[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

SCVNews.com | Opinion/Commentary: Feds Crush Collectors’ Age-Old Free Trade Rights | 02-15-2013
Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
October 9
1861 - Pioneer Acton rancher & stonecutter George Blum born in Switzerland [story]

Commentary by Wayne G. Sayles
| Friday, Feb 15, 2013

waynesaylesSome 50,000 Americans who call themselves ancient coin collectors are hopeful that Feb. 12, 2013, will be remembered by numismatic historians as an auspicious day.

Washington bureaucracy broke with law and tradition in 2007 by imposing draconian import restrictions on ordinary coins that are freely and routinely exchanged and collected worldwide, say coin collecting advocates in filed court documents.  Under these restrictions, American collectors are now subjected to requirements that they claim are impossible to meet and are extralegal on several counts.

“Congress limited restrictions to culturally significant artifacts found in a specific country, but now Americans importing common coins made in a specific country are forced to prove the negative — that their coins have not illegally exited a specified country subsequent to the signing of a bi-lateral agreement between that nation and the United States,” said  attorney Peter K. Tompa.

Since coins have flowed endlessly across national boundaries, without documentation, for more than two thousand years, collectors argue that it is impossible to say with certainty where any given specimen has been during that time.  Literally millions of very common and low value ancient coins lack specific pedigrees of ownership or “provenance” and consequently cannot satisfy the burden of proving a negative.

Are these coins all, by default, illicit because it is impossible to say where they were found in modern times?  Not at all, say collectors who point to a 600-year-old legitimate market that has witnessed a constant and massive flow of ancient coins from every conceivable source country.   Many believe a presumption of guilt has trumped the venerable presumption of innocence that Americans hold dear.

Law enforcement agencies in some third-world countries, and even more prosperous nations, are sometimes unable or unwilling to enforce their own nationalistic cultural property laws.  As a result, some objects of “national patrimony” eventually find their way to foreign markets.

Under U.S. law, foreign nations may in exceptional cases appeal to the U.S. State Department for emergency assistance through import restrictions.  However, a collector group’s lawsuit complains of bureaucratic overkill, where the State Department has reacted capriciously by creating what amounts to broad barriers to trade in all undocumented objects, both licit and illicit, significant and insignificant, that they arbitrarily designate as cultural property at risk.  That, collectors believe, is extralegal and ignores the plain language of the law.

By importing a group of unprovenanced Cypriot and Chinese coins from a British dealer in 2009, the nonprofit Ancient Coin Collectors Guild set in motion a test case before the U.S. District Court at Baltimore to challenge the State Department’s interpretation of law and their actions.

After lengthy hearings and deliberation, a trial court dismissed the case claiming that the issue was not one for the courts to decide. Disagreeing with this view, the ACCG appealed that decision to the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals where ultimately the lower court ruling was affirmed.

The essence of the ACCG argument is that the governing law does not give unbridled authority and discretion to the president’s representative in the State Department, particularly when another agency, U.S. Customs, is ultimately responsible for the final regulations. They argue that the court should say what the law is and judge whether its provisions were followed in the process of imposing the restrictions being challenged.  After almost four years of litigation, no lower court has been willing to take that stand.

Meanwhile, the case has grown from a rather provincial test of bureaucratic agency decision-making to something of far greater consequence.

Does the executive branch inherit absolute discretion when Congress gives it oversight authority?  Even when there are limits and conditions established in the governing legislation?

This question has now been posed by ancient coin collectors to the United States Supreme Court in a petition for a writ of certiorari.

The potential ramifications are significant and extend well beyond the world of coin collecting.  A decision on this question could well set the bar for presidential discretion for years to come.

From small acorns do mighty oaks grow.


Wayne G. Sayles is executive director of the Ancient Coin Collectors Guild. He can be reached at director@accg.us.


Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


  1. Tommy says:


  2. None Anonymous says:

    Ebay there are thousands of ancient coins crossing borders daily.
    Vcoins has 175 ancient coin dealers.
    The US Government is attempting to stop our hobby.
    Ancient money and modern money cross borders many times a second.
    The US government is acting draconian to a Great hobby of Holding history in your hand.
    Remember Next election, Vote these bums out of office.

Commentary Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: INFO (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Related Content
Friday, Oct 9, 2015
There are nearly 13 months to go before the next presidential election. The negative flack will only intensify. Carly Fiorina is the piñata for “30,000 HP jobs going overseas” and for being fired as Hewlett Packard’s CEO. Both charges make good straw.
Thursday, Oct 8, 2015
About 10 years into home ownership, I noticed a small amount of white, fluffy substance on my cactus. I wasn’t sure what it was, so I took a sample to a local nursery.
Wednesday, Oct 7, 2015
To hear many local observers tell the story, with the BLM’s cancellation of the mining contracts, the multi-decade battle to save Soledad Canyon was over. Victory was ours. Cemex’s Soledad Canyon plans were kaput. Finished. Done. Dead as a doornail. Well, at Safe Action for the Environment Inc., we knew better.
Tuesday, Oct 6, 2015
The president expressed outrage that nine people were killed at the hands of a gunman. Why is he not outraged about the 2,600 people shot in the “gun-free” city of Chicago this year? What about the 370 lives lost there? And most of them black lives. Not a word. No outrage. Don’t #BlackLivesMatter to him?
Sunday, Oct 4, 2015
The alpha lioness became injured by a Cape buffalo when she was hunting. She was gored in her left hind quarter. Her leg was almost ripped off, but no bones were broken, and no organs were damaged. However, she lost a lot of blood, and it was painful for her to walk. She probably would not live without human intervention, and neither would her cubs.
Friday, Oct 2, 2015
October is a great month for special events in the city of Santa Clarita, and this year, there is something for everyone.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
There are nearly 13 months to go before the next presidential election. The negative flack will only intensify. Carly Fiorina is the piñata for “30,000 HP jobs going overseas” and for being fired as Hewlett Packard’s CEO. Both charges make good straw.
Aye, Carly
1861 - Pioneer Acton rancher & stonecutter George Blum born in Switzerland [story]
On October 6, 2015, the Board of Supervisors selected Sachi A. Hamai as the candidate for the position of Chief Executive Officer, and instructed the Mayor to negotiate an annual salary and other contractual provisions, and to return to the Board on October 13, 2015, for final action.
Antonovich Motion Would Finalize Hiring of County CEO
Santa Clarita City Council agenda for Tuesday, Oct. 13, 2015.
Council Tuesday: Valencia Water Franchise, Via Princessa Extension, more
Two award-winning artists are featured in the “Two for the Road” art exhibition at Fast Frame Valencia this month.
Meet 2 Local Artists Saturday in Valencia
On Saturday, Santa Clarita’s Democratic Alliance for Action will recognize individuals who are fighting to turn the SCV from red to blue.
Oct. 10: SCV Democrats to Bestow Awards
More than 50 employees of Eternal Valley Memorial Park Mortuary in Newhall and local residents have joined as Team Dignity LA to raise funds for critical ADA type 1 and type 2 diabetes research, education programs and advocacy programs.
Eternal Valley Employees Team Up to Fight Diabetes
Whole Foods Market is recalling cheese sold in all stores nationwide that came from its supplier because it has the potential to be contaminated with Listeria monocytogenes, an organism which can cause serious and sometimes fatal infections in young children, frail or elderly people, and others with weakened immune systems.
Whole Foods Recalls Papillon Organic Roquefort Cheese
The county plans to extend the lease term for seven years and increase the office space currently occupied by the Department of Public Health located at 26415 Carl Boyer Dr., Santa Clarita by an additional 1,659 sq ft and 6 on-site parking spaces, for a total of 7,253 sq ft of office space and 34 on-site parking spaces.
County Public Health Dept. to Expand at Centre Pointe
Tonight on SCV NewsBreak, Santa Clarita Sheriff's are seeking the community's help in car theft case. Plus, the Hart District honored employees during meeting. Also, your local weather report. Click the link to see these stories and more on tonight's edition of SCV NewsBreak.
SCV NewsBreak for Thursday, October 8, 2015
Three beautiful Santa Clarita Valley homes will be decked out in true holiday splendor during Henry Mayo’s 35th annual Home Tour on Saturday, Dec. 5
Henry Mayo Helpers Prepping for Dec. 5 Home Tour
October is National Domestic Violence Awareness Month. See what we're doing this month to help raise awareness in our community.
Domestic Violence Center News: Learn Legal Rights, Rent a Santa, more
Give yourself over to absolute pleasure on Friday, Oct. 30, as you experience the ultimate Time Warp movie, "The Rocky Horror Picture Show," at Frank-N-Furter’s Halloween Ball, held in the Spiegeltent at Wolf Creek Brewery in Valencia’s Rye Canyon.
REP to Host ‘Rocky Horror’ Viewing, Costume Contest at Brewhouse
Nineteen classified employees were honored as the employees of the year Wednesday night at the William S. Hart Union High School District’s governing board meeting.
Hart District Honors Classified Employees of Year
Here's a roundup of items the Hart School Board tackled at its meeting Wednesday.
Hart Board: CHS Auditorium Project, VHS Science Lab, SV Shade Structures, more
Reese Field will serve as center stage for a national powerhouse showdown on Saturday as the men’s and women’s soccer teams from The Master’s College and Vanguard University will compete in matches that bear major postseason implications.
Masters And Vanguard Go Head-to-Head On Saturday
In addition to building nearly 100 WaterSense labeled homes in 2014, KB Home also constructed model homes in California featuring innovative water-efficient products, along with graywater recycling systems that provide water for toilet-flushing or landscape irrigation.
EPA Recognizes Local Homebuilder, Others for Promoting Water Efficiency
The gift includes both a substantial monetary contribution to the Academy Museum of Motion Pictures’ capital campaign as well as key artifacts from Shirley Temple Black’s indelible early career. To recognize this gift and honor the star’s legendary childhood contribution to entertainment, the Academy Museum’s education center will be named The Shirley Temple Education Studio.
Family of Shirley Temple Donates $5 Mil. in Cash and Memorabilia for Academy Museum
Assemblyman Scott Wilk has honored D’Wilfri DanceArt and Entertainment as the 38th Assembly District Small Business of the Month.
Wilk Names D’Wilfri Dance Studio Business of Month
Gov. Jerry Brown signed legisation Thursday that would begin to bring water back to the residents of Bouquet Canyon.
Salvation Coming to Upper Bouquet Canyon
Robbery is a crime “against the person” and a frightening experience. It can result in injury or even death to the victim. It is important to remember, in protecting your business from robbery, to take preventive measures and make it obvious that those measures have been taken.
Blotter: Armed Robbery, Battery, Domestic Violence in Valencia
If you recognize the pictured individuals, please contact the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff Station.
Wanted: Info Leading to Capture of Truck Thieves
One of the great popular successes of recent American theatre history, this ingeniously constructed play offers a rare and skillful blending of two priceless theatrical ingredients —gasp-inducing thrills and spontaneous laughter.
‘Deathtrap’ Opens Nov. 13 at REP Theater
Today Governor Brown signed Assembly Bill (AB) 949, introduced by Assembly Member Lorena Gonzalez (D-San Diego), to classify competition cheer as a California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) sport beginning in the 2017-18 school year.
Cheerleading Added To CIF Competitive Sports List By 2017-18