header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather
Santa Clarita CA
Mostly sunny
Mostly sunny
61°F
 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
January 19
1967 - Original airing of Star Trek "Arena" Episode: Kirk battles the Gorn commander (Saugus resident Bobby Clark) at Vasquez Rocks [watch]
Kirk vs. Gorn commander


| Wednesday, Mar 6, 2019
In this Dec. 9, 2015, file pool photo, crews work on a relief well at the Aliso Canyon facility above the Porter Ranch area of Los Angeles. (Dean Musgrove/Los Angeles Daily News via AP, Pool, File)
In this Dec. 9, 2015, file pool photo, crews work on a relief well at the Aliso Canyon facility above the Porter Ranch area of Los Angeles. (Dean Musgrove/Los Angeles Daily News via AP, Pool, File).

 

By Maria Dinzeo

SAN FRANCISCO – A group of small businesses said that Southern California Gas Company should be held accountable for the ruinous losses they suffered in the wake of the most catastrophic gas leak in California history at the state Supreme Court Tuesday.

The California Supreme Court heard arguments in their class-action case, which has the potential to upend tort law and the concept of duty of care.

Attorney Leslie Brueckner, arguing for a class of small businesses operating within a five-mile radius of the 2015 Aliso Canyon methane gas blowout, said SoCal Gas deliberately failed to replace a safety valve at its storage field near Porter Ranch, triggering a leak that spewed methane into the atmosphere for months.

“SoCal knew its aging facility was on the brink of catastrophe,” Brueckner said.

The ruptured well was built in 1979, and replacing or repairing the valve would have cost the company relatively little, but Brueckner said SoCal prioritized profits over safety.

More than 100,000 tons of methane poured out from the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage site beginning in October 2015, prompting the evacuation of several nearby communities, including Porter Ranch in the northwest region of Los Angeles.

About 8,000 families were forced out of their homes, some for months, as the utility company worked to fix the gas well. The leak was finally capped in February 2016.

Before the leak was discovered, however, residents reported headaches, nose bleeds and other health issues.

Some 50,000 plaintiffs have sued the gas company for personal injury and property damage, but the Second Appellate District Court ruled in 2017 that seven businesses that suffered purely economic losses could not go after SoCal for damages. These businesses include a realtor, camera shop, a daycare center and a gas station.

“SoCal is asking the court to do something radical, which is to hold SoCal immune from any liability from economy losses,” Brueckner told the justices at Tuesday’s oral argument.

She urged the court to look at the case through the framework of Rowland v. Christian, another California Supreme Court case that established seven factors for determining the duty of care in negligence cases: the foreseeability of harm, the degree of certainty regarding the injury, the closeness of the connection between the conduct and the injury, moral blame, preventing future harm, the extent of the burden to the defendant and consequences to the community and the availability and cost of insurance to cover the risk.

“There should be an industry-by-industry analysis under Rowland,” Brueckner said.

But SoCal attorney Kathleen Sullivan said the court should apply the rule of no duty of care for purely economic losses for third parties.

“Rowland does not control everything in California tort law,” she said. “We’re not asking the court to do anything radical here. We’re just asking the court to apply 60 years of settled law.”

Sullivan said there was no special relationship between the business owners and SoCal Gas that would warrant an exception to the economic loss rule, as in an heir suing a notary for botching a will.

“But as a matter of social policy, if there’s no special relationship and purely economic loss, is there no application of tort law?” asked Justice Mariano-Florentino Cuellar.

Sullivan said the social policy would be to prevent “limitless liability,” or a slew of lawsuits from aggrieved people and businesses burdening the courts with a wave of indeterminate claims that will ultimately drive up insurance costs and ratepayers’ bills.

“It’s a harsh rule, you’ll probably admit,” Cuellar said.

“If you want to carve out classes, that would be the province of the Legislature. That’s not how this court operates,” Sullivan said, adding, “Yes, it is a harsh rule, but don’t take it from me. This doctrine is a rule, not a standard. You need to give certainty and predictability in tort law.”

Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye said holding SoCal liable could be a deterrent to future tragedies. “Does society have an interest in ensuring that businesses don’t cause disasters? Doesn’t this case cry out for an exception?”

“Respectfully, I would have to disagree,” Sullivan said. “The answer is not to create a new, unmanageable exception to the economic loss rule.”

Cantil-Sakauye said this was “cold comfort” to those who lost everything because of SoCal’s deliberate negligence.

“If businesses knew it could face downstream liability, it wouldn’t take that valve off,” she said.

Sullivan pointed to the 50,000 pending cases against SoCal as a deterrent, and that the seven businesses’ cases would add “no bang for the deterrent buck.”

On rebuttal, Brueckner said the economic loss rule “an extremely rigid, inflexible rule that’s unfair.”

“We’re not asking for an exception to the economic loss rule. We’re saying the economic loss rule doesn’t apply in this case,” she said.

Aliso Canyon storage facility

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

1 Comment

  1. Melody says:

    When they opened the model homes for Porter Ranch, I toured them and could smell the gas. The gas smell was so bad that it made it hard for me to breathe even then. That is why I was not interested in buying in the area. I am surprised that others did not smell the gas. It was really bad around the largest homes near the hillside. This was way before the blowout.

Leave a Comment


SCV NewsBreak
LOCAL NEWS HEADLINES
Tuesday, Jan 18, 2022
Santa Clarita 2022 Cowboy Festival Cancelled
Due to L.A. County Department of Public Health restrictions and the recent surge in COVID-19 cases, the city of Santa Clarita "regretfully" is announcing the cancellation of the 2022 Santa Clarita Cowboy Festival, reported Santa Clarita PIO Carrie Lujan in a statement released to the press.
Monday, Jan 17, 2022
Judge Advances Environmental Suit Against Massive Centennial Project
LOS ANGELES (CN) — A lawsuit by two environmental groups to stop the enormous and controversial Tejon Ranch Centennial Project can continue, a Los Angeles County judge ruled Friday, despite a recent settlement in a related case.
Monday, Jan 17, 2022
Monday COVID Roundup: Henry Mayo Reports 201st Death
Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital reported Monday an additional death from COVID-19, bringing the total number to 201 since the onset of the pandemic, spokesman Patrick Moody confirmed.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
More than twenty years ago I led the animal control division for an agency in northern California, and at one point we received a series of complaints from students at a local community college regarding a fellow student’s emotional support animal (ESA).
Marcia Mayeda: Protecting Service Animals
1967 - Original airing of Star Trek "Arena" Episode: Kirk battles the Gorn commander (Saugus resident Bobby Clark) at Vasquez Rocks [watch]
Kirk vs. Gorn commander
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Tuesday 45 additional deaths and 22,688 new cases of COVID-19 countywide, with 60,980 total cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Tuesday Covid Roundup: Omicron Continues to Surge as ICU Admissions Rise in LA County
Los Angeles County Department of Parks and Recreation is hiring. This summer, the department aims to hire over 250 new lifeguards to work at 30 aquatic facilities, all across L.A. County.
LA County Department of Parks, Recreation Seeks to Hire Over 250 Lifeguards
Due to L.A. County Department of Public Health restrictions and the recent surge in COVID-19 cases, the city of Santa Clarita "regretfully" is announcing the cancellation of the 2022 Santa Clarita Cowboy Festival, reported Santa Clarita PIO Carrie Lujan in a statement released to the press.
Santa Clarita 2022 Cowboy Festival Cancelled
With COVID-19 cases in Los Angeles County at high levels, the Los Angeles County Department of Consumer and Business Affairs (DCBA) will temporarily pause in-person services starting Tuesday, Jan. 18.
LA County DCBA Temporarily Pausing In-Person Services
Put your knowledge to the test with Winter Games Trivia on the second day of Winter Olympic Games Beijing 2022.
Feb. 3 Winter Games Trivia Contest at The Cube
The Santa Clarita Community College District’s Independent Citizens Bond Oversight Committee voted to accept the results of an independent audit confirming the district properly accounted for all bond expenditures in the 2020-21 fiscal year.
COC Citizens Oversight Committee Affirms Audits of College Bond Spending
Fred Gruchalla, a veteran of the Vietnam War, received the 2020-2021 Veteran of the Year Award from the Van Nuys/Reseda Elks Lodge 2790 on Jan. 10.
Fred Gruchalla, Veterans’ Advocate, Named Veteran of the Year
The Zonta Club of Santa Clarita Valley is now accepting applications for the annual Virginia Wrage Memorial Fund Scholarship. Deadline is March 30, 2022.
Zonta SCV Accepting Applications for Wrage Scholarship
A 7,383 square foot freestanding office building located at 28015 Smyth Drive in Valencia recently sold for $2,675,000.00 announced Executive Vice President Randy Cude and Vice President Matt Sreden of Spectrum Commercial Real Estate, Inc.
Smyth Drive Office Building in Highridge Business Park Sells for Over $2.6M
1899 - Martin & Richard Wood buy J.H. Tolfree's Saugus Eating House, rename it Saugus Cafe [story]
Saugus Cafe
Impulse Music Co., which is located at 21515 Soledad Canyon Road, Suite #120, is hosting an Open Mic Night free to all ages, on Wednesday, Feb. 2, from 6:00 p.m. - 7:00 p.m.
Impulse Music Hosting Open Mic Night
The Santa Clarita Community College District's Board of Trustees will hold a virtual business meeting and public hearing via Zoom Wednesday, Jan. 19, at 5:00 p.m.
Jan. 19: COC Board of Trustees Business Meeting
The William S. Hart Union High School District's Governing Board will hold its regular meeting Wednesday, Jan. 19, beginning with a closed session at 5:45 p.m., followed immediately by open session at 7:00 p.m.
Jan. 19: Hart School District’s Regular Meeting
Whether you’ve just finished an ice skating lesson, are watching a youth hockey game or want to take a break during a public session, The Grille at The Cube is the perfect place to unwind with a delicious meal or snack.
SCV’s Newest Dining Spot Opens at The Cube
The city of Santa Clarita's Planning Commission will hold its regular meeting Tuesday, Jan. 18, at 6:00 p.m.
Jan. 18: Planning Commission Regular Meeting
LOS ANGELES (CN) — A lawsuit by two environmental groups to stop the enormous and controversial Tejon Ranch Centennial Project can continue, a Los Angeles County judge ruled Friday, despite a recent settlement in a related case.
Judge Advances Environmental Suit Against Massive Centennial Project
Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital reported Monday an additional death from COVID-19, bringing the total number to 201 since the onset of the pandemic, spokesman Patrick Moody confirmed.
Monday COVID Roundup: Henry Mayo Reports 201st Death
1994, 4:31 a.m. - Magnitude 6.7 Northridge earthquake rocks Santa Clarita Valley [video]
collapsed freeway bridge
1926 - Newhall Community Hospital, est. 1922, opens in larger, more modern hospital building at 6th & Spruce streets [story]
Newhall Community Hospital
1875 - Henry Mayo Newhall buys western half of the Santa Clarita Valley for $2 an acre [story]
Henry M. Newhall
College of the Canyons returned to the court for the first time in three weeks on Wednesday, suffering an 81-73 road loss at the hands of Glendale College in a contest that officially started Western State Conference (WSC), South Division play for the Cougars Men's Basketball team.
COC Men’s Basketball Suffers 81-73 Road Loss to Glendale in WSC, South Opener
SCVNews.com
%d bloggers like this: