header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
November 22
1843 - Rancho Castec (Lebec-Tejon area) granted to French immigrant Jose Covarrubias [story]
Rancho Castec diseno map


Commentary by Ken Pfalzgraf
| Monday, Apr 13, 2015

KenPfalzgrafI am an Acton resident and Acton Agua Dulce Unified School District school board observer. My last piece (here) looked into the compensation package and responsibilities of the AADUSD superintendent in comparison to his regional peers. With the enrollment in the superintendent’s own schools falling off and with an ever-increasing portion of the budget being dedicated to legal fees associated to the myriad of charter schools that the district is sponsoring all over the place, I wondered just what direction the superintendent is being given from the school board to earn his keep.

 

Typically, the governing boards of public agencies conduct an annual priority exercise that sets the agency’s direction and focus for staff. Through this process, the agency’s constituents are given an opportunity to participate in the development of the agency’s goals, to be informed of what to expect from the agency for the foreseeable future and, most importantly, to have a means of rating the effectiveness of board members at election time.

Short of a priority exercise, a school board’s direction for the future can typically be found in the performance goals the board gives its superintendent in the superintendent’s employment contract.

Since the Acton-Agua Dulce school board does not conduct a priority exercise or share its goals for the year with the public, I decided to ask for the superintendent’s employment contract. Shouldn’t be a problem, right? By virtue of school board policy 4300 (read it here), the superintendent’s employment contract “shall be available to the public upon request.”

As you’ll see in the letter below, it is clear that the four and a half AADUSD school board members have put the superintendent’s performance goals, and thus the guidance of the district, behind a firewall of attorneys paid with funds intended to educate students.

What is in the AADUSD superintendent’s contract and performance goals that is so secretive that the school board feels the need to lawyer up and violate its own board policies to keep the public from knowing?

Lots of riddles; I’ve got one myself.

Knock, knock. Who’s there? Fran Pavley. Fran Pavley who? Fran Pavley SB 739.

By the way, if you’re thinking about taking an appointment to the AADUSD board to replace the absentee member without having to be voted in through a typical election process, use care. The baggage you take on might not be good if you’re thinking about flying to Washington, D.C., anytime soon.

Anyway, here’s my third attempt to get information regarding the AADUSD superintendent’s employment contract from the school board:

 

Ken Pfalzgraf

(Street Address)

Acton, CA 93510

(661) xxx-xxxx

March 13, 2015

 

Acton Agua Dulce Unified School District Board of Trustees

Ed Porter, President

Acton Agua Dulce Unified School District

32248 Crown Valley Road

Acton, CA 93510

 

RE: Third request for AADUSD superintendent employment contract information

 

Dear AADUSD Board of Trustees,

By virtue of the responses from attorneys representing AADUSD, I assume that you are aware that I submitted a records request regarding AADUSD administrative team compensation information to the AADUSD board president on March 2, 2014. That request included the following:

“The employment contract(s) for the AADUSD Superintendent, beginning with the initial employment contract that was awarded when the employee was appointed Interim Superintendent and each subsequent employment contract thereafter to include any and all modifications and addendums and the most recent contract.”

AADUSD chose to group this request with an unrelated March 9, 2015 request for information regarding contracts for the demolition and clearance work at the Vasquez High School site. To be clear, I would assume that the superintendent’s employment contract with the board is the one document, above all, that should be most easily located at the district office. Yet, in AADUSD’s March 13, 2015 untimely response to this request, penned by the superintendent himself, AADUSD unnecessarily prolonged providing the superintendent’s employment contract with the following irrelevant justification:

“The need to search for and collect the requested records from field facilities or other establishments that are separate from the office processing the request;

“The need to search for, collect, and appropriately examine a voluminous amount of separate and distinct records that are demanded in a single request; and

“The need for consultation, which shall be conducted with all practicable speed, among two or more components of the agency having substantial subject matter interest therein.”

On March 26, 2015, AADUSD counsel provided the first response to my request for the superintendent’s employment contract with the following statement and attached documents:

“The District has determined that it possesses disclosable public records responsive, at least in part, to this request. The District has attached responsive documents to this correspondence. The District now considers this request complete.” (F3-Ayden).

1. AGREEMENT FOR EMPLOYMENT OF DISTRICT SUPERINTENDENT-June 24, 2010 (link)

2. AGREEMENT FOR EMPLOYMENT OF DISTRICT SUPERINTENDENT-January 24, 2013 (link)

On March 28, 2015, with respect to my request for the superintendent’s employment contract, I advised AADUSD that the district’s response of March 26, 2015 was incorrect and incomplete, specifically because:

1. “Addendums for the agreement dated “24th day of June, 2010” are missing. Specifically, addendums B (1) and B (2) for section “2. Salary” are missing from the AADUSD response of March 26, 2015”.

2. “Addendums for the agreement dated January 24, 2013 are missing from the AADUSD response of March 26, 2015. On page one (1) of that document (“AGREEMENT FOR EMPLOYMENT OF DISTRICT SUPERITENDENT”), under part two (2) “Salary” find the following in section “C”:

“The parties agree that each year of this agreement, on or before November 1st, the Superintendent and board president will propose five (5) merit/performance incentive goals which, upon completion, the Superintendent shall receive a merit/performance incentive in the amount of three thousand dollars ($3,000), not to exceed a total of fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000), payable on the achievement of each goal. The Superintendent’s merit/performance incentive goals will be subject to Board approval. An addendum identifying the five (5) merit/performance incentive goals will be attached to this agreement each year and incorporated herein.”

By virtue of AADUSD board policy 4300, the superintendent’s employment contract “shall be available to the public upon request.” These attachments are, by the terms of the AADUSD board employment contract with the superintendent, an integral part and “attachment” of and to the superintendent’s contract which, again, “shall be available to the public upon request” by virtue of the terms of AADUSD board policy 4300 (link). This information was not provided in the March 26, 2015 AADUSD response to the records request of March 2, 2015.”

On April 3, 2015, AADUSD district counsel responded to my second request for:

“The “addendum identifying the five (5) merit/performance incentive goals” attached to the “AGREEMENT FOR EMPLOYMENT OF DISTRICT SUPERINTENDENT” commencing with the contract for January 24, 2013 and the “five (5) merit/performance incentive goals” for each year thereafter to include the current set of “five (5) merit/performance incentive goals.”

With the following comment:

“The District does not possess responsive, non-privileged records responsive to your request. As noted, employee personnel files, including evaluations, are exempt from disclosure under the PRA. (See e.g. , Gov. Code §§sections 6254 (c) and 6255; California Constitution, Article I, section I.; Los Angeles Unified Sch. Dist. v Superior Court, supra.) (F3-Ayden).

Be advised that the district’s response of April 3, 2015 is irrelevant, inappropriate and thus, still incomplete. To be clear, at no time have I requested the superintendent’s annual evaluation, performance review or bonus report, nor am I doing that at this time.

Now, be advised that I will again for the third time, request the “addendum identifying the five (5) merit/performance incentive goals” attached to the “AGREEMENT FOR EMPLOYMENT OF DISTRICT SUPERITENDENT” commencing with the contract for January 24, 2013 and the “five (5) merit/performance incentive goals” for each year thereafter to include the current set of “five (5) merit/performance incentive goals.” In addition, I will remind the district that the annual merit/performance incentive goals for the superintendent’s employment contract of June 24, 2010, by virtue of being embedded into pages one(1) and two (2) of that document , are inherently available for “public review”. Therefore, along with AADUSD board policy 4300 that makes the superintendent’s employment contract “available to the public upon request,” the board’s past practice of making the annual merit/performance incentive goals for the June 24, 2010 sets precedence that the same shall be provided with respect to the superintendent’s employment agreement of January 24, 2013 and each year thereafter, to include the current contract.

In closing, I find the time, effort and legal fees being given to the withholding of this information, which the public is legally entitled to by virtue of the district’s own board policy, alarming. Furthermore, in that the board does not conduct an annual priority exercise and that the board does not issue an annual statement of focus, direction or intent for the district’s constituents to consider or lend input to, the merit/performance incentive goals included in the superintendent’s employment contract are the best indicator of the board’s intention of guidance of the district into the future. When this information is withheld from the public, who are ultimately the heritors of the decisions this board makes, and driven behind a firewall of attorneys and into the hands of four and a half board members, constituent right to transparency of process in a publicly funded agency has been breached. I now more fully understand the concern of the Fiscal Crisis Management Assistance Team’s (FCMAT) regarding “Inadequate community participation and communication” on page six of oversight agency Los Angeles County Office of Education’s (LACOE) requested report on the condition of the AADUSD issued just seven short months ago (link).

Be assured that, until I receive the information I am entitle to by virtue of AADUSD board policy, I will continue to file a steady stream of public record requests for, once again:

“The “addendum identifying the five (5) merit/performance incentive goals” attached to the “AGREEMENT FOR EMPLOYMENT OF DISTRICT SUPERITENDENT” commencing with the contract for January 24, 2013 and the “five (5) merit/performance incentive goals” for each year thereafter to include the current set of “five (5) merit/performance incentive goals.”

Thank you for your time and attention to this matter. Hopefully this third time will be the charm.

Sincerely,

Ken Pfalzgraf

CC: Dr. Arturo Delgado – Los Angeles County Office of Education Superintendent Press

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

3 Comments

  1. M Sanchez says:

    We citizens appreciate your efforts, Ken.

    • Ken Pfalzgraf says:

      Thank you M. Sanchez. While my opinions may differ from some others, or even all others, given that AADUSD is the sponsor of K-6 AEA campuses which hold students from both the Acton Agua Dulce area and Santa Clarita Valley, I believe constituent of both areas have the right to know where things are headed in the future. It seems 4 board members, an absentee board member and a flock of attorneys are steering the bus and we are all blindfolded just waiting to see where this will go.

      I’ll post a link to the 3rd records request form letter so anyone that wants to spend 49 cents can get a rejection letter too. If enough of us get together and request this information:

      “The “addendum identifying the five (5) merit/performance incentive goals” attached to the “AGREEMENT FOR EMPLOYMENT OF DISTRICT SUPERITENDENT” commencing with the contract for January 24, 2013 and the “five (5) merit/performance incentive goals” for each year thereafter to include the current set of “five (5) merit/performance incentive goals.”

      maybe the law firm will give us a cut of the action they get sending us all rejection notices. We can turn around and give that money back to the teachers so they can buy crayons or something. ;0)

  2. Ken Pfalzgraf says:

    Here’s a link to the form letter. Fill in the bolded parts, waste 49 cents and see what you get:

    https://www.dropbox.com/s/9bd1ysx4248yuem/AADUSD%20super%20contract%20records%20request.docx?dl=0

Leave a Comment


Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
RECENT COMMENTARY
Thursday, Nov 21, 2024
The holiday season is just around the corner and it’s one of the most magical times of the year.
Wednesday, Nov 20, 2024
Supervisor Kathryn Barger commented on Attorney General Rob Bonta’s announcement that he is pursuing additional monitoring and strengthened protections for youth in Los Angeles County’s juvenile halls.
Wednesday, Nov 13, 2024
I think we’re all glad that the extreme heat of the past few months here in southern California has passed, and we are now enjoying some beautiful fall days.
Monday, Nov 11, 2024
This week, I took my Oath of Office for my third and final term as Fifth District Supervisor.
Monday, Nov 11, 2024
As we conclude the 2024 Fall season, I would like to thank all the athletic directors, school administrators, athletic trainers and anyone else responsible for helping implement and navigate our new Health and Safety Bylaws.
Thursday, Nov 7, 2024
Did you know that our local Santa Clarita Public Library offers passport acceptance services? Whether you’re planning a vacation, studying abroad or reconnecting with family, the Santa Clarita Public Library is here to support your journey.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
The Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce will hold its annual Awards + Installation event on Friday, Jan. 31 at the Hyatt Regency.
Jan. 31: SCV Chamber Awards + Installation Early Bird Tickets
The Valley Industry Assoction will host a Cocktails & Conversation event with Cameron Smyth on Thursday, Dec. 12, 5:30=7:30 p.m. at Margarita’s Mexican Grill, 23320 Valencia Blvd., Valencia, CA 91355.
Dec. 12: Cocktails & Conversation with Cameron Smyth
Following an extensive search, the Governing Board of the William S. Hart Union High School District has unanimously selected current Interim Superintendent Dr. Michael Vierra as the new Hart District Superintendent, filling the vacancy created when Mike Kuhlman resigned effective June 30.
Hart Board Selects Current Interim Superintendent to Fill Vacancy
"Christmas Carol: The True Meaning of Christmas" will be performed on stage at the Canyon Theatre Guild on weekends beginning Friday, Nov. 29 thru Monday, Dec. 23 at 24242 Main St., Newhall, CA 91321.
Nov. 29: ‘Christmas Carol, The True Meaning of Christmas’
The California Air Resources Board has approved a $34.94 million incentives funding plan that will continue support ongoing efforts to increase access to medium- and heavy-duty zero-emission trucks, buses and equipment, with a focus on small businesses.
CARB Incentive Plan Focuses on Fleets for Small Businesses
Preparing to decorate for the holidays? If you come across broken string lights that are no longer usable, instead of tossing in the trash you can now drop them off for recycling at one of the SAFE collection centers
Recycle Broken Holiday Lights at SAFE Collection Centers
The nonprofit Raising the Curtain Foundation will host a fundraising event, "Holidayland" with mid-century pop culture expert Charles Phoenix, on Sunday, Dec. 8 at 3 p.m.
Dec. 8: ‘Charles Phoenix Holidayland’ at Newhall Family Theatre
The Santa Clarita City Council will hold its regular meeting Tuesday, Nov. 26, beginning with a special closed meeting at 5 p.m., followed immediately with open session at 6 p.m.
Nov. 26: City Council Meets to Discuss Contracts, Open Space Naming
The American Cancer Society Relay for Life of Santa Clarita Valley will present its holiday boutique fundraiser, 10 a.m.-3 p.m. Saturday, Nov. 23, at Santa Clarita United Methodist Church, 26640 Bouquet Canyon Road, Santa Clarita, CA 91350.
Nov. 23: ACS Relay for Life SCV Holiday Boutique
California State Parks Office of Historic Preservation has announced it will begin accepting applications for the State Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credit Program at 8 a.m. on Jan. 6, 2025.
State Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credit Program Launch
1843 - Rancho Castec (Lebec-Tejon area) granted to French immigrant Jose Covarrubias [story]
Rancho Castec diseno map
Due to construction and weather delays, the closure of the exercise staircase at Central Park, 27150 Bouquet Canyon Road, Santa Clarita, CA 91350, will be extended through Nov. 28.
Central Park Exercise Staircase Closure Extended Thru Nov. 28
Santa Clarita Ballet's 30th anniversary production of "The Nutcracker" will perform, Saturday and Sunday, Dec. 14-15 at the Santa Clarita Performing Arts Center, 26455 Rockwell Canyon Road, Santa Clarita, CA 91355.
Dec. 14-15: Santa Clarita Ballet’s ‘The Nutcracker’
Registration is underway for the College of the Canyons winter 2025 session, which boasts more than 300 class sections.
COC Winter 2025 Registration Underway
Christmas came early for The Master's University Men's Basketball Head Coach Kelvin Starr.
TMU Men’s Basketball Knocks Off No. 2, Starr Sees 300th Win
Theatre in a Week and Off Book Theatre is back with its holiday one act comedy "Holiday Hijinx" Friday, Dec. 13- Sunday, Dec. 15 at The MAIN in Old Town Newhall.
Dec. 13-15: ‘Holiday Hijinx’ Presented by Theatre in a Week, Off Book Theatre
The Santa Clarita Master Chorale presents its Silver Bell Jubilee concert Sunday, Dec. 8, 4 p.m. at Santa Clarita Performing Arts Center, 26455 Rockwell Canyon Road, Santa Clarita, CA 91355.
Dec. 8:  Santa Clarita Master Chorale Presents Silver Bell Jubilee
The holiday season is just around the corner and it’s one of the most magical times of the year.
Mayor Cameron Smyth | Experience Holiday Cheer on the Tracks
Celebrate this special time of year with the 29th annual Winter Magic Lighted Boat Parade and holiday event Saturday, Dec. 7 at Castaic Lake, Lower Lagoon.
Dec. 7: The 29th Annual Winter Magic Lighted Boat Parade
1967 - Local voters approve formation of community college and elect COC's first five-member board - Dr. William G. Bonelli Jr., Bruce Fortine, Sheila Dyer, Peter Huntsinger, Edward Muhl [story]
COC board
You can make a difference in a child or teen’s life this holiday season through the Boys and Girls Club of the Santa Clarita Valley. You can volunteer at a club holiday event, host a toy drive, sponsor a club family or make a donation.
Hope for the Holidays with Boys & Girls Club of SCV
Art, in whatever the medium, can communicate so much. It can inspire imagination, exude peace and calm, or tell the world the stories of a community and a culture or connect on an extremely personal level.
Kalli Arte Collective to be CSUN’s First Orndorff Artist-in-Residence
The city of Santa Clarita invites community members to attend the unveiling of the newest inductees to the Walk of Western Stars.
Nov. 23: New Honorees Inducted into Walk of Western Stars
Supervisor Kathryn Barger commented on Attorney General Rob Bonta’s announcement that he is pursuing additional monitoring and strengthened protections for youth in Los Angeles County’s juvenile halls.
Barger on Protections for Youth in Juvenile Halls
SCVNews.com