header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
75°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
June 13
1949 - Frank Walker deeds over the first 40 acres of Placerita Canyon State Park [story]
Deed


Facing an existential threat to their industry, bail agents are fighting back with a double-edged attack on a law that abolishes bail in California.

California Supreme Court Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye called it a “transformative day for our justice system” when Gov. Jerry Brown signed Senate Bill 10, the law that replaces bail with a system based on risk assessments that gives judges broader discretion over release.

But the bill now faces both a referendum to repeal and a ballot initiative to grant bail constitutional protection.

The initiative, filed quietly last month, would amend the California Constitution to shield the right to bail through a bail bonds agent from legislation like SB 10. The Bail Reform Act would ensure “the right to obtain release at all times before trial by posting bail.”

The California Constitution already prohibits excessive bail, but the Bail Reform Act seeks to define it specifically. “Bail in excess of the amount reasonably necessary to ensure the personal appearance of the person charged with a crime to appear in court when his or her attendance is lawfully required, is excessive,” the initiative reads.

Sacramento lawyer Tom Hiltachk, who filed the initiative and sought the referendum on behalf of the bail industry, did not respond to calls seeking comment.

“It seems to me it’s a little desperate,” said Sen. Robert Hertzberg, a Democratic lawmaker who helped write SB 10 and has championed the anti-bail movement in California. He says he finds it odd that the state constitution would be amended to protect an industry.

“It’s the weirdest thing. All of a sudden they care about the liberty of people?” he said. “They care about making money. I don’t have a problem with making money, but do it honestly. One of the dark sides of being in public service is these advocates so often never care about the public good, they care about preserving their interests.”

For Hertzberg, the initiative is a last-ditch effort, like throwing everything against the wall to see what sticks.

“Do they want to repeal SB 10 or do they want bail in the Constitution?” he said, adding that for voters “it will be confusing”

Under SB 10, those charged with nonviolent, “low-level” misdemeanors could be released within as little as 12 hours after being booked into jail, and charges of stalking or domestic violence are exempt. Those arrested for felonies will be immediately assessed for their risk to public safety and likelihood of returning to court.

Although SB 10 does away with a system that many social justice groups decried as unfairly punitive towards the poor, it was also seen as replacing one flawed framework for another. Critics have assailed algorithms and actuarial methods that assess a person’s threat to public safety as racially biased, and say they may lead to more people being incarcerated than before. Others are uncomfortable with judges being given even broader discretion to determine risk.

Jeff Clayton, executive director of the American Bail Coalition, is among SB 10’s strongest critics. “I think the same things that were issues when SB 10 passed are still issues,” he said. “We’re not going to solve society’s evils by fixing the bail system. We’re certainly not going to solve racism. It’s more fundamental and it’s more about economics and the legacy of slavery and discrimination.”

Clayton says he’s not even sure enshrining bail as a constitutional right in California will solve the problem.

“I don’t think any initiative is going to fix the system at this point,” he said. “Obviously it would continue what we’ve all known as the right to bail for centuries on this continent so it’s probably a good thing, but the fundamentals of the issue are not going to be fixed by this amendment.”

Clayton is more optimistic about the effort to repeal SB 10.

“The referendum has a chance because of the wide opposition,” he said. “The no-money bail system movement is over in my mind. It’s a bad concept. People don’t want that. This is about finding doors out of the jail, not finding more pathways to keep people in.”

Hertzberg said he’s working to address concerns about bias. He pointed to this year’s Senate Bill 36, written in partnership with the Ella Baker Center for Civil Rights, which establishes guidelines for using risk assessment tools to mitigate bias.

“SB 36 requires the issue of bias to be assessed,” Hertzberg said. “The whole purpose was to fix the things I could not fix last year.”

Though the future of SB 10 is uncertain given the bail industry’s two-pronged challenge, courts are forging ahead to craft a justice system without bail.

On Friday, the Judicial Council will meet to discuss how to dole out $75 million designated by then-Gov. Brown for pretrial pilot projects in 16 courts. The projects, which will be tested over a period of two years, will analyze bias based on race, ethnicity and gender in pretrial decision making.

Contra Costa County Public Defender Robin Lipetzky had concerns about the final version of SB 10, as it does not require a full evidentiary hearing for a judge to make a risk determination. “It was more of a rubber-stamp procedure,” Lipetzky said.

But she said the law is a step in the right direction and blasted the initiative as a money grab by the bail industry.

“Money bail is what needs to be gotten rid of. We have completely gotten away from what the purpose of bail was, which was you deposit an amount with the court you can afford and you get that money back,” she said. “I see this initiative as nothing more than an effort to enshrine the for-profit bail bond industry with constitutional protection. It’s unnecessary. Worse, it perpetuates the existing wealth-based pretrial system which unjustly burdens poor people and people of color.”

Lipetzky added, “It’s just disingenuous for them to argue it’s an issue of justice. For them it’s an issue of profit.”

The initiative could very well be a response to a pending constitutional challenge to bail in the California Supreme Court. In May, the court agreed to take up the case of 64-year-old Kenneth Humphrey, accused of robbing his 79-year-old disabled neighbor of $7 and a bottle of cologne in 2017. An appellate court found Humphrey’s initial $600,000 bail and later $350,000 reduction unconstitutional, and ordered a new bail hearing. The appellate panel also said judges must consider a defendant’s ability to pay when setting bail.

“The Humphrey decision is going to be as important, if not more, than what happens with SB 10 in terms of the landscape of bail within California,” Lipetzky said. “When Humphrey comes down it’s going to clarify what the constitutional parameters are of bail. Right now, that’s still unclear.”

Like Lipetzky, Hertzberg mourns what the bail system has become.

“My father used to be a jailhouse lawyer. In the old days the judge would say ‘$100 bail’ and you’d put up your $100 and then next day you come back to court and you would get your $100 back,” he said. “Today because of the way these bail companies work they put up $5,000 for a $50,000 bail, you come back the next day, the charges are dropped and you lost your $5,000 bucks. The whole thing got prostituted by the insurance companies and the payday type lenders and it lost its purpose.”

Hertzberg said he doesn’t have a problem with a bail system based on a person’s ability to pay, but he doesn’t see the point in moving backward.

“What we know is you can make sure people are safer, that they return to court through cheaper and better ways and we know the impact on poor people. We have such tools available to be able to ensure justice and safety and reduce public costs,” he said. “We’ve learned a lot from the days when my dad was a jailhouse lawyer.”

— By Maria Dinzeo

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Friday, Jun 11, 2021
America’s Job Center to Offer Career Transition Support Sessions
America’s Job Center of California is offering virtual career transition support sessions for displaced workers in Los Angeles County on the second and fourth Thursday of the month at 2 p.m. via Zoom.
Friday, Jun 11, 2021
SCV Hotels Bounce Back as Pandemic Winds Down
As COVID-19 ravaged the nation, the hotel and hospitality industry were among the hardest hit, experiencing major losses in 2020.
Friday, Jun 11, 2021
High Heat Alert Issued Throughout L.A. County Starting Monday
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has issued a Heat Alert as high temperatures have been forecast throughout the County including the Santa Clarita Valley.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1949 - Frank Walker deeds over the first 40 acres of Placerita Canyon State Park [story]
Deed
1868 - Ravenna post office established in Soledad Canyon [story]
Ravenna depot
America’s Job Center of California is offering virtual career transition support sessions for displaced workers in Los Angeles County on the second and fourth Thursday of the month at 2 p.m. via Zoom.
America’s Job Center to Offer Career Transition Support Sessions
As COVID-19 ravaged the nation, the hotel and hospitality industry were among the hardest hit, experiencing major losses in 2020.
SCV Hotels Bounce Back as Pandemic Winds Down
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has issued a Heat Alert as high temperatures have been forecast throughout the County including the Santa Clarita Valley.
High Heat Alert Issued Throughout L.A. County Starting Monday
On Friday, Los Angeles County Public Health officials confirmed five new deaths and 198 new cases of COVID-19 countywide, with 28,037 total cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Friday COVID-19  Roundup: 28,037 Total SCV Cases; County MIS-C Cases in Children Plummet
California’s high-speed rail project got a much-needed boost Friday when the federal government agreed to restore nearly $1 billion in grant funding for the embattled infrastructure project.
State and Federal Government Restore Nearly $1 Billion in Funding to the High-Speed Rail Project
Hart High School’s show choir is once again hosting its Summer Show Choir Camp next month for students fifth grade and up.
Hart High School’s Summer Show Choir Camp to Return
Due to an excessive heat forecast for the Santa Clarita Valley, the city of Santa Clarita will have its three branches of the Santa Clarita Public Library open as cooling centers beginning Tuesday, June 15.
Cooling Centers to Open In Anticipation of Excessive Heat
State legislators had until June 4 to pass their bills out of the house in which they originated, and legislators representing the Santa Clarita Valley are reporting multiple bills on the move.
Local Legislators See Bills Move Forward
Although they are still awaiting the autopsy results, Los Angeles County Homicide Bureau detectives said they do not believe at this time that foul play resulted in a body being discovered near Castaic Lake on Tuesday.
No Foul Play Suspected in Castaic Lake Investigation
In an improvement from his critical, yet stable, status last week, the Los Angeles County Fire Department captain hospitalized at Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital is in “fair” condition, according to officials.
Hospital Officials Say Fire Captain Now in ‘Fair’ Condition
1956 - Bill Bonelli incorporates Solemint Water Co., his second of two predecessors of Santa Clarita Water Co. [story]
Bonelli
For the past few years, Walmart Academies have focused on training our associates to succeed in their jobs and upskill for the future.
Registration Open for Walmart Santa Clarita’s Free Virtual Community Academy
Princess is introducing a new on-demand service that allows guests to call a crew member to their exact location to make an in-person request for assistance.
Princess Cruises Unveils New On-Demand Feature that Increases Personalized Service
Following its selection by the American Public Works Association’s (APWA) Southern California Chapter as a 2020 Project of the Year, the city of Santa Clarita’s Inclusive Play Area at Canyon Country Park was recently named the Innovative Design of the Year Project by the APWA’s High Desert Branch.
Canyon Country Park’s Inclusive Play Area Earns Award for Innovative Design
SCV Water’s 2021 Annual Water Quality Report is now available.
Annual SCV Water Quality Report Released
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station detectives are seeking the public’s help in identifying three robbery suspects who physically assaulted a Circle K clerk in Saugus in April.
Detectives Seek Public’s Help in Identifying Saugus Circle K Robbery Suspects
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Thursday 7 new deaths and 220 new cases of COVID-19, with 28,031 total cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Thursday COVID-19 Roundup: SCV Cases Total 28,031; New Vaccination Sweepstakes Coming to L.A. County Friday
Thinking about a career move? Jumping back into the job market after a challenging year? With the end of the pandemic in sight, people may be wondering about their next job prospects, career choices, or what's next on the horizon.
June 21: JCI Santa Clarita Hosting Virtual Resume, Interview Workshop
In anticipation of the grand opening of their newest tenant, Bird Dog Arts, the Outlets at Tejon is pleased to announce, it will be hosting “Art at OAT.”
June 12: Outlets at Tejon Unveil Interactive Art Walls
More than 200 teachers gathered outside the William S. Hart Union High School District office ahead of Wednesday’s board meeting, sharing frustration over their salaries.
Hart Teachers Protest to Demand Pay Raise
The Saugus Union School District held groundbreaking events last week for a handful of new buildings coming to the Cedarcreek and Skyblue Mesa elementary schools.
Saugus Union Breaks Ground on New Cedarcreek, Skyblue Mesa Facilities
1910 - Trick roper Montie Montana of Agua Dulce born in North Dakota as Owen Harlan Mickel [story]
Montie Montana
%d bloggers like this: