[CN] – A federal judge has blocked a California law that would tax trains — but not trucks — that carry hazardous materials, to pay for training and emergency responses to accidents involving the dangerous substances.
U.S. District Judge Richard Seeborg on Friday granted BNSF and Union Pacific Railways’ request for a preliminary injunction, finding the railroads likely to succeed on the merits of some of their arguments.
“The public interest does not weigh against such relief,” Seeborg wrote.
BNSF and Union Pacific sued the state in August, claiming Senate Bill 84 of 2015 unfairly forces railroads and their clients pay for emergency response and preparedness even though truck accidents are more frequent. The law required the railroads to be ready to collect the fees as of Oct. 1 this year.
Railroads were to charge $45 for each railcar carrying hazardous materials, such as ethanol and crude oil, loaded in or coming into California.
The railroads said the fee would drive away their business to truckers, and that only the federal government can regulate interstate railroads.
“California’s scheme will disserve the public interest, either by encouraging shippers to switch to riskier modes of transportation, or by simply discouraging interstate commerce in hazardous materials that are vital to the nation’s industrial and agricultural economy,” the railroads said in their lawsuit.
Seeborg found that California failed to show that charging railroads but not other forms of transportation complies with the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act. He noted that the fees could be used to pay for emergency responses to trucking accidents.
Seeborg agreed that the fee acts as a tax, supporting the railroads’ claim that the law is unfair under the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act.
“As the railroads point out, merely requiring reimbursement of equipment operating expenses does not excuse saddling the rail industry with the cost of acquiring equipment that very well could be used by the trucking industry as much or more than by the rail industry,” Seeborg wrote.
The railroads said the California Legislature rejected a similar law that would have charged rail and trucking companies a hazardous materials fee.
The state argued in opposition that a train can carry more hazardous material than a truck, making a train accident much more harmful. California also claimed that its emergency response system for trucking accidents with hazardous materials is adequate, but its emergency response system for rail accidents is not.
“The public’s interest in assessing a minimal fee designed to protect the shippers of hazardous materials by mitigating the damage caused by a spill clearly outweighs the potential harm caused by having to collect the fee,” the state said in its argument against the injunction.
But Seeborg found that the railroads showed that their business will take a hit if they’re required to collect the fees while the litigation continues.
“If the fees take effect and the law is later ruled invalid, the railroads have established that the fees will drive at least some business to trucking — damages that they will not be able to recover against the state,” Seeborg wrote.
BNSF is represented by Benjamin Horwich with Munger, Tolles and Olson; Union Pacific by Carol Thompson with Sidley Austin, both of San Francisco.
BNSF could not be reached for comment Friday evening.
A Union Pacific spokesman said the railroad had no comment.
Sen. Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, announced the introduction of Senate Joint Resolution 5, urging the federal government to immediately pass a correction to the Social Security formula to protect benefits for millions of Americans who turned 60 during the pandemic.
The Santa Clarita City Council will consider allocating a little over $3.5 million in federal funding intended to support low- and moderate-income residents with decent and affordable housing and economic opportunities.
After publicly expressing their support for hosting live graduations earlier this year, William S. Hart Union High School District officials outlined their proposed plans for the Class of 2021 ceremonies during their Wednesday night governing board meeting.
After plans fell through for a $100 million mall expansion that would have brought a second Costco to the Santa Clarita Valley, representatives from the big box retailer reached out to city officials to see if they could still make a second location a reality.
Nurses Week is underway and the Registered Nurse Response Network (RNRN) is calling on registered nurse volunteers to assist with Covid-19 vaccinations at the Kedren Community Health Center in partnership with International Medical Corps.
The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department announced it will begin a phased reopening of jail visitations at the Century Regional Detention Facility starting on Mother’s Day weekend, with all other locations predicted to reopen in June.
The L.A. County Financial Navigators program, operated by the Los Angeles County Department of Consumer and Business Affairs’ Center for Financial Empowerment in partnership with Cities for Financial Empowerment Fund, announced it is currently providing L.A. residents with free assistance to help them deal with the financial challenges brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic.
The city of Santa Clarita Human Relations Roundtable voiced strong support for the removal of the race-based “Indians” mascot at Hart High School in an open letter to the William S. Hart District School Board in alignment with the recently released statement of the Fernandeno Tataviam Band of Mission Indians.
The California Interscholastic Federation has renewed a multi-year agreement with GoFan as the official digital ticketing partner to provide touchless, digital ticketing solutions to high schools and state-wide post season play across California.
The County of Los Angeles announced Thursday that it has distributed 23 million units of free PPE through its joint effort with PPE Unite to protect 433,000 employees at small businesses across the County.
The Department of Public Social Services (DPSS) has launched its annual CalFresh Awareness Month campaign to publicize the CalFresh Nutrition Program and acknowledge community partners throughout the month of May for helping to raise public awareness year-round.