[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | State Supreme Court: Hart District Can Be Held Liable in Molestation Case | 03-08-2012
Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
August 20
1967 - New Town of Valencia dedicated; homes sell for $25,000 [story]

In a unanimous decision Thursday, the California Supreme Court ruled that the William S. Hart Union High School District bears a measure of responsibility for alleged sexual molestation incidents involving a female guidance counselor and a male student at Golden Valley High School five years ago.

The case pertains to Roselyn Hubbell, a school counselor who was arrested in June 2008 in connection with the ongoing molestation of a 15-year-old boy from January to September 2007.

According to court papers filed by attorneys for the boy, Hubbell drove the victim home from school “and spent long hours with (him) on and off the high school premises. The guidance counselor performed a variety of sexual acts on (the victim) and required him to perform a number of sexual acts on her.”

Hubbell’s charges were ultimately reduced to one misdemeanor count of annoying or molesting a minor. In April 2009 she pleaded no contest to that charge and was placed on three year’s probation. A “no contest” plea cannot be used as an admission of guilt in a civil court.

Attorneys for the victim’s family filed a civil lawsuit against the school district, alleging the district knew Hubbell had a history of child molestation before it hired her and did nothing to warn people about it or prevent it from happening in the future.

The Hart District won at the trial court level and the Appeals Court upheld the decision. According to court documents, the appellate court ruled that even if the district knew about Hubbell’s history before it hired her, the district can’t be held laible if she did it again.

The question for the California Supreme Court was whether the appellate court decision was correct. It said no.

The specific issue for the high court was this:

“When a school district’s employees hire, retain or supervise a school guidance counselor they know or have reason to know has a history of child molestation, can the school district be vicariously liable for that negligent hiring, retention or supervision under Government Code section 820 if that counselor molests a student entrusted to her – or is the molested student unable to sue the school district because there is no separate statute imposing direct liability on the district for that conduct, as the Court of Appeal majority held in its published opinion in this case?”

Writing for the Supreme Court, Justice Kathryn Mickle Werdegar said, “We conclude plaintiff’s theory of vicarious liability for negligent hiring, retention and supervision is a legally viable one. Ample case authority establishes that school personnel owe students under their supervision a protective duty of ordinary care, for breach of which the school district may be held vicariously liable.”

In other words, yes, a school district can be sued for damages if it knew or should have known about an employee’s history of child molestation.

Which is well and good from a theoretical standpoint.

But the underlying question remains:

Before she was hired into the William S. Hart Union High School District, did Roselyn Hubbell have a history of child molestation that the district knew or should have known about?

The Supreme Court assumed she did.

But that “fact” has never been proved in a court of law.

When the plaintiffs initially sued the Hart District, the school district filed a demurrer, alleging the court lacked statutory authority to hear the case because the Hart District (thought it) couldn’t be held liable. The trial court agreed, and the facts of the case – Did Hubbell have a history or not? – were not argued.

Plaintiffs appealed the trial court’s decision to uphold the demurrer, meaning the appellate court only ruled on whether the Hart District could be sued. It didn’t delve into Hubbell’s history.

At the Supreme Court level, Hubbell’s history was not open to debate. The only question was whether a school district could be held liable IF it knew an employee had a history.

In a statement Thursday from the law firm handling the matter for the Hart District – whose costs were covered under the school district’s insurance policy – attorney Steve Harber of McCune & Harber said the case is in the “allegations stage. It is one thing to make allegations; it is another to establish facts.”

At this point, the idea that Hubbell had a history of child molestation is merely an allegation – as is the idea that she molested the boy at Golden Valley, from the court’s standpoint. Because Hubbell’s “no contest” plea in the criminal court can’t be used as an admission of guilt in a civil court, the “fact” that she molested the boy at Golden Valley hasn’t been established in the civil case against the Hart District.

Hubbell was a Hart District employee from August 2002 to June 2008. When she was hired, state law required school district employees to be fingerprinted for background checks. Hart District administrators were not immediately able to give details about Hubbell’s background check Thursday – and aren’t likely to do so because it’s a matter of pending litigation – but if she was cleared in the background check, she might not have had a criminal history.

“When the true facts come out, they will show that the (school) district appropriately screens its teachers and counselors,” Harber’s statement said. “The alleged perpetrator here was found out, arrested and prosecuted because of the district’s vigilance.”

The public is likely to find out whether Hubbell had a prior history of child molestation – and whether the Hart District knew or should have known about it. That’s because Thursday’s Supreme Court decision opens the door for the victim’s attorneys to bring the case back to the trial court and argue the facts for the first time.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

No Comments

    Leave a Comment

    Related Content
    Wednesday, Aug 16, 2017
    The Saugus Union School Board is establishing a committee to advise on the development of policies and procedures for the sale or lease of surplus real property owned by the District.
    Wednesday, Aug 16, 2017
    The Castaic Union School District's Governing Board will hold a special meeting on Thursday, August 17 at 5 p.m.
    Tuesday, Aug 15, 2017
    Arroyo Seco Junior High School will be celebrating its 50th Anniversary on Friday, September 1, with a midday ceremony and festivities.
    Thursday, Aug 10, 2017
    The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board has approved the hiring of Ralph Peschek as Chief Financial Officer and John Muraki as Director of Classified Personnel.
    Wednesday, Aug 9, 2017
    The SCV Education Foundation seeks to further support its literacy programs at the Castaic, Newhall, Saugus and Sulphur Springs elementary school districts with its annual "Bag of Books" fundraising campaign.
    Keep Up With Our Facebook
    Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
    The Santa Clarita Public Library invites residents to view the total solar eclipse on Monday, August 21 at the Old Town Newhall Library starting at 10 a.m.
    August 21: Solar Eclipse Viewing at Newhall Library
    1967 - New Town of Valencia dedicated; homes sell for $25,000 [story]
    1879 - Newhall civic leader Charles Henry Kingsburry born in Missouri [story]
    Alerted by a concerned citizen Friday, Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station deputies once again rescued dogs the owner left in a car with the windows rolled up and no water.
    Deputies Break Window, Rescue Dogs Locked in Car
    40 oz. to Freedom arrives in Santa Clarita as part of its anniversary tour at Concerts in the Park at Central Park on Saturday, August 19, with showtime at 7 p.m.
    August 19: 40 Oz. to Freedom Rocks Central Park
    Two local environmental groups filed a complaint in L.A. Superior Court Thursday regarding the approved plan to provide water to the Newhall Ranch development, set to break ground in 2018.
    Environmental Groups File Complaint Against Newhall Ranch Water Plan
    County Supervisor Kathryn Barger has provided $143,000 in funding to extend the season of youth and adult swim programs offered at the Castaic Aquatic Center through October 31.
    Castaic Aquatic Center Programs Extended to October 31
    Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Los Angeles County firefighters and government leaders welcomed back the Super Scoopers Friday morning. Plus, the Old Town Newhall Library helped get the community ready for it as well by handing out free eclipse viewing glasses. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
    SCV NewsBreak for Friday, August 18, 2017
    CalArts alumna Audrey Chan (Art MFA 07) will host a free, all-ages interactive arts workshop in Little Tokyo on Saturday and Sunday, August 19 and 20, as part of the Japanese American Cultural & Community Center’s 2017 Nisei Week activities.
    August 19-20: Nisei Week Arts Workshop with CalArts Alum Audrey Chan
    Western singer and songwriter John Zipperer headlines the next episode of "SCVTV Presents The OutWest Concert Series" at The MAIN in Old Town Newhall the evening of Friday, August 25.
    August 25: John Zipperer Headlines ‘SCVTV Presents The OutWest Concert Series’
    Habitat for Humanity SFV/SCV is honored to have received a $25,000 grant from the Disabled Veterans National Foundation, which will fund trauma workshops.
    Habitat for Humanity Receives $25K Grant from Disabled Veterans
    Here are agenda highlights for the next meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, set for Tuesday, August 22, starting at 9:30 a.m..
    August 22: Board of Supervisors Meeting Agenda
    Ashley Olivier, a student worker at the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station, summited Mt. Whitney with her dad, a lieutenant at LASD's Monterey Park station.
    SCV Sheriff’s Station Student Worker, LASD Dad Top Mt. Whitney
    Looking to enter the win column for the first time in 2017 on day two of the Summer Slam volleyball tournament, the TMU Mustangs squared off against 11th-ranked Eastern Oregon but lost in straight sets.
    Mountaineers Spike Mustangs at Summer Slam
    Caltrans has released "Rail and the California Economy," a research report investigating how the state’s vast passenger and freight rail system contribute to California’s economy, as well as an overview of opportunities for rail to address the state’s needs and challenges in the future.
    New Report Details Rail Role in State Economy
    The Master’s University women’s soccer team soared to a 7-0 victory over the visiting Eagles from Sierra Nevada College Thursday.
    Lady Mustangs Soccer Win Opener 7-0
    The Master’s University women's volleyball team concluded their first day of HIU Summer Slam tournament play with a five-set thriller against the Southern Oregon University Raiders on Wednesday evening, dropping the fifth set 15-9.
    Lady Mustangs Fall in 5 to Raiders at HIU
    A federal judge on Wednesday ruled against claims by a state workers’ union that California’s pension system unfairly changed the terms of a pre-existing collective bargaining agreement.
    Court Upholds Increase in CalPERS Retirement Age
    Friday's alert from the South Coast Air Quality Management District that air quality will be unhealthy for sensitive individuals in the Santa Clarita Valley has been extended through Saturday.
    Updated: SCV Air Quality Unhealthy Saturday
    Four annual crime reports, which provide law enforcement agencies and the public with statewide data on crime statistics, were released Friday by California's Attorney General.
    AG Releases 4 California Crime Reports for 2016
    The Master’s University women’s volleyball team lost their 2017 season opener Wednesday at the HIU Summer Slam in straight sets against the Warriors from national powerhouse Corban University (OR).
    Warriors Drop TMU Lady Mustangs in Straight Sets
    Here's the Castaic/Val Verde (Zone 2) Crime Information and Public Safety Report from the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station for the week of August 7 to August 13.
    Crime Blotter: Assault, Theft in Castaic-Val Verde
    Two Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station employees will be recognized at the City Council meeting to be held on August 22 at 6 p.m.
    City Council to Honor 2 SCV Sheriff’s Station Employees
    The city of Santa Clarita’s Youth Sports program has seen measured success thus far in 2017.
    Santa Clarita Youth Sports Program Sees Spike in Participation
    The Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center’s new building campaign now only has $1.3 million remaining to raise before groundbreaking on the site can begin.
    New SCV Senior Center Needs $1.3M to Break Ground
    Sacramento County sued the California Department of Water Resources on Thursday over DWR's certification of the California 'WaterFix' delta tunnels project’s “dizzying” and “shifting” environmental review.
    Sacramento County Sues to Freeze California ‘WaterFix’
    1946 - Pioneering Placerita Canyon movie producer Trem Carr dies in San Diego [story]
    ' style=
    The storewide remodel of the Walmart Supercenter at 26471 Carl Boyer Drive is complete and, in addition to the many physical changes inside, Santa Clarita residents now have access to Online Grocery Pickup.
    Walmart on Carl Boyer Drive Celebrates Grand Reopening Friday
    Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, two people have been hospitalized after a major collision. Plus, an acquisition of land near the 14. Watch these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
    SCV NewsBreak for Thursday August 17, 2017
    Le Chene French Cuisine, a long-time Santa Clarita local favorite restaurant along Sierra Highway, has announced that they will be hosting a thrilling Murder Mystery Dinner on Saturday, November 4th, 2017.
    Nov. 4: Le Chene Murder Mystery Dinner
    Senator Scott Wilk, R- Antelope Valley, today announces that he is one of the 2017 inductees into the Antelope Valley High School Alumni Hall of Fame.
    Sept. 22: Wilk to be Inducted into AV High School Hall of Fame
    Signups are under way for the Santa Clarita Walk to End Alzheimer’s, which offers participants an opportunity to take a healthy stroll, experience outstanding live entertainment, honor loved ones who have been affected by Alzheimer’s and raise funds to battle the debilitating disease.
    Oct. 7: Walk to End Alzheimer’s; Signups Under Way
    Trammell Crow Company (TCC) andand Clarion Partners are pleased to announce the acquisition of 54 acres of land for the development of The Center at Needham Ranch, a state-of-the-art business park in the city of Santa Clarita, CA.
    TCC, Clarion Partners Acquire More Than 50 Acres of SCV Real Estate
    The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration is hosting what will be a highly educational and informative (and free) Tax Seminar for Nonprofits and Exempt Organizations.
    Sept. 6: Tax Seminar for Non-Profits and Exempt Organizations