[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Cloudy
Cloudy
52°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
May 23
1941 - SCV's first real movie house, the American Theater, dedicated in Newhall [story]


By Martin Macias Jr.

SAN FRANCISCO – A Ninth Circuit panel on Tuesday affirmed a federal judge’s order preliminarily barring California from enforcing a voter-approved ban on high-capacity gun magazines.

In Duncan v. Becerra, U.S. District Judge Roger Benitez temporarily blocked a portion of Proposition 63 that prohibits possession of magazines holding more than 10 rounds of ammunition.

The issue is set to go to trial this fall.

California Attorney General Xavier Becerra appealed to the Ninth Circuit, arguing Benitez abused his discretion in granting the injunction in favor of Virginia Duncan and the California Rifle & Pistol Association.

But in an 8-page unpublished memorandum issued Tuesday, U.S. Circuit Judge Norman Smith and U.S. District Judge Deborah Batts of the Southern District of New York ruled Benitez used the correct level of scrutiny to decide the preliminary injunction.

“The district court did not abuse its discretion by concluding that magazines for a weapon likely fall within the scope of the Second Amendment,” the judges said, adding that Becerra hadn’t pointed to any errors made by Benitez.

“[Becerra’s argument] is insufficient to establish that the district court’s findings of fact and its application of the legal standard to those facts were “illogical, implausible, or without support in inferences that may be drawn from facts in the record,” the majority held.

In his June 2017 order, Benitez said gun owners’ “entitlement to enjoy Second Amendment rights and just compensation is not eliminated simply because they possess ‘unpopular’ magazines holding more than 10 rounds.”

In his dissent, U.S. Circuit Judge John Wallace said a “reasonable fit” between gun owners’ rights and Proposition 63 can be accommodated if the state can show it does not challenge or burden core elements of the Second Amendment.

Wallace disagreed with his colleagues’ “judgment calls” on evidence submitted by the state in the case.

“California’s evidence – which included statistical studies, expert testimony, and surveys of mass shootings showing that the use of large-capacity magazines increases the lethality of gun violence – was more than sufficient to satisfy intermediate scrutiny,” Wallace wrote.

Wallace said the September 2013 Mayors Against Illegal Guns Survey, which Benitez wrote off as “inconclusive and irrelevant,” satisfied the requirement for relevant evidence.

The survey shows that assault weapons or large-capacity magazines were used in at least 15 percent of the mass shootings reported, and that in those incidents 151 percent more people were shot – and 63 percent more people died – than in other mass shootings the researchers looked at.

Wallace said he would have reversed Benitez’s injunction, though he did credit the judge for “ensuring the case did not stall awaiting disposition of this appeal.”

Plaintiff attorney Chuck Michel with Michel Associates said his clients are “thrilled” with the court’s ruling. He said gun owners hope they won’t be “turned into criminals” by state laws that ban what they’ve possessed legally for years.

“These standard capacity magazines are overwhelmingly chosen by law-abiding citizens for sport or to protect their families,” Michel said.

In a statement, the California Rifle & Pistol Association – which joined as a plaintiff in the case – called the ruling a blow to Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom’s “anti-gun agenda.” Newsom is also the front-runner to be California’s next governor.

The gun-rights advocacy group questioned the merits of Becerra’s appeal, pointing to a motion for summary judgment which Benitez has yet to decide. A ruling on the merits of the case is also expected later this year.

“Regardless of the outcome, the case will most certainly be appealed again to the Ninth Circuit,” the group said. “But by that time, the Supreme Court will likely have a new justice who respects the right to keep and bear arms as protected by the Second Amendment.”

In an emailed statement to Courthouse News, the California Department of Justice it is reviewing the court’s opinion and “will continue to vigorously defend the challenged law.”

Magazines holding more than 10 rounds have been banned in California since 2000, but a previously intact grandfather clause allowed lawful owners who purchased high-capacity magazines before the law to keep them. Proposition 63, passed by 63 percent of voters in 2016, eliminated the grandfather clause.

A section of Proposition 63 required owners of guns with high-capacity magazines to surrender lawfully purchased property or face criminal prosecution. The ban was to take effect on July 1, 2017.

No government buyback was included in the law. The plaintiffs say some gun owners could lose thousands of dollars in magazines – amounting to an unlawful taking, they say.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

5 Comments

  1. Tom Duran Tom Duran says:

    Who supports the mag ban?

  2. Kurt Buck Kurt Buck says:

    The ninth circuit finally got something right!

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Wednesday, May 22, 2019
Prostitution Sting Leads to 7 Arrests in Valencia
Seven adults were arrested at a Valencia hotel Tuesday during an operation conducted by the Los Angeles Regional Human Trafficking Taskforce and deputies from the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station, authorities reported Wednesday afternoon.
Wednesday, May 22, 2019
Newsom Forms Homeless, Housing Task Force Headed by Ridley-Thomas, Steinberg
California Governor Gavin Newsom on Tuesday announced the formation of the Homeless and Supportive Housing Advisory Task Force and its co-chairs, Los Angeles County Supervisor Mark Ridley-Thomas and Sacramento Mayor Darrell Steinberg.
Wednesday, May 22, 2019
Wilk Hemp Bill Clears California Senate, Heads to Assembly
The California Senate has approved Senate Bill 153, which would ensure California law is in full compliance with changes to federal law regarding the cultivation of industrial hemp, Senator Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, who introduced the bill, announced Wednesday.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1941 - SCV's first real movie house, the American Theater, dedicated in Newhall [story]
Emmy Award-winning broadcast journalist Elizabeth Espinosa is the newest partner with the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Communications team, Sheriff Alex Villanueva announced Wednesday.
Emmy-Winner Espinosa Joins LA County Sheriff’s Communications Team
Seven adults were arrested at a Valencia hotel Tuesday during an operation conducted by the Los Angeles Regional Human Trafficking Taskforce and deputies from the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station, authorities reported Wednesday afternoon.
Prostitution Sting Leads to 7 Arrests in Valencia
California Governor Gavin Newsom on Tuesday announced the formation of the Homeless and Supportive Housing Advisory Task Force and its co-chairs, Los Angeles County Supervisor Mark Ridley-Thomas and Sacramento Mayor Darrell Steinberg.
Newsom Forms Homeless, Housing Task Force Headed by Ridley-Thomas, Steinberg
Lief Labs, a premier formulation and product development innovator and manufacturer of dietary supplements, hosted a field trip for approximately 80 10th, 11th and 12th-grade students from San Fernando Valley High School on Friday, May 17.
Lief Labs Hosts Students Prepping for Careers in Biotech, Health Science, Medical Tech
At its monthly meeting on Tuesday, the Civilian Oversight Commission for the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department covered several topics including further review of LASD's Internal Administrative Investigations, a presentation on the Mental Evaluation Teams, and the approval of the Immigration Ad Hoc Committee Report.
Oversight Panel Reviews LASD Internal Probes, ICE Cooperation
The Lancaster JetHawks played for the first time since in four days Tuesday night, hanging on to edge the Inland Empire 66ers 2-1 at San Manuel Stadium.
Lancaster JetHawks Return to Action, Edge Inland Empire 66ers
Zoey White was four classes away from completing her animation degree at College of the Canyons when she decided to switch gears to study automotive technology instead.
COC Student Shifts Gears, Speeds Toward Auto Tech Career
The California Senate has approved Senate Bill 153, which would ensure California law is in full compliance with changes to federal law regarding the cultivation of industrial hemp, Senator Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, who introduced the bill, announced Wednesday.
Wilk Hemp Bill Clears California Senate, Heads to Assembly
Los Angeles County District Attorney Jackie Lacey's Conviction Review Unit has expanded its criteria for cases eligible for evaluation to include any felony conviction in which the defendant remains in custody, the DA's office said Wednesday.
LA County DA Expands Conviction Review Criteria
The SCV Veterans Memorial Committee and Eternal Valley Memorial Park and Mortuary will present Santa Clarita’s annual Memorial Day Tribute at the park in Newhall on Monday, May 27, starting at 10 a.m.
May 27: Annual Memorial Day Tribute to Veterans at Eternal Valley
Eternal Valley Memorial Park is inviting members of Santa Clarita Valley scout troops and packs, community volunteer groups and individual volunteers to place flags on veterans' graves on Saturday, May 25, in preparation for the Newhall park's annual Memorial Day Tribute on Monday, May 27.
May 25: Call for Volunteers to Place Flags on Veterans’ Graves
Los Angeles County supervisors, citing the same number of worrisome scientific studies that convinced them in March to place a 30-day ban on the use of glyphosate, have banned the controversial herbicide from being used by county work crews anywhere in the county.
Supes Nix Use of Glyphosphate Herbicide by LA County Departments
More than two dozen people had the opportunity Tuesday to tour the proposed Sand Canyon Resort project site, with the majority voicing concerns over open-space preservation.
Visitors to Proposed Sand Canyon Resort Site Voice Concern Over Open Space
The city of Santa Clarita is now accepting names to be included as part of the 2019 additions to the Youth Grove in Central Park, with a due date of June 30 for nominations.
June 30: Central Park Youth Grove Nominations Due
More residents died from air pollution in Los Angeles County in 2017 than in any other U.S. county, according to a new study released Wednesday, but nationally, the number of deaths and illnesses caused by smog has fallen dramatically in the last decade.
Better Air Quality Has Saved Thousands of Lives, Study Finds
From Memorial Day weekend through Labor Day weekend, the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department will have additional officers on patrol looking for drivers suspected of driving under the influence of alcohol and/or drugs.
Sheriff’s Deputies to Kick Off Summer with Holiday DUI Enforcement
COBRA detectives from the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station reported Tuesday night that an estranged husband who allegedly kidnapped his wife from a Canyon Country location on April 9 is now in custody.
LAPD Arrests Canyon Country Kidnapping Suspect in SFV
The California Senate has approved Senate Bill 387, which would streamline how SCV Water Agency Board of Directors vacancies are to be handled, and the legislation will now go to the state Assembly for consideration.
Wilk SCV Water Board Bill Passes Senate, Heads to Assembly
Los Angeles County Sheriff's deputies will take part in a bicycle and pedestrian safety enforcement operation in the city of Santa Clarita on Monday, May 27, between 5 a.m. and 3 p.m.
May 27: ‘Heads Up’ Bike, Pedestrian Safety Push in SCV
A body tasked with oversight of the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department said Tuesday that it may subpoena Sheriff Alex Villanueva for documents regarding his decision to halt investigations into officer misconduct.
Watchdog May Subpoena LA Sheriff Over Closed Officer Probes
The San Gabriel Mountains Community Collaborative will hold a meeting at the Altadena Community Center on Thursday, May 23, from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m.
May 23: San Gabriel Mountains Community Collaborative Meeting
1865 - Discoverer Ramon Perea and partner sell Pico Canyon oil claim to Edward Beale & Robert Baker for $300 [story]
grave marker
SAN MATEO — Freshman thrower Jordan Palmer finished runner-up in the shot put and Delon Buncio placed fourth in the long jump as College of the Canyons track & field closed out its season by competing at CCCAA State Championship meet hosted by the College of San Mateo May 17-18.
COC Freshman Thrower Finishes Runner-Up at State Championships
NORTHRIDGE - With the programs' most qualifiers since 2017, the CSUN men's and women's track and field teams are getting ready to compete in the 2019 NCAA Division I West Regional this weekend at Sacramento State.
Matadors Track Team Heads to Sacramento for West Regionals
As part of ongoing efforts to provide the public and university stakeholders with additional access to financial information, the California State University has launched a new financial transparency portal.
CSU Launches Transparency Portal to Provide Additional Financial Access
On April 24, millions of people across the world celebrated Denim Day and wore denim to show their support for education and awareness about all forms of sexual violence.
Art Piece Inspired by Denim Day on Display at City Hall
Hart High School’s Regiment Band will be holding its annual Spring Concert Tuesday, May 21, at 7:00 p.m. in the Hart High School Auditorium.
May 21: Hart High School’s Annual Spring Concert
U.S. Air Force Airman Matthew G. Hernandez graduated from basic military training at Joint Base San Antonio-Lackland, San Antonio, Texas.
Cornerstone Christian Alum Graduates from Air Force Basic Training
SACRAMENTO - State Sen. Scott Wilk, representing the 21st Senate District, announced Tuesday that Senate Bill 202 (SB 202) unanimously passed the Senate. SB 202 allows for the commercial use of animal blood from community-sourced donors.
Wilk’s Doggie Donor Bill Would Allow Community Animals to Donate Blood
Since Medicare pays for a significant amount of prescription opioids, we strive to ensure appropriate stewardship of these medications that can provide a medical benefit but also pose risks.
Medicare Helps Seniors Use Opioids Safely | Commentary by Greg Dill
To honor California State University, Northridge alumna Virginia Orndorff and her passion of the arts, her husband Chris Orndorff donated $218,000 to create an endowment for art student scholarships.
CSUN Gifted with $218K to Create Endowment for Art Scholarships
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station deputies are on scene at Sierra Vista Junior High investigating a report of an attack by a student, according to officials.
Deputies Respond to Report of Attack at Sierra Vista Junior High
The College of the Canyons men's and women’s soccer programs are inviting boys and girls in kindergarten through eighth grade to participate in the 2019 Youth Summer Soccer Camp, with two sessions running this summer.
Registration for COC Youth Summer Soccer Camps Now Open
SACRAMENTO – With summer around the corner, Memorial Day weekend traffic will likely increase on California roadways.
CHP Focusing on Seat Belt Usage Ahead of Memorial Day Weekend
Waste Management’s service for residential trash, recycling, and green waste pick-up, as well as commercial service will be delayed by one day throughout the week of May 27, in observance of Memorial Day.
Waste Management Delays Services by 1 Day in Observance of Memorial Day