[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
56°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
March 30
1993 - Federal govt. declares coastal California gnatcatcher (bird) a threatened species [story]
Gnatcatcher


SACRAMENTO – With an outdated prize payout scheme and lack of oversight, the California Lottery flouted education funding laws and owes public schools $36 million, according to an audit released Tuesday.

Confirming the concerns of suspicious lawmakers, State Auditor Elaine Howle says the lottery hasn’t complied with a 2010 funding law, nor can it prove its payouts are crafted to maximize education benefits. Howle warns the lottery needs better state oversight in order to meet its voter-approved purpose of bolstering public education.

“The lottery failed to provide $36 million in funding to education in fiscal year 2017–18 because it did not budget to adhere to the proportionality requirement in the Lottery Act,” the audit opens.

Passed by California voters in 1984, the lottery’s purpose is to boost education funding without raising or passing new taxes. Under the law, it relies solely on revenue generated from the sales of its game to fund itself, pay out winners and contribute to the state’s K-12 and public universities. California and more than 40 states operate their own lottery systems.

For decades, state law required the lottery to divvy a minimum of 34% of its total annual revenue directly to education, 16% toward operational and administrative costs, and the remaining 50% for prizes.

But after a drastic drop in revenues during the Great Recession, lawmakers in 2010 amended the law from a strict percentage requirement to a proportional mandate that gave the lottery more authority over how much of its net revenue goes to schools.

Revenues have rebounded over the last decade, and in 2017-18 it raised over $1.7 billion for education – about 1% of the budget for public schools.

Critics have wondered whether the lottery has kept up with its end of the bargain as lotto and scratcher sales have more than doubled since 2010. Last year, lawmakers ordered an audit into whether it was complying with the law.

According to Howle, the answer is not always. She found that of the three years audited, the lottery only met its mandate twice and, most alarmingly, shortchanged schools $36 million in 2017-18.

“It is critically important that the lottery adhere to these requirements because they are safeguards that ensure that the lottery’s education funding increases as the lottery’s revenues increase and that the education funding is at its highest possible level and does not decline sharply from one year to the next,” the audit states.

The audit also criticizes the lottery’s prize payout scheme and its procurement system.

Howle says the lottery last studied its payout structure 10 years ago. Meanwhile, it handed out $5.7 million in noncompetitive contracts without “inadequate evidence.”

“Until the lottery determines the correct prize payout percentage, California will not know whether education is receiving all of the funding from the lottery that it should,” Howle said.

The lottery’s directors pushed back on many of the audit’s findings, writing in a response letter that in the four years the proportionality requirement has been in place, it has provided $6.7 billion to education. It says Howle’s findings of a shortchange “arise from a fundamental difference of opinion over interpretation” of the law, and that the lottery has set a goal of contributing $2 billion to education by 2021.

According to the audit, lawmakers have been left out of the loop about the lottery’s performance due to a lack of oversight by the State Controller’s Office. Howle says the regulator removed information about $720,000 worth of questionable travel and hotel costs from a 2019 audit, and has allowed the lottery to essentially conduct its own reviews.

“The controller’s office relied solely on the lottery to prepare a report for the Legislature on the lottery’s performance without assessing the thoroughness of the report, and therefore the Legislature has gone without independent analysis of whether the lottery has fulfilled the purposes of the 2010 changes to the Lottery Act,” the audit continues.

The lottery came under fire in 2018 when a whistleblower released photos of lottery officials partying at a bar. The whistleblower accused rank-and-file employees of fraud and lewd behavior, and the lottery’s former director and other officials later resigned.

The state controller’s office responded that the “audit makes assumptions and selective interpretations of fact that are inconsistent with responsible auditing practices.”

Howle says the Legislature should order the lottery to repay $36 million and require the controller’s office to conduct audits of the lottery’s procurement methods. As for the lottery, Howle recommends it study and come up with a better prize payout rate by August.

State Sen. Ling Ling Chang, R-Diamond Bar, who requested the audit, says she is not surprised by the findings.

“They’ve wasted money that should go to classrooms. I will be introducing legislation to ensure schools get their lost funding back and get max funding in the future,” Chang said in a statement.

— By Nick Cahill

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Sunday, Mar 29, 2020
L.A. County Sunday: Cases Climb from 36 to 42 in SCV; 2,136 Countywide
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health has confirmed five new deaths and 332 new cases of 2019 novel coronavirus for a total of 2,126,  including 42 cases in the Santa Clarita Valley, an increase of 17 percent in the last 24 hours.
Sunday, Mar 29, 2020
After Onslaught, All State Parks Closed to Vehicles
On Saturday, many state parks once again experienced visitation surges that made it impossible for the public to implement appropriate social/physical distancing practices.
Sunday, Mar 29, 2020
Local Man, 34, Arrested on Gun, Drug Charges
Patrolling in Canyon Country, a deputy found two loaded firearms in vehicle that was stopped for speeding, in addition to various narcotics.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1993 - Federal govt. declares coastal California gnatcatcher (bird) a threatened species [story]
Gnatcatcher
All three nonprofit Samuel Dixon Family Health Centers have made the necessary changes to their daily operations and are providing services virtually.
Dixon Health Centers Stay Open, Provide Virtual Aid
For the first time in at least a quarter century - maybe ever - the Easter Sunrise Service at Vasquez Rocks is canceled due to concerns about the novel coronavirus outbreak and the decision by the County of Los Angeles to shutter natural-area parks, including Vasquez.
Vasquez Rocks Easter Sunrise Service Canceled
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health has confirmed five new deaths and 332 new cases of 2019 novel coronavirus for a total of 2,126,  including 42 cases in the Santa Clarita Valley, an increase of 17 percent in the last 24 hours.
L.A. County Sunday: Cases Climb from 36 to 42 in SCV; 2,136 Countywide
Many healthcare professionals make house calls: nurses, physical and occupational therapists, wound care specialists, nutritionists, social workers, psychologists and case managers. What rules protect patients and the healthcare professional?
House Calls: What Are the Rules? | Doctor’s Diary with Dr. Gene Dorio
Looking for comfort and friendship? Molly might be just what you need.
Need a Friend? Adopt a Social Distancing Partner
On Saturday, many state parks once again experienced visitation surges that made it impossible for the public to implement appropriate social/physical distancing practices.
After Onslaught, All State Parks Closed to Vehicles
I listen to the complaints about how horrible this “social distancing” thing is. I just think about the time I was underwater for 87 days.
Grounded Again | Commentary by Darryl Manzer
Patrolling in Canyon Country, a deputy found two loaded firearms in vehicle that was stopped for speeding, in addition to various narcotics.
Local Man, 34, Arrested on Gun, Drug Charges
The Central Sierra’s snowpack stands at 55% of normal and the Southern Sierra is at 42% of normal.
Snowpack Half Normal; California Experiencing Drought
1928 - Little dam victim, thought unidentified & buried in SCV, actually ID'd & buried in Chatsworth [story]
Newhall Cowboys
The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department's Youth Services Unit has developed an online curriculum for explorer recruits for Academy Class 104.
Sheriff’s Dept. Develops Online Explorer Curriculum
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health has confirmed six new deaths and 344 new cases of 2019 novel coronavirus for a total of 1,804 cases, including 36 in the Santa Clarita Valley, a 33% increase over Friday's reported 27.
L.A. County Saturday: 344 More Cases to 1804; SCV Cases Up 33%
California now has 4,643 confirmed cases, including 73 healthcare workers.
California Saturday: 29% More Deaths in 1 Day; 4,643 Cases
Waiting rooms are empty, appointment cancellations escalating, and there are no walk-in visits. If this were because of great doctoring, I would feel proud and worthy. But, no.
The Struggling Doctor’s Office | Doctor’s Diary with Dr. Gene Dorio
Students may retake any course attempted during the pandemic; colleges must disregard the previous grade. The deadline to select pass/no pass is extended.
State: All Community College Students Can Retake Classes; More
#TeamLA is a new movement launched by UCLA Health designed to empower everyone – from influencers and celebrities to the general public - to show our collective support of social distancing and to express gratitude for all of the workers who are on the front lines.
UCLA Health Launches #TeamLA to Help Tackle Virus
The National Rifle Association and other gun advocate organizations sued Los Angeles County and other officials, claiming the shutdown of gun shops in the county as nonessential businesses during the coronavirus outbreak violates the Constitution.
NRA Sues State, County Over Closure of ‘Nonessential’ Gun Stores
Defense Secretary Mark T. Esper's action creates a conditional pre-authorization in response to FEMA requests that ensures quicker federal funding for State National Guard forces mobilizing to aid in whole-of-government COVID-19 response efforts.
Pentagon Speeds Funding Process for State National Guard Rollout
The order allows the Judicial Branch to allow for remote depositions in every case (the law had previously required that parties be deposed in person) and electronic service of process.
Gov.’s Order Allows Online Process-Serving, Depositions, More Court Flexibility
1934 - Bouquet Canyon Reservoir, replacement for ill-fated St. Francis Dam & reservoir, begins to fill with water [story]
Bouquet Reservoir
Those in charge of quarantined soldiers kept them isolated from communities and inoculated as many as they could. Thirty percent of the population died.
COVID-19: History Repeats | Doctor’s Diary with Dr. Gene Dorio
Governor Gavin Newsom issued an executive order Friday banning the enforcement of evictions of residential renters affected by coronavirus COVID-19 through May 31, 2020.
Newsom Orders Statewide Halt to Residential Tenant Evictions
Los Angeles County Public Health Officer Dr. Muntu Davis has closed beaches, beach bathrooms, piers, promenades, beach bike paths and beach access points in the county in an increased effort to stem the spread of COVID-19.
L.A. County Closes Beaches, Trailheads, Piers, Beach Bike Paths
%d bloggers like this: