[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: Charter Judgment Day | 08-22-2016
Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Clear
Clear
79°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
September 28
1918 - Box-office superstar William S. Hart promotes 4th series of Liberty Loan (World War I) bonds, which go on sale on this date [story]


Commentary by Ken Pfalzgraf
| Monday, Aug 22, 2016

KenPfalzgraf2016For the better part of five years, I have been a regular – and often the only – attendee of the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District (AADUSD) board of trustees meetings. In the past three years, I’ve watched the district go from teetering at fiscal insolvency to operating with an ample surplus, funded by income from a vast network of charter schools developed using processes that have yet to be legally or legislatively validated – much less understood by the district’s constituents.

In addition to providing an alternative for educating students who were not being reached by standard methods, the charter school movement started as a means of developing innovations that would ultimately benefit public education. The ever-increasing popularity of charter schools has fueled a nasty division between public schools and charters over funding and test scores. Public schools lose funding when a student leaves for a charter. Some claim that charters “cream off” the best students, leaving the public schools with artificially deflated test scores and an inordinate share of the cost of instructing students with the highest needs.

Legislative intervention may be necessary to balance the fiscal well-being of public schools and the educational innovations being gained through the charters. But for now, the courts and the Legislature are focusing on the outer fringe of the charter school game, the prolific charter authorizers who are in it for the money.

First are “corporations and corporate interests — which are not about improving academic outcomes for students, but about maximizing revenues for the benefit of management’s personal wealth and/or to fund future growth” (see No. 1 below). Then there is the small, “cash strapped” school district struggling to maintain its market share of local students and looking to recoup lost funding by taking a cut off of the charters it sponsors elsewhere.

California Sen. Carol Liu recently requested to have three of California’s 997 school districts audited by the Joint Legislative Audit Committee, stating: “There have been accusations that some districts are authorizing in order to generate revenue through ‘oversight fees.’ Several extreme examples of this include Acton Agua Dulce Unified which has only four (actually three) traditional schools but authorizes 14 various charter schools, most outside the district. One of the district charters, Assurance Learning Academies, is located almost 60 miles away in Los Angeles. That school has significant academic issues including 91 percent of students not meeting standards in math” (2).

What happens to the fiscal stability of AADUSD if a legislative change wipes out the recent charter-generated windfall or if the few employees, past or present, who actually understand how the plan works take their ball and head off to another game?

With a California state auditor headed to AADUSD to have a closer look (3), does anybody else think it might be time to turn the focus back on the local students and fiscal self-sustainability?

 

Ken Pfalzgraf is an Acton resident and a candidate for the AADUSD Board of Trustees.

 

(1) https://www.csba.org/Newsroom/CSBANewsletters/2014/June/InPrint/VantagePoint.aspx

(2) https://www.dropbox.com/s/u9ow70cboesic46/Liu%20documents%20audit.pdf?dl=0

(3) https://www.dropbox.com/s/wnmutmeczab1w57/Charter%20audit%20methodology.pdf?dl=0

 

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

3 Comments

  1. Joe says:

    You neglected to mention that charter schools are public schools and offer parents an alternative to district run education.

    • Ken Pfalzgraf says:

      Certainly not wanting to get into a last word contest here but my piece makes several references to the educational innovations coming out of charter schools. I think the sheer number of students attending charters is a clear indicator of a demand for choice as no one is forcing anyone to attend a charter in lieu of a traditional public school. In fact, one of my children attends a charter school. Likewise, this is not about all charter schools or public schools being one thing or another. This is about 3, again 3, school districts out of 997 (that’s 3/10ths of 1 percent where I come from) being looked at for a suspect process. Problem for me is that one of the three, or 1/10th of 1 percent of all school districts in the state, is the district where I live and where I am a candidate for the board. In other words, what Lee Jenkinson said.

  2. Lee Jenkinson says:

    As always, a potentially good idea is abused by those in charge for personal gain. It sounds as if legislation to tighten up oversight and practices is overdue.

Leave a Comment


Commentary Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Related Content
RECENT COMMENTARY
Tuesday, Sep 27, 2016
Social justice warriors at the University of Kansas screamed obscenities at white students who didn’t feel the need for "safe spaces." Imagine that. The self-proclaimed warriors of civility and equality respond to what was supposed to be an open conversation by shouting them down, using foul language, and screaming in the faces of students with a different viewpoint.
Sunday, Sep 25, 2016
I have taken many walks on the plains of Tanzania with Masai body guards armed with spears and occasionally rifles. It is rather unnerving to think at any moment, you could become prey to a lion, cheetah or another apex predator.
Thursday, Sep 22, 2016
If you find yourself traveling east on Interstate 40 to Needles or beyond, you might want to consider a short side trip to explore Amboy Crater National Natural Landmark. It’s located just off of National Trails Highway (Historic Route 66) about 28 miles east of the town of Ludlow.
Tuesday, Sep 20, 2016
Medicare’s annual open enrollment season begins Oct. 15 and runs through Dec. 7. This is the time every year when you can sign up for a new Medicare drug or health plan, or switch the one you have now.
Tuesday, Sep 20, 2016
“Pseudologia fantastica” is defined as “a condition involving compulsive lying by a person with no obvious motivation. The affected person might believe their lies to be truth and may have to create elaborate myths to reconcile them with other facts.”
Monday, Sep 19, 2016
Edel Alonso is the best choice for new leadership and change on the COC Board of Trustees. She has the intelligence and dedication to ensure that the college’s priorities are focused on assisting students to reach their career and educational goals.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Support Hart Cheer and buy a raffle ticket for $10 to win 12 VIP tickets plus parking to see the LA Kings take on the Vancouver Canucks at the Staples Center on Saturday, Oct. 22.
Help Hart Cheer: Enter to Win Kings VIP Tix, $6,000 Value
Join expert archivists who work in the entertainment industry in celebrating the 14th annual International Home Movie Day on Saturday, Oct. 15, from noon to 4 p.m. at the Valencia Public Library.
Oct. 15: Share Your Old Home Movie at Valencia Library
Los Angeles County Supervisor Don Knabe is proud to announce that the County’s Safe Surrender Program celebrated success for the fifth time this year with the report of a safely surrendered newborn baby boy. This most recent Safe Surrender occurred on Monday, Sept. 27m at a hospital in Montebello.
Baby Boy Safely Surrendered in L.A. County
The City of Santa Clarita’s March-through-October Thursdays@Newhall series comes to a close with an interactive dance night, one-of-kind car show, a zombie outbreak, interesting speakers and more on Main Street in Old Town Newhall.
From Zydeco to Zombies: Thursdays in Newhall in October
Former Los Angeles County Sheriff Leroy Baca says he will not get a fair trial on charges he obstructed an investigation into jailhouse abuses because a federal judge is already convinced of his guilt and media coverage has prejudiced him.
Baca Wants New Judge, Prosecutor, Trial Location
The Master’s University’s women’s soccer team’s 2016 record moved to 4-4-2 (0-2 GSAC) after falling to Biola University 4-0 Tuesday night.
Soccer: Biola Shuts Door on Lady Mustangs
Morgan Koch paced the Lady Mustangs with eight kills, while Tate followed with seven. Kayla Sims tallied 27 assists, while Emily Clark notched 12 digs. Stevens finished the evening with four blocks and six kills.
Volleyball: Lady Mustangs Improve to 13-5 with Win Over Warriors
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, see how local students are combating body image issues. Plus, Hart Park will celebrate Native American culture this weekend. See how, coming up.
SCV NewsBreak for Wednesday, September 28, 2016
Work will begin on Monday, Oct. 3, 2016, and is expected to be completed in six (6) working days. Detonation will occur on October 4th, 5th, 6th, 10th, 11th, and 12th, 2016. All work will be conducted between the hours of 7 a.m. and 5 p.m.
Explosions Scheduled for Whittaker-Bermite Site
The Castaic Board of Trustees is looking to hire an attorney to help with the legal issues surrounding a home entrusted to Castaic Middle School.
Castaic Board Looking to Hire Attorney to Battle Over Home
The Friends of Hart Park 23rd Annual Hart of the West Powwow and Native American Craft Fair is this Saturday and Sunday.
Oct 1-2: Annual Hart of the West Powwow and Native American Craft Fair Returns
The annual American Indian Celebration at Antelope Valley Indian Museum returns on Oct. 15 and 16 from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. Native artists will sell jewelry, beadwork, gourd art, paintings, and crafts at the event.
Oct. 1: Help Repair Red Rock Trail; Oct. 15-16: Native Celebration at AV Museum; more
1918 - Box-office superstar William S. Hart promotes 4th series of Liberty Loan (World War I) bonds, which go on sale on this date [story]
The Santa Clarita Homeless Coalition presents SCV CARES – a community event to bring homeless awareness and resources to the Santa Clarita Valley.
Oct. 15: Homeless Resources, Awareness Event at Real Life Church
The Saugus Union School District today announced the appointment of Nick Heinlein to the position of Assistant Superintendent, Business. Mr. Heinlein comes to the Saugus District from a similar position with the Tehachapi Unified School District, Tehachapi and will officially join the district on Tuesday, Oct. 4.
Saugus School District Names New Asst. Superintendent for Business
For the second week in a row, a member from The Master’s University has been named the GSAC Men’s Soccer Offensive Player of the Week award as Benjamin Tembo earned the honor after scoring the game-winning, sudden-victory goal in last Tuesday's 1-0 thriller over No. 8 Vanguard.
TMU Soccer’s Tembo is GSAC Offensive Player of Week
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, the county awaits "all clear" to fix Vasquez Canyon Road. Plus, some quick tips on how to register to vote in honor of National Voter Registration Day. Check out these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Tuesday, September 27, 2016
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson thanked Gov. Jerry Brown on Tuesday for signing legislation requiring schools that serve students from grades 7 to 12 to adopt suicide prevention policies.
State Requires Suicide Prevention Policies for 7-12 Schools
The College of the Canyons Athletics department is inviting all players, coaches and cheerleaders associated with a Santa Clarita Valley youth sports league or cheer organization to attend Saturday’s Cougar football game free of charge.
COC Football Saturday: Free Entry for Youth Sports Players, Cheer, Coaches
The Trinity Knights Varsity Football (3-1), led by Coach Les Robinson, will play host to the Santa Clarita Christian Cardinals (0-4) this Saturday, October 1 at 7 p.m. as they battle it out to claim the title of Faith Bowl Champion 2016.
Crosstown Showdown Oct. 1: Trinity vs. SCCS in 2nd Annual Faith Bowl
Santa Clarita-based BioSolar Inc., a developer of breakthrough energy storage technology and materials, announced it has initiated a new program for the development of a high energy anode for current and next generation lithium batteries.
SCV Firm Developing High-Energy Battery Anode
After months of attempts to negotiate with a property owner of the hillside next to Vasquez Canyon Road, county officials are moving forward with the condemnation process in hopes making repairs.
County Awaits ‘All Clear’ to Fix Vasquez Canyon Road
The Santa Clarita Valley Economic Development Corp. received a Gold Excellence in Economic Development Award on Tuesday for its 2016 "Still Golden" campaign project in the category of Special Purpose Print Brochure from the International Economic Development Council.
Peers Say SCV Economic Development Corp. is Pure Gold
The annual Fight It race raises thousands of dollars to help young professionals across The United States battling cancer by providing financial assistance.
Oct. 8: 5K Race is On for Brenda Mehling Cancer Fund
Drawing is seeing. Recognizing the lines and shapes of objects around us, we can learn to draw what we see and advance our drawing skills. Join the ARTree for a beginner-level class in drawing with a highly experienced educator and artist.
New ARTree Class: Basic Drawing for Kids; more
"Startup Weekend SCV 2016" is going to help aspiring entrepreneurs grow their startup from an idea to a business in 54 hours.
Nov. 4: Local Entrepreneurs Have Opportunity to Test Out Startup Ideas
Noah's Park Preschool is hosting the 3rd annual Trunk-or-Treat on Friday, October 21 from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m.
Oct. 21: Trunk-or-Treat Returns to Noah’s Park Preschool
To end uncertainty in the collection of victim restitution from convicted offenders that resulted from public safety realignment, Gov. Jerry Brown on Tuesday signed a bill by Senator Fran Pavley that will both ensure restitution is collected from the accounts of county jail inmates and that funds aren’t double-collected from individuals on Post-Release Community Supervision.
Gov. Signs Pavley’s Crime Victim Restitution Bill
A unique Fall Festival that showcases food, interactive art and family entertainment while offering an opportunity to meet and learn from people with developmental disabilities will be held from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Saturday, Oct. 15, at the idyllic seven acre Tierra Del Sol Sunland campus.
Oct. 15: Tierra Del Sol Festival to Showcase Talents of Special Adults
A recap of some of the things that have been happening around U.S. Rep. Steve Knight's 25th Congressional District.
Around the 25th District with Rep. Steve Knight
Social justice warriors at the University of Kansas screamed obscenities at white students who didn’t feel the need for "safe spaces." Imagine that. The self-proclaimed warriors of civility and equality respond to what was supposed to be an open conversation by shouting them down, using foul language, and screaming in the faces of students with a different viewpoint.
The Safe Spacers
2014 - Towsley Canyon Loop Trail named for naturalist Don Mullally [story]
"Instead of arresting and stigmatizing young child sex trafficking victims, law enforcement will now play a critical role in helping these girls get the support and treatment they need to escape life on the streets," Supervisor Don Knabe said.
Knabe Praises Brown for Decriminalizing Prostitution for Minors
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, the Valencia Ice Station ATM is stolen and Golden Valley High School students learn about preventing domestic violence. Plus, Be the Light 5k and a woman fights an aggressive form of cancer.
SCV NewsBreak for Monday, September 26, 2016
More than 4,000 students and their families attended William S. Hart Union High School District’s 6th Annual College & Career Fair at Golden Valley High School Thursday evening.
Thousands Attend Hart District College, Career Fair
After battling through a pair of five-set victories against Biola University and Vanguard University last week, The Master’s University’s Allison Child has been named the GSAC’s Attacker of the Week while Kayla Sims was pegged as the conference’s Setter of the Week.
Volleyball: 2 Lady Mustangs Earn Weekly Conference Kudos