[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
92°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
July 15
1891 - R.E. Nickel publishes area's first newspaper, The Acton Rooster [story]
Acton Rooster


Carl Kanowsky, Esq.

As you might recall from my last column, Charles Lee, that 15-day wonder from Dynamex (the document-delivery service company), sued Dynamex, challenging that he should have been considered an employee rather than an independent contractor, contrary to the agreement he’d signed when he went to work for the company.

In 2018, thirteen years after his brief stint at Dynamex, the California Supreme Court ruled on Charles’ allegations.

So, is a driver who delivers documents for a company that postures itself as a document-delivery company an employee or an independent contractor?

You might ask, what difference does it make what agreement two parties make in a private transaction?

The Supreme Court forcefully addressed that question: “Although in some circumstances classification as an independent contractor may be advantageous to workers, as well as to businesses, the risk that workers who should be treated as employees may be improperly misclassified as independent contractors is significant in light of the potentially substantial economic incentives that a business may have in mischaracterizing some workers as independent contractors. Such incentives include the unfair competitive advantage the business may obtain over competitors that properly classify similar workers as employees and that thereby assume the fiscal and other responsibilities and burdens that an employer owes to its employees.

“In recent years,” the court continued, “the relevant regulatory agencies of both the federal and state governments have declared that the misclassification of workers as independent contractors rather than employees is a very serious problem, depriving federal and state governments of billions of dollars in tax revenue and millions of workers of the labor law protections to which they are entitled.”

Now that we understand why it’s important to examine whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor, how do businesses and workers know how to determine which is which?

 

Employee or contractor?

For decades, as outlined in my last column, courts used a multifactor test from a 1989 decision in a worker’s compensation case to resolve that issue.

Boiled down to its essence, the question was the amount of control the business had over the person it retained to do a specific job: a lot of control — employee; not too much control — independent contractor.

But the challenge came in weighing how much control would tip the scales one way the other.

Just as one person’s wine is the epitome of taste, another may find it to be simply swill. Similarly, many felt too often judges reached what some thought were questionable decisions.

So, the California Supreme Court decided it was time to simplify matters. Setting aside the Borello multifactor test, the Supreme Court ruled: “An individual worker who has been hired by a company can properly be viewed as the type of independent contractor to which the wage order was not intended to apply only if the worker is the type of traditional independent contractor — such as an independent plumber or electrician — who would not reasonably have been viewed as working in the hiring business.”

Thus, “When a clothing manufacturing company hires work-at-home seamstresses to make dresses from cloth and patterns supplied by the company that will thereafter be sold by the company; when a bakery hires cake decorators to work on a regular basis on its custom-designed cakes; the workers are part of the hiring entity’s usual business operation, and the hiring business can reasonably be viewed as having suffered or permitted the workers to provide services as employees.”

Under this standard, a company will have a heavy burden to disprove employment. Merely asserting that the worker provides services outside of the company’s normal business will fail.

Instead, the company must establish “(a) that the worker is free from control and direction over performance of the work, both under the contract and in fact; (b) the work provided is outside the usual course of the business for which the work is performed; and (c) the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation or business. If the hirer fails to show that the worker satisfies each of the three criteria, the worker is treated as an employee, not an independent contractor.”

In a word, this ruling is huge and will have long lasting impacts going forward. Dynamex’s seemingly insignificant decision to bring on Charles Lee for 15 days changes everything. Now, if a company hires a worker to provide a service that is the essence of that company’s business, the worker is an employee.

 

Carl Kanowsky of Kanowsky & Associates is an attorney in the Santa Clarita Valley. He may be reached by email at cjk@kanowskylaw.com. Nothing contained herein shall be or is intended to be construed as providing legal advice.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
RECENT COMMENTARY
Wednesday, Jul 10, 2019
California Supreme Court weighs in on the question of whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor.
Tuesday, Jul 2, 2019
When was the last time you checked your emergency kit, stocked up on water or practiced your family emergency plan?
Monday, Jul 1, 2019
Patriotism and love for our country run deep in our city. These sentiments are proudly displayed in the many Fourth of July celebrations that take place throughout the day.
Friday, Jun 21, 2019
The relationship between workers and the companies that hire them has undergone a sea change in the past 15 months, at least in California.
Friday, Jun 14, 2019
Medicare doesn’t cover "free" genetic tests or cancer screenings unless a doctor who’s treating you orders them and they’re medically necessary.
Friday, Jun 7, 2019
In her Friday, June 7 "Keeping Up with Kathryn" newsletter, Los Angeles County Fifth District Supervisor Kathryn Barger addresses the recent spike in the county's homeless population and calls for additional public and mental health outreach.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
After more than a decade, the Whittaker-Bermite cleanup reached a significant milestone this month as soil remediation efforts in contaminated areas are now complete, according to officials close to the matter.
Whittaker-Bermite Soil Cleanup Complete, Officials Report
Monday's air quality is very unhealthy for all individuals in the Santa Clarita Valley and the Los Angeles County Mountains and unhealthy for sensitive individuals in the Pomona-Walnut, San Fernando and San Gabriel valleys, according to an alert from the South Coast Air Quality Management District.
SCV Air Quality Very Unhealthy Monday
1891 - R.E. Nickel publishes area's first newspaper, The Acton Rooster [story]
Acton Rooster
1769 - Portolá party sets out from San Diego; first Europeans to "discover" Santa Clarita Valley 3½ weeks later [story]
Gaspar de Portola
1884 - Hardison & Stewart start drilling Star No. 1 oil well in Pico Canyon; later form Union Oil Co. [story]
Lyman Stewart
The Valencia Jazz & Blues Summer Concert Series continues Friday, July 12, with singer-guitarist and series favorite Jim Gibson live on Town Center Drive at the Westfield Valencia Town Center Mall.
July 12: Jim Gibson to Groove at Valencia Jazz & Blues
The Live Oak Manor rock arch, a landmark for Sierra Highway motorists for nine decades, was moved Friday for the third time in history – only about 75 feet from its old location and still visible from the road.
Iconic Rock Arch Returns to Sierra Highway Frontage
Assembly Bill 392 (AB 392), legislation looking to reduce the number of officer-involved shootings across the state, has received bipartisan support from Santa Clarita Valley lawmakers and now heads to the governor’s desk for approval.
AB 392, Use of Force Bill, Heads to Governor
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors has published the agenda for their Tuesday, July 16 meeting starting at 9:30 a.m.
July 16 Meeting Agenda – LA County Supervisors
A man accused of stealing a Ferrari from a Canyon Country residence and then smuggling meth into the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station accepted a plea deal Thursday.
Canyon Country Ferrari Thief Cops Plea, Gets 2 Years
The Lancaster JetHawks added another crazy comeback to the season on Thursday night, beating Stockton 11-10 after overcoming a seven-run deficit at The Hangar.
JetHawks Pull Off Another Crazy Comeback
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has issued a heat alert for the Santa Clarita Valley as triple-digit temperatures are forecast for both Saturday and Sunday, July 13-14.
Heat Alert Called for SCV Saturday, Sunday
In separate statements Thursday afternoon, Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva ripped the federal ICE deportations of undocumented immigrants slated to begin Sunday and said he was not aware of any FBI probe into Sheriff's Department subgroups, as reported earlier Thursday by the Los Angeles Times.
Villanueva Rips ICE Deportations, Says He’s Unaware of FBI Probe
Congresswoman Katie Hill (D-Agua Dulce) and the United States House of Representatives voted Friday to pass the FY20 National Defense Authorization Act, which includes funding for major priorities in the 25th Congressional District.
House OK’s Defense Bill; Hill Delivers on Local Funding
The Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce honored local veterans at its ninth annual Patriots Luncheon at the Hyatt Regency on Thursday.
Chamber Honors SCV Veterans at Annual Patriots Luncheon
The Santa Clarita Valley business community supported new city rules aimed at enhancing the area’s “business-friendly” reputation and attracting new jobs before the City Council voted Tuesday to approve the regulations.
City Council OK’s New Jobs Creation Overlay Zone
Air quality Saturday will be unhealthy for sensitive individuals in the Santa Clarita Valley, according to an alert Thursday from the South Coast Air Quality Management District.
SCV Unhealthy Air Quality Alert Extended to Saturday
The SCV Water Board of Directors approved expedited testing of treatment options for toxic per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances or PFAS which were recently found in groundwater in SCV’s service area.
SCV Water Testing Treatments to Remove Toxic Chemicals
When it comes to advocating vital issues affecting the community, from water to transportation and CEMEX, the city of Santa Clarita has turned to Mike Murphy since the beginning.
Mike Murphy Says Farewell to City of Santa Clarita
Louie Gonzalez was identified and taken into custody by Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station deputies on Thursday as the suspect in a massage parlor robbery case.
Massage Parlor Robbery Suspect Found, Arrested
California utilities will soon be able to access a $21 billion state insurance policy to settle wildfire-related lawsuits and liabilities under legislation approved Thursday by lawmakers.
Lawmakers OK Wildfire Liability Fund for California Utilities
The Lancaster JetHawks opened a homestand after a six-game road swing, losing 15-2 to the Stockton Ports at The Hangar on Wednesday night.
JetHawks Drop Homestand Opener to Ports
A Trump administration-approved logging project in Los Padres National Forest will destroy habitat for endangered California condors and elevate wildfire risks for local communities, conservation groups say in a federal lawsuit filed Wednesday.
Feds Sued Over Logging Project OK’d in Condors Habitat
%d bloggers like this: