header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Clear
Clear
47°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
February 9
1971, 6:01 a.m. - Sylmar/San Fernando Earthquake centered in Iron Canyon/Sand Canyon [WATCH FILM]
1971 earthquake film


| Friday, Oct 26, 2018
Tesla Model S electric car (left) and Fisker Karma plug-in hybrid at the parking spots reserved for green cars by Virgin Airlines at San Francisco International Airport. | Photo: Steve Jurvetson/WMC 2.0
Tesla Model S electric car (left) and Fisker Karma plug-in hybrid at the parking spots reserved for green cars by Virgin Airlines at San Francisco International Airport. | Photo: Steve Jurvetson/WMC 2.0.

 

A coalition of politicians from states and cities coast to coast filed formal written comments Friday demanding the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and National Highway Traffic Safety Administration withdraw their proposal to eliminate the national Clean Car Standards, calling the plan “dangerous and misguided.”

The comments submitted by California Air Resources Board Chair Mary Nichols, Governor Edmund G. Brown Jr., Attorney General Xavier Becerra, 21 attorneys general and the cities of Oakland, Los Angeles, San Francisco and New York included rigorous legal and technical analyses highlighting the consumer, climate and public health benefits of the current achievable standards.

The comments also pointed out the federal proposal’s numerous flaws, use of faulty assumptions, incorrect modeling, cherry-picked data and fundamental misunderstanding of consumer behavior, according to a news release from the California AG.

“This Trump Administration attack on innovative vehicle technology jeopardizes the health of millions and will cost drivers billions at the pump,” Brown said. “Foolishly, it mandates gas guzzlers instead of clean and zero-emission cars. Wrong way to go.”

“The evidence is clear: we must act now to protect ourselves and future generations from the existential threat of climate change, but instead Trump is driving us on a collision course with catastrophe,” Becerra said.

“This is no longer merely a looming threat; in California and throughout the nation, we’re already suffering the impacts of climate change,” he said. “It makes zero sense to eliminate a successful program that is projected to save vehicle owners $1.7 trillion over the life of the program and will help the U.S. achieve oil independence through significant fuel savings. We demand that the Trump Administration reverse course and withdraw this foolish proposal that will not only cost consumers money, but will endanger their health and well-being.”

“The rules in effect today constitute the basis for the successful one national program and have been in place since 2012,” Nichols said. “They have been fully incorporated into auto company planning, and automakers are already meeting these rules with a fleet that is growing cleaner, safer and more efficient. There is no justification in law or in fact for the current de-regulatory proposal as our extensive comments clearly demonstrate.”

The current Clean Car Standards require appropriate and feasible reductions in fuel economy and greenhouse gas emissions from passenger cars and light trucks. These standards save consumers money, reduce harmful carbon emissions and help protect the health of Americans.

In fact, the current rule is expected to prevent up to 2,000 premature deaths, 50,000 cases of respiratory ailments and reduce asthma symptoms for 24 million Americans, including 6.3 million children. It is also estimated to save the average consumer $1,620 over the lifetime of a car or truck.

Additionally, the standards promote technological innovation, as well as research and development – supporting thousands of American jobs.

The Trump Administration’s proposal would throw out these standards – which are supported by scientific research and technical analysis (including EPA’s own extensive study) – in favor of a proposal that requires no vehicle fuel economy or GHG emissions improvements for a period of at least six years.

In addition, the proposal unlawfully attempts to revoke California’s long-standing authority to manage its own more stringent GHG standards and its successful zero-emission vehicle (ZEV) program, putting millions of Californians – and Americans across the country – at risk.

This proposal poses significant harm to consumers, public health, the economy and the environment. It would degrade air quality and put millions of additional tons of climate-disrupting pollution into the atmosphere, while costing consumers billions of dollars in additional gasoline to operate less efficient vehicles.

The EPA and NHTSA’s plan also blatantly disregards pleas from the scientific community, businesses and world leaders to curb GHG emissions and provide leadership for continued innovation and job growth in advanced technologies.

Experts have warned that rolling back protections such as the Clean Car Standards would aggressively accelerate global warming with wide-ranging consequences, including temperature increases, ocean warming, sea level rise, increased hospitalizations and mortality, stress and die-off of animal and plant species, extreme weather events, famine, drought and forced human migration.

The comments submitted Friday include a letter from 21 attorneys general and the cities of Oakland, Los Angeles, San Francisco and New York as well as more than 400 pages of analysis from CARB identifying important reasons why the proposal is both unlawful and flawed, runs counter to the evidence and should be immediately withdrawn.

Specifically, the federal proposal:

* Ignores overwhelming scientific consensus that immediate and continual progress toward a near-zero emission economy by mid-century is necessary to avoid irreversible and catastrophic climate change impacts;
* Requires little or no progress on GHG emission standards or fuel economy for a period of six years, replacing technically feasible standards requiring significant reductions in emissions and fuel consumption;
* Threatens public health and welfare, including worsening smog and toxic exposure;
* Grossly inflates the costs of compliance using outdated models and incorrect engineering assumptions about both gasoline-powered and electric-drive automobiles;
* Relies on flawed technical analyses, including illogical assumptions about how consumers buy and keep cars, along with a host of unsupported assumptions about why people will purportedly drive longer in older cars under the existing standards;
* Depends on a flawed safety analysis that incorrectly and unreliably predicts more fatalities under the existing standards;
* Draws conclusions about the available technology – and capacity to develop technology – that are not based on reasonable inferences or technical expertise;
* Fails to fully disclose the extent to which jobs and competitive advantage in the world will be lost;
* Violates numerous important procedural requirements, and is based on an illegitimate mid-term evaluation based on unsound evidence and data;
* Violates the Clean Air Act by increasing GHG emissions the agency is tasked to reduce; and
* Violates NHTSA’s duty to promote energy efficiency and conservation and is contrary to the Energy Policy Conservation Act.

The comments also note that NHTSA’s proposed finding that California’s emissions standards are preempted is unfounded and has already been rejected by two federal courts; EPA’s proposal to revoke parts of California’s Advanced Clean Cars waiver is contrary to statute and long-standing agency practice, and is unsupported by either facts or the law; and the proposal is an unlawful assault on the ability of California to retain the standards it designed and adopted specifically to protect Californians and could deprive other states of the ability to choose between the federal standards and California’s standards.

To date, 12 other states have adopted these standards.

Background
In 2010, the EPA, NHTSA, CARB and car manufacturers established a unified national program harmonizing GHG emission standards and fuel efficiency standards. Two years later, the agencies extended the national program to model years 2017-2025 vehicles. As part of the program, California and the federal agencies agreed to undertake a mid-term evaluation to determine if the greenhouse gas emission standards for model years 2022-2025 vehicles should be maintained or revised.

In January 2017, the EPA completed the midterm evaluation by issuing a final determination, affirming that the existing standards were appropriate and would not be changed. The EPA arrived at this conclusion based on an extensive record it developed in conjunction with NHTSA and CARB. CARB also confirmed in March 2017 that its Advanced Clean Cars standards, which are part of the national program, remained appropriate and feasible.

On April 13, 2018, however, the Trump Administration took a significant step toward dismantling the national program when it issued a revised final determination that alleged the federal greenhouse gas standards for model year 2022-2025 vehicles were no longer appropriate. The administration failed to provide any appropriate or relevant evidence for its arbitrary and capricious revision of its previous midterm evaluation. Leading a coalition of 17 states and the District of Columbia, Governor Brown, Attorney General Becerra and CARB sued the EPA on May 1, 2018, over the Trump Administration’s April 13 action.

On August 24, 2018, the Trump Administration made its rollback proposal official. In place of commonsense standards to increase vehicle fuel efficiency and reduce GHG emissions, as federal law requires, the administration moved to freeze the standards at the 2020 level through model year 2026. The administration’s proposal would likely also block many other states that use California standards from moving forward. The day of the Trump Administration’s announcement, California Governor Brown, California Attorney General Becerra and CARB Chair Nichols voiced their strong opposition. The attorneys general of Connecticut, Maryland, New Jersey, Virginia and the District of Columbia did the same.

On September 24, 2018, at a public hearing in Fresno, California, Attorney General Becerra along with CARB Chair Nichols, Cal EPA Secretary Matt Rodriquez and other California state leaders provided testimony to EPA and NHTSA officials on the importance of the current standards and criticized the agencies’ failure to uphold the law.

The car industry is currently on track to meet or exceed existing Clean Car Standards. The federal Clean Air Act of 1970 preserves California’s authority to set its own stricter-than-federal vehicle emissions regulations to address the state’s extraordinary air quality challenges, because it had vehicle air quality regulations on its books predating the Clean Air Act and the creation of the federal EPA. Since the late 1960s, CARB has adopted, implemented and enforced a wide array of nation-leading air pollution controls, based on a strong foundation of science and reflecting a longstanding partnership with federal air quality regulators. Its pollution control strategies have proven to be a model for other states, the nation and other countries.

The ability of other states to adopt California’s strict vehicle emission standards, under specified conditions, is explicitly written into section 177 of the Clean Air Act.

A copy of the letter from the 21 attorneys general and the cities of Oakland, Los Angeles, San Francisco and New York as well as CARB’s analysis, both submitted Friday, can be found here and here.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

2 Comments

  1. Denny NNWofLA says:

    Once again California leads the way despite the current administration’s efforts to take us backward. Anyone else remember when outdoor incinerators were common place in people’s yards?
    How about leaded gas?
    I, for one, am not willing to go back to breathing poisoned air no matter how much profit goes to polluters.
    Vote for a progressive agenda on Nov. 6th. That excludes Mr. Knight!

  2. LOIS THOMPSON HICKS says:

    look at the cities you are comparing the whole state to la,nyc,oakland,san fran. these are some of the biggest cities you can find. every day working people work hard to get out of debt but you seem to want to keep us living from paycheck to paycheck. we depend on our cars and trucks for a living so it is a relief to get them paid off. we have to take good care of them so they last longer and no more payments. regs are fine right now and ca doesn’t have to push other states to follow suit.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Wednesday, Feb 8, 2023
Assemblywoman Schiavo Announces First Bill Package; Focus on Homelessness
Assemblywoman Pilar Schiavo introduced a package of three bills focused on critical issues to help solve our homelessness crisis.
Wednesday, Feb 8, 2023
Senator Wilk Coauthors Early Prisoner Release Accountability Measure
Sen. Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, announced today he’s coauthoring a bill to bring much-needed accountability and transparency to the prisoner early release process.
Wednesday, Feb 8, 2023
Wednesday COVID Roundup:  Santa Clarita Daily Count Adds 20 Cases
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health today confirmed 18 new deaths throughout L.A. County, 1,105 new cases countywide and 20 new cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1971, 6:01 a.m. - Sylmar/San Fernando Earthquake centered in Iron Canyon/Sand Canyon [WATCH FILM]
1971 earthquake film
The Master's men's volleyball team has made history ranking No. 1 in the most recent NAIA Men's Volleyball Top 15 Poll
The Master’s University Men’s Volleyball Ranks No. 1 In The Nation
The Valley Industry Association is returning their Cocktails & Conversations program later this month with Sheriff's Captain Justin Diez. 
Feb. 21: VIA Cocktails & Conversation, An Evening with Captain Justin Diez
The LA County Department of Economic Opportunity was selected to participate in the second phase of Results for America's Good Jobs & Equity Project, backed by the Families and Workers Fund, which will help 12 communities implement innovative job quality strategies that promote economic mobility and strengthen local economies.
Los Angeles County Selected to Advance in National Initiative to Boost High-Quality Jobs
Assemblywoman Pilar Schiavo introduced a package of three bills focused on critical issues to help solve our homelessness crisis.
Assemblywoman Schiavo Announces First Bill Package; Focus on Homelessness
Sen. Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, announced today he’s coauthoring a bill to bring much-needed accountability and transparency to the prisoner early release process.
Senator Wilk Coauthors Early Prisoner Release Accountability Measure
Get your tickets! The Cube, Ice and Entertainment Center, Powered by FivePoint Valencia is excited to host the 2023 West Coast Hockey Conference.
The Cube To Host West Coast Hockey Conference
Los Angeles County Parks is hiring. This Spring, Parks and Rec is looking to employ local L.A. County Youth with an entry level job that pays more than minimum wage, $16.04, and allows them to work at their local LA County Park.
L.A. County Parks is Hiring Youth For Spring Jobs
The countdown is on, in just one year, Sun Princess, the newest Princess Cruises ship will debut in the Mediterranean.
Debut of New Sun Princess Just One Year Away,  Inaugural Team Announced
In partnership with the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station, the city of Santa Clarita is proud to announce the release of LioLi (LEE-OH-LEE), the new and improved Lock It or Lose It theft prevention system.
City Launches New Lock it or Lose it Campaign This Spring
The CSUN Softball team opens its 46th season at the SDSU Season Kickoff Feb. 9-11. This concludes the 2023 preview with the Matadors' outfield and a look at CSUN's opponents.
CSUN Softball Preview: The Outfield, The Schedule
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health today confirmed 18 new deaths throughout L.A. County, 1,105 new cases countywide and 20 new cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Wednesday COVID Roundup:  Santa Clarita Daily Count Adds 20 Cases
1990 - Rock 'n' Roller Del Shannon, whose hit "Runaway" topped the charts in April 1961, found dead at home in Sand Canyon [story]
Del Shannon
The Santa Clarita Valley Man & Woman of the year committee has released the names and nominating SCV nonprofit organizations for the 2023 SCV Man & Woman of the Year.
Nominations Released for 2023 SCV Man, Woman of the Year
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health today confirmed 14 new deaths throughout L.A. County, 1,103 new cases countywide and 27 new cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Tuesday COVID Roundup: L.A. County Remains in Low Community Level
The SCV Education Foundation is excited to announce it will be hosting the Inaugural Sweet Side of Education Chocolate Walk on Saturday, May 13 in Old Town Newhall from 2 p.m. to 5 p.m.
May 13: SCV Education Foundation’s  Inaugural Sweet Side of Education Chocolate Walk
Four weeks after declaring a local emergency on homelessness, the Los Angeles Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a $609.7 million budget for the Los Angeles County Homeless Initiative for fiscal year 2023-24, the largest investment in any given year to date to prevent and address homelessness.
Supes Approve Largest-Ever One-Year Spending Plan of $609.7M to Address Homelessness
Opera legend Shigemi Matsumoto and her husband Marty Stark have donated nearly $1.5 million to the music program at California State University, Northridge. The university is naming a recital hall in her honor.
CSUN Recital Hall to be Named in Honor of Opera Legend Shigemi Matsumoto
American Sports Entertainment Company and the Los Angeles Kings, collectively referred to as JV Ice at The Cube, are seeking proposals for the operation of retail space at The Cube – Ice and Entertainment Center, Powered by FivePoint Valencia, located at 27745 Smyth Drive in Santa Clarita.
The Cube Seeks Pro Shop Partner
DFYinSCV will present a "Social Media Safety" online Workshop Wednesday, Feb. 8 from 6 p.m. to 7 p.m.
Feb. 8: DFYinSCV Presents ‘Social Media Safety’ Virtual Workshop
Spring is the perfect time to take advantage of document shredding services in Santa Clarita. Mark your calendars for Saturday, March 18, for a free drive-thru document shredding event, which will be held at the Via Princessa Metrolink Station, 19201 Via Princessa, Santa Clarita, CA 91321, from 9 a.m. – 1 p.m.
March 18: Drive-thru Shredding Event Requires Pre-registration
The Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce today announced their 2022 businesses award recipients who will be honored at the Centennial Celebration Awards + Installation on Thursday, Feb. 23, at the Canyon Country Community Center.
SCV Chamber Announces Business Choice Award Honorees
1919 - First publication of weekly Newhall Signal newspaper, $2 a year [story]
Signal Century
It was the most anticipated event on the campus.
Stanford Hands TMU Volleyball First Loss of Season
SCVNews.com
%d bloggers like this: