[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
67°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
September 22
1969 - College of the Canyons opens with first class of students in temporary quarters at Hart High School [story]


Commentary by Max S. Duran
| Tuesday, Jul 11, 2017

For those who don’t know me, my name is Max Duran. I once held the position of trustee for the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District (AADUSD). Prior to that, I was a senior project manager, responsible for the construction of new schools and the modernization of existing schools for the Los Angeles Unified School District. I also held the position of school facilities planner and at one time I was a certified Division of State Architect (DSA) construction inspector.

After my retirement, I consulted with many school districts wishing to navigate the Department of Education’s cumbersome regulations on school construction. Until recently, I was a member of the county’s Facilities Network Committee.

Recently, the Agua Dulce-Acton Country Journal reported that the AADUSD board of trustees was attempting to reopen Acton Elementary. The article gave the impression that our school district was being hampered by DSA.

On the surface, one can make a case against DSA, but in reality, the role of DSA is to insure that all school districts provide students, teachers and to a lesser degree, parents, with a safe environment while at a publicly funded school.

During my tenure with the AADUSD, there were occasions when the district sought the easy way out and bypassed DSA’s inspection on several projects. It was always a challenge to encourage others to see the benefits of installing items per code. In the long run, it became easier and cheaper to label me as an obstructionist.

At one point, the board had considered reopening Acton Elementary School. As a former school facilities planner, I volunteered to conduct a survey of the school.

Ron Byrd and I visited the entire campus, including the outside spaces. We compiled a comprehensive report that modernized the school, which included making the site American with Disabilities Act compliant, repair or replacement of HVAC units, boiler and water heater upgrades. The report included a cost estimate and a timeline for completion.

At the end of my term, the new board had commissioned a consultant to perform the same task. We submitted our report to the consultant and the district superintendent, along with a cost estimate and photos. We never saw the consultant’s report, but I was told the school district paid $50,000. Our report had been done pro bono. Both reports went dormant and no action was ever taken.

A short time later, the board purchased several portable classrooms “on the cheap” and was applauded for its effort.

I bring up this story to remind the reader that all portables are not alike. During the class size reduction program, the California Department of Education allowed districts to place K-3 students in classrooms that were less than the traditional 960 square feet in size. Students enrolled in this program were loaded into classrooms of 20 students (or fewer) to 1 teacher. At the time, the loading standards (number of students housed in a classroom) were 35 square feet per student. Simple math tells us that for 20 students, times 35 square feet per student, a classroom size could be as small as 700 square feet.

At the time of the board’s purchase, the state had terminated this program due to lack of funding, and many districts were unloading portables. Our board acquired several buildings and placed them at Vasquez High.

Just before that school reopened, Vasquez held an open house. I visited the school and saw 30 desks crammed inside these classrooms (remember, the rule was 20 to 1 for K-3 students). Immediately, I wrote a letter to the then-superintendent, informing him of this fire- and life-safety hazard.

My warning fell on deaf ears. I never received a response. The students were placed inside these classrooms like sardines. I shudder to think of what could have happened if there had been a fire or earthquake.

The Country Journal has reported that the school board is reopening Acton School. The article quoted Mr. Tegtmeyer of TDM Architects Inc.: “DSA wants one project for all the required work. We (on the contrary) want to do the work in phases so (we) can take advantage of DSA guidelines – in order to break it down to make it more manageable so that we don’t need upgrading disabilities work when just fixing air conditioning.”

If the contract involved “fixing” air conditioning units, then this project might be exempt, assuming the new units weighed the same or less; otherwise the roof framing would have to be recalculated by a structural engineer.

DSA spells out a list of projects that are exempt from DSA’s approval; repairing air-conditioning units is one of them. A list of exempt projects can be found in DSA’s IR A-10.

But one need only do a “drive by” down Crown Valley Road to see the extent of the work being done. The board has removed from use one of the most valuable classrooms of this school: the kindergarten classroom. Remember, this classroom is a whopping 1,950 square feet. It contains a boys’ and girls’ restroom, one or two wash-sinks, extra cabinetry and a large storage room for supplies. No other classroom has its own separate playground space. The only other classroom that compares itself in cost would be a special education classroom which could include a tub and shower.

Why is this important information? Because the board approved the transformation of the kindergarten, along with its playground space and converted into office space and parking lot. All of this for the sake of a new board room – thereby devaluating the cost of that school. Also, had the town sought to declare Acton school a “historic site,” this modernization project just negated that possibility.

While many costs associated with this modernization project remain hidden from public view, it has been estimated the total cost of the project (excluding ADA requirements, because there aren’t any) exceeded $2 million – a far cry from fixing a few air conditioners. It’s no wonder DSA wants to review the total scope of work.

Also, the district’s architect has ignored complying with the ADA regulation. This failure could result in penalties being levied against the district, or civil lawsuits against individual board members. As a handicapped person, I appreciate the value of facilities with the ease to access to my destination.

Another observation was that “Acton currently has an old fire alarm system that works, but DSA want an automatic system.” And why not? Schools in California with new or modernized project exceeding $200,000 are required to have both automatic sprinklers and a fire alarm system that are connected to a supervising station.

In years past, a neighbor or a passerby would call the Fire Department if they heard the water gong or the fire horn activated at the school. Now, any fire alarm or sprinkler activation requires an automatic transmission to a remote supervising station, thereby notifying the Fire Station.

The comment was made that “the delay is now from DSA. Someone turned in the district.” Comments like that are inflammatory. All it does is ratchet up the rhetoric and place the district in an adversarial role with DSA.

Mr. Tegtmeyer reminds the board that the former inspector died and that another inspector would need to come on board and “start again,” whatever that means. Mr. Tegtmeyer should know that during the course of a project, a DSA inspector will often go on vacation, become ill or be reassigned. Most inspectors adapt to these circumstances. As a former inspector, I would mark up my set of working drawings with notes indicating the progress made or annotate any change orders that occurred during the course of the project. Most new inspectors would look at my drawings and familiarize themselves quickly with the project.

Finally, another board member played the “guilt card” by stating: “It’s the parents, teachers and students who will pay. The additional money is robbed from the classroom to pay for fees to the state and for contractors.” Comments like that attempt to blame others for their lack of planning.

In their attempt to usurp DSA’s role, the school board fragmented the project in order to deceive DSA. The board forgot that there are well over 1,050 school districts in this state, and all too often, many of them try to take the easy approach.

Instead, the board should learn to plan properly before committing to venture into a project. Otherwise the change orders alone will eat up any savings.

 

Max S. Duran is an Acton resident.

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

6 Comments

  1. Ken Pfalzgraf Board Candidate

  2. Janet Klein Janet Klein says:

    Just thought you should know what is happening with your school district@Cheryl Klein

  3. “Taking the easy way out” means more money for the administrators at the DO, doesn’t it?

  4. Ken Pfalzgraf says:

    As we see in Max’s piece, this is about trying to fix something that’s been going on for a decade. Without going into detail, the district is certainly on a compliace track with DSA now, with Vasquez High School being a recent example of a fully permitted, inspected and signed off project. There’s a bit on this issue and Max’s editorial starting at the 1 minute mark of this Youtube video. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=8yc8hvdlAwk

  5. Mike Rowe Mike Rowe says:

    That’s good old AADUSD for you. Always wasting money and time.

  6. Dawna Kennedy says:

    The board has been corrupt and self serving for many years. Although many residents such as myself have tried to fight for what’s right, we really lack the means and knowledge necessary to sway the vote. How can we get organized and make a concerted effort toward change?

Leave a Comment


Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
RECENT COMMENTARY
Thursday, Sep 21, 2017
Now that the formerly great state of California is a sanctuary, I’ve got to compare that action with the actions in the early 1860s of the Confederate States of America. They decided what laws they wanted to follow and what ones they didn’t.
Thursday, Sep 21, 2017
Hans' family did not know too much about his childhood or the country he had grown up in. About all the family knew was that Hans and his wife were born in Germany but had lived in this small Minnesota town for the last 60 years or more.
Thursday, Sep 21, 2017
There is a common insect that most people are not aware of because you never see it. It is mostly active underground. However, if you know what you are looking for, its traps are in many places and are very obvious.
Saturday, Sep 16, 2017
While not perfect, SB 54 kept intact our ability to maintain partnerships with federal law enforcement officials who help us in the fight against gangs, drugs and human trafficking. It also retains the controlled access that the United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement has to our jails.
Thursday, Sep 7, 2017
Local residents have the right to record things their congressional leaders and legislative staff members say to residents of the 25th District and any of Rep. Knight's town hall meetings and legislative decisions.
Tuesday, Sep 5, 2017
Speaking with one of our Santa Clarita sheriff’s deputies recently, he was telling me about the hardest part of his job.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Gatorade made misleading “anti-water statements” while pushing the benefits of its sports drinks in a video game marketed to teenagers, according to a settlement announced Thursday by California’s attorney general.
California Fines Gatorade $300K for ‘Anti-Water’ Ad Campaign
John Gasparyan, an off-duty Los Angeles Police Department officer and Canyon Country resident, died when his motorcycle crashed in Porter Ranch around 6:50 p.m. Thursday.
LAPD Officer from Canyon Country Dead in Motorcycle Crash
1969 - College of the Canyons opens with first class of students in temporary quarters at Hart High School [story]
The most prestigious recognition for government assessment agencies has been awarded to the Office of the Assessor in Los Angeles County.
County Awarded Prestigious Government Assessment Award
The Dodgers, who have clinched a postseason berth for the fifth consecutive year, return home tomorrow to open their final homestand of the regular season against the San Francisco Giants (Sept. 22-24) and San Diego Padres (Sept. 25-27).
Dodgers Back Home Friday; Last Homestand of 2017 Season
Auditions for the the upcoming Canyon Theater Guild's production of A Christmas Story are just around the corner.
Sept. 30-Oct. 1: Christmas Story Auditions at CTG
Now that the formerly great state of California is a sanctuary, I’ve got to compare that action with the actions in the early 1860s of the Confederate States of America. They decided what laws they wanted to follow and what ones they didn’t.
No Home for Me | Commentary by Darryl Manzer
Santa Clarita Valley residents have known the family-owned Italian restaurant, Sisley Kitchen, since 1993 when their doors first opened at the top of Valencia Town Center Drive in Westfield Valencia.
Renovations Complete at Sisley Kitchen
The Women's Soccer team will be finishing up their non-conference matches this weekend.
Sept. 22-24: CSUN Athletics Roundup
David Wolfram will demonstrate pastel-over-watercolor painting at the Santa Clarita Artists Association (SCAA) meeting on Monday evening, Nov. 20 at 6:30 pm. This event is free, open to the public and meets at Barnes & Noble, 23630 Valencia Blvd.
Nov. 20: Pastel-Over-Watercolor Demonstration at SCAA Meeting
Beginning October 1, all 23 California State University (CSU) campuses will accept applications for admission to the fall 2018 term.
Oct. 1: CSU Accepting Fall 2018 Applications
College of the Canyons launched its First-Year Promise (FYP) program this fall, and to ensure the future of the FYP program, which offers full-time freshman students waived tuition and fees during their first year of study, the COC Foundation has committed to fundraising $500,000 over the next two years
COC First-Year Promise Fundraising Campaign Underway
The city of Santa Clarita is inviting our younger residents to take part in the 30th anniversary celebration.
City Launches, “30 Things for 30 Years” Contest, Students Invited to Take Part
California State University, Northridge’s Friends of the Oviatt Library welcomes members of the community to nominate their favorite stories about the San Fernando Valley for consideration of the San Fernando Valley Award for Non-Fiction.
CSUN Library Group Invites Community to Nominate Favorite San Fernando Valley Story
The Los Angeles Dodgers today announced sellouts for all seven potential postseason home games in the Division Series and League Championship Series just hours after tickets went on sale to the public at 10:00 a.m. It’s believed to be the quickest that the club has sold out of postseason tickets in Dodger Stadium history.
Dodgers NLDS, NLCS Tickets Already Sold Out
Sales of existing single-family homes increased 7.4 percent throughout Santa Clarita during August while the median price of homes that changed owners rose 6.6 percent, the Southland Regional Association of REALTORS® reported today.
Increase in SCV August Home Sales, Prices
Mountainview Elementary School parents were greeted with a voicemail Thursday morning informing them of a break-in on campus believed to have occurred the night before.
Vandals Trash Library, Computers, Classrooms at Mountainview
Hans' family did not know too much about his childhood or the country he had grown up in. About all the family knew was that Hans and his wife were born in Germany but had lived in this small Minnesota town for the last 60 years or more.
Lesson from History | Commentary by John Windsor
A gang sweep targeting Newhall 13, a well known Santa Clarita criminal organization, netted three arrests Thursday.
Three Arrests Made in Newhall 13 Gang Sweep
The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department is proud to announce the launch of our new LASD Facebook Español.
LASD Facebook Español Now Online
Autumn Gratitude, Santa Clarita Artists Association's new show will be open on Sept 28th and run to November 4th, with a free artists’ reception on Friday October 6th, 5 to 9 pm.
SCAA’s Newest Show, “Autumn Gratitude,” Opens
September is for seniors. Businesses around Santa Clarita are taking part in the following SCV Senior Center New Building Campaign events and asking the community to show support.
SCV Businesses Holding End-of-Month Events to Support New Senior Center
Kaiser Permanente Panorama City Medical Center will kick-off its no-cost flu shot clinics this Saturday, September 23, 2017 in the Atrium of Medical Offices 2 from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Kaiser Permanente to Hold Flu Shot Clinics Saturday
Starting September 23, Santa Clarita residents can get a flu shot at no cost — no appointment needed.
Sept. 23: SCV Flu Shots
The College of the Canyons Athletics department is inviting all staff and students associated with a Santa Clarita Valley school district or campus to attend Saturday's Cougar football game free of charge.
Sept. 23: COC Football Game Free to SCV School District Staff, Students
There is a common insect that most people are not aware of because you never see it. It is mostly active underground. However, if you know what you are looking for, its traps are in many places and are very obvious.
You Won’t See Them | Commentary by Evelyne Vandersande
1974 - COC's new Cougar Stadium opens for first game of football season; Harbor beats COC, 26-21 [story]
A “fabulist” coming-of-age novel about a queer mixed-race boy in the bayous of Louisiana, written by California State University, Northridge English professor Martin Pousson, has won the 2017 PEN Center USA Fiction Award.
CSUN’s Martin Pousson Wins PEN’s Literary Award for Fiction
Public notification that the Santa Clarita Community College District (College of the Canyons) Early Childhood Education Center on the Valencia campus is participating in the USDA Child and Adult Care Food Program.
COC Valencia Participates in USDA Child and Adult Care Food Program
Public notification that the Santa Clarita Community College District (College of the Canyons) Early Childhood Education Centers are participating in the United States Department of Agriculture’s Child and Adult Care Food Program.
COC Canyon Country Participates in USDA Child and Adult Care Food Program
The Santa Clarita Valley Service Center has moved from its previous location in Newhall to a new location in the Santa Clarita Plaza, and will host a grand opening celebration Thursday from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Sept. 21: SCV Service Center Grand Opening, Resource Fair
The Los Angeles County Fire Department’s Urban Search and Rescue Team, known internationally as USA-2, has been deployed to Mexico to assist with the aftermath of a 7.1 magnitude earthquake near Mexico City.
L.A. County Fire Sends Search and Rescue Team to Mexico
The city of Santa Clarita invites nonprofit organizations interested in learning more about the city's 2018 Community Services and Arts Grants Program to a meeting on Wednesday, September 27 at 12 p.m.
Sept. 27: Info Session for Nonprofits Seeking City Grants
The Santa Clarita Valley Economic Development Corporation has published an ebook free to entrepreneurs titled '10 Characteristics of a Successful Startup.'
SCVEDC’s 10 Characteristics of a Successful Startup