[KHTS] – Santa Clarita City Council members voted 4-1 to prolong the discussion over whether Santa Clarita should allow a fake eucalyptus tree-shaped cellphone structure near a water tower in Valencia to improve AT&T coverage.
The move followed a more than three-hour discussion about the location, whether the service provider misled with its application and whether fake eucalyptus trees are ugly.
As a result of the vote, Santa Clarita city staffers were directed to see if there was a way to alleviate Northbridge residents’ concerns about the tower, and also to draft a resolution of denial so it could be voted on if the City Council wishes to reject AT&T’s plan.
Newly elected City Councilman Dante Acosta repeatedly questioned a Crown Castle representative, as well as AT&T, regarding their preparation for the appeal.
A Crown Castle representative who was contracted on behalf of AT&T said a coverage-area map questioned by Northbridge residents only showed voice service, which wasn’t the only problem area.
“I erred on the side of the residents,” Acosta said, noting there appeared to be discrepancies between the map presented to Santa Clarita City Council for the hearing and the one on AT&T’s website. The one on the site said it included voice and data, and contradicted the one shown at the hearing, Acosta said.
“You don’t appear to have all your ducks in a row,” Acosta said. “I have a problem with that.”
He also noted the Crown Castle agents working on behalf of AT&T didn’t have adequate information on their attempts to look at other sites for the eucalyptus tree-shaped facility.
The Planning Commission approved the cellphone structure, which would actually be a 47-foot tall fake eucalyptus tree adjacent to a water tower and several other shorter trees. It also calls for a 200-square-foot supporting structure at the base of the tree.
However, a couple dozen residents showed up to Council Chambers to argue an appeal claiming the tower was unnecessary, as there was no coverage gap, and the tree would only add “blight” to the area in addition to detracting from their property’s value.
The residents brought a video of themselves making calls on what they claimed were AT&T phones throughout the area where AT&T claimed there was no service.
The service providers’ reps said the residents’ evidence was anecdotal, but it seemed to be a factor for council members Marsha McLean and TimBen Boydston, who also questioned the presentation.
If Santa Clarita City Council members wanted to reject AT&T, they had to do so formally in writing with a resolution, which staff had to be directed to prepare. This move was put off until a date to be determined at City Manager Ken Striplin’s request.
Bob Kellar was the lone vote of opposition, noting while he sympathized with the residents, the issues affected more than just Northbridge.
If the city stopped all cellphone towers from going into residential areas, there would be a bigger problem — there would be no service.
“If this tower only affected you I would vote with you 100 percent,” he said to the residents. “But this affects everyone and we rely on this system.”
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.
I live very close to where this tower would go. I’ve been to a couple of Planning Commission meetings on this and if I could have made it to last nights meeting would have spoken in favor of it. I’m completely with Bob Kellar on this. Why would ATT be spending the money on this if there are no coverage issues? They are trying to do the right thing for their customers and taking steps to mitigate the appearance. My protesting neighbors need to get over this. I’m sure they would have also protested the huge water tank that is on the site if it was no there first.
In the sixth paragraph, you quoted Dante Acosta as saying, “I aired on the side of the residents”. Didn’t he really say, “I erred on the side of the residents.”?
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Wednesday no new deaths and 22 new cases in the Santa Clarita Valley, with 12 additional deaths and 537 new cases countywide.
On March 21, 2023, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a motion adopting a plan for the County Probation Department’s halls and camps, specifically as it relates to establishing Secure Youth Treatment Facilities following the transfer of juvenile serious offenders from state to county custody.
Playing for the third time in five days, the CSUN women's tennis team extended its longest winning streak since 2015 to nine as the Matadors defeated Chaminade 7-0. CSUN's nine-dual winning streak is tied for the fifth-longest in school history with the 2006 and 2015 teams.
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Wednesday no new deaths and 22 new cases in the Santa Clarita Valley, with 12 additional deaths and 537 new cases countywide.
Circle of Hope Inc., a non-profit organization in Santa Clarita dedicated to providing emotional, financial, and educational support to individuals and families affected by cancer, is thrilled to announce their upcoming Hoedown For Hope Music Festival and BBQ fundraising event.
Girl Scouts of Greater Los Angeles has openings at its all-girl summer camps and are enrolling now for camps that take place June through August. Openings are at day camps in Inglewood and Claremont, and overnight camps in Frazier Park.
Beginning Monday, March 27, crews will start the construction of median modifications, paving, grinding and overlay operations along Plum Canyon Road, between Bouquet Canyon Road and Skyline Ranch Road.
On March 21, 2023, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a motion adopting a plan for the County Probation Department’s halls and camps, specifically as it relates to establishing Secure Youth Treatment Facilities following the transfer of juvenile serious offenders from state to county custody.
Already a two-time All-State selection, College of the Canyons sophomore LuLu Salloom has been named a 2023 Women's Basketball Coaches Association (WBCA) Two-Year College Coaches' All-American Honorable Mention honoree, just the second player in program history to receive such an honor.
On Monday afternoon, the California State University, Northridge women's tennis team extended its longest winning streak since 2015 when the Matadors defeated St. Thomas (Minn.) 7-0.
College of the Canyons, ranked No. 13, split a non-conference doubleheader vs. No. 10 Fullerton College on Saturday, taking the opener at Whitten Field in shutout fashion behind pitcher Allyson Melgar's big game before seeing the Hornets come away ahead in the late afternoon affair.
College of the Canyons student-athletes Alyssa Hamilton (women's swim) and Alexander Moores (men's golf) have been named the COC Athletic Department's Women's & Men's Student-Athletes of the Week for the period running March 13-18.
More than 1 billion Muslims around the world are preparing for Ramadan, and fasting which takes during the holiday is recognized as one of the Five Pillars of Islam.
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Tuesday no new deaths and 22 new cases in the Santa Clarita Valley, with 12 additional deaths and 644 new cases countywide.
The Master's University baseball team won both games of Saturday's doubleheader against the No. 7 Hope International Royals to win the three-game series.
The Master's men's and women's track and field teams set three school records and had 51 personal bests at the Ross and Sharon Irwin Collegiate Meet hosted by Point Loma Nazarene University.
The Sierra Hillbillies Square Dance Club will hold an Alumni Dance Sunday, April 2, hosting former members and class graduates with former club instructor and caller Rod Shuping at the mic.
The Santa Clarita Community College District Board of Trustees will meet in open session for a joint business meeting with the Associated Student Government Wednesday, March 22, at 3:30 p.m., in the University Center, Room 301 on the Valencia campus of College of the Canyons.
Tweet This
Facebook
Digg This
Bookmark
Stumble
RSS
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.
2 Comments
I live very close to where this tower would go. I’ve been to a couple of Planning Commission meetings on this and if I could have made it to last nights meeting would have spoken in favor of it. I’m completely with Bob Kellar on this. Why would ATT be spending the money on this if there are no coverage issues? They are trying to do the right thing for their customers and taking steps to mitigate the appearance. My protesting neighbors need to get over this. I’m sure they would have also protested the huge water tank that is on the site if it was no there first.
In the sixth paragraph, you quoted Dante Acosta as saying, “I aired on the side of the residents”. Didn’t he really say, “I erred on the side of the residents.”?