header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
December 4
1962- Actress and future Soledad Canyon big-cat rescuer Tippi Hedren, "Hitchcock's New Grace Kelly," makes cover of Look magazine for upcoming thriller, "The Birds" [story]
Tippi Hedren

Commentary by Ron Bird
| Friday, Mar 6, 2015

Ron BirdA recent commentary by Ken Pfalzgraf focused on the costs of the current Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District superintendent and his board’s insistence on out-of-district charter schools, which is proving costly both to students and taxpayers.

Here, I focus on the “facts” that the Acton-Agua Dulce (AADUSD) superintendent pitches to justify his plan – most of which I find to be based in deception.

For example, on June 25, 2014, Superintendent Brent Woodard testified before the Assembly Education Committee regarding AADUSD’s sponsorship of 20 charter schools and the SB1263 legislation to curtail out-of-district charter approvals. You can watch this testimony [here].

Here are some excerpts.

Woodard: “Until yesterday, we really didn’t have the opportunity to get involved with the creation of this bill.” The facts: SB1263 was introduced in February 2014, with testimony taken and debated in the Senate Education Committee. Opportunity existed and was missed by Woodard. The bill passed the Senate committee and went on to pass in the full Senate before it was forwarded over to the Assembly. Finally, in the Assembly Education Committee, Woodard testified.

Woodard: “We are in fiscal crisis as many schools around the State of California are.” The facts: in June 2014 when this testimony was given, only seven districts out of more than 1,400 statewide were in negative certification, one of which was AADUSD.

Woodard: “(H)owever we are to the point of where we will be certified positive in a short amount of time exclusive of any kind of revenue or indirect costs associated with the charter schools.” The facts: As of March 2015, AADUSD still has not produced a budget that is balanced without the help of out-of-district charter school revenue. In December 2014, Woodard gave a PowerPoint presentation indicating AADUSD expects $800,000 in charter school revenue assuming it is charging 1 percent oversight fees to charter. The reality is that AADUSD charges 3.5 percent, generating far more than this projection.

Woodard: “I want to dispel this myth that we are a rogue district.” Hmm, why would anyone think that?

Woodard: “Our community was demanding they had a charter school opportunity and option.” I don’t remember any large local parental movement for charter schools. I don’t remember residents circulating any petitions at either of the Acton markets or Sweetwater Farms. Neither do I remember people attending school board meetings demanding local charter schools. Was a community survey conducted? Did the school board update its Strategic Plan to include charters? I don’t think so.

Regarding how many of the Agua Dulce elementary students are attending Einstein, Woodard said, “98 percent of those parents are attending that charter school.” At a December 2014 board meeting, Woodard happily stated that only 108 of our Agua Dulce kids attend Einstein. Given that 149 students enrolled there the prior year, then the real percentage is 72 percent, not 98 percent.

Regarding how Einstein kids were housed within AADUSD in 2013-14, Woodard said, “We had kids all over the district in order to do that.” The reality is, all Einstein students were housed in only two schools that year: Acton Elementary School and Agua Dulce Elementary. Now in 2014-15, with Einstein moving its Acton operation to Newhall, Acton Elementary is mainly used for storage. This creates an artificial shortage of in-district classroom space, forcing charters to find space out of the district.

Woodard stated: “We have authorized one seat-based program outside our district. All the other authorizations are independent study.” In addition to the Einstein Newhall seat-based charter, AADUSD sponsors three separate Valley Prep programs in the San Fernando Valley and the Scale Academy in Pasadena – all of which was authorized at the time of Woodard’s testimony – and all have students sitting in seats.

In regard to how many charters AADUSD approves, Woodard stated: “We have a very rigorous screening process. Only about half of those that apply actually even see a hearing before the board.” Since the AADUSD board has approved about 20 charters, I challenge Woodard to name the 20 charter petitions he has not brought before the board. Of the charters the board has approved, I have only seen one that specifies a physical address where the charter school plans to locate. Without an address, a charter petition is incomplete, and the board should not grant a public hearing on the charter. The Charter Schools Act is clear on this matter.

Woodard said, “We have multiple charter schools in our district that our kids are attending currently.” The only one I am aware of is Einstein-AD. Hope-Inspire independent program did have an office on Santiago Road, which since has closed. It claims an Acton Elementary School address and pays AADUSD $6,000 per year in rent. I suspect students don’t attend there, and they might just be using it for storage space.

Assembly Education Committee Chair Buchanan: “How many students attend charter schools in your district”? Woodard affirmed the number is “in between 300 to 350 and is probably growing.” The reality is that in 2013-14, Einstein enrolled only 14 AADUSD students that year. I’d like to see what charters the other 286 to 336 students were enrolled in.

Chair Buchanan: “Are you telling me that 50 percent of those students come from your attendance area? Is that correct?” Woodard: “Absolutely.” She further questioned the idea that 50 percent of the students in the schools AADUSD has chartered reside in the district when AADUSD has only 2,200 students (500 of those Woodard claimed attend the Hart District). Woodard then did a little stuttering dance. Chair Buchanan said, “It’s pretty unbelievable.”

Chair Buchanan: “What is the amount you are getting from these charter schools, both current and projected?” Woodard: “I’d have to go back and do a calculation.” In December 2014, Woodard released a number claiming $800,000 in charter school revenue going into the AADUSD coffers.

Chair Buchanan: “This is where I am on this: School boards are created for a reason, and school districts have boundaries, and the charter law was intended so that parents of children could form a charter. … I have a problem with a school district issuing charters the way you are in other school districts and making it a money maker, because in my opinion that is exactly what you are doing (by) charging 3.5 percent. That’s the price of admission to have a charter approved by your district. … In the long run, this is going to hurt all charters, because this is just not an ethical way to operate. … You may be shaking your head (gesturing to Woodard), but I’m sorry, I don’t buy what you are selling here, and I think these other districts have a legitimate concern.”

What Woodard is trying to sell is that AADUSD sponsoring 20 charters not for the money generated in oversight fees, but for providing charter choice. Just one month prior to Woodard’s education committee testimony, the AADUSD board president at the time publicly stated why they need charter revenue: “This is a mechanism for us to enter into collaboration with charter schools in order to create alternative budget capacity.”

SB1263 was passed by both houses of the Legislature but vetoed by Gov. Brown. It would have stopped practically all out-of-district charters and truly was way too restrictive.

Now, I admit that some of Dr. Woodard’s testimony was more embellishment than deception, but much of it stretched truth beyond its limits.

What are the consequences? When your boss is the AADUSD School Board, apparently there aren’t any. Maybe they will find “it’s about the money” and give him a raise. And Pfalzgraf, my commentarial nemesis, thinks the Charter King’s salary should be cut, haha.

It is a new year, and new legislation in the form of SB739 has been submitted. I’m looking forward to Dr. Woodard’s testimony on the matter. Maybe he will have the opportunity and attend the Senate hearing this time.


Ron Bird is a former school board member in the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District.


Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment

Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Tuesday, Dec 1, 2020
If you are looking to get into the holiday spirit this month, I encourage you to visit Old Town Newhall.
Tuesday, Nov 3, 2020
As restrictions remain in place for gatherings and events in Los Angeles County, one of Santa Clarita’s most important traditions will take place on an online format in 2020.
Tuesday, Nov 3, 2020
The holiday shopping rush is upon us! As with everything this year, checking loved ones off your shopping list will look a little different in 2020. There will be no braving the crowds and tussling for the first crack at the doorbuster deals on Black Friday.
Friday, Oct 2, 2020
In his monthly message for October 2020, Santa Clarita City Manager Ken Striplin spotlights results of the city's 2020 public opinion survey about the quality of life in our community.
Thursday, Oct 1, 2020
As with everything in 2020, this year’s State of the City event will be different than years past. We are looking on the bright side, embracing the necessary changes for safety’s sake and rejoicing in the fact that this year’s event is truly inclusive of the entire Santa Clarita community.
Saturday, Sep 19, 2020
Assembly Bill 1457, authored by Assembly Members Cervantes and Reyes, and supported by Santa Clarita’s Senator Scott Wilk, Assemblyman Tom Lackey and Assemblywoman Christy Smith, represents an important step forward in jumpstarting California’s economic recovery.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1962- Actress and future Soledad Canyon big-cat rescuer Tippi Hedren, "Hitchcock's New Grace Kelly," makes cover of Look magazine for upcoming thriller, "The Birds" [story]
Tippi Hedren
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health again confirms the highest daily number of new cases and people hospitalized with COVID-19.
Thursday COVID-19 Roundup: L.A. County Cases, Hospitalizations Continue to Surge; 10,201 Total SCV Cases
Are your plants growing slower than you would like? Feeling a little frustrated? The health of your plants depends on the soil they’re planted in and the fertilizer you use to help them grow!
SCV Water Takes On Proper Soils, Fertilizers at Next Virtual Gardening Class
After imposing a temporary ban on outdoor dining, Los Angeles County health officials have to prove in court how it poses a significant risk for COVID-19 transmission, according to a county judge’s ruling Wednesday.
L.A. County Ordered to Provide Proof Outdoor Dining Poses COVID-19 Risks
Some Santa Clarita Valley residents were without power Thursday morning, while others remained under consideration for power shut-offs amid Red Flag conditions.
Red Flag Conditions Prompt SCV Power-Shutoffs
The Los Angeles County Probation Department is the recipient of a one-year, $356,615.00 grant from the California Office of Traffic Safety (OTS) to monitor high-risk, repeat DUI offenders.
County Probation Receives Grant to Monitor High-Risk DUI Offenders
Gov. Gavin Newsom announced a new regional stay-at-home order Thursday, aimed at getting residents to stay home as much as possible in areas hardest hit by the COVID-19 surge for at least three weeks, with L.A. County on track to be placed under the order in the coming days.
New Regional Stay-at-Home Order Issued for California
JCI Santa Clarita, a premier young professional organization in the community, is partnering with our local WiSH Education Foundation to present the First Annual Virtual WiSH Run starting Friday, Jan. 1 - Saturday, Jan 9.
JCI Santa Clarita, WiSH Foundation Partner for Inaugural Virtual WiSH Run
(CN) — Real estate developers who promised to fund a nonprofit dedicated to preserving 90% of a 270,000-acre property north of Los Angeles are violating a 12-year-old pact by cutting their quarterly conservation payments, environmental groups claim in a new lawsuit.
Tejon Ranch Accused of Violating Pact to Fund Conservation
The city of Santa Clarita encourages interested residents to apply for several positions serving on the Arts Commission; the Parks, Recreation and Community Services Commission; the Planning Commission; and the Open Space Preservation District Financial Accountability and Audit Panel (FAAP).
Santa Clarita Seeking Local Residents for Appointment Vacancies
GreenPal, an app that connects homeowners with local, vetted lawn care professionals, is launching this week in Santa Clarita.
GreenPal Lawn Mowing App Launches in Santa Clarita
The Santa Clarita Valley Education Foundation (SCVEF) is pleased to announce that they will be hosting a virtual Teacher Tribute on Friday, Dec. 4, at 4:00 p.m.
Dec. 4: SCV Education Foundation’s Virtual Teacher Tribute
1887 - Prohibitionist Henry Needham purchases land in Newhall, attempts to establish "dry" colony [story]
H.C. Needham
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health on Wednesday reported 40 new deaths and 5,987 new confirmed cases of COVID-19 countywide, as the total number of Santa Clarita Valley residents diagnosed with the virus topped 10,000.
Wednesday COVID-19 Roundup: Record Hospitalizations in L.A. County; SCV Total Cases Top 10K
In response to the current surge of COVID-19 cases, the Los Angeles County Department of Parks and Recreation is suspending in-person outdoor programs in accordance with the county's Nov. 30 "Safer At Home" Health Officer Order to stop the spread of COVID-19.
L.A. County Parks Halt In-Person Outdoor Programs Due to COVID-19 Surge
The California Interscholastic Federation or CIF has postponed youth sports competitions including championship events until at least Jan. 1, due to the surge in COVID-19 cases statewide.
CIF Postpones Education-Based Athletics into 2021
California Senator Scott Wilk (R-Santa Clarita) and more than 50 other lawmakers are demanding answers from Bank of America surrounding the state Employment Development Department’s latest problem: the freezing and draining of unemployment benefits in EDD accounts.
Lawmakers Demand Answers from Bank of America on Draining of EDD Accounts
Noah Michael Englerth of Castaic has been missing a month, and Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department Missing Persons Unit investigators are asking for the public’s help locating him.
Missing: Noah Englerth of Castaic; LASD Asks Public’s Help
With a multiday Red Flag warning issued throughout Southern California, multiple parts of the Santa Clarita Valley remained under consideration for power shutoffs Wednesday.
SCE Warns of Power Shutoffs, State Readies Fire Resources
Santa Ana winds are forecast to return this week, bringing another fire weather watch to the Santa Clarita Valley after thousands across the region faced power shutoffs on Thanksgiving.
Santa Ana Winds Return, SCV Under Fire Weather Watch
A spokesman for the William S. Hart Union High School District confirmed Tuesday a food services worker “participating in meal service on (Nov. 23-24) at Golden Valley High School has since tested positive for COVID-19.”
Hart District Confirms GVHS Food Worker Diagnosed with COVD-19
1972 - Five wounded in Vagos biker gang shooting at Curtis & JoAnne Darcy's Acton '49er Saloon [story]
Darcys 49er
SCV Water ongoing communication efforts surrounding per- and polyfluoroalkyl (PFAS) chemicals were honored with a PRism Award from the Public Relations Society of America – Los Angeles Chapter (PRSA-LA).
SCV Water’s PFAS Community Outreach Earns Top Honors
What is the most effective way for the city of Santa Clarita to allocate Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funding?
Residents Encouraged to Provide Input on 2021-22 Community Needs Survey
%d bloggers like this: