header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
September 29
1969 - College of the Canyons opens with first class of students in temporary quarters at Hart High School [story]

| Friday, Jul 31, 2020
unemployment agency
California lawmakers take the Pledge of Allegiance from a social distance. | Photo: Nick Cahill / CNS.


State lawmakers including Assemblymember Tom Lackey, R-Palmdale, and out-of-work Californians unleashed a torrent of criticism and frustration Thursday in a tense hearing over the Employment Development Department’s persistent failure to deliver unemployment insurance benefits, despite promises to do better.

Jennifer Cogan was among the dozens of people who flooded the Assembly budget committee’s public comment phone line Thursday to share stories of unprecedented hardship, of depleted savings and unpaid bills and of hours spent waiting on hold only to be hung up on by unemployment agency staff who claim they can’t help.

“I have heart palpitations when thinking of the emotional trauma I have endured at the hands of the dysfunction of the EDD,” Cogan said, adding that the initial sympathy she had for the overworked department “quickly eroded after my initial outreaches to EDD consisted of spending six hours on hold only after having a representative hang up on me when they did not know to answer my question.This happened multiple times. I have broken down and cried ad nauseam.”

The employment department has long been plagued with understaffing and outdated technology. But these struggles have been thrown into sharp relief by the COVID-19 pandemic and resulting economic collapse.

Assemblymember Tom Lackey, R-Palmdale, said, ”Many of the people in my district have had no income, no income since March. I am embarrassed, and I hope that members of the EDD are more embarrassed and that will trigger action. I don’t think government has ever looked more broken than it has right now.”

Assemblyman Tom Lackey, R-Palmdale.

Assemblyman Tom Lackey, R-Palmdale.

The tenor of Thursday’s hearing was one of absolute disgust and vexation as lawmakers have lost all patience with the embattled department and its director Sharon Hilliard, whose answers revealed a puzzling incongruence with reality.

“Without using expletives I don’t have the vocabulary to describe the frustration I feel on behalf of my constituents,” Assemblymember Adrin Nazarian, D-San Fernando Valley, said.

Assemblymember Cottie Petrie-Norris, D-Laguna Beach, grilled Hilliard over the agency’s limited call center hours and Hilliard’s reticence to offer a clear answer on why its main location is only open for a few hours in the morning.

“Why do you have caseworkers only working four hours a day?” she asked. “Many of the constituents in my district and around the state have had the experience of spending literally hours on the phone waiting for someone to pick up, and it’s three in the afternoon they’re told ‘Sorry, our trained, actual caseworkers are only here from 8-12 p.m.’ That’s not working around the clock and that’s not acceptable customer service.”

Hilliard said the unemployment agency has one center with 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. service, and that it is continuing to add fully trained caseworkers every day.

Petrie-Norris questioned the truth of this assertion since so many of her constituents have been unable to get through during those hours. When they do, they’re either hung up on or the representative cannot answer their question. Again, she asked when the department will have full around-the-clock service.

“You’re not in the room so you’re not seeing the number of eyes rolling and an exasperated number of folks in the audience as you continue to fail to answer this question,” she said.

Hilliard insisted that the unemployment agency is working on combining its two call centers to provide full service from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., seven days a week.

Petrie-Norris also skewered the department for call-back wait times lasting 4-6 weeks. Hilliard agreed that this is unacceptable.

“We’re actually trying to get out of the business of callbacks,” she said. “That’s why we’re upgrading our call center so we can have fully trained staff from 8-8, one virtual call center providing service seven days a week.”

She said she didn’t know when that one consolidated call center would go online, but speculated that wouldn’t be until after mid-October.

“These timelines seem out of step with the urgency of the moment we are in,” Petrie-Norris said, noting that the agency is just now appointing a single point of contact for each legislative office, something lawmakers requested in April. “This just exemplifies how slowly things are moving.”

The unemployment agency has also been slow to handle its case backlog. Hilliard proudly announced that it has 239,000 cases awaiting resolution, a figure Assemblymember David Chiu, D-San Francisco, disputed. He said there are at least 889,000 whose claims have not been addressed because the EDD “needs more information.”

“Your online portal doesn’t tell the constituents what information the EDD needs,” he said. “EDD doesn’t send communication to the constituents that specify what information EDD needs. Our constituents cannot reach people through your call centers to tell you what you need. So how on Earth are these 889,000 Californians supposed to figure out how to resolve their claims?”

Hilliard said the agency has been sending email prompts to those who may be eligible for benefits but still need to answer some basic questions.

“If people don’t go in and certify there is nothing we can do,” she said.

Chiu further accused the unemployment agency of hiding the true extent of its backlog through conflicting statements to lawmakers and the press.

“Director Hilliard, why did you lie to us? Why have you been hiding this information from the public?” he asked.

“I would never lie to the public or the legislative body,” Hilliard said. “It has been a struggle for us to pull data, the way people want to hear the data is not the way our system was designed. It’s an old antiquated system.”

The computer system the EDD uses to manage its unemployment insurance program runs on the 30-year-old programming language COBOL.

“I view this failure as predominantly an IT failure,” Assemblymember Jay Obernolte, R- Big Bear Lake, said. “It’s horrifying to think about the fact that we have some of these systems still running in COBOL. In my day I was actually a pretty good programmer and I know COBOL, so if public service doesn’t work out for me, you should look me up.”

Obernolte said the department should have a streamlined system to resolve problems without huge call centers.

Hilliard agreed, saying the department will award a contract at the end of October “for a complete end-to-end replacement of our system.”

The EDD’s relationship with Deloitte, the vendor that built its online unemployment insurance system was also a sore point with Chiu. He noted that the EDD spent $259 million on no-bid contracts with the vendor over the last 10 years.

It was a debacle reminiscent of another massive tech project Deloitte spearheaded with the California judiciary during the height of the Great Recession, one that ended in the Legislature pulling funding after cost projections soared into the billion-dollar range.

He said the EDD hired Deloitte to work on a project expected to take four years to complete and cost $47 million. The timeline stretched to six years and the cost ballooned to $94 million

“That project massively failed, created massive delays in paid unemployment claims,” he said, citing an Assembly insurance committee report from 2013.

“I understand Deloitte continues to be a vendor of yours. Our office has met with Deloitte a few times. They claim no responsibility over anything that has taken place with your web-based systems. They say they’re not at fault for what’s happening, they don’t have authority to fix things. Given how much you pay them I want to ask you what you think they actually do.”

Hilliard said Deloitte staff assists with maintaining the system, running the data and adding new features. Chiu said her answers contradicted the vendor’s.

“They have abdicated responsibility and have given us answers that are the exact opposite,” he said. “And you keep signing new contracts with Deloitte. Why do we keep entering into no-bid contracts with someone with a history of cost overruns and problematic IT work?”

Chiu said the enormous amount spent with Deloitte represents another failure. “This vendor has also failed California. That’s a lot of UI [unemployment insurance] checks and because of the collective failure of EDD and Deloitte, millions of Californians haven’t gotten theirs.”

Thursday’s hearing follows Governor Gavin Newsom’s announcement touting the creation of a “strike team” to help the agency process unpaid claims and modernize its technology.

Assemblymember Jim Cooper, D-Elk Grove, who chairs the budget subcommittee on state administration, noted the peculiar timing of the announcement, released just before the hearing was set to take place.

“I was pleased to see the government’s announcement yesterday that he deployed a strike team to address the problems at the EDD,” he said. “The curious timing of the strike team announcement is not lost on the Legislature.”

Nazarian went even further, suggesting that the governor and the unemployment department were playing at political gamesmanship. He pointed to a link at the bottom of Newsom’s announcement that leads to a set of explanatory letters from the department that outlines corrective measures.

“It almost strikes me as a cloak-and-dagger game that we would play in elementary school in trying to say ‘I did this but it’s too bad that you didn’t see it,’” Nazarian said. “It’s so unfortunate because there are people’s lives at stake.”

— By Maria Dinzeo, CNS

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment

SCV NewsBreak
Tuesday, Sep 29, 2020
Tuesday COVID-19 Roundup: 269,284 Cases Countywide, 39 New Deaths; 6,156 SCV Cases
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Tuesday 39 new deaths and 905 new cases of confirmed COVID-19, with 6,156 total cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Tuesday, Sep 29, 2020
Breweries, Wineries Can Reopen Outdoors Countywide Next Week
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to allow breweries and wineries to resume outdoor operations in one week.
Tuesday, Sep 29, 2020
Westfield Sues L.A. County Over Indoor Mall Closures
The largest indoor mall operator in the region, with locations including the Westfield Valencia Town Center, has filed a lawsuit against Los Angeles County over COVID-19 health guidelines that have kept the shopping centers closed.
Keep Up With Our Facebook

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health confirmed Tuesday 39 new deaths and 905 new cases of confirmed COVID-19, with 6,156 total cases in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Tuesday COVID-19 Roundup: 269,284 Cases Countywide, 39 New Deaths; 6,156 SCV Cases
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to allow breweries and wineries to resume outdoor operations in one week.
Breweries, Wineries Can Reopen Outdoors Countywide Next Week
The largest indoor mall operator in the region, with locations including the Westfield Valencia Town Center, has filed a lawsuit against Los Angeles County over COVID-19 health guidelines that have kept the shopping centers closed.
Westfield Sues L.A. County Over Indoor Mall Closures
The Board of Supervisors approved a motion by Supervisor Kathryn Barger, whose 5th District includes the Santa Clarita Valley, and coauthored by Supervisor Sheila Kuehl to begin sharing data about veteran suicides between the Department of Veterans Affairs and Los Angeles County and explore the possibility of establishing a countywide veteran suicide review team.
L.A. County to Explore Veteran Suicide Review Team
Each October Circle of Hope recognizes Breast Cancer Awareness Month with its annual event, 31 Days of Hope to help increase attention and support for the awareness, early detection and treatment of this disease.
31 Days of Hope to Help Increase Breast Cancer Awareness, Support
SAN FRANCISCO (CN) — Fed up with the growing number of untraceable homemade firearms used in gun crimes and mass shootings, California Attorney General Xavier Becerra announced a federal lawsuit Tuesday to force the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives to crack down on so-called “ghost guns” that skirt laws requiring background checks and age verification.
California Sues Feds to Force Crack Down on ‘Ghost Guns’
Thousands of Southern California Edison customers were suddenly left without power late Tuesday morning in Newhall after balloons came in contact with power lines, according to officials.
Newhall Power Outage Due to Mylar Balloons
The Board of Supervisors approved a motion by Supervisor Kathryn Barger and coauthored by Supervisor Janice Hahn that will enable elementary schools to begin applying for a waiver to reopen grades TK-2 in schools, prioritizing schools with a high number of low-income students.
Barger Motion to Begin School Waiver Reopening Process Approved by Supes
While in-person events may be postponed for the time being, the city of Santa Clarita events team is bringing you virtual and physically distanced happenings to fill the void.
Santa Clarita Arts Calendar Features New Online October Events
The fast-moving Martindale Fire, which started near Bouquet Reservoir, remained at 230 acres overnight, with firefighters able to achieve 40% containment by Tuesday morning.
Martindale Fire Remains at 230 Acres, 40% Containment
EDUCAUSE, the nonprofit higher education information technology association, awarded former California State University, Northridge Vice President for Information Technology and Chief Information Officer Hilary J. Baker with its 2020 Community Leadership Award.
Higher Education Nonprofit Recognizes Former CSUN VP for Community Leadership
The Valley Industry Association will welcome Santa Clarita Mayor Cameron Smyth as the Keynote Speaker for the October VIA Virtual Series taking place Tuesday, Oct. 13, from 11:00 a.m - 12:30 p.m.
Oct. 13: VIA Virtual Series with Mayor Cameron Smyth
A fatal traffic collision south of the Newhall Pass on Interstate 5 stalled traffic for morning commuters Tuesday.
Multi-Vehicle Traffic Collision on SB I-5 Leaves One Dead
A gas main break at Costco in Canyon Country prompted evacuations and road closures Tuesday morning.
Costco Gas Main Break Prompts Evacuations, Road Closures
In its 2015 regional annual report, UNESCO, a specialized agency of the United Nations that promotes international collaboration in education, science, and culture, listed Mozambique as one of the countries in Africa with the highest incidence of girl marriage.
Santa Clarita Youth Education Advocate’s Annual Award Brings Hope Across Africa
1969 - College of the Canyons opens with first class of students in temporary quarters at Hart High School [story]
Smoke from a brush fire dubbed the Martindale Fire in Bouquet Canyon near the Bouquet Reservoir was visible from areas in the Santa Clarita Valley shortly after the blaze broke out Monday afternoon, quickly burning 200 acres and threatening structures.
‘Martindale’ Brush Fire in Bouquet Canyon, Visible from SCV, Threatens Strctures
The global COVID-19 death toll surpassed 1 million Monday afternoon, a grim milestone in a pandemic that caught much of the world unprepared for a health crisis and left economies reeling, convulsed politics and fundamentally altered the world.
World Marks Grim Milestone: 1 Million COVID-19 Deaths
SCV Water invites the community to a virtual ribbon-cutting on Monday, Oct. 5 at 10 a.m., celebrating the completion of a new water treatment plant.
Oct. 5: SCV Water Treatment Plant Virtual Ribbon-Cutting Ceremony
Newhall resident Daniel Bradley, a Vietnam veteran and Gold Star son, had the chance to fly to Washington, D.C., to attend a reception at the White House Sunday to honor Gold Star families and their loved ones who’ve died in service.
Daniel Bradley of Newhall Honored as Gold Star Son at White House
The city of Santa Clarita’s Film Office reports a busy slate of production activity in the Santa Clarita Valley this week, September 28-October 4.
Busy Slate of Productions This Week in SCV
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has extended the current extreme heat warning for the Santa Clarita Valley through Saturday evening.
SCV Extreme Heat Warning Extended Through Saturday
The Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce on Monday announced the launch of a forum for small business owners -- the Small Business Roundtable.
SCV Chamber to Launch Monthly Roundtable for Small Business Owners
%d bloggers like this: