement campaign from December 15 through January 1.
    LASD, CHP Join ‘Drive Sober or Get Pulled Over’ DUI Campaign
    The Caribbean is back, better than ever, and Valencia-based Princess Cruises is offering the best fares of the season during the “Exclusively Caribbean Sale,” on 7-, 8-, 10-, 14-day sailings departing February through April 2018.
    Princess Cruises ‘Exclusively Caribbean Sale’ Offers Season’s Best Fares
    Designer and animator Jamie Tan (Film/Video BFA 15) started baking cakes and fancy French pastries as a meditative practice to help her balance the 20 credit semesters she was taking as a student at CalArts.
    Jamie Tan on Art, Baking for Rojas’ ‘Theater of Disappearance’
    CalArts School of Critical Studies faculty Janet Sarbanes recently received a grant from The Creative Capital | Andy Warhol Foundation Arts Writers Grant Program for her essay "Reframing the House of Dust: A Meditation in Many Parts."
    CalArts’ Janet Sarbanes Wins Writers Grant from Creative Capital
    Artist and CalArts alumna Carrie Mae Weems (Art BFA 81) concludes her year-long residency at New York’s Park Avenue Armory with a day-long convening of artists, writers, poets, musicians and social theorists on Sunday, Dec. 17.
    Dec. 17: Weems Wraps Year-Long NYC Residency
    Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk Dean C. Logan was named winner of the 2017 Electoral Ergonomy Award at the International Electoral Awards on December 5 in Dead Sea, Jordan.
    LA County Registrar-Clerk Wins International Electoral Award
    The CSUN women's basketball team looks to extend its winning streak to four when the Matadors return home to face the Northern Arizona Lumberjacks on Monday, December 18.
    Dec. 18: CSUN Women’s Basketball Team Goes for 4
    Sport fishing permits for 2018 are now on sale from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife.
    Sport Fishing Licenses for 2018 Now on Sale
    The National Weather Service has issued a Red Flag Warning for the Santa Clarita Valley and other areas of Los Angeles, Ventura and Santa Barbara counties through Friday morning.
    Critical Fire Conditions in SCV Though Friday
    Steve Gerischer, proprietor of Larkspur Garden Design, will simplify the art of rose pruning and share tips on keeping your roses flourishing at the next installment of CSUN's CSUN-al Gardening series on Saturday, Jan. 13.
    CSUN-al Gardening to Tackle the Prickly Topic of Pruning Roses
    The Master’s University profiles 2017 men's basketball star Brock Gardner.
    TMU Basketball’s Brock Gardner – Tough Decisions, Terrific Transfer
    The list of Daktronics-NAIA Scholar-Athletes, released recently, was backloaded with four athletes from The Master’s University.
    4 TMU Men’s Soccer Players Named NAIA Scholar-Athletes
    During October, 15 junior high and high school campuses in Santa Clarita hosted a toiletries drive as part of their annual DFY in SCV community campaign.
    DFY in SCV Students Help Others in Need