[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Clear
Clear
57°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
January 17
1994, 4:31 a.m. - Magnitude 6.7 Northridge earthquake rocks Santa Clarita Valley [video]


| Thursday, Mar 24, 2016
Foster parent Rusty Page and DCFS social workers bring Lexi out of the foster home in Saugus Monday afternoon for relocation.
Foster parent Rusty Page and DCFS social workers remove Lexi from her foster home in Saugus Monday.
 

A custody battle between a Santa Clarita foster family and a biological family over a 6-year-old girl wages on.

The foster parents, Summer and Rusty Page, raised the foster child known as “Lexi” since she was 2 years old. Lexi was supposed to be relocated Sunday morning to family members in Utah by the Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services. The move was rescheduled to Monday after supporters rallied to “Keep Lexi Home” near the Page residence on Ron Ridge Drive in Saugus.

The Pages’ attorney, Lori Alvino-McGill of the Washington, D.C., law firm of Wilkinson, Walsh and Eskovitz, released a statement Tuesday on the “Save Lexi” Facebook page stating:

“A happy, thriving 6-year-old girl was forcibly removed from the people she knows as her parents because of a terribly misguided interpretation of a federal law that was designed to keep families together, not tear them apart.”

A Facebook page titled “Lexi is Home” was created by supporters of Lexi’s biological family.

In an op-ed piece published Thursday in the Wall Street Journal, Goldwater Institute of Arizona attorneys Aditya Dynar and Timothy Sandefur, who are involved in a similar case, assert that Lexi’s race was the sole reason for her relocation.

“In Brown v. Board of Education, the Supreme Court ruled that creating a separate and substandard system for children of one race is repugnant to America’s highest law,” the attorneys write. “Fifty years later, it is unacceptable that children like Lexi – and the non-Indian parents who love them – are still subjected to disfavored treatment based on their ancestry.”

But court documents show the county had planned for years to relocate Lexi to members of her biological family, who had been pursuing custody since 2011.

“The court has to do their due diligence to notice all parties, whether or not children have an American Indian affiliation,” said Neil Zanville, a spokesman for the Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services. “Before anyone would adopt, we have to exhaust all options with the family. We’re always trying to act in the child’s’ best interest, and if we know of family and we know of siblings, then that would be optimum to place the child, near their siblings.”

Zanville said the preferred outcome is to reunite foster children with their parents, if it is safe to do so, and if it isn’t, social workers begin to look for other relatives.

“Frequently children are placed with extended family members,” Zanville said, because DCFS “wants to keep siblings together.”

There are cases where foster children are put up for adoption, and DCFS often looks to foster families to adopt those children, Zanville said.

“If there are no relatives,” he said, “and a child is in a foster home, and if the foster parents have had a great relationship (with the child) and they are well bonded … then we look to the foster families for adoption.”

Also, Title IV-E of the federal Social Security Act states that the county must “consider giving preference to an adult relative over a nonrelative caregiver when determining placement for a child.”

Lexi is not only subject to DCFS placement procedures but also falls under the protections of the Indian Child Welfare Act, which “mandates that adoptive placements be made preferentially with members of the child’s extended family, other members of the same tribe or other Indian families.”

By law, the county must follow federal procedures if a child is found to be eligible for membership in a recognized Indian tribe or if parents, grandparents or great-grandparents were a member of a tribe. Court documents show that Lexi was identified as having Indian heritage after her paternal grandmother notified DCFS that Lexi’s father and half-sister are members of the Choctaw Tribe of Oklahoma (aka Choctaw Nation), and the tribe publicly identified Lexi as a member.

Once the tribal determination is made, several people are assigned to the case including a county social worker, an Indian social worker, an attorney for the child and an attorney for DCFS. The Pages hired their own attorney, and the Choctaw Nation provided legal representation for its members.

“This case is about one of our children, one of our tribal members,” according to a statement from the Choctaw Nation. “And regardless of tribal membership, Lexi should be allowed to live with her family, just as all children in any deprived case should…The law requires Lexi be given the chance to grow up with her family, with her sisters. The California courts, time and again, found that Lexi should live with her family.”

“There is nothing unusual about child placement with relatives after a stay in a foster home,” according to the National Congress of American Indians. “The only unusual factor in this case is that the foster family in California used extended litigation to prevent placement of a native child with her family.”

Lexi’s removal from the Page home came after the foster parents lost their third appeal on Friday, March 18.

 

Background

Lexi’s early childhood was an unhappy one. She was removed from her mother’s custody when she was 17 months old because of “a lengthy substance abuse problem,” according to court records. Her mother had also lost custody of at least six other children. Her father also had an “extensive criminal history” and had lost custody of another child.

Lexi was placed with two foster families before coming to the Page family in December 2011 when she was 2, and the Pages “were aware that (Lexi) was an Indian child and her placement was subject to the ICWA,” according to court records.

In October 2011, her extended family in Utah reached out to Choctaw representatives to express their interest in adopting Lexi, according to court records.

lexifosterchild_2

Foster father, Rusty Page, gives press conference Monday morning announcing that Lexi will be relocated that afternoon.

“The tribe agreed to initial foster placement with the (Pages)” because they lived near the girl’s biological father “at a time when he was working on reunification. If reunification services were terminated” after 2011, which they subsequently were, “the tribe recommended placement with the (extended family) in Utah.”

In December 2012, about a year later, Lexi’s Indian case worker Ruth Polcino recommended “that (Lexi) be allowed to stay in touch with the (Page) family, even after she is placed with her aunt in Utah.” The recommendation was intended to allow Lexi “to stay in touch with the (Page) family as extended family who care about her.”

Prior to June 2012, Lexi’s biological father had “successfully complied with reunification services for more than six months, progressing to such an extent that he was granted unmonitored eight-hour visits,” according to court records. DCFS “reported a substantial probability he would reunify with Lexi within the next six months.”

But Lexi’s father’s “emotional state deteriorated dramatically,” according to court records. “He separated from his new wife, left California, and did not visit (Lexi) after July 28, 2012. By September 2012, he had communicated to (DCFS) that he no longer wished to continue reunification services.”

A report in April 2013 stated Lexi’s “ability to re-attach to a new caretaker is stronger because of the stability that the (Page) family has provided for her.”

While Lexi was living with the Page family, DCFS “consistently reminded (them) that (Lexi) is an Indian child subject to the ICWA placement preferences,” according to court documents. “At some point after father’s reunification efforts failed, the (Pages) decided they wanted to adopt (Lexi). They discussed the issue with the (DCFS) social worker, who advised them that the tribe had selected (Lexi’s family members in Utah) as the planned adoptive placement.”

On April 12, 2013, all parties – DCFS, social workers, therapists, Lexi’s extended family and Summer and Rusty Page – agreed on a transition plan with “both families meeting for breakfast or at a park, explaining to (Lexi) that she would be going to live with (her extended family), who are family who love (Lexi) very much and would take good care of her. The (Pages) would reassure (Lexi) that they love her and would always be a part of her family,” according to court documents.

In the next six months, the court granted “de-facto parent” status to the Pages; the Interstate Compact on the Placement of Children request permitting Lexi’s placement with the extended family in Utah was approved; Lexi’s attorney withdrew her objection to the girl’s change in placement; and all parties submitted documents addressing whether there was cause to stray from ICWA’s adoptive placement preferences.

The court then ordered Lexi placed with the Utah family after finding that the Pages “had not proven by clear and convincing evidence” that it was certain the girl would be traumatized by the transfer, court documents show.

But Lexi’s placement in her new home was delayed for year while the Pages appealed the ruling.

lexifosterchild_4

Protestors rally Sunday night in Saugus.

After they lost the appeal earlier this month, friends of the Pages initiated the “Keep Lexi Home” protest on social media and on the family’s street in Saugus.

DCFS delayed Lexi’s planned Sunday relocation because of protestors in the street. Officials returned Monday, removing her just before 3 p.m. Rusty Page was surrounded by television cameras as he carried Lexi out of his home while Lexi’s foster mother, Summer, held back her other three children and yelled, “I love you, Lexi!” The Pages and their supporters ran after the DCFS car as it drove off with the wailing 6-year-old inside. Crowds of well wishers including Santa Clarita Mayor Bob Kellar came and went throughout the evening.

The Pages’ attorney said: “Our clients have been the only consistent source of love, nurturing, parenting and protection she has received her entire life.”

 

Utah Relations

Representatives of the Choctaw Nation said Lexi is no stranger to her Utah relatives.

“Lexi’s family (in Utah) made sure they were part of Lexi’s life, and they have a relationship with her,” according to a statement. “Each month, they made the long drive to see Lexi. Twice each week, her family had Skype visits with Lexi. In addition, Lexi has had extended visits in her family’s home in Utah. Lexi has a relationship with her biological sisters, and she knows them as her sisters.”

Tribal representatives said they and L.A. County DCFS have been “vilified” by the reaction to Lexi’s repatriation with her relatives and that “the facts of this case have been warped in an attempt to gain public sympathy for the foster family. This case is not about the foster family, but about a child’s long-term best interest – Lexi’s best interest.

“Lexi (is) a child who should never have been subjected to the trauma of a media circus when the foster parents’ legal remedies were exhausted. (She is) a child who should never have had her rights to privacy and confidentiality violated.”

Under state law, foster parents and other caregivers are to preserve the confidentiality of “all information and records regarding a child,” and the child shall not be “subjected to discrimination or harassment on the basis of actual or perceived race (or) ethnic group identification” or similar factors.

“Juvenile dependency proceedings are confidential, and Lexi is entitled to her confidentiality,” according to the Children’s Law Center of California, whose attorneys represented Lexi in court. “The past few days have been difficult for everyone involved. Our focus now is on ensuring that our client is supported in any every way possible and that she, her sisters, and their family are given the privacy they need.”

“The Choctaw Nation can report that Lexi is safely home with her loving family and her sisters, and she is doing well,” the tribe said in a statement Tuesday.

The Page family and friends are still determined to bring Lexi back to Santa Clarita and held a rally in Valencia Thursday evening. The Pages said they intend to appeal their case to the state Supreme Court.

lexifosterchild_1

Protestors rally Monday morning in Saugus.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

19 Comments

  1. If you see this story please at least know the facts before jumping on the foster parent’s pity party bandwagon… They had a job to do, temporarily care for the child until permanent placement is decided, they are paid well for this job and failed miserably by keeping this child against the courts ruling for 3yrs with continued failed appeals that ruled in the Utah family’s favor every time, this isn’t the first time this family has done this to a foster child in their care either…

    This is pure exploitation of this child for this foster family’s personal gain and should stop if anyone actually cares about this child’s wellbeing. A foster parents role is very clear, temporary care until permanency is decided, this child will never, no matter how much money is raised or how much her name and family are drug through the mud, will be back in this foster family’s care, they probably won’t ever be permitted to foster again seeing as this isn’t the first time they’ve created a situation like this, this is absolutely selfish and only further hurts this already disadvantaged child. Have some decency people and at least know what your talking about. Her family has been fighting this foster family for years, she has had regular visitation with them for years and will now be living with one sister and not far from another, these are not strangers by any means, and if these foster parents had a decent bone in their body they would have never divulged this child’s identity or created this media circus. Family placement and reunification should and is always the goal, this family knew she was not eligible for adoption from the beginning, fostering is hard, your asked to care for and love them as your own until they leave, not everyone can handle it obviously, but this exploitation of this child for their own personal gain has to be stopped for the child’s sake, for she is the only innocent victim here. The state screwed up but that’s to be expected, this foster family completely failed at their job too!! There should be an immediate gag order to stop this exploitation by this foster family for monetary gain and attention. This family has broken the law plastering this child’s face, name, information, and case history all over the web,and has purposely caused this child unnecessary trauma by calling in the media to have cameras in her face and strangers screaming at her during her transition, that is not considering the child’s wellbeing in the least and was done for purely selfish reasons, they should never be allowed to foster or traumatize another child or family in this way, they are the ones that have been delaying the inevitable for 3yrs with appeals that have all been found in the real family’s favor. I’ve been in contact with her family in Utah and she’s thriving there! #LexiIsHome Let’s respect her privacy!! The people behind #savelexi and #bringlexihome need to stop this madness and let this little girl live her life without all the drama and hysterics in the public eye.

  2. Nadiya Littlewarrior says:

    Thank you Amber Monaghan, for being clear and supportive of the truth. I would have not been able to have put it so well. Its beyond time for these people to move on.

  3. I’m just curious – what is your opinion on their ‘gain’ for fighting for a child they were fostering?

  4. Curious Amber, what is your connection to the case? I ask because you said you’ve been in touch with the Utah family, and considering their information hasn’t been released, I can’t imagine they are just fielding calls from average concerned citizens.

    Asking because it helps everyone to understand where your information is coming from. There’s just so much out there and it’s very confusing.

    Thanks.

    • I don’t have a personal connection, I did some of my own investigating and was able to contact the family privately just to let them know there is an entire community of people supporting them too, we didn’t discuss the case itself, just that Lexi is home, happy and enjoying her sisters and new school.

    • And you believe that if Lexi was upset, crying, and not assimilating, they would have told you, a total stranger that?

      Look, I’m not sure which information to believe, but I know that info from parties with a conflict of interest should be taken with a grain of salt. I’ll choose to go with information from people, like the foster agency social worker, who has nothing to gain by manipulating the information.

      My issues are with a father, who is unable to make sound life decisions, having any life decisions for her, with an Indian tribe who designates her as not enough Indian for gaming profits, yet enough Indian to make life decisions for her, and an Indian DCFS that appears to have ignored significant details of Lexi’s reactions just so they can maintain that they are all powerful in these cases.

      This isn’t as much about the Pages for me as it’s about a total lack of a neutral advocate for this child. Had the tribe come and seen her at her home, after her visits and reported all details from the social worker to the court, I’d feel much better that all diligence was done. Instead I feel like the outcome was a decided before the due diligence was done, and all that due diligence was for show. That’s sad when a child’s life is at stake. Maybe the decision would have been the same, but we will never know now.

    • https://turtletalk.wordpress.com/2016/03/23/indian-country-statements-and-some-law-regarding-the-california-icwa-case/

      Here’s the docs, it’s pretty clear to see who’s in the wrong here and who unnecessarily prolonged this case after repeated failed appeals.

    • Children are very resilient and with the right support yes I believe that child could have been happily enjoying her siblings, even after the trauma she endured in California before the reunification, I also support their decision to cut contact with the foster family, for the child’s sake, exposing her to their dramatics and all the chaos they created is definitely not in her best interest at this time, they should have stuck to the transition plan if they truly cared about this child’s wellbeing in the least.

  5. Star says:

    I am glad Lexi is freed from this pseudo traumatic experience Hey, Page family heal yourselves and stop exploiting this child and community with your self-created drama. Monster, heal thy self!

  6. Thank you, Amber Monaghan!!! Voice of truth, reason, and sanity! <3

  7. Jacquelynn says:

    Timely discussion ! I am thankful for the specifics – Does anyone know where I would be able to find a sample CG 20 37 version to work with ?

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
Loading...
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Tuesday, Jan 16, 2018
SCV Veteran Center Finds Permanent Home
The Santa Clarita Valley Veteran Center has found a permanent home in Newhall.
Tuesday, Jan 16, 2018
Becerra, State AGs Press Congress to Let Cannabis Biz Use Banks
SACRAMENTO – Attorney General Xavier Becerra joined a bipartisan group of 18 state attorneys general Tuesday in urging Congress to advance legislation that will enable the cannabis industry to participate in the banking system in states that have legalized medicinal or adult use of cannabis.
Tuesday, Jan 16, 2018
Brian P. Kelly Named New High-Speed Rail Authority CEO
SACRAMENTO, Calif. - As the California High-Speed Rail Authority continues to move from the planning phase to full construction of the nation’s first high-speed rail system, the Board of Directors announced Tuesday that it has selected a new Chief Executive Officer, Brian P. Kelly, to lead the organization, effective Feb. 1.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1994, 4:31 a.m. - Magnitude 6.7 Northridge earthquake rocks Santa Clarita Valley [video]
LOS ANGELES - More than 4,000 newborns in Los Angeles, including some in the Santa Clarita Valley, will be sporting little red caps, instead of the traditional pink or blue, as part of the American Heart Association’s Little Hats, Big Hearts program aimed at bringing attention to heart disease, the number one killer of Americans, and congenital heart defects, the most common type of birth defect in the country.
Newborns to Sport Little Red Caps as Part of AHA Campaign
College of the Canyons Small Business Development Center (SBDC) will be hosting a two-part Business Events and Training Webinar Jan. 24 (Part 1) and Jan. 31 (Part 2) from 12:00 p.m. - 1:00 p.m.
Jan. 24, 31: Start, Grow Your E-Commerce Empire Webinar
The Santa Clarita Valley Veteran Center has found a permanent home in Newhall.
SCV Veteran Center Finds Permanent Home
The California Enterprise Development Authority will be holding a Teleconference Meeting Thursday at 10:30 a.m.
Jan. 18: CEDA Teleconference Meeting
The Oversight Board to the Former Redevelopment Agency of the city of Santa Clarita will hold its Regular Meeting Thursday at 3:30 p.m.
Jan. 18: Oversight Board to the Former Redevelopment Agency Regular Meeting
NORTHRIDGE, Calif - The 2018 CSUN Water Polo season presents the opportunity for the Matadors to take the next step.
Matadors Start 2018 Water Polo Season Ranked No. 21
Santa Clarita Valley International (SCVi), a free public charter school serving grades TK through 12, will host an informational session Thursday for current and prospective high school students in the school’s Shakespeare Theatre at 28060 Hasley Canyon Road in Castaic, the school announced Tuesday.
Jan. 18: SCVi Open House, High School Information Session
Commercials, television shows, and a short film are all being filmed in Santa Clarita this week.
Currently Filming in SCV: Shadow Wolves, Seal Team, Toyota Commercial
SACRAMENTO – Attorney General Xavier Becerra joined a bipartisan group of 18 state attorneys general Tuesday in urging Congress to advance legislation that will enable the cannabis industry to participate in the banking system in states that have legalized medicinal or adult use of cannabis.
Becerra, State AGs Press Congress to Let Cannabis Biz Use Banks
The 25th Anniversary of the City of Santa Clarita’s annual Cowboy Festival, presented by Heritage Sierra Medical Group, is set for Apr. 19 - Apr. 22.
Dates Set for Cowboy Festival’s 25th Anniversary
College of the Canyons, in partnership with the Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center, will host a free “Family Caregivers Essentials” workshop on Saturday, Jan. 27 at the Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center.
Jan. 27: Family Caregiver Workshop at SCV Senior Center
SACRAMENTO, Calif. - As the California High-Speed Rail Authority continues to move from the planning phase to full construction of the nation’s first high-speed rail system, the Board of Directors announced Tuesday that it has selected a new Chief Executive Officer, Brian P. Kelly, to lead the organization, effective Feb. 1.
Brian P. Kelly Named New High-Speed Rail Authority CEO
During her first 25 years in the Santa Clarita Valley, Betty served on the board of the Child and Family Center. She was also a volunteer for the American Red Cross, the American Heart Association, the SCV Chamber of Commerce, the Zonta Club of SCV, the SCV Boys and Girls Club, and the local Elks Lodge.
Seldner, 2000 SCV Woman of the Year, Dies at 94
1926 - Newhall Community Hospital, est. 1922, opens in larger, more modern hospital building at 6th & Spruce streets [story]
The cities of Santa Clarita, Piru, Fillmore, Bardsdale and Santa Paula along with National Historic Site Rancho Camulos will mark the 90th anniversary of the St. Francis Dam Disaster with special events throughout March 2018.
St. Francis Dam Disaster 90th Anniversary Events Set for March
A man arrested for allegedly burglarizing a Walmart Monday morning posted bail, then was soon arrested again for allegedly vandalizing the Valencia Library, according to officials.
Man Arrested After Alleged Walmart Burglary, Library Vandalism
The minimum wage in the city of Santa Clarita for all industries is $11 an hour for businesses with 26 or more employees and $10.50 an hour for businesses with 25 or fewer employees, effective January 1.
Santa Clarita Hourly Minimum Wage Now $10.50-$11
Princess Cruises has unveiled the 2018 programming to be featured at the Valencia, California-based cruise line's custom designed wilderness treehouse at Mt. McKinley Princess Wilderness Lodge.
Princess Cruises Invites Guests to Play in the Trees This Summer
The Master's University women's basketball coach netted a 78-50 win over San Diego Christian at Grossmont College.
Tough Mustangs Take Out Hawks 78-50
Returning on Saturday after a 91-69 win over San Diego Christian, The Master's University men's basketball team found itself in a markedly better position than it was at this time last season.
Mustangs Beat San Diego Christian, Win 17th Straight
College of the Canyons sophomore volleyball player Emily Burns has signed a National Letter of Intent with San Diego State University, after she earned conference Player of the Year and All-State team honors and led the Cougars to the CCCAA State Championship tournament.
Emily Burns Signs with San Diego State University
Saugus High School senior Jacqueline Cascione is the top pick for the 2018 Foothill League cross country season, according to Brando's Blog, compiled by Santa Clarita Valley athlete-journalist Brandon Jauregui.
Cascione Tops 2018 Foothill Girls’ Cross-Country Pre-Season Picks
Federal immigration authorities have quietly resumed accepting requests to renew deferred action under DACA as a result of a preliminary injunction issued last week by a federal judge, according to California's Attorney General.
Feds Resume Accepting DACA Renewal Requests After Injunction
College of the Canyons will host "College2Career Day" at the Valencia campus on Saturday, January 27 from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. to give students of all ages the opportunity to explore college and career opportunities in promising industry clusters.
Jan. 27: College2Career Day at COC Valencia Campus
Starting Monday, February 5, parking on both the Valencia and Canyon Country campuses of College of the Canyons will not require a parking permit or pass after 2 p.m.
Starting Feb. 5: Free Student Parking at COC Campuses After 2 p.m.
The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department will provide resources to assist current mudslide recovery and clean-up efforts in Santa Barbara County January 16 through January 22 as part of a mutual aid request from the California Governor’s Office of Emergency Services.
LASD to Aid with Mudslide Operations in Santa Barbara County
The four leading Democratic candidates agreed Saturday that President Donald Trump is a racist, while the top two Republican candidates defended Trump’s immigration policies but did not comment on his now-infamous language.
California Governor Candidates Tee Off — on One Another
The Sheriff's Department's VIDA program for young people ages 11-17 is now accepting applications for the SCV Sheriff Station's next 16-week session starting in February.
Applications Now Open for Sheriff Department’s Next VIDA Session
Deputies from the SCV Sheriff's Station spotted an illegal encampment in a Canyon Country wash Thursday morning and arrested a man on drug charges and an outstanding warrant, according to a post Sunday on the station's social media.
Deputies Spot Illegal Encampment, Arrest Man on Warrant, Drug Charges
Special Victims Bureau detectives from the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station are looking for a suspect in an alleged sexual assault in a public restroom in Saugus Friday afternoon.
Suspect Sought in Alleged Sexual Assault at Saugus Park
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station deputies arrested two local men for driving under the influence in separate early-morning incidents over the weekend.
Weekend Update: SCV Deputies Arrest 2 for DUI
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station Special Assignment Team deputies arrested three people in Canyon Country last week on drug charges, with one arrestee also the subject of an outstanding no-bail arrest warrant, according to a post on the station's official social media.
SCV SAT Deputies Arrest 3 on Drug Charges, Outstanding Warrant
1875 - Henry Mayo Newhall buys western half of the Santa Clarita Valley for $2 an acre [story]
1978 - Banker Sara Faye Wood installed as president (chair) of SCV Chamber of Commerce [story]
1847 - Gen. Andres Pico (as in Pico Canyon) surrenders to Col. John C. Fremont, effectively ending the war between U.S. and Mexico [story]