[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Mostly clear
Mostly clear
60°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
May 25
1966 - Mustang Drive-In theater opens on Soledad Canyon Road [story]


| Friday, Feb 15, 2019
California Attorney General Xavier Bacerra
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra.

 

By Helen Christofi

SAN FRANCISCO – A San Francisco Bay Area free-speech group sued California’s attorney general and justice department Thursday over the refusal to disclose records on police misconduct under a new police transparency law.

According to the complaint filed in San Francisco Superior Court, California Attorney General Xavier Becerra earlier this month refused the First Amendment Coalition’s request for records pertaining to police misconduct and excessive uses of force, and justified the decision by citing multiple lawsuits over Senate Bill 1421’s disclosure requirements pending in county courts across the state.

The coalition claims the police-backed litigation isn’t a valid reason for denying records under the California Public Records Act and wants a judge to order Becerra to release the requested information.

“This AG has a very good record on transparency issues and it’s unfortunate at this critical juncture that he has retreated from that,” Berkeley-based attorney Michael Risher, one of the attorneys representing the coalition, said by phone Thursday. “It’s completely contrary to the Legislature’s stated intent in enacting SB 1421.”

Introduced by state Sen. Nancy Skinner, SB 1421 opens up access to personnel records on police shootings, excessive uses of force that resulted in death or “great bodily injury,” and confirmed cases of sexual assault and lying by officers while on duty.

Numerous media outlets sought records once the measure took effect Jan. 1, but police unions in Contra Costa, Los Angeles, Orange, San Bernardino and Ventura counties sued to halt the demands. The unions say SB 1421 isn’t “retroactive” because the Legislature didn’t expressly state that it is, and that disclosing pre-2019 records will violate officers’ privacy rights.

Becerra’s office took a similar position, noting in a denial letter to the coalition the “significant privacy right” to personnel information officers have historically had in the state. The letter cites Government Code 6255, which allows an agency to withhold records if the public interest in withholding them “substantially” outweighs public interest in disclosure.

“[U]ntil the legal question of retroactive application of the statute is resolved by the courts, the public interest in accessing these records is clearly outweighed by the public’s interest in protecting privacy rights,” the letter states.

Becerra reiterated his position in an emailed statement Thursday.

“Historically, under state statute, peace officers have had a significant privacy right in their personnel records,” Becerra said. “Several cases have recently raised the issue whether SB 1421’s amendment to section 832.7 requires the disclosure of records relating to conduct that occurred before Jan. 1, 2019, which is SB 1421’s effective date. Given the ongoing proceedings, at this time, we are prepared to disclose only records beginning Jan. 1, 2019. When it comes to disclosing a person’s private information, you don’t get a second chance to get it right.”

On the phone Thursday, First Amendment Coalition attorney David Snyder disputed the litigation is a valid exemption for denying records under the state’s public records laws.

“If the fact that the Public Records Act or a portion thereof being litigated could provide the basis to not disclose records, agencies would be trotting that out all the time,” he said, because the law is challenged in court regularly. “It’s not a valid reason under the Public Records Act to not disclose records, so the AG has taken an odd position.”

Whether the privacy and Public Records Act arguments will survive judicial scrutiny is an open question. On Feb. 8, a judge in Contra Costa County roundly rejected both arguments and refused to issue a preliminary injunction for records held by six law enforcement agencies in the county. But according to Snyder, a judge in Ventura County earlier this week granted a preliminary injunction there based on similar arguments, though a written ruling has not yet been issued.

Regardless of what happens in court, both Risher and Snyder said Becerra’s decision has prompted a growing number of police departments to also deny access to records. Snyder said he believes Becerra’s office sent a direct advisory to law enforcement agencies articulating Becerra’s position, based on response letters Snyder has seen citing or quoting the same language in the letter the First Amendment Coalition received.

“The attorney general is the highest law enforcement officer in the state,” Snyder said. “By denying records…under SB 1421, he’s sending the message to police agencies around the state that they don’t have to comply with the law, at least right now.”

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Friday, May 24, 2019
SCV Detectives Issue Sketch of Indecent Exposure Suspect
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station detectives released a composite sketch Friday afternoon of the man suspected of indecent exposure in Towsley Canyon Park on Thursday, May 16.
Friday, May 24, 2019
SCV Deputies Rescue Suicidal Man on Canyon Country Bridge
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station deputies rescued a suicidal man from a Canyon Country bridge on Thursday night, station officials reported.
Friday, May 24, 2019
Cannabis Tax Revenue in First Quarter 2019 Nearly Doubles 1Q 2018
The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration reported tax revenue numbers Friday totaling $116.6 million for cannabis sales for the first quarter of 2019, nearly doubling revenue over the first quarter of 2018.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1966 - Mustang Drive-In theater opens on Soledad Canyon Road [story]
The Beer Institute and the National Beer Wholesalers Association have released their "Beer Serves America" economic report on the nation’s beer industry, showing the U.S. beer industry supports more than 2.1 million jobs and contributes more than $328 billion to the U.S. economy.
Report: Beer Industry Creates 2 Million Jobs, Pours $328B into U.S. Economy
Los Angeles County's Department of Animal Care and Control has received a 2019 Achievement Award from the National Association of Counties for DACC's "Pawsitive Steps" program.
LA County Animal Care Wins National Achievement Award
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station detectives released a composite sketch Friday afternoon of the man suspected of indecent exposure in Towsley Canyon Park on Thursday, May 16.
SCV Detectives Issue Sketch of Indecent Exposure Suspect
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station deputies rescued a suicidal man from a Canyon Country bridge on Thursday night, station officials reported.
SCV Deputies Rescue Suicidal Man on Canyon Country Bridge
The Valley Industry Association will host "Cocktails and Conversation: An Evening with Kathryn Barger" at the Valencia Country Club on Wednesday, June 26, from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m.
June 26: VIA to Host Evening with LA County Supervisor Kathryn Barger
The Santa Clarita City Council will hold its next regular meeting Tuesday, May 28, starting at 6 p.m. and preceded by a special meeting at 5:30 p.m. for labor negotiations.
May 28: Santa Clarita City Council Special, Regular Meetings
The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration reported tax revenue numbers Friday totaling $116.6 million for cannabis sales for the first quarter of 2019, nearly doubling revenue over the first quarter of 2018.
Cannabis Tax Revenue in First Quarter 2019 Nearly Doubles 1Q 2018
To improve Memorial Weekend holiday traffic flow on Interstate 5 through the Santa Clarita Valley, the California Department of Transportation opened a fourth northbound lane Wednesday where only three lanes were open in recent months due to construction.
Caltrans Opens New I-5 Lane in Time for Memorial Weekend
U.S. Rep. Katie Hill, D-Agua Dulce, will celebrate Memorial Day in all three valleys of California's 25th Congressional District with events on both Saturday, May 25 and Monday, May 27.
Hill to Spend Memorial Weekend in 3 Valleys
After getting rained out on Wednesday, the JetHawks and Inland Empire 66ers split a doubleheader Thursday night at San Manuel Stadium.
JetHawks Split Thursday Double-Header with 66ers
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has called a Cold Weather Alert due to the National Weather Service’s forecast for low temperatures for the Los Angeles County mountain areas on Sunday, May 26.
Cold Weather Alert Called for Local Mountains on Sunday
The Santa Clarita City Council invites the public to attend an unveiling ceremony in front of the Valencia Library for the newest public art sculpture in Santa Clarita called “Imag_ne” by Australian artist Emma Anna on Wednesday, June 5, at 10 a.m.
June 5: Unveiling of ‘Imag_ne’ Public Art Piece at Valencia Library
While college is a faraway thought for most junior high students, Mark Gray was not only thinking about college, but also saving up for it, too.
Hard Work Pays Off for COC Graduating Student
Detectives from the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station seek the public's help to identify a man suspected of stealing personal items from a locker at the LA Fitness club in Centre Pointe.
SCV Detectives Seek ID of Suspected Gym Locker Thief
A housing development plan for Canyon Country, introduced in 2006 when the housing industry entered the Great Recession, was dusted off this week and given a one-year extension by regional planners.
Regional Planners OK Time Extension for Canyon Country Development
Governor Gavin Newsom on Friday issued a proclamation Friday officially declaring Monday, May 27, 2019, as “Memorial Day” in the state of California.
Newsom Issues Proclamation Declaring Memorial Day
While still currently under construction, the development project formerly known as Newhall Ranch, which is also part of Valencia, will bring kids into the Saugus, Castaic and Newhall elementary school districts, as well as the William S. Hart Union High School District, local school officials have been told.
FivePoint Development to Add Enrollments to 4 SCV School Districts
A Santa Clarita woman who led police on a pursuit from Valencia to Tarzana while driving an RV with two dogs inside on Tuesday was charged Thursday with nine felony counts, according to the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office.
Woman Driving RV in Police Pursuit Charged with 9 Felonies
1860 - Colonel Thomas F. Mitchell arrives in Soledad Canyon [story]
T.F. Mitchell
After one and a half hours inside a crumpled car, the last of two people trapped was freed from the wreckage.
3 Hurt in Multi-Vehicle Stevenson Ranch Crash
The city of Santa Clarita is excited to announce the winners of the 16th annual “Bike to Work Day” Challenge that took place on Thursday, May 16.
City Announces Winners of ‘Bike to Work Day’ Challenge
SACRAMENTO – The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) notified California on Wednesday that it is in full compliance with the federal REAL ID Act and regulation.
DHS: California in Full Compliance with REAL ID Regulations
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Social Services (DPSS) announces the expansion of the State of California’s CalFresh Program to now serve older adults and people with disabilities who receive Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits, beginning June 1, 2019.
CalFresh Expanding to Seniors, People with Disabilities Receiving SSI Benefits
LOS ANGELES – The Dodgers will hold their annual Alumni Game on Saturday, June 1, as part of Alumni Weekend presented by Security Benefit, when the club will welcome back over 30 fan-favorite players to Dodger Stadium.
More than 30 Fan Favorites to Take Part in Dodgers Alumni Weekend
SCVi, iLEAD’s founding school, will welcome Dr. Jacob Cohen, Chief Scientist at NASA Ames Research Center, to campus on Friday to kick off the school’s inaugural International Hack Into Space Competition, the school announced Thursday.
May 24: SCVi Hosts Inaugural International Hack into Space Competition
Three-hundred employees from the Los Angeles County Department of Public Social Services (DPSS) volunteered their Saturday morning over Mother’s Day weekend to inspire hope at their annual “Help the Homeless” event at the Weingart Center in downtown L.A.
County Employees Inspire Hope at Annual ‘Help the Homeless’ Event
SACRAMENTO - State Sen. Scott Wilk, representing the 21st Senate District, announced Thursday the Senate unanimously approved Senate Bill 219 (SB 219), a measure that will create a pilot program for foster youth to receive grants for extracurricular and enrichment activities.
Wilk Legislation to Create Foster Youth Pilot Program Clears State Senate
The Old Town Newhall Farmers Market will be celebrating their 4 year anniversary this Saturday, May 25, from 8:30 a.m. - 1:30 p.m. in the parking lot of the Old Town Newhall Library.
May 25: Old Town Newhall Farmers Market 4 Year Anniversary Celebration
Many people in our community have a parent or other family member who may be a veteran, who is presently deployed overseas, or who has recently returned home from active duty in the military.
June 15: Pathways to Empowerment SC Veteran & Family Mental Health Day
Robert Penalber is fairly confident that before long very little of what transpired on the course this week, or over the last four years for that matter, will be remembered.
Penalbar Misses Cut at NAIA Nationals
Well Q2 was removed from service after quarterly perchlorate sampling conducted on May 8, 2019, returned a result of 0.006 mg/L – which is the Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL), where treatment becomes necessary or a supply needs to be removed from service. Q2 is located near the Lowe’s shopping center on the west side of Bouquet Canyon, just north of the Santa Clara River.
Perchlorate Detected in Well Near Lowes Shopping Center
WASHINGTON, DC – U.S. Rep. Katie Hill serves as co-chair of the New Democrats’ Housing Task Force, which made public its goals for the 116th Congress on Wednesday. Hill serves alongside Representatives Denny Heck (D-WA) and Ben McAdams (D-UT).
Hill to Address Homelessness, Housing Shortage with New Task Force
The California Enterprise Development Authority will hold a teleconference meeting Thursday, May 23, at 10:30 a.m.
May 23: California Enterprise Development Authority Teleconference Meeting
WASHINGTON – As the summer vacation and travel seasons opens, U.S. Secretary of the Interior David Bernhardt announced Thursday that visitor spending in communities near national parks in 2018 resulted in a $40.1 billion benefit to the nation’s economy and supported 329,000 jobs.
Visitor Spending at National Parks Contributed $40B to US Economy
%d bloggers like this: