header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
September 28
1987 - Slender-horned spineflower listed in Federal Register as endangered species [story] Slender-horned spineflower

| Friday, Aug 14, 2020
The seal of the Judicial Council of California, the policymaking body of the California courts. | Photo: Judicial Council of California (via YouTube).


By a vote of 19-1 on Thursday, the Judicial Council repealed emergency orders suspending foreclosures and unlawful detainer actions in California’s courts, leaving lawmakers just a few weeks to enact legal protections to avert an impending flood of evictions for unpaid rent when the moratorium is officially lifted on Sept. 1.

“This is good news. It gives us just enough time to pass a bill so there’s not a gap in eviction protections. We can breathe a very brief sigh of relief,” Assemblymember David Chiu, D-San Francisco, said just after the council’s vote Thursday. “But the work is far from over. Potentially millions of Californians are facing eviction.”

Governor Gavin Newsom gave Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye and the council she chairs unprecedented authority in March to adopt emergency rules in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Among other rules it passed in April, the council voted to stay all pending judicial foreclosure actions and prohibit courts from entering default entries or issuing summonses to tenants in unlawful detainer cases — effectively stopping evictions from moving through the court system.

But this week, Cantil-Sakauye made it clear that the time has come to turn that responsibility over to the other two branches of government.

“The judicial branch cannot usurp the responsibility of the other two branches on a long-term basis to deal with the myriad impacts of the pandemic,” she said. “The duty of the judicial branch is to resolve disputes under the law and not to legislate. I urge our sister branches to act expeditiously to resolve this looming crisis.”

While that crisis is not unique — a recent nationwide report says 30-40 million Americans are at risk of eviction — it is particularly acute in California, a state already burdened with rampant homelessness and dearth of affordable housing.

A study by the Terner Center for Housing Innovation at UC Berkeley notes that as of June, 1 million renter households in California have suffered a job loss because of the pandemic’s resulting economic downturn. A model developed by the Aspen Institute predicts that 3.6 million Californians will be at risk of eviction by the end of September, more than any other state in the country.

Another particularly sobering study by a team of UCLA researchers led by law professor emeritus Gary Blasi estimated that with no income, 365,000 renter households in Los Angeles County alone are in immediate danger of eviction. “No one can say when the tsunami of evictions will arrive,” the researchers wrote. “We can say that it is coming.”

In an interview, anti-poverty lawyer and USC Gould School of Law professor Clare Pastore said the “greatest dislocation of families since the Great Depression” is looming.

“It’s truly frightening, and everyone is grappling with what to do about it,” Pastore said. “The pressure is really on the Legislature to act.”

Pastore said the state’s looming eviction crisis is bound up in many factors: a chronic housing shortage, a vast number of people already devoting more of than 30% of their monthly income on rent, and the recent lapse of federal unemployment benefits that had helped renters nationwide make their rent payments in April, May, and June.

“It’s disgraceful that Congress has not acted to prolong expanded unemployment benefits,” she said.

As congressional infighting over another round of pandemic relief drags on, California lawmakers are desperate to ease the financial burden on both tenants and landlords.

Two bills are currently being debated in the state Assembly and Senate. Chiu is the author of Assembly Bill 1436, which bans landlords from evicting tenants for unpaid rent until April 1, 2021, or 90 days after the Covid-19 state of emergency ends, whichever happens first.

Chiu said AB 1436 encourages landlords and tenants to negotiate payment agreements, and while it also prohibits late fees or the application of security deposits to rental debt, property owners will be allowed to sue tenants for unpaid rent in 2022.

“Eviction isn’t a useful way to resolve the issue of unpaid back rent,” he said. “Unlawful detainers really exist to return property back to landlords. The bill says tenants shouldn’t be evicted simply because they can’t immediately pay back rent. We want to give tenants a period of time to earn and save the money to pay it back, but remove eviction as a remedy. The long-term remedy is civil actions.”

The bill also allows property owners to request 12 months of mortgage forbearance for single-family homes and buildings under four units, similar to the 12 months offered by the federal CARES Act. Owners of larger properties can request six months of forbearance.

“We have heard from struggling landlords who would be impacted by their tenants’ inability to pay rent that they were facing mortgage foreclosures,” Chiu said, noting the CARES Act only applies to federally backed mortgages while AB 1436 will authorize all California property owners to seek forbearance. “We think our mortgage forbearance provisions would squarely assist smaller property owners.”

But Chiu’s measure faces resistance from landlord groups who say it doesn’t do enough to help small property owners facing foreclosure.

Debra Carlton, the California Apartment Association’s executive vice president for state public affairs, said AB 1436 does not require tenants to submit any declaration of financial hardship caused by Covid-19. “It encourages people not to pay rent,” she said.

Chiu said it was true that the initial bill did not have a proof of hardship requirement. It has since been amended, he said, to require renters to attest to financial distress from the pandemic.

Carlton said landlords would agree that evictions are not the best way to recover unpaid rent, but many will not be able to wait years to sue tenants in civil court.

“It’s in nobody’s interest for there to be evictions going forward. The landlord isn’t going to get the money, and it’s expensive and time consuming. she said. “What we would rather see is some sort of financing structure system so landlords and tenants can have the money to pay the rent.”

Under AB 1436, she said, landlords would not be able to evict nonpaying tenants until 2022. “That means landlords will go without money for two years. A rational person can see that won’t work,” Carlton said.

Another proposal authored by state Senator Anna Caballero, D-Salinas, will give landlords sellable tax credits to cover rent losses while offering tenants more time to repay rental debt and ask for rent reduction or forgiveness depending on their income. Senate Bill 1410 also suspends evictions for tenants who have signed a “Covid-19 eviction relief agreement” with their landlord.

Critics have said that allowing the sale of tax credits to third parties doesn’t guarantee enough income to alleviate the financial stress on small landlords, who would also be unable to redeem the credits until 2024

The Assembly Judiciary Committee took up Caballero’s bill Wednesday, but legislators still have quite a few wrinkles to iron out regarding the tenant repayment structure, the enforcement of landlord-tenant agreements, and the bill’s various tax implications.

The Apartment Association does not back the bill but is asking for major amendments. But it is the only bill they say that provides dollars for landlords, so they are working with the Senate.

“While larger owners may be able to last until 2024, for small owners who have less than 16 units there’s no way they’ll be able to make it until 2024,” Carlton said. “You lose half of your rent and you’re doomed, especially if you have a mortgage. We’re getting calls from people in their 70s and 80s. This is their retirement. They’re living on this money.”

Carlton said the Apartment Association would like legislation that includes direct financial relief for small landlords. “If there were provisions that gave money to small owners for whom there’s no way they can make it much longer, that would certainly be something we could support,” she said. “It’s just about where’s the money going to come from.”

But Chiu said the state is in dire financial straits.

“The problem is our state has a $54 billion budget deficit and we are required to balance our budget,” Chiu said. “So we literally have no money in our piggy bank.” He said it makes more sense to give monetary relief to tenants so they can pay their landlords.

Pastore agreed landlords face immense pressure. “I’m not unsympathetic to the plight of landlords,” she said. “This is landlords’ income too. Lots of people like to think of big, bad, greedy landlords but there are many mom-and-pop landlords facing desperate times without income from tenants. This dwarfs the 2008 recession.”

But she said landlords would be more immediately helped by legislation to help tenants pay rent rather than through unlawful detainer actions that simply free a property to be rented to someone else.

“Particularly in a pandemic, it is important to protect the landlords’ ability to receive some income if possible or receive it at a later date, but I don’t know that allowing the landlords to evict people is so important because where are they going to get other tenants?” Pastore said. “It’s not clear that the number of tenants displaced by Covid can be replaced by tenants who can pay. We need rent relief and we need a restoration of that federal unemployment extra benefit.”

Pointing out another complication, Pastore said tenants will likely need lawyers to help them navigate new proposed rules on evictions.

She said despite commendable government actions to protect tenants, “They’re often very complicated and not at all straightforward about what to do. We have a desperate need for lawyers to help more people in the housing context.”

Chiu said he is also concerned about the lack of legal representation for tenants trying to negotiate repayment agreements with landlords.

“One of the issues I’m considering is how to ensure that whatever likely complicated new rules that are put in place under which tenants and landlords work things out, we want to make sure that tenants have the ability to understand and defend their rights.”

— By Maria Dinzeo, CNS

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

1 Comment

  1. Mark Wheeler says:

    Gee, maybe people must PAY RENT and stop robbing landlords.
    If you want to prevent evictions, then YOU PAY THEIR RENT.

Leave a Comment

SCV NewsBreak
Monday, Sep 28, 2020
Unemployment: Wilk Urges Governor to Hit ‘Start,’ Not ‘Pause’ on EDD
Senator Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, advocating for the thousands of constituents still in the queue waiting for their unemployment benefits, is urging Governor Gavin Newsom to rethink a two-week pause on new EDD claims.
Monday, Sep 28, 2020
Hart District Won’t Reopen Schools in October
William S. Hart Union High School District officials announced Sunday Santa Clarita Valley public junior highs and high schools will not reopen in October, pushing the potential timeline for partial reopening to Nov. 13.
Monday, Sep 28, 2020
Newsom Signs Bills Strengthening LGBTQ+ Protections
Governor Gavin Newsom signed a series of bills into law Saturday, strengthening protections for LGBTQ+ Californians.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
The city of Santa Clarita’s Film Office reports a busy slate of production activity in the Santa Clarita Valley this week, September 28-October 4.
Busy Slate of Productions This Week in SCV
The Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce on Monday announced the launch of a forum for small business owners -- the Small Business Roundtable.
SCV Chamber to Launch Monthly Roundtable for Small Business Owners
Senator Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, advocating for the thousands of constituents still in the queue waiting for their unemployment benefits, is urging Governor Gavin Newsom to rethink a two-week pause on new EDD claims.
Unemployment: Wilk Urges Governor to Hit ‘Start,’ Not ‘Pause’ on EDD
William S. Hart Union High School District officials announced Sunday Santa Clarita Valley public junior highs and high schools will not reopen in October, pushing the potential timeline for partial reopening to Nov. 13.
Hart District Won’t Reopen Schools in October
Governor Gavin Newsom signed a series of bills into law Saturday, strengthening protections for LGBTQ+ Californians.
Newsom Signs Bills Strengthening LGBTQ+ Protections
California Governor Gavin Newsom took action Sunday on several bills that continue the state’s long-standing leadership as a state of inclusion and refuge.
Newsom Acts on Bills to Support California’s Immigrant, Refugee Communities
1987 - Slender-horned spineflower listed in Federal Register as endangered species [story] Slender-horned spineflower
2014 - Towsley Canyon Loop Trail named for naturalist Don Mullally [story]
Don Mullally
1876 - California oil industry born as CSO No. 4 in Pico Canyon becomes state's first commercially productive oil well [story]
Pico No. 4
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Friday 34 new deaths and 1,401 new cases of COVID-19, with 6,048 total cases in the Santa Clarita Valley, while Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital reported its 24th COVID-related death to date.
Friday COVID-19 Roundup: 24th Death at Henry Mayo; SCV Surpasses 6,000 Total Cases
Air quality in the Santa Clarita Valley will be unhealthy for sensitive groups/individuals Saturday, Sept. 26, according to the South Coast Air Quality Management District (AQMD) forecast.
Air Quality Advisory Issued for SCV
With temperatures in parts of Los Angeles County expected to rise into the triple digits, various public facilities located throughout the County, including Stevenson Ranch Library, will serve as Emergency Cooling Centers.
Stevenson Ranch Library to Serve as Emergency Cooling Center
The 2020 census is underway and it is your civic duty to participate, but beware of scammers using this opportunity to steal your personal information.
Residents Warned of 2020 Census Scam
The Parks, Recreation and Community Services Commission will hold a virtual study session via Zoom, Thursday, Oct 1, at 4:00 p.m.
Oct. 1: Parks, Recreation & Community Services Commission Study Session
Foster youth in Santa Clarita have a new, dedicated place to study and receive homework help and tutoring. The local Fostering Youth Independence (FYI) organization has created The Study Place in response to the transition to online learning due to the Covid-19 pandemic.
FYI Debuts New ‘Study Place’ for Local Foster Youth to Support Online Learning
As part of State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond’s Education to End Hate initiative, California school districts and charter schools have begun applying for mini-grants now available to support educator training in the areas of anti-racism and bias.
Thurmond Announces Mini Grants Available to Provide Anti-Racism, Anti-Bias Educator Training
A crash involving multiple motorcycles Friday afternoon prompted a SigAlert on the southbound lanes of Interstate 5 in the Stevenson Ranch area, according to first responders.
Multi-Motorycle Crash Prompts SigAlert on SB I-5
With the 2020 SCV Walk to End Alzheimer’s quickly approaching on Saturday, October 3, the planning committee and the California Southland Chapter Alzheimer’s Association would like to update everyone regarding the Walk Day events.
Oct. 3: 2020 Walk to End Alzheimer’s Presents Hybrid Event, Drive-By ‘Promise Flower’ Display
The city of Santa Clarita, in partnership with the National Recreation and Park Association (NRPA), is proud to announce it has received $40,000 from the Walt Disney Company to provide increased access to youth sports, play opportunities and physical activity for kids and families and is launching a new Pop-Up and Play Mobile Recreation Program.
City Receives Funding to Support Youth Sports, Access to Play
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has issued a Heat Alert for the Santa Clarita Valley beginning Sunday, Sept. 27 - Wednesday, Sept. 30.
Heat Alert Issued for SCV Beginning Sunday
Economic development services for arts-oriented small businesses, galleries and more are on the priority list for the 2021 Arts Commission Work Plan, a report Santa Clarita City Council members reviewed Tuesday.
City Council Reviews Priority List for 2021 Arts Commission Work Plan
The USDA Forest Service Pacific Southwest Region announces that current closure orders and fire prohibitions in California have been extended.
Forest Service Extends Closures at Angeles, Los Padres National Forests
SCV Water's Engineering and Operations Committee is scheduled to meet via teleconference on Thursday, Oct. 1, at 5:30 p.m.
Oct. 1: SCV Water’s Engineering & Operations Committee Teleconference Meeting
Valencia High Principal Pete Getz sent an alert out to the school’s families on Wednesday evening, regarding a report of a possible on-campus threat.
Possible On-Campus Threat Shuts Down Valencia High School
%d bloggers like this: