header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
December 20
1892 - Benjamin Harrison establishes 555,520-acre San Gabriel Timberland Reserve (Angeles National Forest). First forest reserve in California, second in U.S. [story]
map


Commentary by Darryl Manzer
| Saturday, Jun 20, 2015
hsr061515
It doesn't seem like much of an alternative, does it?

darrylmanzer0215Just about when I thought I had seen it all from the California High Speed Rail Authority and our crazy reps up in Sacramento, they start another round of idiocy.

You see, I’ve read yet another report – or more correctly an addendum to a report – that shows me just how 100 pages of “study” prove that nothing new is being said … except:

Moving a proposed routing of the train a few hundred feet one way or another makes for a lot of pretty maps in color. It does nothing to explain why they even want to slightly reroute it. Let’s face it: Moving the proposed tracks those few hundred feet in any direction does nothing to solve the problem that folks in Acton, Agua Dulce and Sand Canyon have.

Maybe it is the miles of tunnels on any path between Palmdale and Burbank that fails most tests of logic. And will putting the train in a trench solve any problems?

There is a more important problem for the railway that isn’t on the report. So far, they have spent $771 million in Federal Railroad Authority money but only $378 million in state funds. Those amounts are supposed to be equal. That is the law. Federal law. It seems California has to come up with $400 million by the end of the month.

Did I mention that the report shows that if the HSR is run through the SCV and on to San Fernando, it will disrupt nearly 20,000 homes, a score of churches and about as many schools? There are horse farms and ranches on any route, too. If it heads straight south from Palmdale, it affects only about 6,000. Gee, isn’t that wonderful.

Just a few of the many endangered species that would be negatively affected by high-speed rail.

Just a few of the many endangered species that would be negatively affected by the high-speed rail plan.

Whatever route they take here in Southern California, they have managed to find routes that could harm or destroy habitat for just about every endangered and threatened species in this part of our formerly great state.

It all comes down to the need to start a petition to stop this High Speed Rail Authority. We didn’t elect them, and they want to keep things quiet. We need to stop the train.

I’ll bet a lot of you thought it was going to run alongside Interstate 5 on its way south. Heck, the state owns the land, and the disruption would be at a minimum. Many folks I’ve talked with said that was what they thought.

I’ll also wager that you were told it would be a “three hour” trip on the high speed train. Am I right? Estimates now put it at a little over four hours if there are no problems.

It is also going to be a “green” project – yet the source of the electricity to run it hasn’t been identified.

I do think I know why the good governor has stepped up efforts to cut more water resources from farmers. The land will sell for less when it a useless dustbowl. That way, it will cost less for the state to buy it for the HSR.

What is there that’s good about this effort and state-run railroads? Well, it is keeping a lot of people employed. The sales force is still out trying to convince us how good it is.

Maybe it is the fact that one of our U.S. senators has a husband who’s building the first section? Hate to see DiFi starve.

The whole project is a mess. Already far over budget and routes are not yet identified. The Legislature is taking steps to decrease oversight of the HSR Authority. Federal funds might not be forthcoming.

It isn’t what we voted for, and it won’t run as advertised. Ridership is unknown, too.

We Californians like our cars. We like going someplace and being able to drive to dinner or a museum. We like the idea that we might want to leave the road and look for the world’s largest ball of yarn, biggest frying pan, or snake farm.

We would love to see Amtrak go all the way over the Tehachapi Mountains so we don’t have to take a bus to Bakersfield. If we can’t even get that fixed, how is the HSR going to change things?

Yes, a petition is what we need. Yesterday. I’ll get started on it right now.

 

Darryl Manzer grew up in the Pico Canyon oil town of Mentryville in the 1960s and attended Hart High School. After a career in the U.S. Navy he returned to live in the Santa Clarita Valley, where he serves as executive director of the SCV Historical Society. He can be reached at dmanzer@scvhistory.com. His older commentaries are archived atDManzer.com; his newer commentaries can be accessed [here]. Watch his walking tour of Mentryville [here].

 

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

7 Comments

  1. Abigail says:

    Ready to sign!

  2. Bill says:

    I will be the first one to sign it.

    Keep us posted

  3. Lilia Ortiz says:

    Please, I’ll be the first to sign the petition. I’m in agreement, nothing is Ben said about the damage that homes will incurs from the drilling/disruption of land to make the tunnel. How many will ride for 4 hours underground, it is going to be very noisy and it is not going to cheap. It’s not cheap to use the train now from LA to Frisco, best to catch a flight and be there quicker, or drive, choice of highways and scenery.

  4. Lilia Ortiz says:

    Can we recall the ones supporting such idiotic plan? It all is a waste of precious funds that could be used to plan for water desalination plants which can also create jobs. We need to prepare for the climate changes.

  5. Lisa Sendewicz says:

    Once the petition is set up please post it so we can all send it around to get as many signatures as possible. This is so a gross waste of money, resources and hello, we need WATER STORAGE FACILITIES more than some so called bullet train that is not and it will always be cheaper to fly Southwest than a train ticket and faster.

  6. Bruce Smith says:

    Folks this really isn’t about your city or area. This is a statewide project for everyone in the state. The HSR needs to be built ASAP and use the route the experts say is best. I was around back in the 60’s and 70’s when most of the freeways were built. Lots of people were unhappy with the routes they chose and bothered by the construction. It had to be done for the good of all the people. We would be screwed if those freeways weren’t built back then wouldn’t we?

Leave a Comment


Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
RECENT COMMENTARY
Friday, Dec 19, 2025
There's no better way to celebrate the season than with toys, treats, and rollercoasters. My annual Foster Youth Holiday Party is one of the most special traditions we do each year
Wednesday, Dec 10, 2025
I'm overjoyed to share that as of this week, several Altadena residents have moved back into their newly-rebuilt homes in time for the holidays.
Wednesday, Dec 3, 2025
As we wrap up this incredible year with JCI Santa Clarita, my heart is truly overflowing with gratitude. This chapter has shown up in such wonderful ways, and I’m so proud of everything we’ve created together.
Tuesday, Dec 2, 2025
It’s hard to believe that our city will turn 38-years-old as of Monday, Dec. 15.
Tuesday, Dec 2, 2025
As we wrap up another year, I find myself reflecting on how extraordinary and eventful 2025 has been for our city.
Wednesday, Nov 26, 2025
Today, my team and I set out to four different sites across the Fifth District for our 8th Annual Day of Giving.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1892 - Benjamin Harrison establishes 555,520-acre San Gabriel Timberland Reserve (Angeles National Forest). First forest reserve in California, second in U.S. [story]
map
The Saugus Union School District Governing Board of Trustees elected Matthew Watson as 2026 board president at the Tuesday, Dec. 16 organizational meeting.
Watson Elected SUSD Board of Trustees President
Los Angeles–based painter Jasimen Phillips is a featured artist in the city of Santa Clarita’s “Pop Culture” exhibition, currently on view at the Newhall Community Center through March 25, 2026.
Phillips Examines Evolving Relationship with Technology in Exhibit
The Gibbon Conservation Center in Saugus is requesting donations, including memberships and gibbon adoption sponsorships to reach a matching goal of $15,000.
Gibbon Center Needs Donations to Meet $15K Match
The Santa Clarita Community College District Board of Trustees failed to complete its annual organizational vote to elect a new board president during its meeting on Wednesday, Dec. 17.
COC Board Fails to Elect New President in Deadlocked Vote
There's no better way to celebrate the season than with toys, treats, and rollercoasters. My annual Foster Youth Holiday Party is one of the most special traditions we do each year
Kathryn Barger | Keeping Up With Kathryn
The Canyon Theatre Guild’s production of "A Christmas Story," adds shows due to high ticket demand. Shows have been added on Sunday, Dec. 21 and Monday, Dec. 22.
CTG ‘A Christmas Story’ Adds Shows, Dec. 21-22, Due to Demand
The city of Santa Clarita will present its latest art exhibition, “Pop Culture,” on view at the Newhall Community Center now through March 25, 2026.
City Presents ‘Pop Culture’ Art Exhibit at the Newhall Community Center
This week’s Foothill League matches resulted in the Saugus boys getting a firmer grip on first place, and the Saugus girls slipping into second place. Meanwhile, holiday tournaments are bringing both wins and losses from non-league teams, with more on the way.
Foothill League Soccer: Saugus Boys, Hart Girls Leading
1970 - Snow day in Santa Clarita Valley [photos]
Saugus train station
Do you have a passion for swimming and a desire to make an impact in your community? The city of Santa Clarita is seeking individuals with strong customer service skills and a commitment to community engagement to join its lifeguard team.
Applications Are Open for the Summer 2026 Lifeguard Season
Santa Clarita Valley residents need to put down the yule log and refrain from all residental wood burning fires on Friday, Dec. 19.
Dec. 19: No Burn Day Alert Issued for SCV, South Coast Air Basin
U.S. Rep. George Whitesides (D-Aqua Dulce), announced the winners of the 2025 Congressional App Challenge for California’s 27th Congressional District: the “MathViz” team led by local Academy of the Canyons student, Gautham Korrapati.
Whitesides Announces 2025 Congressional App Challenge SCV Winners
The Mardi Gras Madness 1K/5K/10K, set for March 1, in Santa Clarita, is more than a race, it’s a celebration of health, community and giving back. Now through Wednesday, Dec. 24, take $10 OFF race registration with promo code WINTER10 at checkout.
March 1: JCI Santa Clarita Holds Mardi Gras Madness 1K/5K/10K Runs
Theatre Extempore will present the all time classic musical The Fantasticks, 8-10 p.m. Jan. 9-11. 15-18 at The MAIN.
Jan. 9: Premiere of ‘The Fantasticks’ Presented by Theatre Extempore
West Ranch High School senior Braulio Castillo (17) never did any long-distance running before high school, but what he has accomplished in that demanding discipline since taking it up is impressive. And, so far his senior year, it is phenomenal.
West Ranch Runner Going the Distance
Powerlab Studio will hold its grand opening and ribbon cutting 4:30-5 p.m. Thursday, Jan. 8 at 28110 Newhall Ranch Road, Valencia, CA 91355.
Jan 8: Powerlab Studio Grand Opening, Ribbon Cutting
B2 Entertainment will have a Cookies With Santa event, 3-5 p.m. Sunday, Dec. 21 at 21516 Golden Triangle Road, Santa Clarita, CA 91350.
Dec. 21: Cookies With Santa at MB2 Entertainment
The College of the Canyons soccer programs will be hosting 'Friday Night Footy,' small-sided pick-up games, running on Friday evenings Jan. 2 through June 26 at the COC Soccer Facility.
Jan. 2-June 26: Cougars Soccer Programs to Host ‘Friday Night Footy’
College of the Canyons sophomore pitcher Nichole Muro will continue her academic and athletic career at Cumberland University after signing with the Phoenix softball program.
Muro Signs with Cumberland University Softball Program
College of the Canyons men's basketball won its fourth straight contest in an 80-72 affair at Napa Valley College on Monday afternoon, Dec. 15 as freshman Julius Washington led all scorers with 20 points.
Cougars Win Fourth Straight 80-72 at Napa Valley
Canyons women's basketball snapped a five-game losing streak with a 60-44 win over Diablo Valley College during the final day of action at the Napa Valley Storm Surge tournament on Saturday, Dec. 13.
Canyons Finishes Tourney Weekend with 60-44 Win Over Diablo Valley
1929 - Swift justice: Thomas Vernon sentenced to life in prison for Saugus train derailment & robbery 1 month earlier [story]
Tom Vernon
SCVNews.com