[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
79°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
December 15
1987 - Incorporation: Santa Clarita officially becomes a city [story]


Kamala Harris

Kamala Harris

OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

State of California

 

KAMALA D. HARRIS Attorney General

OPINION : No. 13-902 of February 11, 2014

 

KAMALA D. HARRIS : Attorney General

MARC J. NOLAN : Deputy Attorney General

 

Proposed relator SAUGUS UNION SCHOOL DISTRICT has requested leave to sue proposed defendant STEPHEN WINKLER in quo warranto to remove him from the public office of School District Trustee on the ground that he does not reside in the District as required by law.

 

CONCLUSION

Leave to sue is GRANTED to determine whether proposed defendant STEPHEN WINKLER meets the legal residency requirements for holding the public office of School District Trustee.

 

ANALYSIS

Proposed Relator SAUGUS UNION SCHOOL DISTRICT (District) is a public school district organized under the Education Code1 and located in the Santa Clarita Valley in northern Los Angeles County.2 Under state law, a person must reside within the geographical boundaries of a public school district to be eligible for election or appointment as a trustee on that district’s governing board, and must remain a district resident for the entire term of his or her office.3 In November 2011, proposed Defendant STEPHEN WINKLER was elected as a District Trustee to a four-year term that began in December 2011 and ends in December 2015. Based on information that surfaced after Mr. Winkler’s election, the District contends that Mr. Winkler did not reside within District boundaries when elected and does not currently reside there. On this basis, the District has applied to this office seeking our permission to sue Mr. Winkler in quo warranto in order to remove him from the public office of District Trustee. Because there is a substantial issue of law and fact regarding Mr. Winkler’s legal residence that we find suitable for judicial resolution, we grant the District’s application.

Code of Civil Procedure section 803 provides in pertinent part: “An action may be brought by the attorney-general, in the name of the people of this state, upon his own information, or upon a complaint of a private party, against any person who usurps, intrudes into, or unlawfully holds or exercises any public office . . . within this state.”4 An action filed under the terms of this statute is known as a “quo warranto” action, and is the proper legal means for testing title to public office.5 A school district board trustee holds a “public office” for purposes of a quo warranto action.6 A party seeking to bring a quo warranto action in superior court, also known as the “proposed relator,” must first obtain the Attorney General’s consent to do so.7 In determining whether to grant that consent, often called “leave to sue,” we must decide whether the proposed relator’s application presents a substantial issue of fact or law that warrants judicial resolution, and whether granting leave to sue would serve the public interest.8 We now turn to the particulars of the present application.

As mentioned, proposed Defendant Winkler was elected as a District Trustee in November 2011. For purposes of that election, Mr. Winkler listed his residence address as 24600 Town Center Drive in Valencia, which is located within the District’s geographical boundaries. Shortly after the election, however, Mr. Winkler asked that his board meeting information packets be delivered to his brother’s store in the community of Canyon Country, which is located outside District boundaries. The superintendent informed Mr. Winkler that the meeting packets could not be delivered to an address outside the District. A short time later, Mr. Winkler gave his address as 26927 Avenida Terraza in Saugus (within the District) and then, in October 2012, stated to District staff that he was moving to 27135 Rio Prado Drive in Santa Clarita (also within the District).

District staff responsible for delivering the meeting information packets informed the superintendent that, from the time he was elected District Trustee, Mr. Winkler had never been at his stated residence when the packets were delivered. In addition, on one occasion when an information packet was delivered to the Rio Prado address, the person who answered the door informed the delivery person that Mr. Winkler did not live at that location. On another occasion, the District mailed information to Mr. Winkler at the Rio Prado address, but it was returned to the District as undeliverable. As a result of the questions raised by Mr. Winkler’s continued absence from the Rio Prado address, the District employed an investigator to determine Mr. Winkler’s true residence. The investigator visited both the Avenida Terraza and Rio Prado addresses on numerous occasions, at various times of day and night, but never saw Mr. Winkler at either location. The investigator did, however, observe Mr. Winkler at an out-of-District address of 12614 Herrick Avenue in Sylmar on several different occasions, including late at night.

Finally, the District came into possession of two separate Requests for Civil Harassment Restraining Orders, dated August 22, 2012, and January 7, 2013, signed by Mr. Winkler under penalty of perjury, in which he stated that he lived at the Herrick Avenue address. These requests sought restraining orders against a person named Henry Bradley, whom Mr. Winkler described as “[m]y landlord’s brother” and “my housemate and the brother of my landlord.” The requests contain multiple other statements in which Mr. Winkler describes his regular presence and habitation at the Herrick Avenue location. When another District Trustee confronted Mr. Winkler over the written statements made in the two requests, Mr. Winkler did not deny submitting the requests to the superior court and signing them under penalty of perjury, but explained that he only uses the Herrick Avenue address to store his belongings and that he only sleeps at that location at times when he has been drinking too much.

The District argues that the evidence shows that Mr. Winkler’s true residence is the out-of-District Herrick Avenue address. In opposition to the District’s application, Mr. Winkler maintains that he lives within District boundaries, at the Rio Prado address, and he has submitted a copy of a blank personal check and mailings from the Employment Development Department and First Presbyterian Church also listing the Rio Prado location as his address. He argues that a person may be present and stay at any number of locations, yet still have only one true residence, which he asserts is the Rio Prado address.

A member of a school district’s governing board must be a resident of the district during the entire term of his or her office,9 so if Mr. Winkler is not currently a resident of the District, he would not be qualified to hold office as a member of the governing board.10 A person’s legal residence for this purpose is defined as his or her “domicile” within the meaning of Government Code section 244,11 which provides:

(a) It is the place where one remains when not called elsewhere for labor or other special or temporary purpose, and to which he or she returns in seasons of repose.

(b) There can only be one residence.

(c) A residence cannot be lost until another is gained.

….

(f) The residence can be changed only by the union of act and intent.

In short, “domicile” is a place of physical presence coupled with the intention to make that place one’s permanent home.12

While we acknowledge items such as the mailings apparently sent to and received by Mr. Winkler at the Rio Prado address, as well as Mr. Winkler’s current statement that he views that address as his permanent, legal residence, we cannot ignore or discount his regular absence from Rio Prado, his regular presence at Herrick Avenue, and his sworn statements in the requests for restraining orders that Herrick Avenue is his home.13 Mr. Winkler is correct that a person may only have one true, legal residence at a time,14 but the question raised here by his acts and declarations is, where is that residence located?

Although we cannot answer that question with certainty, it is not necessary for us to do so at this stage. Suffice it to say that there is a substantial factual and legal issue as to the location of Mr. Winkler’s domicile. Further, it is in the public interest to have this issue resolved judicially as the determination of Mr. Winkler’s legal residency is critical to his eligibility to serve on the District’s board of trustees.

For these reasons, leave to sue is GRANTED to determine whether proposed defendant Winkler meets the legal residency requirements for holding the public office of School District Trustee.

 

1 See Ed. Code, §§ 35100-35401.

2 http://www.saugususd.org/About-SUSD/Our-District/index.html

3 86 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 194, 195-196 (2003); 84 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 154, 155-156 (2001); see Ed. Code, § 35107, subd. (a).

4 Although Code of Civil Procedure section 803 refers to the complaint “of a private party,” public officers and agencies may also apply to the Attorney General for leave to sue in quo warranto. (76 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 157, 162 (1993).)

5 Nicolopulos v. City of Lawndale (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th 1221, 1125-1126; Visnich v. Sacramento County Board of Education (1974) 37 Cal.App.3d 684, 690 (“title to an elective office cannot be litigated by any other means than in quo warranto”); Elliott v. Van Delinder (1926) 77 Cal.App. 716, 719 (“statutory procedure in the nature of quo warranto is the proper remedy by which directly to test the title to all public offices”); 93 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 144, 145 (2010); 81 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 207, 208 (1998).

6 86 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen., supra, at p. 195; 73 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 354, 356 (1990); see 84 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 91, 92 (2001).

7 See International Association of Fire Fighters v. City of Oakland (1985) 174 Cal.App.3d 687, 693-698.

8 95 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 50, 51 (2012); 93 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 144, 145 (2010); 86 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 205, 208-209 (2003).

9 86 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen., supra, at pp. 195-106.

10 Gov. Code, § 1770; Ed. Code, § 5090; 86 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen., supra, at p. 196.

11 Walters v. Weed (1988) 45 Cal.3d 1, 7-8 (“residence” as used in Gov. Code, § 244 means “legal residence” or “domicile”); Smith v. Smith (1955) 45 Cal.2d 235, 239 (“residence” as used in Gov. Code, § 244 is synonymous with domicile); Fenton v. Bd. of Directors (1984) 156 Cal.App.3d 1107, 1113 (“residence” as used in Gov. Code, § 244 means “domicile”); 89 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 44, 47 (2006) (same).

12 Fenton, supra, 156 Cal.App.3d at pp. 1113-1114.

13 Courts, and this office, have generally considered a range of factors as indicia of a person’s domicile, including various forms of documentary evidence (e.g., voter registration, driver’s license, vehicle registration, etc.) and other official papers; the person’s mailing address for such things as bills and invoices; the location of bank accounts; where the majority of the person’s business and personal contacts are; and the acts and declarations of the person. (See 95 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 43, 45 (2012).)

14 DiMiglio v. Mashore (1992) 4 Cal.App.4th 1260, 1268.

 

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


LOCAL SCHOOL LINKS
Related Content
LATEST SCHOOL NEWS
Thursday, Dec 14, 2017
The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board has approved naming Dr. Collyn Nielsen as Chief Administrative Officer and Jan Hayes-Rennels as Director of Special Programs and Staff Development.
Thursday, Dec 14, 2017
The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board held it’s annual reorganizational meeting Wednesday night, naming Steve Sturgeon as Board President.
Thursday, Dec 14, 2017
Castaic Elementary School is collecting gently used children's clothing and toys for the victims of the Creek Fire in Sylmar.
Wednesday, Dec 13, 2017
During October, 15 junior high and high school campuses in Santa Clarita hosted a toiletries drive as part of their annual DFY in SCV community campaign.
Wednesday, Dec 13, 2017
The nonprofit WiSH Education Foundation is out to raise $100,000 to fund improvements in Hart District school libraries.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Tickets and sponsorships are now available for the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce's 2018 awards ceremony and installation of new officers at Tournament Players Club in Valencia on Friday night, January 26.
Jan. 26: SCV Chamber of Commerce 2018 Awards, Installation Gala
Sponsorships are now open for the Santa Clarita Valley Economic Development Corporation's 2018 Economic Outlook Conference, set for Thursday, March 8, 2018 at a location to be announced shortly.
SCV 2018 Economic Outlook Conference Tickets, Sponsorships Open
SetPoint Medical, a Valencia-based biomedical company developing therapy for chronic inflammatory diseases, has received approval from the FDA to initiate a pilot trial in the U.S. for patients with drug-refractory rheumatoid arthritis.
FDA OK’s SetPoint Bioelectronic Therapy Study for Rheumatoid Arthritis
The regular Planning Commission meeting scheduled for Tuesday, December 19 has been canceled, according to a notification from the city of Santa Clarita today.
City Cancels Dec. 19 Planning Commission Meeting
The next meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors is set for Tuesday, December 19, starting at 9:30 a.m.
Dec. 19: L.A. County Board of Supervisors Meeting
L.A. County's Bringing Our Loved Ones Home Task Force officials unveiled their final recommendations, endorsing a plan to use a voluntary system of trackable bracelets to find people prone to wandering, like those suffering from Alzheimer’s or autism.
County Task Force Calls for Tracking Bracelets to Locate Lost Individuals
The Community Development Commission of the county of Los Angeles looks back on 35 years of advancing its core program areas: affordable housing and housing, community and economic development.
County Community Development Commission Marks 35th Anniversary
The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department looks back at five years of work by its Domestic Highway Enforcement Team, which has disrupted the operations of the drug cartels by confiscating millions of dollars in illegal drugs and drug money.
Elite LASD Drug Enforcement Team Disrupts Cartel Operations
Metro is seeking two new members to join the Measure M Independent Taxpayer Oversight Committee.
Metro Seeks 2 New Measure M Oversight Committee Members
The National Weather Service has called a Fire Weather Watch for this weekend for Los Angeles and Ventura County mountains and valleys including the Santa Clarita Valley due to gusty northeast wind and low relative humidity.
Weekend Fire Weather Watch Called for SCV
The California Air Resources Board approved a $663 million low-carbon transportation plan Thursday to increase the use of clean cars, heavy-duty trucks, buses and freight equipment.
Air Resources Board OK’s $663 Million for Clean Vehicles
The Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station has released its public safety and crime information report for Saugus (Zone 4) for December 4-10, 2017.
Crime Blotter: Shoplifting, Petty Theft in Saugus
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra has filed his strong opposition to the Trump Administration’s illegal attempt to suspend the 2015 Clean Water Rule for two years.
California AG, 10 Others Oppose Feds’ Suspension of Clean Water Rule
1987 - Incorporation: Santa Clarita officially becomes a city [story]
With an offense that challenged the program’s single-season goals record, The Master’s University women’s soccer team was almost almost never out of any game it played: The Mustangs were always within striking range.
Lady Mustangs Within Range of Directors’ Cup Top Spots
When Ed Jackiewicz met Tera Trujillo in spring 2015, she was studying at a desk she’d carried to the corner of the California State University, Northridge soccer field, in a “time out” of sorts, unable to practice because she’d just earned a D in an economics class.
CSUN’s “Under Armour Faculty” Promotes Academic Success in Student-Athletes
When Rafael Munoz recalls his time at the Layer 8 Computer Security Club at California State University, Northridge, he feels proud and thankful.
CSUN’s Tech Education Makes Top 10 List
The city of Santa Clarita Arts and Events division is currently seeking proposals for solo exhibits for 2018 in the gallery space at The MAIN, the City’s newest arts venue in Old Town Newhall.
City Seeking Artists for 2018 Solo Exhibits
NORTHRIDGE, Calif.---CSUN Men's Basketball returns to the road for the final time in the non-conference season this weekend.
CSUN to Face-Off Against Formal Rival Eastern Washington
Here is a list of Santa Clarita arts-related events for Friday:
Dec. 15: Santa Clarita Arts Calendar
This Friday and Saturday (Dec. 15-16), The Sharon Disney Lund School of Dance brings their annual Winter Dance Concert to the REDCAT stage.
Dec. 15, 16: Sharon Disney Lund School of Dance Concert at REDCAT
The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board has approved naming Dr. Collyn Nielsen as Chief Administrative Officer and Jan Hayes-Rennels as Director of Special Programs and Staff Development.
Hart Appoints Nielsen, Hayes-Rennels to District Office Positions
NORTHRIDGE, Calif. - The CSUN men's volleyball team was picked to finish third in the inaugural Big West Men's Volleyball Preseason Coaches Poll announced Thursday.
Big West Pre-Season Coaches Poll Puts Matadors Volleyball at No. 3
A 44-year-old transient was arrested by SCV Sheriff's Station deputies Wednesday afternoon after he allegedly tried to pick up his 8-year-old niece from a school in Santa Clarita.
Suspect Arrested in Attempted Kidnapping
It was a night to honor exceptional mentors at California State University, Northridge, but the five recipients of the 2017 Don Dorsey Excellence in Mentoring Awards just wanted to talk about their students.
CSUN Pays Tribute to Mentors Who Have Made a Difference
The words leapt right off the page and hung in the air, heavy, encircling the audience. Their creator stood, offering his gifts of verse — shared in a powerful baritone voice.
Literary Star Power Comes to CSUN
While critical fire conditions continue through Friday, the final numbers for the Rye Fire have been released.
Officials Release Final Numbers on Rye Fire
The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board held it’s annual reorganizational meeting Wednesday night, naming Steve Sturgeon as Board President.
Steve Sturgeon Named 2018 Hart Board President
Castaic Elementary School is collecting gently used children's clothing and toys for the victims of the Creek Fire in Sylmar.
Local School Collecting Clothes, Toys for Creek Fire Victims
Gusty Santa Ana winds fanned the Thomas Fire's eastern flank Thursday, prompting officials to call for mandatory evacuations for areas near Fillmore.
Officials Issue Evacuation Orders for Fillmore Residents
SACRAMENTO – California Attorney General Xavier Becerra issued the following statement in response to the Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) decision to repeal net neutrality rules instituted in 2015. These rules protect consumers' access to online content without interference or manipulation by an internet service provider:
Becerra Condemns FCC’s Net Neutrality Ruling
Washington—Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) released the following statement Thursday on the fifth anniversary of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting:
Feinstein Issues Statement on Five Year Anniversary of Sandy Hook
SACRAMENTO – California Attorney General Xavier Becerra today filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Department of Education and its Secretary, Betsy DeVos, for refusing to process debt relief claims submitted by tens of thousands of students who took out federal student loans to attend Corinthian Colleges, Inc. (Corinthian).
Becerra Lawsuit Alleges Devos, Education Department Refusing to Process Debt Relief Claims
CAL FIRE has released a statement on its Facebook page regarding the death of one of their own:
CAL FIRE Engineer Killed Battling Thomas Fire
1931 - Season's first major storm deposits 9 inches of snow in Newhall, 10 in Saugus [story]