[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Lawyer Wants Quick Win; Official Sees ‘Cash Grab’ | 07-08-2013
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Clear
Clear
66°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
August 20
1967 - New Town of Valencia dedicated; homes sell for $25,000 [story]


Kevin Shenkman

Kevin Shenkman

The lawyer for plaintiffs who have now sued three local entities said his firm is hoping the defendants settle because going to trial “won’t benefit anyone,” said Kevin Shenkman of Shenkman & Hughes, a Malibu law firm that’s suing the city of Santa Clarita and two local school districts.

“You only need to look to Palmdale to see that that doesn’t help — to look at the hole that they’ve dug themselves into,” Shenkman said.

The firm is handling the litigation for three civil rights suits against Santa Clarita Valley public agencies that could cost local taxpayers anywhere from tens of thousands of dollars to millions in legal fees.

The suits, which are very similar to one that Shenkman’s firm is litigating in Palmdale, allege that at-large elections, which take place throughout the Santa Clarita Valley, have denied access to voters.

The Palmdale suit is thought to be decided “any day now,” with the bill to Palmdale “north of $1 million in legal fees,” if the city loses.

Shenkman is trying the cases on a pro bono basis, which means he is only reimbursed for his billable hours and the expert testimony he is pays for out of pocket, if his suit is successful.

R. Rex Parris joined in the suit against Palmdale in late January, and has also signed on to three suits being filed against Santa Clarita Valley entities.

The Palmdale trial concluded May 15, and the court required written closing statements June 6.

The suits claim that the city – as well as the Sulphur Springs and Santa Clarita Community College – hold at-large elections that deny access to Latino voters.

“We only want to fight enough to get to what’s right for the minority interests in the district,” Shenkman said.

However, a Santa Clarita Valley education official likened the suits to an irresponsible cash grab at the expense of local school district funds and taxpayers’ money.

joemessinamug

Joe Messina is president of the Hart School Board, which isn’t a target in the recent spate of lawsuits.

“What a great way for attorneys to make money — to sue the pockets of the districts,” said Joe Messina, board president for the William S. Hart Union High School District, sarcastically. “The numbers showed that districting would make things worse because they would water down the larger groups, so where you normally have an 18 percent Hispanic population in the whole valley then you get those numbers down to single digits in some areas. How does that change anything?”

The Sulphur Springs School District lawsuit alleges that the district comprises a portion of the city of Santa Clarita with 56,256 residents, and 30.6 percent of the registered voters in that district are Latino.

“The Latino population located within the SSSD is geographically concentrated, particularly in the pockets of the Newhall and Canyon Country neighborhoods,” according to the lawsuit.

The Hart district, a valleywide district that governs the schools for the SCV’s approximately 23,000 junior high and high school students, which also has a Hispanic governing board member in Gloria Mercado-Fortine, who’s announced her intention to run for Santa Clarita City Council next year.

More than a half-year of research proved single-member districts would only make the problem worse, Messina said.

The lawsuit calls for single-member districts, or another suitable remedy, Shenkman said, and cited several school districts’ efforts to move the elections as evidence that they have acknowledged a problem.

Moving the elections to even years has proven to improve access, and would be considered a step in the right direction, Shenkman said.

It’s a move that several local school districts tried to do, including COC’s governing body and the Sulphur Springs School District; however the county cited that it didn’t have the resources to handle so many elections during gubernatorial- or presidential-year elections.

A measure to allow the elections to move was basically nullified by a 2-2-1 vote by the county’s Board of Supervisors in May.

Several school officials have argued that their research has shown that single-member district elections, which would divide the Santa Clarita Valley representation, would not solve anything.

“In a town like this, in a city like this, this will not fix the problem,” Messina said. “This will make partisan politics worse.”

Another alternative is what’s known as limited voting, Shenkman said, whereby voters choose one candidate, instead of a top-three ballot, which is currently the system in place.

“The typical remedy has been to go to single-member districts, however there have been many cases where a court has found, ‘Yes, there is a problem, but we think another remedy is appropriate,” Shenkman said.

Calls seeking comment from Sulphur Springs School District officials have not been returned. Officials with the College of the Canyons and the city of Santa Clarita both said they have not yet had a chance to formally brief their governing boards so an official response has not yet been formulated.

In the meantime, if a judge doesn’t throw out the suit, and then a settlement isn’t reached quickly, a huge burden would be passed on to taxpayers, Shenkman said

District officials for Cerritos Community College decided to settle early on, Shenkman said, and their costs were about $55,000.

However, in the case of Sanchez vs. Modesto, which was litigated by a different firm and resulted in a decision that went with the plaintiff — one that the state’s high court and the Supreme Court refused to review — the legal fees went in excess of $3 million.

Shenkman likened Modesto’s demographics to those of Santa Clarita.

“We served the city and the school districts on June 26 and they have 30 days to respond to the complaint,” he said.

“We would certainly invite a conversation or a discussion as far as where we go from here,” Shenkman said. “It’s not in anyone’s interest to go to a scorched earth litigation routine.”

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

4 Comments

  1. astroak says:

    wow, this is pretty sad. hope the judge throws this out. it’s similar to the case where two guys go out seeking restaurant that don’t display a health sign and takes them to court BUT hoping they settle. If the city would call on its residents to help out I’m sure they would.

  2. Name says:

    Parris and Shenkman are scum of the earth. With apologies to scum.

  3. Adam Thomas says:

    Shenkman sued Chipotle for using lard in their refried beans. Next he’ll sue Olive Garden for using tomatoes in their marinara sauce.

  4. Don Ricketts says:

    The lawsuits would be stayed, if not resolved, if the Council (and districts) would put the matter on the ballot: Should Santa Clarita Council [School District] members be elected by District instead of at-large?

    This is a different city than it was in 1987 and the public should be allowed to reconsider the matter..

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
Loading...
Related Content
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Sunday, Aug 20, 2017
August 21: Solar Eclipse Viewing at Newhall Library
The Santa Clarita Public Library invites residents to view the total solar eclipse on Monday, August 21 at the Old Town Newhall Library starting at 10 a.m.
Friday, Aug 18, 2017
Deputies Break Window, Rescue Dogs Locked in Car
Alerted by a concerned citizen Friday, Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station deputies once again rescued dogs the owner left in a car with the windows rolled up and no water.
Friday, Aug 18, 2017
Environmental Groups File Complaint Against Newhall Ranch Water Plan
Two local environmental groups filed a complaint in L.A. Superior Court Thursday regarding the approved plan to provide water to the Newhall Ranch development, set to break ground in 2018.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
The Santa Clarita Public Library invites residents to view the total solar eclipse on Monday, August 21 at the Old Town Newhall Library starting at 10 a.m.
August 21: Solar Eclipse Viewing at Newhall Library
1967 - New Town of Valencia dedicated; homes sell for $25,000 [story]
1879 - Newhall civic leader Charles Henry Kingsburry born in Missouri [story]
Alerted by a concerned citizen Friday, Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station deputies once again rescued dogs the owner left in a car with the windows rolled up and no water.
Deputies Break Window, Rescue Dogs Locked in Car
40 oz. to Freedom arrives in Santa Clarita as part of its anniversary tour at Concerts in the Park at Central Park on Saturday, August 19, with showtime at 7 p.m.
August 19: 40 Oz. to Freedom Rocks Central Park
Two local environmental groups filed a complaint in L.A. Superior Court Thursday regarding the approved plan to provide water to the Newhall Ranch development, set to break ground in 2018.
Environmental Groups File Complaint Against Newhall Ranch Water Plan
County Supervisor Kathryn Barger has provided $143,000 in funding to extend the season of youth and adult swim programs offered at the Castaic Aquatic Center through October 31.
Castaic Aquatic Center Programs Extended to October 31
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Los Angeles County firefighters and government leaders welcomed back the Super Scoopers Friday morning. Plus, the Old Town Newhall Library helped get the community ready for it as well by handing out free eclipse viewing glasses. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Friday, August 18, 2017
CalArts alumna Audrey Chan (Art MFA 07) will host a free, all-ages interactive arts workshop in Little Tokyo on Saturday and Sunday, August 19 and 20, as part of the Japanese American Cultural & Community Center’s 2017 Nisei Week activities.
August 19-20: Nisei Week Arts Workshop with CalArts Alum Audrey Chan
Western singer and songwriter John Zipperer headlines the next episode of "SCVTV Presents The OutWest Concert Series" at The MAIN in Old Town Newhall the evening of Friday, August 25.
August 25: John Zipperer Headlines ‘SCVTV Presents The OutWest Concert Series’
Habitat for Humanity SFV/SCV is honored to have received a $25,000 grant from the Disabled Veterans National Foundation, which will fund trauma workshops.
Habitat for Humanity Receives $25K Grant from Disabled Veterans
Here are agenda highlights for the next meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, set for Tuesday, August 22, starting at 9:30 a.m..
August 22: Board of Supervisors Meeting Agenda
Ashley Olivier, a student worker at the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station, summited Mt. Whitney with her dad, a lieutenant at LASD's Monterey Park station.
SCV Sheriff’s Station Student Worker, LASD Dad Top Mt. Whitney
Looking to enter the win column for the first time in 2017 on day two of the Summer Slam volleyball tournament, the TMU Mustangs squared off against 11th-ranked Eastern Oregon but lost in straight sets.
Mountaineers Spike Mustangs at Summer Slam
Caltrans has released "Rail and the California Economy," a research report investigating how the state’s vast passenger and freight rail system contribute to California’s economy, as well as an overview of opportunities for rail to address the state’s needs and challenges in the future.
New Report Details Rail Role in State Economy
The Master’s University women’s soccer team soared to a 7-0 victory over the visiting Eagles from Sierra Nevada College Thursday.
Lady Mustangs Soccer Win Opener 7-0
The Master’s University women's volleyball team concluded their first day of HIU Summer Slam tournament play with a five-set thriller against the Southern Oregon University Raiders on Wednesday evening, dropping the fifth set 15-9.
Lady Mustangs Fall in 5 to Raiders at HIU
A federal judge on Wednesday ruled against claims by a state workers’ union that California’s pension system unfairly changed the terms of a pre-existing collective bargaining agreement.
Court Upholds Increase in CalPERS Retirement Age
Friday's alert from the South Coast Air Quality Management District that air quality will be unhealthy for sensitive individuals in the Santa Clarita Valley has been extended through Saturday.
Updated: SCV Air Quality Unhealthy Saturday
Four annual crime reports, which provide law enforcement agencies and the public with statewide data on crime statistics, were released Friday by California's Attorney General.
AG Releases 4 California Crime Reports for 2016
The Master’s University women’s volleyball team lost their 2017 season opener Wednesday at the HIU Summer Slam in straight sets against the Warriors from national powerhouse Corban University (OR).
Warriors Drop TMU Lady Mustangs in Straight Sets
Here's the Castaic/Val Verde (Zone 2) Crime Information and Public Safety Report from the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station for the week of August 7 to August 13.
Crime Blotter: Assault, Theft in Castaic-Val Verde
Two Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station employees will be recognized at the City Council meeting to be held on August 22 at 6 p.m.
City Council to Honor 2 SCV Sheriff’s Station Employees
The city of Santa Clarita’s Youth Sports program has seen measured success thus far in 2017.
Santa Clarita Youth Sports Program Sees Spike in Participation
The Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center’s new building campaign now only has $1.3 million remaining to raise before groundbreaking on the site can begin.
New SCV Senior Center Needs $1.3M to Break Ground
Sacramento County sued the California Department of Water Resources on Thursday over DWR's certification of the California 'WaterFix' delta tunnels project’s “dizzying” and “shifting” environmental review.
Sacramento County Sues to Freeze California ‘WaterFix’
1946 - Pioneering Placerita Canyon movie producer Trem Carr dies in San Diego [story]
' style=
The storewide remodel of the Walmart Supercenter at 26471 Carl Boyer Drive is complete and, in addition to the many physical changes inside, Santa Clarita residents now have access to Online Grocery Pickup.
Walmart on Carl Boyer Drive Celebrates Grand Reopening Friday
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, two people have been hospitalized after a major collision. Plus, an acquisition of land near the 14. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday August 17, 2017
Le Chene French Cuisine, a long-time Santa Clarita local favorite restaurant along Sierra Highway, has announced that they will be hosting a thrilling Murder Mystery Dinner on Saturday, November 4th, 2017.
Nov. 4: Le Chene Murder Mystery Dinner
Senator Scott Wilk, R- Antelope Valley, today announces that he is one of the 2017 inductees into the Antelope Valley High School Alumni Hall of Fame.
Sept. 22: Wilk to be Inducted into AV High School Hall of Fame
Signups are under way for the Santa Clarita Walk to End Alzheimer’s, which offers participants an opportunity to take a healthy stroll, experience outstanding live entertainment, honor loved ones who have been affected by Alzheimer’s and raise funds to battle the debilitating disease.
Oct. 7: Walk to End Alzheimer’s; Signups Under Way
Trammell Crow Company (TCC) andand Clarion Partners are pleased to announce the acquisition of 54 acres of land for the development of The Center at Needham Ranch, a state-of-the-art business park in the city of Santa Clarita, CA.
TCC, Clarion Partners Acquire More Than 50 Acres of SCV Real Estate
The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration is hosting what will be a highly educational and informative (and free) Tax Seminar for Nonprofits and Exempt Organizations.
Sept. 6: Tax Seminar for Non-Profits and Exempt Organizations