header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
59°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
January 28
1850 - Death Valley '49er William Robinson dies in Soledad Canyon from drinking too much cool water [story]
Leaving Death Valley


| Wednesday, Jul 25, 2018
Men with guns in public. Photo: Lucio Eastman/WMC 2.0
Men with guns in public. Photo: Lucio Eastman/WMC 2.0.

 

By Nicholas Iovino

SAN FRANCISCO – The 9th Circuit ruled Tuesday that carrying guns in public is a constitutional right, a decision that could strike down gun laws in California and Hawaii and impact firearm restrictions across the country.

With one judge dissenting, two circuit judges concluded that Hawaii cannot deny permits to non-security guard civilians who want to carry guns in public.

“The court seems to say that generally speaking, the state has to provide some kind of carry,” said UCLA law professor Eugene Volokh in a phone interview.

Plaintiff George Young sued Hawaii in 2012 for denying his applications for permits to carry a concealed or openly visible handgun. A Hawaii state law requires a license to a carry a gun in public.

The police chief may only grant such licenses to those who need a gun for their job or those who show “reason to fear injury” to their “person or property.” No one other than a security guard has ever obtained an open-carry license in Hawaii, lawyers for the county of Hawaii acknowledged during oral arguments.

“Restricting open carry to those whose job entails protecting life or property necessarily restricts open carry to a small and insulated subset of law-abiding citizens,” 9th Circuit Judge Diarmuid O’Scannlain, a Ronald Reagan appointee, wrote for the majority in a 59-page opinion.

Joined by fellow Circuit Judge Sandra Ikuta, a George W. Bush appointee, O’Scannlain built on the 2008 Supreme Court decision in District of Columbia v. Heller, which established a constitutional right to own firearms for self-defense. Denying someone the right to carry a gun in public would interfere with that right, the majority concluded.

“This decision is expanding Heller to say not only do you have the right to have a gun in the home for self defense, you can also carry it anywhere you want,” Stanford University law professor John Donohue III said in a phone interview.

By ruling against state laws that ban carrying guns in public, the 9th Circuit joined two other circuit courts that have issued similar rulings: the D.C. Circuit and 7th Circuit. Meanwhile, the 2nd, 3rd and 4th Circuits have upheld state laws that restrict carrying guns in public.

That makes this dispute ripe for the Supreme Court, which has a solid conservative and presumably pro-gun majority, even as it awaits confirmation of Trump’s nominee to replace retiring Justice Anthony Kennedy.

The state of Hawaii would not say whether it plans to ask the full 9th Circuit to rehear the case en banc, but Donohue believes an en banc rehearing is likely. The Stanford law professor said even if the 9th Circuit overturns the panel’s decision, the Supreme Court is likely to come down on the side of gun rights advocates.

“This decision could be used by the [National Rifle Association] to strike down all of the important gun regulations in the U.S. if it’s read expansively,” Donohue said.

Alan Beck, a San Diego-based attorney who represented the plaintiff in this case, said he considers the panel’s decision a victory for the U.S. Constitution.

“I don’t think this law is even a close call,” Beck said. “Here, the state is effectively banning the exercise of the constitutional right to carry outside the home.”

But that interpretation of the Second Amendment is not accepted among all judges and legal scholars.

Donohue argues the purpose of the Second Amendment was to maintain a militia, not give individuals the right to carry guns in public. He said the Supreme Court created the individual right to own firearms by misinterpreting the Constitution in its 2008 Heller decision.

Circuit Judge Richard Clifton, a George W. Bush appointee, dissented from the majority on Tuesday. Clifton wrote that restrictions on carrying guns in public for “good cause” has existed in law for centuries, going back hundreds of years.

“Regulation of public carry has its roots in English law,” Clifton wrote. “Dating back to the thirteenth century, England regulated public carry of firearms, including both concealed and concealable weapons.”

California is one of five states that prohibits openly carrying guns in public. Florida, Illinois, New York, South Carolina and the District of Columbia also forbid openly carrying firearms.

Hawaii is one of 15 states that requires a permit or license to openly carry a gun in public, according to the Giffords Law Center, a non-profit organization that supports stricter gun control laws.

Adam Skaggs, chief counsel for the organization, criticized the panel’s decision on Tuesday, arguing that the majority “ignored the weight of historical evidence and Ninth Circuit precedent concluding that strong laws restricting the public carry of firearms are consistent with the Constitution.”

Hawaii Attorney General Russell Suzuki said the decision would “undermine Hawaii’s strong gun control laws and commitment to protect the public.”

Suzuki said it was consulting with the County of Hawaii’s counsel and considering further action.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

7 Comments

  1. Jeff Einbund Jeff Einbund says:

    Let’s see how this plays out 😲

  2. Myk Halibut Myk Halibut says:

    Except for California or Hawaii…

  3. Joe Leo Joe Leo says:

    HURRAY FOR THE 9TH CIRCUIT COURT

  4. Lorenzo Curl Lorenzo Curl says:

    What’s the fuss about Navajo buying an arms company. Business been done that way for Navajo as matter of course. My complaint is in the company. Navajo should buy the Henry Arm Company – the code of the west.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Thursday, Jan 27, 2022
Santa Clarita Transit Lends Helping Hand to Guide Dogs
On Saturday, Jan. 22, Santa Clarita Transit partnered with Guide Dogs of America to provide training to service dogs in Central Park.
Thursday, Jan 27, 2022
Thursday COVID Roundup: Henry Mayo Reports Two Additional Deaths
Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital reported two additional deaths from COVID-19 Thursday, bringing the total number to 208 since the onset of the pandemic, confirmed spokesman Patrick Moody.
Thursday, Jan 27, 2022
City, Local Organizations Partner to Thank Henry Mayo Staff
During the month of February, the city of Santa Clarita is teaming up with community partners to help show appreciation for our hospital staff who have been on the frontline of this pandemic for nearly two full years.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
To celebrate the Opening Ceremony of Beijing 2022 winter games, join your friends and neighbors for a free sit-in movie – Disney’s “Miracle” – Thursday, Feb. 3 at 6 p.m at The Cube.
Feb. 3: Parking Lot Screening of ‘Miracle’ at The Cube
Three California Institute of the Arts alums were named USA Fellows by United States Artists, an organization that supports artists and uplifts their essential roles in society.
CalArtians Named to United States Artists’ 2022 Fellowship Class
Carousel Ranch will be offering a special "Val-o-grams" Valentine’s Day-themed fundraiser to benefit the programs at the therapeutic riding ranch.
Val-O-Grams Fundraiser to Benefit Carousel Ranch
1850 - Death Valley '49er William Robinson dies in Soledad Canyon from drinking too much cool water [story]
Leaving Death Valley
Following a nationwide search, Paseo Aquatics, a premier USA-Swimming Sanctioned club located in Santa Clarita, has landed Kameron Kennedy.
Level 4 Coach Kameron Kennedy Joins Paseo Aquatics
College of the Canyons women's basketball, winners of four straight, checked in as the No. 8 ranked team in the state in the first California Community College Sports Information Association (CCCSIA) poll of the 2021-22 season, released on Jan. 26. 
Lady Cougars Ranked 8th in New Statewide Poll
The city of Santa Clarita is pleased to announce that the Santa Clarita Valley (SCV) Trail Users volunteer group will help build out a scenic portion of the new Crest to Coast Trail in Newhall.
Local Trail Users Volunteer Group Assisting New Crest to Coast Trail
The public is invited to an opening reception at the Santa Clarita Artists Association Gallery on Friday, Feb. 18, from 5 p.m. - 8 p.m.
SCAA Hosting ‘Fantastical Flora’ Art Reception
Love is in the air at The MAIN, where “The Diaries of Adam and Eve” will take the stage in February!
‘Diaries of Adam and Eve’ Coming to The MAIN
On Saturday, Jan. 22, Santa Clarita Transit partnered with Guide Dogs of America to provide training to service dogs in Central Park.
Santa Clarita Transit Lends Helping Hand to Guide Dogs
Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital reported two additional deaths from COVID-19 Thursday, bringing the total number to 208 since the onset of the pandemic, confirmed spokesman Patrick Moody.
Thursday COVID Roundup: Henry Mayo Reports Two Additional Deaths
The Santa Clarita City Council will hold its Budget Committee meeting Monday, Jan. 31, at 2:00 p.m.
Jan. 31: Santa Clarita Budget Committee Meeting
During the month of February, the city of Santa Clarita is teaming up with community partners to help show appreciation for our hospital staff who have been on the frontline of this pandemic for nearly two full years.
City, Local Organizations Partner to Thank Henry Mayo Staff
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health cautions residents who are planning to visit the following Los Angeles County beaches to avoid swimming, surfing, and playing in ocean waters
Water Use Warning Issued for L.A. County Beaches
1970 - Gov. Ronald Reagan appoints Adrian Adams as Newhall's first "second" judge [story]
Adrian Adams
Caltrans announced Tuesday it is approving the use of low-carbon cement to help reduce the carbon footprint of California’s transportation system.
CalTrans Approves Use Of Low-Carbon Cement For Future Projects
The Tejon Ranch Conservancy is honoring one college intern's passion for wildlife conservation and highlighting her unique story.
Tejon Ranch Conservancy Recognizes College Intern’s Passion for Wildlife Conservation
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed 91 additional deaths and 20,866 new cases of COVID-19 countywide, with 66,432 total cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Wednesday COVID-Roundup: County Reports Youngest Death Since Pandemic Began
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond announced "A Trusted Space: Redirecting Grief to Growth", a film-based program to help address increasing mental health challenges faced by students during the COVID-19 pandemic.
State Superintendent Launches Statewide Mental Health Program
Symptoms of depression and anxiety have doubled during the pandemic for youth across the country, according to the United States Surgeon General.
Feb 10: County Hosts Youth Mental Health Seminar
Los Angeles County Supervisors Kathryn Barger and Janice Hahn called Tuesday for a thorough assessment of the Department of Children and Family Services that will place a spotlight on how well the organization is guided by evidence-based decisions and data to deliver outcomes for its clients. 
Board of Supervisors Approve Assessment of County Children and Family Services
1990 - "Duplicates" premieres at L.A. Phil; concerto by CalArts Music School dean Mel Powell wins Pulitzer Prize [story]
Mel Powell
The Zonta Club of Santa Clarita Valley’s Empower Hour will be held virtually at noon, Saturday, Feb. 5 on Zoom.
Feb. 5: Zonta Club of SCV Hosts Virtual Empower Hour on Child Marriage
The Sierra Hillbillies Square Dance Club will kick off Super Bowl celebrations a week early at 2 p.m. Sunday, Feb. 6.
Feb. 6: Sierra Hillbillies Square Dance Club Hosting Super Sunday Tailgate Party
SCVNews.com
%d bloggers like this: