[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Intermittent clouds
Intermittent clouds
80°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
July 16
1925 - Actor Harry Carey files patent on the original 160-acre Saugus homestead he'd purchased in 1916 (now Tesoro Del Valle) [story]


[CLICK HERE] to read the report.

 

einstein[KHTS] – A county-requested Extraordinary Audit final report released Tuesday alleged violations in Einstein Academy’s charter school petitions, “significant deficiencies” with the schools’ internal controls and a lack of written accounting policies.

Albert Einstein Academy for the Letters, Arts and Sciences operates a K-6 charter school in Newhall, which is chartered by the Acton Agua Dulce Unified School District, as well as a high school in Valencia, which is chartered through the William S. Hart Union High School District.

“The report speaks for itself,” said Kostas Kalaitzides, spokesman for the Los Angeles County Office of Education.

He declined further comment.

Einstein officials did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The charter schools’ officials faced several local denials for its petition to operate a k-6 charter school in the Santa Clarita Valley, which led the school to seek permission from the Acton Agua Dulce Unified School District.

AADUSD officials granted the petition, which prompted a lawsuit from the Newhall School District against Einstein Academy and AADUSD, claiming the school was usurping Newhall’s local control, among other legal concerns.

The presiding judge in the lawsuit named Newhall as the prevailing party, set aside the previously approved charter and is now asking Einstein to re-seek permission from AADUSD to operate a charter school in the Santa Clarita Valley.

Acton Agua Dulce Unified School District officials are now considering the move, which must be approved by the governing board. A decision by the board is expected in the coming weeks.

According to the findings on “Internal Controls” section of the report:

“Based on the findings of the FCMAT extraordinary audit, the team concludes that significant deficiencies exist with the internal control structure, particularly with monitoring procedures, internal controls over operations and management’s ability to override internal controls.”

The first recommendation in the report to the county’s superintendent of education, who requested the Extraordinary Audit, was: “Notify the governing board of AEALAS that insufficient documentation exists that fraud, misappropriation of charter funds and/or assets or other illegal activities may have occurred and that the county office has concluded its review.”

 

Why the Einstein Academy audit was conducted

The financial review was requested by the county’s Office of Education, after alleged indications of fraud and commingling funds within the AEALAS organization were presented to county Superintendent Arturo Delgado, the draft states.

The report didn’t find substantiation for the fraud claims. It acknowledges the FCMAT team lacks any such legal authority to declare an occurrence of fraud, with its role being one of independent operational review.

The goal of the audit was to present the requested information to Delgado. Delgado has authority to make recommendations to the District Attorney’s Office if he suspects illegal activity occurred.

Before the report’s publication, Acton Agua Dulce Superintendent Brent Woodard said based on conversations he’d had with officials, he didn’t believe the issues with Einstein Academy reached a “red flag” level of concern.

Woodard said he planned to address the concerns at the school’s charter petition hearing, however, Los Angeles County Office of Education officials had not yet finalized the report with FCMAT as of that hearing date.

Woodard did not immediately return calls seeking a comment Tuesday.

 

An overview of the FCMAT audit report for Einstein Academy

The report is broken down into three sections: an explanation of what FCMAT is and the study conducted into the operations for Einstein Academy’s various schools; an explanation of Albert Einstein Academy for the Letters, Arts and Sciences operations they reviewed; and a review of the team’s findings.

The audit was requested in December 2013, and then amended in March 2014, and the audit was underway by April.

During interviews, “FCMAT study team members asked questions pertaining to levels of authority to enter into contracts, governing board oversight, financial management policies and procedures, job duties and responsibilities, the business practices processing of transactions through the various back office service providers, and management’s process for preserving documents and the overall internal control structure and line of authority,” according to the report.

The audit also sampled transactions between three organizations identified in the audit, the schools’ management organization (CMO), the nonprofit AEALAS Foundation and the schools’ operating entity, AEALAS Inc.

 

Below are findings in the report, taken directly from the report.  

 

Internal controls for Einstein Academy

* The 2011-12 independent auditor’s report findings and questioned costs identified two internal control findings:

* Finding 2011-1 identified that AEALAS, Inc. lacks formal purchasing policies because invoices that were tested did not have an audit trail of who initiates, authorizes, and approves the purchases, and a check was issued to a staff member rather than the actual vendor.

* Finding 2011-2 identified the lack of a formal cash receipt process or policy because there was no formal documentation of cash and checks collected and deposited.

* The 2012-13 independent auditor’s report findings and questioned costs identified six findings:

* Finding 2013-1 identified that AEALAS, Inc. had established a CMO without setting aside funding for the CMO’s operations and failed to budget for its activities. Referenced in finding 2013-1 are audit notes one, four, and 14. Audit note four documents that an intercompany payable of $354,260 owed by the CMO to AEALAS-Hart was corrected by the auditor as an audit adjustment at page 21 in the 2012-13 audit report’s Schedule to Reconcile the Unaudited Actuals Report with Audited Financial Statements, as shown above in Table III.

* Finding 2013-1 and audit note 14 describe that AEALAS, Inc. also loaned $457,481 to the Foundation for the purpose of starting new school locations.

Because of the funds loaned to the CMO and Foundation, the AEALAS-Hart charter school had to sell a portion of its receivables and place some of its cash as collateral to fund the CMO activities.

* Finding 2013-1 response of AEALAS, Inc. states that AEALAS, Inc. has hired a new experienced chief financial officer (CFO) who will be addressing the budget and control issues. FCMAT believes the new CFO should provide stability and improve AEALAS’s internal controls and management monitoring, accountability, and communication and the overall control environment of all AEALAS organizations.

* Finding 2013-2 identified that the CMO does not follow the same cash disbursement controls as AEALAS-Hart.

* Finding 2013-3 identified that AEALAS, Inc. authorized a payment on one of its loans resulting in an overpayment of $4,000.

* Finding 2013-4 identified that loan documents were unsigned and minutes of board meetings were missing. In addition, the CMO did not have any budgets readily available for the other charter schools except for AEALAS-Hart.

* Finding 2013-5 identified that the AEALAS, Inc. founder and former executive director were continuing to sign checks and loan documents on behalf of AEALAS, Inc. without express authorization of the governing board. Auditors were unable to obtain board meeting minutes or other documents indicating any authority to perform those functions.

* Finding 2013-6 identified that $142,500 of loans payable to related parties were delinquent and not in compliance with Bond Series 2012A and Bond Taxable Series 2012B loan agreement covenants in the following sections:

* 5.07, failure to file annual report for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2013 on time.

* 5.09, to maintain an arm’s-length relationship with its affiliates such as the Foundation; not to pledge its assets for the benefit of any other entity or make any loans or advances to any other entity such as was done with the Foundation; to hold itself out as a separate entity when the Foundation processed a loan with Mission Valley Bank while the loan was issued to AEALAS, Inc. using AEALAS, Inc.’s tax identification number; to correct any known misunderstanding regarding separate identity, which AEALAS, Inc. did not correct and left the loan in the name of AEALAS, Inc.; to maintain adequate capital whereby the CMO did not have a budget or operating capital for its activities.

* 5.12, AEALAS, Inc. failed to have the required 30 days cash on hand.

* 5.13, AEALAS, Inc. failed to maintain its short-term borrowing to less than 10 percent of its gross revenue, which at June 30, 2013 was 14 percent.

 

Transaction Sampling for the Foundation, CMO, AEALAS-AlpineEA, AEALAS-Acton, and AEALAS-Hart

FCMAT found that consistent and complete audit trail documentation continues to be unavailable. In several instances, the only documentation of the transaction to support the item sampled was a photocopy of a commercial warrant. The team did observe that the most current transactions selected as part of the sample testing were supported by more complete documentation, including vendor invoices, contracts and photocopies of the commercial warrant.

Many loan agreements are unsigned by one or both parties to the loan. In addition, minutes of the governing board approval authorizing the loan were not available.

A deficiency exists with formal written cash receipt processes or policies. For several cash receipt transactions, including donations, AEALAS failed to formally document cash and checks collected and deposited, and failed to present or have available donation acceptance letter copies acknowledging acceptance of any donations. In many instances, only a deposit slip was available and was missing photocopies of checks that support the total amount deposited.

Conversely, stacks of check copies and remittent advice copies were available but did not indicate the date of deposit.

The Foundation accounting records identified six transactions totaling $22,258.12 between March 2014 and May 2014 noted as cash and located in the general ledger account titled “Ask My Accountant–Cash Transactions.” AEALAS was unable to provide any documentation that would explain these cash transactions.

The Foundation accounting records identified a vendor as “Pizza Place” with four transactions in October 2013 totaling $13,847.65; however, the supporting documents indicated that the transactions were for legal services, consulting and reimbursements.

* $10,000 for legal services regarding the Ventura project-AEALAS-TO.

* $2,000 to Mark Blazer for reimbursement; however, no documentation was available to provide the details of the reimbursement.

 

Other findings in the FCMAT report

During FCMAT’s examination of AEALAS books and records, other notable findings involved pledged commitments as part of the charter petitions. AEALAS charter petitions relied on significant and material dollar amount donations from the Foundation to support several charter petitions included in the proposed startup financial budgets. The Foundation’s accounting records show that at no time did its cash accounts have available funding levels to honor the commitments made in the charter petitions to the authorizing entities.

Specific examples include:

* The AEALAS-TO charter petition submitted to the Ventura County Office of Education in November 2012 states on page 8 of the financial plan: “The plan includes a starting balance of $275,000 based on an existing commitment of funds to the school.” The funds are committed by the Foundation and scheduled in the AEALAS-TO charter petition financial plan on Table X cash flow to be received in July 2013.

* The Saugus Union School District August 2012 charter petition that was denied by the district included in the proposed charter petition a commitment letter from the Foundation of $150,000 to be received February 1, 2013 and $150,000 to be received August 1, 2013.

* The AEALAS San Fernando Valley charter petition that was denied by the charter authorizer included in the proposed AEALAS San Fernando Valley charter petitions’ multiyear budget, that in July 2012, the Foundation would donate $275,000 “if needed.”

* FCMAT’s review of the Foundation’s QuickBooks software accounting records from the date of the Foundation’s first transaction recorded on April 30, 2012 through June 4, 2014 revealed that the daily balance never had combined or individual cash of $150,000.

In other words, the Foundation records indicate that the Foundation did not have the ability to pledge or pay the stated donations in the proposed charter school petitions of $150,000 (Saugus petition) or $275,000 (San Fernando Valley).

* The largest cash balance that the Foundation possessed in any of its cash accounts was in its primary checking account, with a balance of $148,379.51 on July 5, 2013. The temporary large cash balance is attributable to an influx of funds lent to the Foundation by the CMO on the same day, July 5, 2013, totaling $150,700. Two days earlier on July 3, 2013, the primary checking account balance was negative by $2,320.49.

* The Foundation account titled Outside Contract Services contains 40 checks dated December 17, 2013, of $599.99 each and totaling $23,999.60 that were paid to employees of AEALAS-Hart. The checks do not describe the purpose of the payment, or type of contract service each of the AEALAS-Hart employees performed to receive $599.99 in compensation.

AEALAS was unable to provide any Internal Revenue Service (IRS) form W-9s signed by the 40 independent contractors. A signed IRS form W-9 – Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification should be required for all independent contractors regardless of the amount the contractor or consultant earns from the organization as a practice of a good system of internal controls.

According to IRS publications specific to issuing IRS Form 1099, if the cumulative earnings of an independent contractor are $600 or more, the Foundation would have been required to issue a 1099-Misc to each contractor. Because a signed W-9 was not provided to FCMAT, each contractor who received the $599.99 may have been subject to the IRS’s 28% backup withholding requirement. In any event, the payment to each employee/contractor is reportable income and should have been included on the individual tax return.

The Foundation is designated to serve the AEALAS charter schools, issue consolidated charter school and CMO financial reports. The AEALAS organizations transfer and lend money among themselves, pay expenses for each other, and operate under common management and control.

Therefore, the Foundation and other AEALAS organizations may be considered one group entity.

For these and other reasons described, transactions such as paying employees as independent contractors may also be considered as circumventing payroll tax withholding and an attempt to avoid paying the employer’s portion of payroll taxes.

Finally, paying for unsubstantiated work by AEALAS-Hart charter school employees with Foundation funds may be considered a gift of public funds and allowed management to override internal controls. This is a critical internal control point because management should be the final check and balance that prevents such transactions.

 

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

2 Comments

  1. I can say they don’t pay homeschool vendors on time or all. Horrible…
    One of the “places” we go for extra classes has considered not accepting Einstein Academy funding. :(

  2. Allen Yang says:

    It’s a good thing the county is making sure the AEA school has $150,000 in its checking account instead of only $148,379.51. And its a good thing the paid an independent auditor over two years to find out they did not withhold taxes on a W-9 for $599. This is really important. Things like test scores, graduation rates and entry to prestigious colleges is not a priority for our education system…

    Will the board stop going after a successful charter school because you see it as a threat to your resources! Please you were educators once…the mission should be to educate kids. Not secure resources for your tenure and pensions.

Leave a Comment


LOCAL SCHOOL LINKS
Related Content
LATEST SCHOOL NEWS
Monday, Jul 16, 2018
The next regular meeting of the Governing Board of the William S. Hart Union High School District is Wednesday, July 18 at the Administrative Center, 21380 Centre Pointe Parkway, Santa Clarita 91350.
Monday, Jul 16, 2018
Members of the Boys & Girls Club of Santa Clarita Valley will participate in the semi-annual Pinewood Derby at the Newhall Clubhouse on Wednesday, July 18 starting at 4:30 p.m.
Monday, Jul 16, 2018
Ingrid Moon, a sixth-grade science facilitator at tuition-free public charter school iLEAD Encino, and Kimberli Lengning, a facilitator at iLEAD Lancaster, have been named Distinguished STEM Educators by Columbia University.
Friday, Jul 13, 2018
Santa Clarita Valley International, a free public charter school serving learners in grades TK through 12, has welcomed veteran educator Farnaz Kaufman as its new School Director, and she will welcome visitors on SCVi’s Prospective Family Night on Thursday, July 19.
Wednesday, Jul 11, 2018
iLEAD Agua Dulce, a free public charter school serving grades TK through 6, has been approved to open in the fall and began enrolling families this week.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
Berry Petroleum Corp., owner of the Placerita oil field west of Sierra Highway between Placerita Canyon Road and Golden Valley Road in Santa Clarita - and many other oil properties in the San Joaquin Valley - announced Monday that it has launched an initial public offering of its common stock.
Placerita Oil Field Owner Going Public Again
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration is alerting health care professionals and patients of a voluntary recall of several drug products containing the active ingredient Valsartan, used to treat high blood pressure and heart failure.
Blood Pressure Medicine Valsartan Recalled for Cancer-Causing Impurity
The next regular meeting of the Governing Board of the William S. Hart Union High School District is Wednesday, July 18 at the Administrative Center, 21380 Centre Pointe Parkway, Santa Clarita 91350.
July 18: Hart District Governing Board Regular Meeting
The Canyon Country Advisory Committee, a division of the Santa Clarita City Council, will hold its next meeting on Wednesday, July 18, from 7 p.m. to 9 p.m.
July 18: Canyon Country Advisory Committee Meeting
Since April, TMU grad Zach Klindworth has worked and trained with a soccer team in Iceland, 4,000 miles from Santa Clarita, the only city he'd ever known.
TMU Soccer Alum Zach Klindworth Takes Talents to Iceland
The Lancaster JetHawks scored a run in the seventh inning to take the lead and hung on to beat Lake Elsinore, 3-2, Sunday evening at The Hangar.
JetHawks Hang on for Sunday Win Over Storm
Lake Elsinore proved too much for the JetHawks Saturday night, handing Lancaster an 11-4 loss at The Hangar.
Lancaster JetHawks Overcome by Storm Saturday
The Lancaster JetHawks opened up a four-game series with a 6-2 win over the Lake Elsinore Storm in front of 4,348 at The Hangar Friday night to kick off Star Wars Weekend.
The Force With JetHawks in Friday Win Over Storm
Saxtravaganza, Santa Clarita's all-saxophone chamber ensemble, will play a free concert at Hart Hall (inside Hart Park) on Thursday, July 19, starting at 7 p.m.
July 19: Saxtravaganza Chamber Ensemble Returns to Hart Hall
Members of the Boys & Girls Club of Santa Clarita Valley will participate in the semi-annual Pinewood Derby at the Newhall Clubhouse on Wednesday, July 18 starting at 4:30 p.m.
July 18: SCV Boys & Girls Club Pinewood Derby
The city of Santa Clarita's Community Preservation Division sent a notice of violation Monday to the owners of the Canyon View Mobile Home Estates property in Canyon Country, ordering the removal of multiple solar panels installed on the hillside just north of the park.
Canyon Country Mobile Home Park Cited for Hillside Solar Panels
Ingrid Moon, a sixth-grade science facilitator at tuition-free public charter school iLEAD Encino, and Kimberli Lengning, a facilitator at iLEAD Lancaster, have been named Distinguished STEM Educators by Columbia University.
iLEAD Science Facilitators Named Distinguished STEM Educators
The city of Santa Clarita has updated the list of productions shooting in the city and the Santa Clarita Valley the week of July 16-22, 2018.
‘Mayans,’ ‘Santa Clarita Diet,’ Spots, Student Films Now Shooting in SCV
The Greater Los Angeles County Vector Control District confirmed West Nile virus in a sample of mosquitoes collected from Panorama City (zip code 91402), the first confirmation of WNV activity in the district’s service area this year.
First West Nile Positive Mosquitoes Found – Panorama City
Air quality is very unhealthy for all residents of the Santa Clarita Valley Monday, according to an alert from the South Coast Air Quality Management District.
AQMD: Air Quality Very Unhealthy Monday for SCV Residents
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station deputies arrested a man with an outstanding warrant who was allegedly also in possession of drugs in Stevenson Ranch early Saturday morning.
Golden Valley High School grad U.S. Air Force Airman Victoria A. Arguello has graduated from basic military training at Joint Base San Antonio-Lackland, San Antonio, Texas.
Santa Clarita USAF Airman Victoria Arguello Completes Basic Training
1925 - Actor Harry Carey files patent on the original 160-acre Saugus homestead he'd purchased in 1916 (now Tesoro Del Valle) [story]
1891 - R.E. Nickel publishes area's first newspaper, The Acton Rooster [story]
Stay out of the water at Pyramid Lake in Los Angeles County until further notice and avoid eating fish from the lake due to the presence of blue-green algae.
Algae in Pyramid Lake at ‘Danger’ Level – Keep Out
1769 - Portolá party sets out from San Diego; first Europeans to "discover" Santa Clarita Valley 3½ weeks later [story]
The CTG Stars teenage summer workshop production of "Shrek: The Musical, Jr." takes the stage at the Canyon Theatre Guild in Old Town Newhall for two final performances on Saturday night and Sunday afternoon.
July 14-15: CTG Stars Teen Workshop Stages ‘Shrek: The Musical Jr.’
The William S. Hart Museum will host an open house and summer fun event for kids on Thursday, July 19 from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m.
July 19: Open House, Summer Fun Event for Kids at Hart Museum
College of the Canyons will accept an additional 500 students to its First-Year Promise program for the fall 2018 semester, an expansion made possible by funding from a new state program called California College Promise.
COC to Accept 500 More First-Year Promise Students
The city of Santa Clarita invites residents to explore the newest exhibit at the Westfield Valencia Town Center Art Space -- “Urban Objects” by artist Aaron Kramer, on display now through October 2.
‘Urban Objects’ by Aaron Kramer on Display at Town Center Art Space
Bank of Santa Clarita announced Friday that for the second quarter of 2018, earnings again reached record levels, as net earnings totaled $867,000, a 91 percent growth over its earnings for the second quarter of 2017.
Bank of Santa Clarita’s Earnings Continue to Grow Significantly
Los Angeles County voters may soon be asked to vote on a new "parcel" tax to be levied on private property owners' "impenetrable areas" -- everything from rooftops to driveways -- to help pay for the capture of recyclable stormwater runoff.
Supes Float New Tax on Roofs, Driveways, Patios
In an effort to keep property crime in the Santa Clarita Valley low and help residents protect their valuables, the city of Santa Clarita and the SCV Sheriff’s Station have partnered to bring a new public safety campaign to the city called 'The Stolen Collection.'
Don’t Let Your Items Become Part of ‘The Stolen Collection’
The California Air Resources Board and the United States Environmental Protection Agency have approved emissions modifications for the last remaining Volkswagen vehicles containing undisclosed software which deliberately shut down emission control equipment.
CARB, EPA OK Final VW Diesel Modification to Kill Illegal ‘Defeat Devices’
Vince Fernandez cranked a three-run homer to give the Lancaster JetHawks a lead, but the bullpen and defense couldn’t hold on in an 8-4 loss to the Rancho Cucamonga Quakes on Thursday night at LoanMart Field.
Series Finale Slips Away from JetHawks
A coalition of 13 Attorneys General including California's, along with the California Air Resources Board and the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, submitted a letter to the U.S. EPA Friday demanding the immediate reinstatement of the Glider Rule for high-polluting trucks.
AG’s Demand EPA Reinstate ‘Glider Rule’ for High-Polluting Trucks
The next meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors is set for Tuesday, July 17, starting at 9:30 a.m.
July 17: LA County Board of Supervisors Meeting
Santa Clarita Valley International, a free public charter school serving learners in grades TK through 12, has welcomed veteran educator Farnaz Kaufman as its new School Director, and she will welcome visitors on SCVi’s Prospective Family Night on Thursday, July 19.
July 19: SCVi Open House, Meetup with New Director
1884 - Hardison & Stewart start drilling Star No. 1 oil well in Pico Canyon; later form Union Oil Co. [story]
The Valencia Jazz & Blues Summer Concert Series continues Friday, July 13, with Jim Gibson.
July 13: Jim Gibson Takes Stage at Valencia Jazz & Blues Series
Los Angeles County Department of Parks and Recreation presents its latest Recreation After Dark at William S. Hart Regional Park in Newhall with an evening showcase of music and dance featuring the Sue Rey and the Runarounds.
July 28: Sue Rey & the Runarounds at Hart Park