[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Mostly cloudy
Mostly cloudy
53°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
November 20
1831 - Local entrepreneurs Sanford and Cyrus Lyon (as in Lyons Avenue) born in Machias, Maine [story]


[KHTS] – A judge issued a tentative ruling Wednesday in the only unsettled California Voting Rights Act lawsuit in the Santa Clarita Valley.

judge-issues-tentative-cvra-ruling-coc-lawsuit-trialJudge Rolf Treu denied the Santa Clarita Community College District’s request for a summary judgment dismissing the lawsuit alleging a violation of the CVRA. A trial date is tentatively scheduled for June 2. The SCCCD governing board oversees the College of the Canyons‘s two SCV campuses, and its district boundary encompasses the Santa Clarita Valley and a very small portion of the San Fernando Valley. 

The ruling left the attorney for Jim Soliz andRosemarie Sanchez-Fraser, who were also plaintiffs in a lawsuit against the city of Santa Clarita alleging similar violations, upbeat about his case’s potential.

“The court expressed its view of the law and it mirrors what we’ve said,” said Kevin Shenkman of Shenkman & Hughes. “And with that view, (the Santa Clarita Community College District) can’t win.”

Shenkman garnered settlements in lawsuits against the Sulphur Springs School District and the city of Santa Clarita. Those changes are expected to take place in the 2015 and 2016 elections, respectively.

The city agreed to move its election to November of even-numbered years and allow for cumulative voting, which means, for example, in a City Council race with three seats, a voter would receive three votes he or she could cast in any combination for the candidates.

The Sulphur Springs School District agreed to go to districting, which would divide the district’s coverage area into boundaries, and an elected official would represent a specific area. District officials will not be moving their election year.

Both entities acknowledged the enormous cost of fighting such a claim, as well as the fact that no such claim has ever been successfully defended, as part of the reason for settling.

In the filing of a similar lawsuit against the city ofPalmdale, the legal fees are expected to reach approximately $5 million, according to case documents. That case is still being litigated on appeal, as the initial ruling went against Palmdale.

Shenkman also disagreed with a recent assessment that the remedy approved by Santa Clarita officials — lining up the City Council race with the other November ballots, would cause confusion and affect turnout.

Shenkman pointed out Long Beach’s municipal elections, which follows procedure similar to those adopted by Santa Clarita, statistically affect the voter turnout by 2-3 percent, while the turnout for November increases by approximately 30-40 percent.

Santa Clarita Community College officials repeatedly expressed a desire to fight the lawsuit.

In Wednesday’s tentative ruling, Treu declares the fact that no Latino candidate has run for the SCCCD board in the last 21 years is irrelevant to the case. He also discounts the need for the plaintiffs to establish a majority Hispanic district in the Santa Clarita Valley, which is a SCCCD contention.

Treu also found fault with experts on both sides, noting the SCCCD’s expert, Jonathan Katz, a Caltech professor, looked at too limited of a sample in denying the existence of racially polarized voting; the data considered by the plaintiff’s expert, Morgan Kousser, who’s also a Caltech professor, did not have a proper foundation establishing its relevance.

