header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
April 7
1835 - Outlaw and Rocks/Park/High School namesake Tiburcio Vasquez born in Monterey, Calif. [story]
Tiburcio Vasquez


The court upheld the decision by a state appellate panel that the language of the California Constitution doesn't exclude ballot initiatives over workers' compensation.
| Thursday, Jul 25, 2024
Uber

By Edvard Pettersson

(CN) — The California Supreme Court on Thursday rebuffed a union-backed challenge to the voter-approved law that exempts app-based drivers working for companies such as Uber, Lyft and DoorDash from being classified as employees rather than independent contractors under the state’s labor code.

The court in an unanimous decision said Proposition 22, which passed with 59% of the vote in November 2020 and has since been encoded, doesn’t conflict with a provision of the state’s constitution from 1918 that purports to give the Legislature plenary power “unlimited by any provision of this Constitution” over workers’ compensation law.

As such, the court upheld a split decision by a state appellate court two years ago, which in interpreting the meaning of that provision, article XIV, section 4, said voters and the Legislature “jointly and severally have authority to create a workers’ compensation system.”

“We agree with the Court of Appeal that it seems ‘most improbable’ that the voters in 1918 — seven years after they ‘approved a far-reaching measure incorporating a broad initiative power as part of the California Constitution’ — would have intended, ‘without any direct or explicit statement to this effect, to limit the use of the initiative power by virtue of the language’ in article XIV, section 4,” Associate Justice Goodwin Liu said.

The opinion relied in great part on a previous case where the court analyzed nearly identical language in the state’s constitution that appeared to give the Legislature unlimited power with respect to the authority and expansion of the Public Utilities Commission at the exclusion of ballot initiatives.

In that decision, as cited by Liu, the court observed that the 1911 amendment to the California Constitution “to provide for the initiative and referendum signifies one of the outstanding achievements of the progressive movement of the early 1900’s.”

Even the plaintiffs admit, Liu said, that the meaning of “unlimited” can’t mean that the Legislative can disregard any and all constitutional bounds on the workers’ compensation laws it enacts.

At a hearing in May, Associate Justice Joshua Groban questioned the union’s interpretation of the “unlimited” power in the 1918 constitutional amendment insofar as it implied that voters gave lawmakers unrestricted power to pass any law when it came to workers’ compensation, even otherwise unconstitutional ones such as limiting workers’ comp to men only, the justice observed.

“The clause requires interpretation,” Liu said, “and without a specific indication that the 1918 voters who enacted the clause meant to limit the initiative power, it is ‘our judicial policy to apply a liberal construction to this power wherever it is
challenged in order that the right be not improperly annulled.’”

A group of Uber and Lyft drivers backed by the Service Employees International Union initially prevailed in their challenge to enactment of the ballot initiative, which had been funded by the gig economy juggernauts, when Alameda County Superior Court Judge Frank Roesch agreed with them in August 2021 that the entirety of Proposition 22 was unenforceable.

That decision was reversed on appeal, prompting the plaintiffs to ask the California Supreme Court to take up the case.

“We’re disappointed in today’s ruling,” said Tia Orr, executive director of Service Employees International Union California. “Still, we are hopeful that an earlier ruling which validated the state legislature’s authority to pass laws enabling rideshare drivers to join together in a union gives workers a path to collectively bargain for better pay, benefits and protections.”

Protect App Based Drivers + Services, the industry group that defended Proposition 22 along with the California attorney general, called the decision an overwhelming victory for voters’ rights and the integrity of California’s initiative system.

“This ruling is not just a win for the nearly 1.4 million drivers who rely on the flexibility of app-based work to make ends meet, but for millions of consumers and thousands of businesses who rely on app-based services across the state” said Molly Weedn, a spokesperson for the organization. “The courts have spoken, and this issue can finally be put to rest.”

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
Current Time 0:00
/
Duration Time 0:00
Loaded: 0%
Progress: 0%
Stream TypeLIVE
Remaining Time -0:00
 
1x
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Monday, Apr 7, 2025
April 7-12: 10 Productions Filming in SCV
The city of Santa Clarita Film Office has released the list of 10 productions filming in the Santa Clarita Valley for the week of Monday, April 7 to Saturday, April 12.
Friday, Apr 4, 2025
April 26: SCV Family History, Genealogy Fair
The Santa Clarita Valley Family History & Genealogy Fair, an annual free genealogy fair hosted by the Valencia FamilySearch Center, will be held on Saturday, April 26, 8 a.m.-2:30 p.m.
Friday, Apr 4, 2025
April 11: Deadline to Vote in Best of California State Parks Poll Nears
California State Park enthusiasts from across the state have nominated their favorite state parks, and now it’s time to decide. State Parks has gathered the top nominations, and now it is time for you to determine the Best of California’s State Parks.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
The Small Business Development Center hosted by College of the Canyons will offer a free webinar, Fundamentals of Food Businesses, on Thursday, April 10 from noon to 1 p.m.
April 10: Webinar on the Fundamentals of Food Businesses
As we move through the budget process for Fiscal Year 2025/26, our focus remains clear-fiscal responsibility, long-term stability and protecting the quality of life our residents have come to expect.
Ken Striplin | Holding the Line in Uncertain Times
The Master's University baseball team traveled to Glendale, Ariz. and was able to split the first of two doubleheaders against Arizona Christian University with a 10-7 win and a 19-4 loss at Greenway High School Friday evening, April 4.
Mustangs Split Doubleheader Against Firestorm
The Santa Clarita Community College District Board of Trustees will hold a business meeting Wednesday, April 9, beginning at 5 p.m. The board will first meet in closed session at 4:30 p.m.
April 9: COC Board of Trustees Business Meeting
The Master's University beach volleyball team came away with a 3-2 win Friday, April 4 in the final match of the regular season.
TMU Beach Gets Dramatic Win in Final Match
Dueling Pianos is back at El Trocadero Kitchen and Bar, 7-10 p.m. Friday, April 18 at 24274 Main St., Newhall, CA 91321.
April 18: El Trocadero Dueling Pianos Show
Backed by a standout out pitching performance from sophomore Nichole Muro, College of the Canyons softball picked up a 7-2 conference win over No. 13 state-ranked Antelope Valley College on Thursday, April 3.
Canyons Knocks Off No. 13 Antelope Valley 7-2
The Splash N’ Dash Egg Hunt, presented by Kaiser Permanente, will take place on Saturday, April 19, at 10 a.m. at the Santa Clarita Aquatic Center Waterslide Pool, when hundreds of eggs will rush down the slide and into the water for kids to collect.
April 19: Splash N’ Dash Egg Hunt
The city of Santa Clarita Film Office has released the list of 10 productions filming in the Santa Clarita Valley for the week of Monday, April 7 to Saturday, April 12.
April 7-12: 10 Productions Filming in SCV
The Santa Clarita Arts Commission will hold its regular meeting Thursday, April 10, at 6 p.m., in Council Chambers at City Hall, 23920 Valencia Blvd., 1st Floor, Santa Clarita, CA 91355.
April 10: Santa Clarita Arts Commission to Hear Arts Master Plan Update
1835 - Outlaw and Rocks/Park/High School namesake Tiburcio Vasquez born in Monterey, Calif. [story]
Tiburcio Vasquez
Today in SCV History (April 7)
1820 - '49er diarist William Lewis Manly born in Vermont [story]
William Lewis Manly
1970, minutes before midnight - Newhall Incident: 4 officers murdered in worst-ever CHP slaying [story]
Newhall Incident
The Santa Clarita Valley Family History & Genealogy Fair, an annual free genealogy fair hosted by the Valencia FamilySearch Center, will be held on Saturday, April 26, 8 a.m.-2:30 p.m.
April 26: SCV Family History, Genealogy Fair
The Los Angeles County Treasurer and Tax Collector reminds Santa Clarita Valley residents that the second installment of the 2024-25 Annual Secured Property Taxes becomes delinquent if not paid by Thursday, April 10.
April 10: Second Half of L.A. County Property Taxes Due
The 52nd Annual Frontier Toyota Henry Mayo Golf Classic will host a $20 per ball Helicopter Golf Ball Drop at 3 p.m. on Saturday, May 10 at Valencia Country Club.
May 10: Frontier Toyota Henry Mayo Golf Classic Golf Ball Drop
California State Park enthusiasts from across the state have nominated their favorite state parks, and now it’s time to decide. State Parks has gathered the top nominations, and now it is time for you to determine the Best of California’s State Parks.
April 11: Deadline to Vote in Best of California State Parks Poll Nears
Residents wanting to wear their Santa Clarita pride can now shop online at the city of Santa Clarita City Store. The store offers a variety of city-branded merchandise options, including t-shirts, hoodies, hats, totes and more.
Santa Clarita Opens Online Merchandise Store
Explore the world by traveling to the Canyon Country Community Center for the Celebrate event series. Experience different customs and cultures, no plane ticket needed.
Travel the World in 2025 with the Celebrate Passport
After three successful years guiding the Teton Ranch Conservancy, Executive Director Jaron Cramer will be stepping down from his position effective Friday, April 18.
Tejon Ranch Conservancy Leadership Transition Announced
The Santa Clarita City Council will meet in open session on Tuesday, April 8 at City Hall to consider sending a letter, signed by all city council members, to the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors regarding Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department deputy vacancies and encouraging the board to make investments in enhancing LASD retention and strengthening recruitment efforts.
April 8: City Council to Discuss Letter on LASD Vacancies to County Supes
1893 - Large earthquake centered in Pico Canyon; locals believed oil drilling caused it [story]
map
California State University, Northridge’s Department of Theatre will host Native Voices, the only professional theatre company in the United States devoted to bringing Indigenous playwrights, 7:30 p.m. Monday, April 7, to perform “To Indigeneity and Beyond!”
April 7: Native Voices to Perform at CSUN
SCVNews.com