[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Santa Clarita CA
Mostly clear
Mostly clear
Today in
S.C.V. History
June 3
1855 - Ship leaves New York harbor bound for Tunis to acquire animals for the United States Camel Corps [story]
Camel Corps

SAN FRANCISCO – Three judges overseeing a long-running legal battle overcrowded and unsanitary conditions in state prisons will not allow the mass release of California inmates to mitigate the threat of a large-scale COVID-19 outbreak.

In a ruling released over the weekend, the panel of judges denied the inmates’ emergency motion to reduce the state prison population, saying the decision was not theirs to make.

The panel was originally convened in 2007 in response to two inmate lawsuits brought in 1990 and 2001 against the state for constitutionally inadequate medical care.

The panel determined at the time that the only way that California could live up to its constitutional obligations was to reduce the state prison population significantly, which it ordered the state to do by 137.5% of its design capacity.

The U.S. Supreme Court affirmed the population reduction order in a 2011 ruling that found overcrowding to be the main cause of the state’s failure to provide prisoners with adequate medical and mental health care.

In 2015, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation met the 137.5% population cap for the first time.

But the case took a new turn as the COVID-19 epidemic became ever more of a threat to the health and safety of inmates and prison staff.

On March 25, attorneys with the Prison Law Office filed an emergency motion to modify the population reduction order, requesting release of low-risk, non-violent prisoners.

At a telephonic hearing last week, attorneys Sara Norman and Donald Specter asked the panel to order the state to release as many inmates as necessary to allow remaining prisoners to stay six-feet away from each other.

“The conditions in the prisons are a tinderbox and will remain a tinderbox unless this court acts,” said attorney Donald Specter with the Prison Law Office, calling the persistent overcrowding “literally a matter of life and death.”

The panel, comprising U.S. District Judge Jon Tigar, U.S. District Judge Kimberly Mueller in Sacramento, and Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Kim Wardlaw, said its original population reduction order cannot apply to an unprecedented viral pandemic.

“That order was never intended to prepare defendants to confront this unprecedented pandemic. Nor could it have, given that the entire world was unprepared for the onslaught of the COVID-19 virus,” they wrote.

At last week’s hearing, an attorney representing the state said the CDCR has stopped admitting new inmates, and plans to release 3,496 non-violent offenders whose crimes do not involve sex offenses or domestic violence and who are within 30-60 days of their parole dates.

The CDCR touted those steps and others in a statement sent to Courthouse News Sunday.

“The order speaks for itself. CDCR has taken significant steps to address the safety and well-being of inmates and staff during the COVID-19 pandemic; including, temporarily suspending all intake from county jails, which, absent any other measures, would result in a net population reduction of about 3,000 inmates in 30 days due to normal attrition; the expedited paroles of approximately 3,500 non-violent male and female inmates who are within 60 days of their release date within the next several weeks; and approximately 480-530 inmates living in dorms will be transferred to other prisons with unoccupied buildings or space available to increase physical distancing space,” said spokeswoman Dana Simas.

“This is in addition to the other proactive steps we’ve taken to prevent the spread of COVID-19; including temperature and verbal screening of all staff entering CDCR and CCHCS locations, the development of comprehensive healthcare guidelines based on CDC and CDPH recommendations for correctional settings, and limited inmate movement to essential transfers only.”

The judges seem to trust the prison system’s current mitigation approach, at least for now.

“While we cannot know with certainty due to the pathogenesis of the virus, it appears that COVID-19 has not yet surged in California’s prisons,” they wrote. “Thus far, only thirteen inmates have confirmed cases of the disease. And, to their credit, defendants have already taken steps to combat the virus, including taking measures to reduce the prison population. But given the undisputed risk of further contagion in a carceral environment, plaintiffs’ desire to maximize the reduction in the state’s prison population is understandable.”

But the determining factor for the panel was the Prison Reform Litigation Act, which restricts a federal court’s ability to remedy a constitutional violation by releasing prisoners.

While the civil procedure rule empowers courts to change prior orders, the judges said it does not give them boundless authority.

“Rule 60(b)(5) does not provide us with free-standing authority to remedy any harm defendants may inflict upon plaintiffs, regardless of whether it is tethered to the previous findings of structural constitutional shortcomings in the delivery of medical and mental health care,” their order says.

They said the prisoners’ emergency motion doesn’t stem from unconstitutionally inadequate medical and mental healthcare, but a completely different constitutional injury—the system’s failure to protect inmates from a widespread contagion.

That there’s currently no vaccine for Covid-19 only furthers the premise that it could ravage the inmate population whether or not the prisons provide adequate medical care.

“We therefore conclude that to the extent plaintiffs can establish a constitutional violation based on the threat posed by COVID-19, it must be based on shortcomings in defendants’ response to the virus, not on the longstanding systemic constitutional deficiencies in California’s prison health care delivery system,” the judges wrote.

Mueller joined in the opinion but said she disagreed that the constitutional violation isn’t related to inadequate medical care.

“The current circumstances appear to expose, in stark terms, the potential need to revisit the current population cap. Even as I do not believe plaintiffs’ motion grounded in Rule 60(b)(5) can be granted, I am inclined to think this court retains broad equitable powers that might permit some reconsideration of the current cap in light of the unprecedented exigent circumstances here,” Mueller wrote.

She added, “Those circumstances, as is undisputed, present potentially grave risks to members of the Plaintiff classes, as well as to correctional staff and the communities in which they reside, as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and its impact on the delivery of medical and mental health care in the state prisons. It is undisputed that the delivery of care, to date, remains below constitutional minima.”

Attorney Michael Bien with Rosen, Bien, Galvan & Grunfeld represents a prisoner class led by inmate Ralph Coleman. He said by phone on Sunday that if the state refuses to release the elderly and most medically vulnerable prisoners, the corrections department needs to start taking bolder measures to keep them separated.

He pointed to Mueller’s concurrence, which recommends that inmates be relocated to places where they can maintain a six-foot distance.

“The message is you need to do more and it would be much better to do it on your own without a court order. They’re doing a lot of good things— they just need to do more about the population in prisons,” Bien said.

But the corrections department cannot start releasing prisoners without prior authorization from Governor Gavin Newsom.

“The staff, both clinical and custody, are doing an amazing job but they have an impossible job,” Bien said. “And they need help from the governor’s office.”

Bien said Newsom has the right to commandeer empty state buildings and state hospitals to house prisoners. The national guard could also supply tents.

“We want to suggest that the state come up with a plan that’s not just limited to things inside the existing prisons, but again achieving some of the spacing we need and getting the most vulnerable out of those situations even if you don’t release them,” Bien said. “This is an emergency, and it’s not going to last forever. We need to start taking bolder steps.”

Though reported infection numbers remain low, Bien said he fears the possibility of massive outbreaks at prisons in New York, Georgia and Louisiana. As of Sunday, 13 prisoners and 45 staff have the virus.

“We all know the real numbers because of lack of testing is much, much higher,” he said.

The inmates can still plead their case before a single judge from either of the district courts that handled the original overcrowding lawsuits from 1990 and 2001. A federal judge could order the CDCR to take additional steps short of release, and if that proves insufficient, the inmates may request to reconvene the panel.

— By Maria Dinzeo, CNS

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment

SCV NewsBreak
Wednesday, Jun 3, 2020
City Council Declares Emergency, Sets 6 p.m. Curfew Thursday (Video)
In an emergency meeting at City Hall Wednesday afternoon, the Santa Clarita City Council unanimously adopted a resolution declaring a local emergency amid civil unrest in the Southern California region and set a 6 p.m. to 6 a.m. curfew for the city Thursday night.
Wednesday, Jun 3, 2020
Wednesday COVID-19 Roundup: Another SCV Death, 76 New SCV Cases
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Wednesday 1,155 new cases of COVID-19 and 46 new deaths due to the virus countywide, as Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital reported its 11th COVID-19 fatality.
Wednesday, Jun 3, 2020
L.A. County Sets Wednesday Curfew at 9 p.m.
Los Angeles County officials have set a Wednesday curfew to be in effect countywide from 9 p.m. through Thursday at 5 a.m.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
In an emergency meeting at City Hall Wednesday afternoon, the Santa Clarita City Council unanimously adopted a resolution declaring a local emergency amid civil unrest in the Southern California region and set a 6 p.m. to 6 a.m. curfew for the city Thursday night.
City Council Declares Emergency, Sets 6 p.m. Curfew Thursday (Video)
Every day, Lianne McMahon is reminded of how proud her dad was of her when she looks at a handwritten note from him that she keeps framed in her room.
COC Nursing Student Overcomes Setbacks to Reach Graduation
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Wednesday 1,155 new cases of COVID-19 and 46 new deaths due to the virus countywide, as Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital reported its 11th COVID-19 fatality.
Wednesday COVID-19 Roundup: Another SCV Death, 76 New SCV Cases
The city of Santa Clarita and the city's Art Commission are recognizing the recent milestone of 2020 graduates in a virtual “Graduation Cap Showcase,” with a deadline for entries extended to Monday, June 8.
June 8: Deadline to Enter Cap in City’s Graduation Cap Showcase
The Hart High School Class of 2020 graduated Tuesday in two special ceremonies for Hart seniors: a drive-thru graduation in the morning and a follow-up virtual ceremony in the evening.
Hart Seniors Graduate in Drive-thru, Virtual Ceremonies
Los Angeles County officials have set a Wednesday curfew to be in effect countywide from 9 p.m. through Thursday at 5 a.m.
L.A. County Sets Wednesday Curfew at 9 p.m.
California Governor Gavin Newsom issued a proclamation Wednesday declaring a statewide General Election on Tuesday, November 3, 2020, and signed an executive order to ensure that Californians can exercise their right to vote in a safe, secure and accessible manner during the upcoming election.
Newsom Declares General Election, Orders Voting by Mail or In Person
Black church leaders in Los Angeles marched to LAPD headquarters Tuesday in a sign of unity with the community after several days of unrest across the nation and a day after peaceful protesters and clergy members were tear-gassed outside the White House.
Church Leaders Rally L.A. Crowd in Protest of Police Violence
Those who divide, threaten, insult and incite hate and animosity lack skill in leadership. When we work united as a team, we flourish. Divided, we fall.
Together As One | Doctor’s Diary with Dr. Gene Dorio
Due to extension of the closure of cruise ports in regions around the world and other factors impacting international travel, Princess Cruises is extending its cruise operations pause
Princess Cruises Extends Operations ‘Pause’ into Fall 2020
After serving the Santa Clarita Valley for 23 years as a Board member for the Newhall County Water District, Castaic Lake Water Agency and SCV Water, Tom Campbell resigned his position, effective May 27.
Campbell Exits SCV Water Board of Directors
Christo Vladimirov Javacheff, known for his environmental art pieces such as “The Umbrellas Japan-USA” installation in the Tejon Pass, died Sunday.
Christo, Artist Behind Umbrellas Project in Tejon Pass, Dies at 84
Desperate to patch a COVID-19-sized budget hole, the California Legislature is warming to the once-taboo subject of sports betting and has begun handicapping its potential tax windfall.
California Moves Closer to Legalizing Sports Betting
1855 - Ship leaves New York harbor bound for Tunis to acquire animals for the United States Camel Corps [story]
Camel Corps
The Valley Industry Association (VIA) will host a virtual State of the State presentation Tuesday, July 7, from 11:30 p.m. - 1:00 p.m., via Zoom.
July 7: VIA’s Virtual State of the State
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Tuesday 1,202 new cases of COVID-19 and 60 new deaths due to the virus countywide, and a total of 1,681 cases reported in the Santa Clarita Valley since the pandemic began, 79 more than reported Monday.
Tuesday COVID-19 Roundup: 115,310 Cases Statewide, 1,681 SCV Cases
The William S. Hart Union High School District will hold a special (virtual) meeting on Wednesday, June 03, at 8:00 a.m.
June 3: Hart District Special (Virtual) Meeting
The Summer 2020 edition of Seasons magazine, the city of Santa Clarita’s quarterly recreation publication, is now online.
Seasons Summer 2020 Edition Now Online
Smart phone cameras are invaluable in documenting truth and facts, in case they might be disputed in the future. All of us, including police or looters, should be aware you might be captured on someone’s phone committing a crime.
You’re On Candid Camera | Doctor’s Diary with Dr. Gene Dorio
Westfield Valencia Town Center officials said Tuesday they’re moving back the mall’s reopening as a precaution due to protests throughout Los Angeles County following the death of George Floyd in Minneapolis.
Westfield Taking Precautions Amid Protests; Pushes Back Reopening
Los Angeles County has extended a curfew that will run Tuesday, June 2, at 6:00 p.m. through Wednesday, June 3 at 6:00 a.m.
L.A. County Extends Curfew
The Los Angeles County Development Authority (LACDA) has released a draft of its Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy (CEDS) for Los Angeles County.
County Seeking Public Comments on Draft Economic Development Strategy
The Valley Industry Association (VIA) is launching Breakfast Club, a member-exclusive program designed to provide a business coaching experience to working professionals delivered by industry experts and professional speakers on a wide range of topics.
VIA Launching Breakfast Club
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has issued a Heat Alert as temperatures topping 100 degrees Fahrenheit are forecasted for the Santa Clarita Valley through Wednesday.
Heat Alert Issued for SCV Through Wednesday
%d bloggers like this: