header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Sunny
Sunny
92°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
July 29
1983 - U.S. release of "National Lampoon's Vacation;" Magic Mountain is Walley World [story]
Chevy Chase and Magic Mountain crew


| Thursday, Jul 1, 2021
SCOTUS
Supreme Court of the United States building. (Courthouse News photo/Jack Rodgers)

 

By Brad Kutner

WASHINGTON (CN) — In a closely watched case for nonprofit political groups that want privacy for their supporters, the U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday struck down a California law that says groups seeking tax-exempt status must tell the state the names of some of their biggest donors.

California has long insisted that it will not share the information it gathers, and legislative efforts aimed at beefing up security abound, but the state’s own history of data vulnerabilities undercut those assurances.

A 6-3 conservative majority of the high court focused on that vulnerability in striking the law down as unconstitutional Thursday.

“Given the amount and sensitivity of this information harvested by the state, one would expect Schedule B collection to form an integral part of California’s fraud detection efforts,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the majority. “It does not. To the contrary, the record amply supports the District Court’s finding that there was not ‘a single, concrete instance in which pre-investigation collection of a Schedule B did anything to advance the attorney general’s investigative, regulatory or enforcement efforts.’”

The data collection was also fraught with examples of lax control. When the conservative Americans for Prosperity Foundation filed its 2014 case, an amicus brief by a group on the opposite side of the political spectrum, the American Civil Liberties Union, found nearly 1,800 confidential disclosure forms on the website for the State Registry of Charitable Trusts. Thirty-eight of these were discovered on the eve of trial, and some had been up since at least 2012.

“‘By altering the single digit at the end of the URL’ corresponding to each file on the Registry website, Petitioner’s expert witness ‘was able to access, one at a time, all 350,000 of the Registry’s confidential documents,’” the ACLU wrote, quoting from the trial record.

The names of donors appear on Schedule B tax forms that nonprofit organizations file with the IRS, listing the names and addresses of individuals who contributed $5,000 or more in a given tax year. Though the IRS does not include Schedule B forms among the documents it makes available for public inspection, the California Department of Justice has said its duty to police charitable fraud and self-dealing justify giving it blanket access to the filings.

At the time the suit was filed, the California Justice Department was led by now-Vice President Kamala Harris.

A federal judge ruled against the state in 2016, but the San Francisco-based Ninth Circuit reversed two years later, setting the stage for Supreme Court oral arguments in April.

On appeal, the challenge by the Americans for Prosperity Foundation, the charitable arm of Charles and David Koch’s libertarian advocacy group Americans for Prosperity, was consolidated with that of the Thomas More Law Center.

“Once the state posts donors’ personal information on the internet, it remains public forever and puts donors’ and their families’ privacy at risk,” Kristen K. Waggoner, an attorney with Alliance Defending Freedom, wrote in a 2019 petition to the high court.

The majority was sympathetic to that argument in Thursday’s ruling, part of the high court’s final release of opinions for this term.

“When it comes to ‘a person’s beliefs and associations,’ ‘[b]road and sweeping state inquiries into these protected areas . . . discourage citizens from exercising rights protected by the Constitution,’” Roberts wrote, citing the court’s 1971 ruling in Baird v. State Bar of Arizona. “We understand this Court’s discussion of rules that are ‘broad’ and ‘broadly stifle’ First Amendment freedoms to refer to the scope of challenged restrictions—their breadth—rather than the severity of any demonstrated burden.”

California had argued that the burden on nonprofit groups was not a substantial one because the data being collected was already being sent to the IRS as part of tax filings, but Roberts was unpersuaded and also said it was “irrelevant” whether some donors might not mind disclosing their identities to the state.

The chief justice ultimately found that California’s donor law “was not narrowly tailored to the state’s objective.”

But in a dissenting opinion, the court’s liberal justices pushed back on the majority’s reasoning.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor, joined by Justices Elena Kagan and Stephen Breyer, wrote that the court has long held parties don’t have standing to sue if the complaint asserts only a “subjective ‘chill’” on free association rights.

“Today’s analysis marks reporting and disclosure require­ments with a bull’s-eye. Regulated entities who wish to avoid their obligations can do so by vaguely waving toward First Amendment ‘privacy concerns,’” Sotomayor wrote.

The Barack Obama appointee added, “It does not matter if not a single individual risks experiencing a single reprisal from disclosure, or if the vast majority of those affected would happily comply. That is all irrelevant to the Court’s determination that California’s Schedule B requirement is facially unconstitutional. Neither precedent nor common sense supports such a result.”

In a statement, Americans for Prosperity Foundation CEO Emily Seidel praised the high court’s ruling as a decision that will protect Americans from “being forced to choose between staying safe or speaking up.”

“The ability to maintain one’s privacy makes it possible for people to join together in causes and movements,” she said. “Especially given how polarized our country has become, the work of addressing injustice and advocating for change is hard enough without people facing fear of harassment and retaliation from the government and from potentially violent opposition.”

Requests for comment sent to the California Attorney General’s Office and the Thomas More Law Center were not returned by press time.

Praise for the decision came from groups on both sides of the aisle that expressed concern over the data collection.

“On cusp of Independence Day, #SCOTUS vindicated that most cherished American freedom: the freedom of association—including right not to have the govt bother you about your associations, or facilitate neighbors’ harassment of you for them,” Ilya Shapiro, vice president of the libertarian Cato Institute, wrote in a tweet posted shortly after the ruling was issued.

But not everyone was pleased by the ruling. Gautam Hans, law professor at Vanderbilt University and founder of the school’s Stanton Foundation First Amendment Clinic, slammed the precedent used in the majority opinion, specifically the court’s 1958 decision in NAACP v. Alabama striking down a state law requiring the civil rights group to disclose the names of its members.

“I will have to do a lot of screaming into the void today to deal with the fact that the Court effectively treats as equivalent the suffering of NAACP members during the 1950s to the *potential* — not even alleged — suffering of rich donors who buy elections,” he wrote on Twitter, echoing Sotomayor’s dissenting opinion.

“Justice Sotomayor says it in a much more measured way than me, of course,” he added.

But others thought the NAACP link was warranted, including attorney Mike DeGrandis of the New Civil Liberties Alliance, which filed an amicus brief in the case.

“A bedrock of the civil rights movement for more than 60 years—has been revitalized,” he said in an emailed statement. “In an age of political polarization, it is heartening to know that governments cannot chill our First Amendment civil rights with state-sponsored cancel-culture.

Thursday’s release of opinions marked the end of this year’s Supreme Court session. The next term begins in October.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Thursday, Jul 29, 2021
Equipment Failure Cause of Saugus Power Outage
More than 2,400 Saugus homes were impacted by a power outage that began shortly after midnight Thursday morning.
Thursday, Jul 29, 2021
SCV Heat Alert Extended Until Sunday
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has extended a Heat Alert as high temperatures have been forecast for the Santa Clarita Valley through Sunday, Aug. 1.
Thursday, Jul 29, 2021
Water Use Warning Issued for L.A. County Beaches
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health is cautioning residents who are planning to visit several Los Angeles County beaches near Dockweiler and El Segundo to be careful of swimming, surfing, and playing in ocean waters around discharging storm drains, creeks, and rivers.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
With the reinstatement of in-person instruction this Fall, the Outlets at Tejon is excited to help students, teachers, and parents with all their back-to-school shopping.
Tejon Outlets Kickoff Back-to-School Shopping with Steep Discounts, Secret Gifter
The Los Angeles County Department of Arts and Culture (Arts and Culture) has announced Leticia Rhi Buckley has joined its Arts Commission, L.A. County’s longstanding advisory body for the arts.
Leticia Buckley Joins L.A. County’s Arts Commission
Yair Haimoff, SIOR, and Andrew Ghassemi of Spectrum Commercial Real Estate, are pleased to have represented the seller in the recent sale of this ±4,828-square-foot office/flex condo in a prime Valencia location.
Valencia-Based Spectrum Real Estate Closes on Discovery Gateway Office/Flex Condo
More than 2,400 Saugus homes were impacted by a power outage that began shortly after midnight Thursday morning.
Equipment Failure Cause of Saugus Power Outage
As the Santa Clarita Public Library takes a programming break to prepare for Fall programming in September, residents are reminded to take advantage of the wide variety of services and online resources available.
Santa Clarita Public Library Gearing Up for Fall Programming
Trent Norkus is excited to join TMU Men's Volleyball and play alongside his older brother Brett, a starting middle blocker for the Mustangs.
TMU Men’s Volleyball Adding Another Norkus to Roster
The Los Angeles County Development Authority (LACDA) is proud to announce the launch of its new website.
L.A. County Development Authority’s New Website Goes Live
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has extended a Heat Alert as high temperatures have been forecast for the Santa Clarita Valley through Sunday, Aug. 1.
SCV Heat Alert Extended Until Sunday
Following a year of cancellations due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the city of Santa Clarita’s wildly popular SENSES block parties will make their triumphant return to Main Street in Old Town Newhall.
SENSES Block Parties Returning to Old Town Newhall
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health is cautioning residents who are planning to visit several Los Angeles County beaches near Dockweiler and El Segundo to be careful of swimming, surfing, and playing in ocean waters around discharging storm drains, creeks, and rivers.
Water Use Warning Issued for L.A. County Beaches
1983 - U.S. release of "National Lampoon's Vacation;" Magic Mountain is Walley World [story]
Chevy Chase and Magic Mountain crew
Local business leaders are gathering to celebrate Santa Clarita Valley Day Aug. 14 with an inaugural job fair and boutique expo.
SCV Day Celebrates With Job Fair, Boutique Expo
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Wednesday 15 new deaths and 2,454 new cases of COVID-19 countywide, with 29,668 total cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Wednesday COVID-19 Roundup: SCV Cases Total 29,668 With One Additional Death; L.A. County Urges Workers To Get Vaccinated, Wear Masks
The city of Santa Clarita is looking for public feedback on a public safety grant proposal for the U.S. Department of Justice’s Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant program.
City Seeks Public Input On Public Safety Grant Proposal
The California Department of Public Health has updated their guidance for face coverings statewide, aligning it with the mandates that L.A. County and the CDC calling for the public to wear masks indoors regardless of vaccination status. 
California Public Health Updates Statewide Mask Guidelines
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors approved a substitute motion authored by Kathryn Barger and Hilda L. Solis, in response to the proposed motion by Holly Mitchell and Shelia Kuehl that would move forward with the placement of youth realigned from the Department of Juvenile Justice and the L.A. County Probation system, specifically at Camps Scott and Scudder in Santa Clarita. 
Board of Supervisors Approves Alternative Approach For Juvenile Justice
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors approved a motion by Supervisor Kathryn Barger and coauthored by Supervisor Hilda L. Solis to create a Blue Ribbon Commission on Homelessness to assess existing structures and systems and provide recommendations on reforms that will help Los Angeles County and its 88 cities solve homelessness.
Barger’s Blue Ribbon Homelessness Commission Gets Board Approval
The inaugural Cars Under the Stars car show brought together families and car enthusiasts Saturday night to raise funds for the WiSH Education Foundation.
WiSH Cars Under The Stars Show Supports Hart Students
A hearing for Senate Bill 520, authored by Sen. Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, was cancelled by Wilk last month. 
Hearing For Anti-CEMEX Bill Pushed To January
1938 - Newhall Tunnel cut away, replaced by Sierra Highway [story]
Sierra Highway
The California State University announced Tuesday that it will require faculty, staff and students who are accessing campus facilities at any university location to be immunized against SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.
California State University Implementing COVID-19 Vaccine Mandate for Fall 2021
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Tuesday 15 new deaths and 2,067 new cases of COVID-19 countywide, with 29,581 total cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Tuesday COVID-19 Roundup: SCV Cases Total 29,581; L.A. County’s Case Rates Increasing Across All Adult Age Groups
Lauren Park's work ethic in midfield will seamlessly fit in with the Mustangs' style of play.
Former Saugus High Midfielder Lauren Park Signs with TMU
The city of Santa Clarita is seeking public feedback on a new, permanent public art piece which will be displayed at the nearly-completed Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station.
City Seeking Community Input for New SCV Sheriff’s Station Art Piece
%d bloggers like this: