header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
February 7
1919 - First publication of weekly Newhall Signal newspaper, $2 a year [story]
Signal Century


csun-logoThe sexual revolution has seen women progress from the secretarial pool to being presidents of corporations and universities. While there is still room for improvement, women are making inroads in fields never thought possible just decades ago, except in a few areas — including the building trades.

A recent study by California State University, Northridge sociology professor Amy Denissen and her colleague Abigail Saguy, a sociology professor at UCLA, found that a combination of gendered homophobia and sexist stereotypes have kept the numbers of women to less than 2 percent of those working in the construction industry.

Amy Denissen

Amy Denissen

“There are two stages where women encounter obstacles in their ability to get a job, and then maintain that job and progress in their profession,” Denissen said. “The first is at the point of entry, when they face sex discrimination in hiring. In construction, women who are applying for a job have been told, ‘you are not going to be hired because you are a woman.’

“The second stage is the woman’s ability to stay on a job,” she continued. “This is where sexual harassment, withheld training, the lack of support or mentoring from their male colleagues and other ways of excluding women impede a woman’s ability to progress or remain in the field.”

For their study, “Gendered Homophobia and the Contradictions of Workplace Discrimination for Women in the Building Trades,” Denissen and Saguy interviewed 63 tradeswomen to examine how cultural meanings of sexual orientation — as well as gender presentation, race and body size — affected a woman’s ability to work in the construction industry.

Demonstrating the salience of gender at work, this sheet metal worker's tool is engraved with a flower, rather than the tradewoman's initials, as tradesmen traditionally do for each other. Photo courtesy of Amy Denissen.

Demonstrating the salience of gender at work, this sheet metal worker’s tool is engraved with a flower, rather than the tradewoman’s initials, as tradesmen traditionally do for each other. Photo courtesy of Amy Denissen.

Demonstrating the salience of gender at work, this sheet metal worker’s tool is engraved with a flower, rather than the tradewoman’s initials as tradesmen traditionally do for each other. Photo courtesy of Amy Denissen.

Denissen said one of the most significant stereotypes is that if a woman wants to work in construction, the assumption is often made that she is a lesbian, regardless of her true sexual orientation, and she regularly faces homophobic and sexist remarks at work.
“Tradeswomen told me they would avoid other women on the job site to prevent homophobic remarks and discrimination from coworkers,” Denissen said. “Many of the women said that even if they could handle the harassment, they didn’t want to put other tradeswomen at risk.”

The homophobia is so pervasive that some male construction workers discourage their female colleagues from networking with other tradeswomen or attending tradeswomen support groups or conferences “because it’s a bunch of lesbians.”

“According to the tradeswomen I interviewed, there is a lot of homophobia in the

construction industry,” Denissen said. “While some if it is banter between straight men, it

can create a hostile climate and a lot of gay and lesbian women do not feel safe and are pressured to stay in the closet for their safety.

“It’s a burden that they carry with them at all times,” she added. “Construction work is not easy and, regardless of your gender, it requires you to be vigilant at all times to ensure your safety and that of those around you. When you add that additional layer of sexual harassment and homophobia, the pressures are even worse.”

Within that homophobic stereotype lies a contradiction for those women who hope to stay in the industry and succeed.

“For some tradesmen, if a woman is masculine presenting — whether straight or lesbian — such as women who look ‘butch’ or tomboyish, then the men were more willing to treat her like ‘one of the guys’ under the presumption that this was a woman who wanted to be a guy and do guy things,” Denissen said. “But at the same time, other men would call them ‘freaks’ for violating the gender norms and subject them to homophobic harassment.”

The study found that women who are more feminine presenting face other obstacles. They are subjected to more sexual harassment, as well as assumptions that they were incompetent and given stereotypical tasks such as sweeping or cleaning up the worksite. However, male colleagues sometimes see them as “sisters or daughters” and take them under their wing.

“Women never know what they are going to face on the job site, and it’s complicated for women to prepare themselves for the variety of reactions from their coworkers” Denissen said.

Denissen noted that in all the conversations she had with tradeswomen, none of them could point to a single male colleague who was openly gay.

“As hard as it is for them, they said it was too dangerous for an openly gay man to work in the industry,” she said.

Denissen pointed out that in the late 1970s, women made up 7 percent of apprentices in the construction industry. It was during a time when Executive Order 11246 was extended to enforce affirmative action standards for women in the building trades. But by the 1980s, support for those standards waned, and women in the construction industry had little recourse in trying to fight harassment and discrimination. As a result, women’s numbers in the industry have declined.

“First and foremost, if we enforced the laws we already have, we’d see a big improvement for women in the construction industry,” Denissen said. “Next, we need to strengthen laws that have been weakened over the years regarding protections for workers.

“What’s really encouraging is that tradeswomen are forging ahead despite the pressures they face at work, forming their own support and networking groups,” she continued. “And there are more tradesmen who are willing be mentors and advocates for women. With greater enforcement of the law and more men stepping up to combat discrimination and harassment in the industry, the true progress can be made.”

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


HIGHER EDUCATION LINKS
LOCAL COLLEGE HEADLINES
Thursday, Feb 6, 2025
The California Institute of the Arts Patty Disney Center for Life and Work will be hosting a Valentines pop-up market noon-4 p.m. Thursday, Feb. 13 at CalArts, 24700 McBean Parkway, Santa Clarita, CA 91355.
Wednesday, Feb 5, 2025
Steven Leigh Morris, founding editor of "Stage Raw," curated his list of the 10 best Los Angeles theater productions of 2024. Among them were three shows that featured the creative talents of California Institue of the Arts alumni and faculty.
Wednesday, Feb 5, 2025
The Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business has granted California State University Northridge’s David Nazarian College of Business and Economics supplementary accreditation for its accounting program.
Wednesday, Feb 5, 2025
California State University, Northridge is celebrating Black History Month with a variety of events that highlight Black achievements and provide advice on how to navigate the workforce. 
Wednesday, Feb 5, 2025
Members of California State University Northridge’s Jazz “A” Band are getting a rare opportunity next month to perform alongside acclaimed artist and jazz pianist Jason Moran as they explore the music of jazz great Duke Ellington.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1919 - First publication of weekly Newhall Signal newspaper, $2 a year [story]
Signal Century
Autonomous vehicles under testing permits have collectively covered over 4 million miles on California’s public roads from Dec. 1, 2023, to Nov. 30, 2024, the California Department of Motor Vehicles has announced.
Over 4M Test Miles Logged in State by Autonomous Vehicles
Federal, state and local agencies will come together to host an informative webinar, "Understanding Air Quality After the L.A. Fires" on air quality impacts in the wake of the Los Angeles wildfires.
Feb. 10: Understanding Air Quality After the L.A. Fires
The Santa Clarita College of the Canyons Performing Arts Center will host singer and musician, John Waite, 8 p.m. Friday, Feb. 21 at 26455 Rockwell Canyon Road, Santa Clarita, CA 91355.
Feb. 21: Santa Clarita PAC Presents Singer John Waite
Maginns Pub is hosting a Valentine's Day five-course farm-to-table Irish Pub style dinner Friday, Feb. 14, at 24480 Main St., #140, Santa Clarita, CA 91321.
Feb. 14: Maginns Pub Valentine’s Day Farm-to-Table Dinner
The American Cancer Society Relay For Life of Santa Clarita Valley invites cancer survivors and caregivers to the 2025 Survivor and Caregiver Celebration Dinner, 5 p.m, Saturday, March 1 at at the Canyon Country Community Center, 18410 Sierra Highway, Santa Clarita, CA, 91351.
March 1: ACS Relay For Life Survivor Celebration Dinner
Santa Clarita Public Libraries are looking for volunteers for its Tween Spring Clean-Up beginning 8:45 a.m.- 12:45 p.m. Sunday, Feb. 16 at Valencia Library, with other volunteer opportunities Sundays, March 2 and 9.
Feb. 16: Libraries Looking for Volunteers for Tween Spring Clean-Up
The California Institute of the Arts Patty Disney Center for Life and Work will be hosting a Valentines pop-up market noon-4 p.m. Thursday, Feb. 13 at CalArts, 24700 McBean Parkway, Santa Clarita, CA 91355.
Feb. 13: CalArts Valentines Artisan Market
Join Los Angeles County parks as they celebrates Black History Month. From Feb. 13–28, the parks invite you to honor the achievements, contributions and resilience of black Americans through an exciting lineup of workshops, art exhibits, music, storytelling and community events.
Feb. 13-28: Celebrate Black History Month at L.A. County Parks
As a longtime Santa Clarita resident, I believe one of our community’s most important responsibilities is the preservation of our rich history and beautiful open spaces.
Laurene Weste | Stepping Back into History at William S. Hart Park
Quincy Phillips had a career-high 37 points to lead The Master's University men's basketball team to a 95-69 win over the Park-Gilbert Buccaneers Wednesday night, Feb. 5 in The MacArthur Center.
Phillips Leads TMU over Buccaneers
The Master's University baseball team continued its impressive start to the season with a 9-5 win over Cedarville University at Lou Herwaldt Stadium in Santa Clarita Wednesday afternoon, Feb. 5.
Mustangs Keep Yellow Jackets at Bay
Four players scored in double figures as The Master's University women's basketball team avenged an earlier conference loss to the Park-Gilbert Buccaneers with a 99-89 win Wednesday night, Feb. 5 in The MacArthur Center.
TMU Comes from Behind for Conference Win
1988 - Saugus Speedway owners demolish historic Bonelli Ranch House [story]
Bonelli House
Steven Leigh Morris, founding editor of "Stage Raw," curated his list of the 10 best Los Angeles theater productions of 2024. Among them were three shows that featured the creative talents of California Institue of the Arts alumni and faculty.
CalArtians in ‘Stage Raw’s’ Top 10 L.A. Theater Productions of 2024
Applications for the 2025 Virginia Wrage Memorial Scholarship are now available from the Zonta Club of Santa Clarita Valley.
Zonta of SCV Wrage Scholarship Applications Available
Hockey fans, get ready! The Cube, Ice and Entertainment Center, Powered by FivePoint Valencia, is excited to welcome back the 2025 West Coast Hockey Conference Playoffs.
Feb. 9: The Cube Hosts 2025 West Coast Hockey Conference Playoffs
Interested members of the public are invited to the Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency’s Water Resources and Watershed Committee meeting on Feb. 12, 2025.
Feb. 12: SCV Water Agency Water Resources,Watershed Meeting
The Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business has granted California State University Northridge’s David Nazarian College of Business and Economics supplementary accreditation for its accounting program.
CSUN’s Nazarian College Receives Dual Accreditation
The Department of Animal Care and Control has announced that the Castaic Animal Care Center has reopened its doors to the community after a temporary closure due to the recent Hughes Fire on Jan. 22.
Castaic Animal Care Center Reopens Following Temporary Closure Due to the Hughes Fire
California State University, Northridge is celebrating Black History Month with a variety of events that highlight Black achievements and provide advice on how to navigate the workforce. 
CSUN Celebrates Black Success During Black History Month
Los Angeles County Sheriff's Homicide investigators are responding to a death investigation.
LASD Homicide Bureau Responding to a Death Investigation, 21000 Nandina Lane, Newhall
Members of California State University Northridge’s Jazz “A” Band are getting a rare opportunity next month to perform alongside acclaimed artist and jazz pianist Jason Moran as they explore the music of jazz great Duke Ellington.
Feb. 13: CSUN Jazz “A” Band to Perform with Jason Moran
1921 - After leasing since 1918, William S. Hart purchases the Horseshoe Ranch in Newhall from Babcock Smith [story]
Hart ranch
SCVNews.com