Kousser was also the expert used in the case against the city and the school district, and Shenkman said that would be addressed at trial. A schedule conflict could push back the case, but a tentative date was set in June.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Monday, Nov 19, 2018
SCV Housing Inventory Rises for 5th Straight Month; Sales Slow
The number of active listings of homes and condominiums for sale in the Santa Clarita Valley rose in October for the fifth consecutive month while sales slowed and resale prices continued to move higher, the Southland Regional Association of Realtors reported Monday.
Monday, Nov 19, 2018
All CHP Officers on Duty for Thanksgiving Weekend Safety
The California Highway Patrol will have all available officers on patrol Thanksgiving weekend, traditionally one of the busiest travel times in America, in a maximum enforcement period from Wednesday through Sunday.
Friday, Nov 16, 2018
Smith Widens Lead in 38th Assembly District Tally
Democratic challenger Christy Smith's lead has widened to 3,099 votes over Republican incumbent Dante Acosta in the race for California's 38th District, according to the updated ballot count released Friday afternoon by the Los Angeles County and Ventura County registrars of voters.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1831 - Local entrepreneurs Sanford and Cyrus Lyon (as in Lyons Avenue) born in Machias, Maine [story]
The Master's University women's volleyball team learned Monday which teams will be in its pool at next week's NAIA national championship in Sioux City, Iowa.
Pools Announced for NAIA Women’s Volleyball Tournament
To describe his stay at The Master's University, one that's included a rocky beginning, a handful of role changes and a stellar climax, including Saturday when he topped 1,000 career points, senior Delewis Johnson chose a roller coaster analogy.
Johnson Tops 1,000 Career Points in TMU Win Over Saint Katherine
For the first time this season, fans of The Master's University women's basketball team didn't need a laptop or tablet to catch a glimpse of the Mustangs — and there was a lot to like about Friday's live rendition.
TMU Women’s Basketball Team Cruises in Home Opener
The Master's University men's cross country team felt the sting of Friday's lower-than-expected finish at NAIA nationals but also turned an eye to a promising 2019.
TMU Men’s Cross Country Finishes 20th at Nationals
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health recommends several tips to avoid foodborne illness and keep the Thanksgiving holiday celebration festive.
Health Officials Offer Thanksgiving Food Safety Tips
A group of SCV Water staff and members of TreePeople and the Sierra Club teamed up for a "Restoration Field Day" Friday to learn about the local watershed and restore a creek-side habitat in San Francisquito Canyon.
SCV Water, TreePeople, Sierra Club Team for Restoration Field Day
Santa Claus will visit Heritage Junction William S. Hart Regional Park on Saturday, Dec. 1, from 1 p.m. to 3 p.m., then slide on over to Hart Hall in Newhall Park at 6 p.m. as the Friends of Hart Park celebrate 'Cowboys and Carols.'
Dec. 1: Santa to Visit Heritage Junction, Hart Park
Pocock Brewing Company invites everyone 21 years old and older to its 3rd Anniversary Beer Festival on Dec. 1 to benefit the Castaic Education Foundation and the Santa Clarita Valley Education Foundation.
Dec. 1: Pocock Beer Fest to Benefit Castaic Schools, SCV Education Foundation
Valencia High School’s Theatre Department took home first place at the recent Drama Teachers Association of Southern California Fall Festival held at Canyon High School.
Valencia High School Theatre Wins SoCal Competition
Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk Dean C. Logan announced the third ballot counting update for the Nov. 6 General Election Friday afternoon.
County Releases Third Ballot Tally Update for Nov. 6 Election
The Home Depot Fund has pledged $500,000 while a multimedia benefit event raised more than $1.1 million to aid victims of the Woolsey Fire.
Home Depot Pledges $500K for Fire Relief; LA Benefit Raises $1.1M
With Woolsey Fire recovery and relief efforts underway, Los Angeles County officials caution the public to beware of charity scams and to donate to organizations they know and trust.
County Officials: Beware of Woolsey Fire Charity Scams
College of the Canyon's women's volleyball team will host a first-round California Community College Athletic Association Southern California Regional Playoff match vs. San Diego Mesa College on Tuesday, Nov. 20, at the Cougar Cage, with the first serve scheduled for 6 p.m.
Nov. 20: Canyons Volleyball to Host First Round Playoff Match
Highway 14 motorists and Metrolink train riders alike can tell the new buildings at Vista Canyon just south of Sand Canyon are just about complete and ready for business.
Vista Canyon Prepares to Welcome Its First Tenants
The city of Santa Clarita has updated the list of productions shooting in the city and the Santa Clarita Valley for the week of Nov. 19-25, 2018.
‘Lethal Weapon,’ ‘SEAL Team,’ ‘NCIS’ Filming in SCV This Week
The number of active listings of homes and condominiums for sale in the Santa Clarita Valley rose in October for the fifth consecutive month while sales slowed and resale prices continued to move higher, the Southland Regional Association of Realtors reported Monday.
SCV Housing Inventory Rises for 5th Straight Month; Sales Slow
William S. Hart High School’s Hart Regiment won top honors at the 2018 Southern California School Band and Orchestra Association Marching Band Championship at Downey High School on Saturday, Nov. 17.
Hart Regiment Wins Gold at Marching Band Championship
The California Highway Patrol will have all available officers on patrol Thanksgiving weekend, traditionally one of the busiest travel times in America, in a maximum enforcement period from Wednesday through Sunday.
All CHP Officers on Duty for Thanksgiving Weekend Safety
College of the Canyons cross country capped its season by sending three runners to compete at the California Community College Athletic Association State Championships at Woodward Park in Fresno last Saturday.
Cougar Cross Country Ends Season at State Championship Meet
2003 - U.S. Rep. Howard "Buck" McKeon introduces the first of several bills intended to block the 78-million-ton Cemex gravel mine in Soledad Canyon [story]
1957 - Newhall County Library dedicated on Ninth Street; rededicated as city of Santa Clarita's Business Incubator exactly 57 years later (2014) [story]
1969 - Construction begins on Magic Mountain amusement park [story]
Democratic challenger Christy Smith's lead has widened to 3,099 votes over Republican incumbent Dante Acosta in the race for California's 38th District, according to the updated ballot count released Friday afternoon by the Los Angeles County and Ventura County registrars of voters.
Smith Widens Lead in 38th Assembly District Tally
Retired Los Angeles County Sheriff's Lt. Alex Villanueva has pulled ahead of incumbent Sheriff Jim McDonnell by 57,810 votes in the Nov. 6 general election
Sheriff’s Race: Villanueva Widens Lead Over McDonnell by Nearly 58K Votes
A new three-year collective bargaining agreement between Kaiser Permanente and the Alliance of Health Care Unions is now in effect through Sept. 30, 2021.
Kaiser Permanente, Health Care Unions Ratify New National Deal
The next meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors is set for Tuesday, Nov. 20, starting at 9:30 a.m.
Nov. 20: LA County Board of Supervisors Meeting
The Santa Monica Mountains National Recreation Area suffered significant damage from the Woolsey Fire, including the destruction of the Western Town at Paramount Ranch and a building housing priceless archives, the National Park Service reported Friday.
Woolsey Fire Destroys Western Town, Museum, Archives at Paramount Ranch
A multitude of important disaster recovery resources from government, non-profit, and private agencies are now available online at www.lacounty.gov/woolseyfire to help support residents, business owners, and others impacted by the Woolsey Fire.
County Launches Recovery, Damage Reporting Webpage for Woolsey Fire Victims
Red Rock Canyon State Park officials have set their schedule of interpretive events for the second half of November.
Red Rock Canyon State Park Sets November Walks, Talks, Slide Show
Registration is underway for the College of the Canyons winter semester, and registration for the spring 2019 semester will begin Tuesday, Jan. 2.
Register Now for COC Winter Semester; Spring Registration to Open Jan. 2
The California State Auditor rebuked the agency in charge of implementing the state’s high-speed rail project Thursday, finding lack of planning and poor oversight has led to cost overruns plaguing the Golden State’s efforts.
Cost Overruns, Poor Oversight Plague California Bullet Train
The U.S. Small Business Administration has issued a disaster declaration for Los Angeles County that will make low-interest federal disaster loans available to businesses and residents impacted by the Woolsey Fire.
Feds Offer Low-Interest Loans to LA County Wildfire Victims
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station deputies arrested a man on Friday suspected of vandalizing a Newhall business over the Veterans Day holiday weekend.
SCV Deputies Arrest Newhall Vandalism Suspect
The city of Santa Clarita, in partnership with Parkway Motorcars, will once again hold a Thanksgiving Community Dinner at the Newhall Community Center, located at 22421 Market Street in Newhall.
Nov. 19: City’s Annual Thanksgiving Community Dinner