[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Santa Clarita CA
Mostly clear
Mostly clear
Today in
S.C.V. History
March 20
2012 - County supervisors approve 50-year operating agreement for Placerita Canyon State Park [read]
Placerita Canyon

By Helen Christophi

SAN FRANCISCO – A divided Ninth Circuit on Thursday partly lifted a nationwide injunction barring enforcement of the Trump administration’s interim rules letting employers opt out of covering birth control on religious and moral grounds, limiting the injunction to California and four other states.

In a 2-1 decision, the appellate panel’s majority affirmed findings by U.S. District Judge Haywood Gilliam Jr. that the administration probably violated mandated procedures for issuing the rules and that their enforcement would “imminently” financially harm plaintiffs California, Delaware, Maryland, New York and Virginia as women turn to state-funded programs for coverage.

But it ruled the preliminary injunction’s nationwide scope “overbroad” and lifted it for the remaining 45 states, concluding a scaled-back version would sufficiently protect the plaintiffs.

In doing so, it rejected Gilliam’s justification that federal officials violated the Administrative Procedure Act as to every state by failing to provide a notice-and-comment period for agencies around the country.

Writing for the majority, U.S. Circuit Judge J. Clifford Wallace said Gilliam “abused [his] discretion in granting a nationwide injunction.”

“District judges must require a showing of nationwide impact or sufficient similarity to the plaintiff states to foreclose litigation in other districts, from Alaska to Puerto Rico to Maine to Guam,” Wallace, a Nixon appointee, wrote in a 48-page decision.

In a statement, California Attorney General Xavier Becerra didn’t address the decision to limit the injunction. But he called the ruling “an important step to protect a woman’s right to access cost-free birth control and make independent decisions about her own reproductive healthcare.”

He added, “A woman’s health decisions should be made by a woman and her doctor – not her employer or politicians.” Congress, he said, “made clear that all women and their families have the right to access cost-free birth control under the ACA. The Trump Administration’s rules attempt to trample these rights, with no regard for public comment or the rule of law.”

The Affordable Care Act requires employers to offer health insurance that covers contraception with no co-payment. Houses of worship have an exemption to the mandate, and nonprofits were allowed to opt out via an accommodation by which an employer certifies its objection to the mandate to the federal government. The government is consequently tasked with confirming that insurers provide separate coverage.

But the Trump administration issued new interim rules in October 2017 letting any employer or health insurer with religious or moral objections to providing birth control opt out of the ACA requirement. Under these rules, exempted entities no longer need to certify their objection or otherwise notify the federal government of their decision to stop providing coverage.

The appellate panel on Thursday also admonished Gilliam over the delay his decision to freeze the case during the appeal had caused. But it affirmed the reasoning on which he based the injunction.

On the Administrative Procedure Act claim, Wallace said federal officials had satisfied none of the APA’s three exceptions to notice-and-comment rulemaking. He chided as disingenuous their insistence there was no time for notice and comment because violations of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act had to be immediately eliminated, noting federal officials in January 2017 “explicitly declined to change the accommodation in light of Zubik and RFRA.”

“They then let nine months go by and failed to specify what developments necessitated the agencies to change their position and determine, in October 2017, that RFRA violations existed,” Wallace said. “The [Interim Final Rules] are devoid of any findings related to the issue. Indeed, the agencies cited no intervening legal authority for their justification … “Given these failures, the agency action cannot be upheld on unexplained about-face.”

Wallace next found it “reasonably probable that loss of contraception coverage will inflict economic harm to the states.” To back this up, he cited the administration’s own estimates that up to 120,000 women nationwide will lose some contraception coverage under the rules at a cost of up to $63.8 million annually, and specific employers it had identified as likely to use the expanded exemptions, like Hobby Lobby.

“The injury asserted is traceable to the agencies’ issuing the IFRs allegedly in violation of the APA’s requirements, and granting an injunction would prohibit enforcement of the IFRs. The states have thus established standing,” Wallace wrote.

Dissenting, U.S. Circuit Judge Andrew Kleinfeld said the states had not in fact established standing.

The George H.W. Bush appointee relied on the Supreme Court’s 1976 decision in Pennsylvania v. New Jersey, in which the high court held the plaintiff states couldn’t “demonstrate that the injury for which [they sought] redress was directly caused by the actions of another state.”

“The reason they lack standing is that their injury is what the Supreme Court calls ‘self-inflicted,’ because it arises solely from their legislative decisions to pay these moneys,” Kleinfeld wrote. “Under the Supreme Court’s decision in Pennsylvania v. New Jersey, we are compelled to reverse.”

The majority, however, questioned the application of Pennsylvania in light of a newer Supreme Court ruling in Wyoming v. Oklahoma. The 1992 ruling concluded Wyoming had standing to challenge an Oklahoma statute that decreased some Wyoming tax revenues because Wyoming had suffered a “direct injury” caused by the Oklahoma law.

But, Wallace wrote, “we need not decide whether Pennsylvania’s ‘self-infliction’ doctrine applies to the ordinary injury-in-fact requirement of Article III standing because…the injury here is not “self-inflicted” within the meaning of Pennsylvania.”

Justice Department Spokeswoman Kelly Laco said in an email, “The ruling by the Ninth Circuit today to eliminate the nationwide preliminary injunction is a victory for restoring the constitutional order of the federal government and ending abuses of judicial power. The Constitution does not grant to a single, unelected judge the power to veto executive branch actions and issue a ruling that affects people across the nation and the world, regardless of whether they were part of the case or not. The Department of Justice will continue to fight injunctions that are contrary to the law and the Constitution.”

Last month, the federal government published final versions of challenged rules. Once they take effect in January 2019, the alleged APA violations will become moot.

U.S. Circuit Judge Susan Graber, a Clinton appointee, also sat on the panel.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment

SCV NewsBreak
Wednesday, Mar 20, 2019
Cemex Loses Federal Appeal; Soledad Canyon Mega-Mine Effectively Dead
A U.S. Department of the Interior review board has denied Cemex, Inc.'s appeal of a 2015 Bureau of Land Management decision that canceled the company's mining contracts in Soledad Canyon.
Wednesday, Mar 20, 2019
California Bill to Keep Environmental Rules Clears First Hurdle
In the wake of a catastrophic wildfire that ripped through a foothill community during what’s normally the beginning of California’s rainy season, state Senate leader Toni Atkins wanted to be the first lawmaker to act.
Wednesday, Mar 20, 2019
Hill Works on Behalf of Veterans, Military Families
U.S. Rep Katie Hill (D-Agua Dulce) continues her work on behalf of local veterans and military families through legislation and local events, while the White House threatens military funding cuts in California.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
The College of the Canyons Small Business Development Center will present a two-part webinar about making it in the fashion industry on Thursdays, March 21 and March 28, from 6:30 to 7:30 p.m.
March 21 & 28: Webinar on How to Succeed in Fashion Industry
Santa Clarita Mayor Marsha McLean and 38th District Assemblywoman Christy Smith (D-Santa Clarita) attended ribbon-cutting festivities on Saturday to welcome new vendor En Fuego BBQ to the Old Town Newhall Farmers Market.
Old Town Newhall Farmers Market Welcomes New Vendor, En Fuego BBQ
A U.S. Department of the Interior review board has denied Cemex, Inc.'s appeal of a 2015 Bureau of Land Management decision that canceled the company's mining contracts in Soledad Canyon.
Cemex Loses Federal Appeal; Soledad Canyon Mega-Mine Effectively Dead
The inventory of homes and condominiums listed for sale rose for the ninth consecutive month during February as sales fell and prices backed off of recent highs, the Southland Regional Association of Realtors reported Wednesday.
SCV Housing Inventory Up as Home Sales Slow, Prices Moderate
In the wake of a catastrophic wildfire that ripped through a foothill community during what’s normally the beginning of California’s rainy season, state Senate leader Toni Atkins wanted to be the first lawmaker to act.
California Bill to Keep Environmental Rules Clears First Hurdle
U.S. Rep Katie Hill (D-Agua Dulce) continues her work on behalf of local veterans and military families through legislation and local events, while the White House threatens military funding cuts in California.
Hill Works on Behalf of Veterans, Military Families
The United States Attorney’s Office for the Central District of California collected more than $317 million in criminal, civil and forfeiture actions in Fiscal Year 2018, U.S. Attorney Nicola T. Hanna announced Tuesday.
US Attorney’s Office in LA Collects $317M in Civil, Criminal Actions in 2018
2012 - County supervisors approve 50-year operating agreement for Placerita Canyon State Park [read]
Placerita Canyon
The Lancaster JetHawks announced Monday that they will become “El Viento de Lancaster” for ten Friday night games throughout the 2019 season, as they celebrate local Hispanic and Latin culture in the Antelope Valley.
JetHawks to Celebrate Hispanic, Latin Cultures with ‘El Viento de Lancaster’
The Valencia High School Concert Band was selected to perform at the legendary Carnegie Hall in New York City on Sunday, March 17.
Vikings Concert Band Selected to Perform at Carnegie Hall
The Southern California Chapter of the Construction Management Association of America (CMAA) is honoring Lundgren Management with a Project Achievement Award for its excellent work on the Santa Barbara City College New West Campus Center.
Local Construction Firm Lauded for Santa Barbara City College Project
Dust off your boots, and dance the night away at the city of Santa Clarita’s Line Dance Night, to be held at the Canyon Country Community Center on Saturday, April 6, from 7:00 p.m. - 9:00 p.m.
April 6: Santa Clarita Line Dance Night at Canyon Country Community Center
On Friday, Golden Valley High School’s competitive show choir team, Voltage, dominated the intermediate mixed division at the Los Alamitos 2019 Xtravaganza.
Golden Valley’s Choir Dominates Los Alamitos 2019 Xtravaganza
West Ranch High School’s Instrumental Music Program is excited to announce their inaugural Golf Tournament fundraiser to be held on Monday, April 22, at The Oaks Club at Valencia.
April 22: West Ranch Instrumental Music Program’s Golf Fundraiser
A quarantine has been placed on the barnyard at William S. Hart Park in Newhall and birds at the Placerita Canyon Nature Center, due to the threat of Virulent Newcastle Disease.
Hart Park’s Barnyard, Placerita Nature Center Birds Under Quarantine
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station is honoring a fallen deputy. Forty-one years ago, SCV Sheriff's Deputy Arthur Pelino was shot and killed by a mentally deranged suspect.
SCV Sheriff’s Honoring Fallen Deputy Arthur Pelino
When Lisa Capella stumbled upon thousands of educational books in a school building that was waiting to be demolished, she knew something had to be done.
Nearly 2,000 Educational Books Waiting to be Donated In Bulk
Los Angeles County residents have been receiving phone calls from alleged Los Angeles County Sheriff’s personnel.
Residents Warned of Jury Duty Scam
Mary Jane Hartman, who has been volunteering with the SCV Senior Center since 1994, received the Carmen Sarro Community Service Award on Saturday from Zonta Club of the Santa Clarita Valley.
Zonta Club Celebrates Women in Service
WASHINGTON, DC – Congresswoman Katie Hill, (D-Agua Dulce) announced Tuesday that CA-25 will be participating in the Congressional Art Competition, an annual nationwide competition for high schoolers sponsored by the members of the U.S. House of Representatives.
SCV High School Students Urged to Take Part in Congressional Art Competition
In a small library, deep in the basement of the Los Angeles County Hall of Administration, Assessor Jeffrey Prang discovered 20 historic journals that will now become part of the collections at the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County (NHM).
Discovery of Historic Journals Offers Glimpse into LA County’s Past
1875, 1:35PM - Outlaw Tiburcio Vasquez hanged in San Jose [story]
Tiburcio Vasquez
The Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce's next Business After Hours mixer is set for L.A. Film Locations in Newhall on Wednesday, March 20, from 5:50 p.m. to 7:30 p.m.
March 20: Chamber After Hours Mixer at L.A. Film Locations
The next regular meeting of the Governing Board of William S. Hart Union High School District will take place Wednesday, March 20, at 7 p.m.
March 20: Hart District Governing Board Regular Meeting
Friday afternoon on a sunny, windy day in Placerita Canyon, the Mustangs rode Robert Winslow's strong right arm to an 11-1 victory over Hope International in the second game of a double-header. The Royals won the opener 7-3.
Winslow Pitches Mustangs to Split with Hope Int’l
March is recognized as Poison Prevention Awareness Month and National Poison Prevention Week is globally observed in the third week of March.
March 18-24: National Pet Poison Prevention Week
Homes 4 Families hosted its third Celebs4Vets Build at the Veteran Enriched Neighborhood off Soledad Canyon Road in Santa Clarita on Saturday.
Celebrities Help Build Homes for Veterans in SCV with Homes 4 Families
Southern California Gas Co. announced Monday that it achieved the highest level of spend with diverse business enterprises in the history of the company, spending more than $673 million dollars with 583 diverse suppliers last year.
SoCalGas Records More Spending with Diverse Suppliers Than Ever
An eight-member jury on Friday found Apple infringed three of Qualcomm’s patents used in iPhones, awarding the San Diego-based company over $31 million in damages in the first U.S. jury trial of a global intellectual property dispute between the two technology giants.
Qualcomm Awarded $31M in Patent Spat With Apple
Rep. Katie Hill (D-Agua Dulce) has sent a letter to the Interior Board of Land Appeals requesting that immediate action be taken to resolve the dispute between the city of Santa Clarita and Cemex USA.
Hill Picks Up Fight to Stop Cemex Mega-Mine in Soledad Canyon
In a room filled with at least 75 young speechmakers, Santa Clarita students celebrated their city’s first ever World Speech Day on Saturday.
Orators, Speechwriters Gather for First SCV World Speech Day Event
The California Central Coast Area Team of AFS Intercultural Programs is pleased to announce that Justine Tuncan, a Valencia High School junior, has become the team’s newest registered volunteer.
Valencia Junior Joins AFS Intercultural Programs as Registered Volunteer
Positioned in front of a backdrop sprinkled with NAIA logos, and wearing a lapel mic, Stephanie Soares tried to explain the Mustangs' staple defense.
Women’s Hoops: TMU Advances to NAIA Quarterfinals for Second Time
Feature films, reality TV shows and commercials among the productions filming in the Santa Clarita Valley aka "Hollywood North" the week of March 18-24, 2019.
‘Bless This Mess,’ ‘Murder for Hire,’ ‘Good Trouble’ Now Shooting in SCV
The next meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors is set for Tuesday, March 19, starting at 9:30 a.m.
March 19: LA County Board of Supervisors Meeting
In celebration of its 15 years of educating the students and community of Santa Clarita, Golden Valley High School held a quinceanera celebration Saturday.
Golden Valley High School Celebrates Quinceanera