[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
79°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
October 23
1888 - 8:15 a.m.: Newhall's luxurious Southern Hotel burns to the ground [story]


By Martin Macias Jr.

SAN FRANCISCO – A Ninth Circuit panel on Tuesday affirmed a federal judge’s order preliminarily barring California from enforcing a voter-approved ban on high-capacity gun magazines.

In Duncan v. Becerra, U.S. District Judge Roger Benitez temporarily blocked a portion of Proposition 63 that prohibits possession of magazines holding more than 10 rounds of ammunition.

The issue is set to go to trial this fall.

California Attorney General Xavier Becerra appealed to the Ninth Circuit, arguing Benitez abused his discretion in granting the injunction in favor of Virginia Duncan and the California Rifle & Pistol Association.

But in an 8-page unpublished memorandum issued Tuesday, U.S. Circuit Judge Norman Smith and U.S. District Judge Deborah Batts of the Southern District of New York ruled Benitez used the correct level of scrutiny to decide the preliminary injunction.

“The district court did not abuse its discretion by concluding that magazines for a weapon likely fall within the scope of the Second Amendment,” the judges said, adding that Becerra hadn’t pointed to any errors made by Benitez.

“[Becerra’s argument] is insufficient to establish that the district court’s findings of fact and its application of the legal standard to those facts were “illogical, implausible, or without support in inferences that may be drawn from facts in the record,” the majority held.

In his June 2017 order, Benitez said gun owners’ “entitlement to enjoy Second Amendment rights and just compensation is not eliminated simply because they possess ‘unpopular’ magazines holding more than 10 rounds.”

In his dissent, U.S. Circuit Judge John Wallace said a “reasonable fit” between gun owners’ rights and Proposition 63 can be accommodated if the state can show it does not challenge or burden core elements of the Second Amendment.

Wallace disagreed with his colleagues’ “judgment calls” on evidence submitted by the state in the case.

“California’s evidence – which included statistical studies, expert testimony, and surveys of mass shootings showing that the use of large-capacity magazines increases the lethality of gun violence – was more than sufficient to satisfy intermediate scrutiny,” Wallace wrote.

Wallace said the September 2013 Mayors Against Illegal Guns Survey, which Benitez wrote off as “inconclusive and irrelevant,” satisfied the requirement for relevant evidence.

The survey shows that assault weapons or large-capacity magazines were used in at least 15 percent of the mass shootings reported, and that in those incidents 151 percent more people were shot – and 63 percent more people died – than in other mass shootings the researchers looked at.

Wallace said he would have reversed Benitez’s injunction, though he did credit the judge for “ensuring the case did not stall awaiting disposition of this appeal.”

Plaintiff attorney Chuck Michel with Michel Associates said his clients are “thrilled” with the court’s ruling. He said gun owners hope they won’t be “turned into criminals” by state laws that ban what they’ve possessed legally for years.

“These standard capacity magazines are overwhelmingly chosen by law-abiding citizens for sport or to protect their families,” Michel said.

In a statement, the California Rifle & Pistol Association – which joined as a plaintiff in the case – called the ruling a blow to Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom’s “anti-gun agenda.” Newsom is also the front-runner to be California’s next governor.

The gun-rights advocacy group questioned the merits of Becerra’s appeal, pointing to a motion for summary judgment which Benitez has yet to decide. A ruling on the merits of the case is also expected later this year.

“Regardless of the outcome, the case will most certainly be appealed again to the Ninth Circuit,” the group said. “But by that time, the Supreme Court will likely have a new justice who respects the right to keep and bear arms as protected by the Second Amendment.”

In an emailed statement to Courthouse News, the California Department of Justice it is reviewing the court’s opinion and “will continue to vigorously defend the challenged law.”

Magazines holding more than 10 rounds have been banned in California since 2000, but a previously intact grandfather clause allowed lawful owners who purchased high-capacity magazines before the law to keep them. Proposition 63, passed by 63 percent of voters in 2016, eliminated the grandfather clause.

A section of Proposition 63 required owners of guns with high-capacity magazines to surrender lawfully purchased property or face criminal prosecution. The ban was to take effect on July 1, 2017.

No government buyback was included in the law. The plaintiffs say some gun owners could lose thousands of dollars in magazines – amounting to an unlawful taking, they say.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

5 Comments

  1. Tom Duran Tom Duran says:

    Who supports the mag ban?

  2. Kurt Buck Kurt Buck says:

    The ninth circuit finally got something right!

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Tuesday, Oct 23, 2018
Hart District Seeking New Members for Oversight Committee
The William S. Hart Union High School District needs two new members of the Measure SA Citizens’ Oversight Committee. These members will serve a two-year term with a maximum of three consecutive terms.
Monday, Oct 22, 2018
Child Airlifted from Saugus to UCLA in Medical Emergency
A Los Angeles County Fire Department helicopter flew a pediatric patient in need of emergency treatment from Saugus to UCLA Medical Center late Monday morning, according to LACoFD officials.
Monday, Oct 22, 2018
SCV Detectives Arrest Valencia Bomb Threat Suspect
A Santa Clarita woman was arrested Sunday and charged with two felonies after allegedly making bomb threats at businesses in Valencia.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
NORTHRIDGE - CSUN Women's Soccer (6-7-1, 2-4-0 BWC) dropped a heartbreaker to UC Davis in overtime by the final of 1-0 on Sunday afternoon at Matador Soccer Field.
CSUN Drops Heartbreaker to UC Davis
Oscar-winning producer Donna Gigliotti will produce the 91st Oscars, and Emmy-winning director Glenn Weiss will co-produce and direct the show, Academy President John Bailey announced Monday.
Academy Announces Producers, Director for 91st Oscars
The Cinema Legacy program at AFI Fest (Nov. 9-15) celebrates film history and features screenings of recently restored classic and lesser-known films.
Cinema Legacy AFI Fest to Include Films from CalArts Faculty
It’s fall in the SCV. Leaves are falling and the temperature is dropping, but your landscape can still thrive with proper care.
SCV Water Offering Free November Gardening Classes
The William S. Hart Union High School District needs two new members of the Measure SA Citizens’ Oversight Committee. These members will serve a two-year term with a maximum of three consecutive terms.
Hart District Seeking New Members for Oversight Committee
The Valencia High School Marching Band & Color Guard is pleased to announce the 7th Annual Pride of the Vikings Field Show Tournament on Thursday, Nov. 8, at 4:30 p.m. in Santa Clarita.
Nov. 8: Pride of the Vikings Field Show Tournament
Santa Clarita-based landscaping firm Stay Green, Inc. has been recognized in a national industry-wide competition, bringing home accolades for its ability to keep local communities green.
Local Landscape Firm Nabs 3 National Awards
The second annual “Heart to Hart” benefit concert is scheduled for Friday, Nov. 2, at 7:00 p.m. in the Hart High School Auditorium, 24825 Newhall Ave., Newhall.
Nov. 2: ‘Heart to Hart’ Concert Benefiting Children with Cancer
Six Flags Magic Mountain, the “Thrill Capital of the World,” and its sister park, Six Flags New England, have placed a friendly wager on the upcoming World Series between the Los Angeles Dodgers and Boston Red Sox.
Six Flags Magic Mountain, Six Flags New England Vie for Bragging Rights
1888 - 8:15 a.m.: Newhall's luxurious Southern Hotel burns to the ground [story]
Several recent reports list California State University, Northridge as one of the leading institutions of higher education in the United States.
New Rankings List CSUN Among Top U.S. Colleges
In celebration of its 10th anniversary at the Canyon Country campus, College of the Canyons' Center for Early Childhood Education will host an outdoor movie night and open house on Friday, Oct. 26 from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m.
Oct: 26: ‘Coco’ to Screen at COC Early Childhood Education Open House
The No. 11-ranked Mustangs beat San Diego Christian, 3-0, by scores of 25-15, 25-21 and 25-14, maintaining a two-match lead in conference standings on Saturday with four to play.
TMU Women’s Volleyball Team Sweeps San Diego at Home
The Master's University men's cross country team finished three points, and about three seconds, behind conference rival Westmont College at the Warrior Invitational in Rocklin, Calif. on Saturday.
TMU Men’s Cross Country Takes Big Step as Championship Race Looms
TMU freshman and cross-country runner Arianna Ghiorso ran a personal best 17 minutes, 58.2 seconds to finish fourth overall at the Warrior Invitational in Rocklin, Calif. on Saturday.
TMU Freshman Ghiorso Shines for Women’s Cross Country
The Mustangs women's volleyball team beat Hope (13-12, 6-7) on Friday for the second time in the last 10 days, rolling in sets one and three and playing clutch in set two.
TMU Women’s Volleyball Gets Back on Track with Win in Fullerton
A Los Angeles County Fire Department helicopter flew a pediatric patient in need of emergency treatment from Saugus to UCLA Medical Center late Monday morning, according to LACoFD officials.
Child Airlifted from Saugus to UCLA in Medical Emergency
A Santa Clarita woman was arrested Sunday and charged with two felonies after allegedly making bomb threats at businesses in Valencia.
SCV Detectives Arrest Valencia Bomb Threat Suspect
On-location filming in Greater Los Angeles rose 3 percent in the third quarter of 2018, according to the latest update from FilmL.A.
On-Location Feature Production in LA Up for 3rd Straight Quarter
Dr. John MacArthur, who will step aside as president of The Master's University in Newhall by May 2020, released a statement to students and faculty Monday.
MacArthur to Step Aside as Master’s University President
The University of Southern California agreed Friday to pay $215 million to settle a federal class action on claims a former campus gynecologist sexually abused students over several years.
USC Agrees to $215 Million Settlement in Sex-Abuse Scandal
The city of Santa Clarita has updated the list of productions shooting in the city and the Santa Clarita Valley for the week of Oct. 22-28, 2018.
‘Design Hacks,’ ‘Magnum Opus,’ ‘The Laundromat’ Now Filming in SCV
Two people were injured when their car veered off Vasquez Canyon Road in Saugus Sunday afternoon.
Crash Injures 2, Sparks Brush Fire off Vasquez Canyon Road
The Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station and Ralphs Pharmacy will partner with the Drug Enforcement Administration for a prescription drug take-back drive on Saturday, Oct. 27, from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Oct. 27: Prescription Drug Take-Back Drive at SCV Sheriff’s Station
The first annual International Charity Fraud Awareness Week is Oct. 22-28, and California Attorney General Xavier Becerra has issued some tips for consumers.
Oct. 22-28: First International Charity Fraud Awareness Week
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station deputies arrested a man on two felony firearms charges in Castaic early Friday morning.
Deputies Arrest Man in Castaic on Felony Weapons Charges
1898 - Birth of Mary S. Ruiz, eldest child of Enrique & Rosaria Ruiz of San Francisquito Canyon; all died in 1928 dam disaster [cemetery census]
Here is the Santa Clarita Valley Football Roundup for Week 9 of the 2018 season. College of the Canyons remains undefeated with a win against East LA, while Hart handed West Ranch its first defeat of the season.
Santa Clarita Valley Football Roundup
2007 - Buckweed fire chars 38,000 acres, destroys 21 homes in Canyon Country and Agua Dulce [story]
1873 - Santa Barbara lawyers Charles Fernald and J.T. Richards purchase Rancho San Francisco for $33,000 (75 cents an acre) in a sheriff's sale [story]
Santa Clarita City Councilmembers on Tuesday night will discuss how to respond to county planners' request that developers consider a homeless shelter in Phase II of the proposed Tesoro del Valle housing project just north of city limits.
Oct. 23: City to Weigh Response to County Idea for Tesoro Homeless Shelter
The annual "Fun in the Sun" Chili Cook-Off staged by the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department to benefit the Special Olympics is set for Saturday, Oct. 20 from 11 a.m to 4 p.m. at the Jack Bones Equestrian Center in Castaic.
Oct. 20: LASD ‘Fun in the Sun’ Chili Cook-Off to Benefit Special Olympics
College of the Canyons administrators alerted students and faculty Friday morning to a report of an unwanted sexual encounter Thursday in a COC restroom.
Unwanted Sexual Encounter Reported at COC
Brian O’Connor has been promoted to vice president brand and corporate communication at Santa Clarita-based Princess Cruises.
Princess Cruises Ups O’Connor to VP Brand, Corporate Communications
The Santa Clarita City Council will hold its next meetings at City Hall on Tuesday, Oct. 23.
Oct. 23: Santa Clarita City Council Regular, Special Meetings
The National Weather Service issued an urgent red flag warning at 3 p.m. Friday that will remain in effect in the Santa Clarita Valley until 10 p.m. due to gusty Santa Ana wind and low humidity.
Red Flag Warning Flies Till 10 Friday Night