header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
November 26
1916 - A score of Wobblies bust up Newhall Jail after commandeering SP freight train [story]
Wobblies logo


| Wednesday, Apr 15, 2020
Colfax Avenue is the main street that bisects the metropolitan area in Denver, Colorado. Today many of the businesses that line the street are closed, part of a tapestry of millions of layoffs around the country. | Photo: Amanda Pampuro / CNS.
Colfax Avenue is the main street that bisects the metropolitan area in Denver, Colorado. Today many of the businesses that line the street are closed, part of a tapestry of millions of layoffs around the country. | Photo: Amanda Pampuro / CNS.

 

Federal courts across the country are being asked to step in as small businesses hit roadblocks applying for billions of dollars in COVID-19 relief funds.

Pointing out a “significant flaw” in the government’s emergency coronavirus response bill, a federal judge nevertheless declined to block Bank of America from prioritizing its own customers over small businesses who don’t have a preexisting relationship with the bank.

The problem is banks requiring previous relationships with borrowers before new lending contracts can be created. While one federal judge sided Monday with Bank of America in a case out of Maryland, she noted the existence of a “significant flaw” with the government program.

Signed into law at the end of March, the CARES Act – short for the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act – includes several financial support systems for people and businesses across the country struggling in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Among other measures, the law created the Paycheck Protection Program, or PPP, which set aside nearly $350 billion for businesses to maintain their payrolls during the virus outbreak that has forced millions of businesses to close in hopes of slowing the spread of the respiratory disease.

The bipartisan agreement was hailed by leaders in both parties, but when banks created online portals for small businesses to apply for PPP over the first weekend in April, issues began to surface.

Senator Ben Cardin, a Maryland Democrat and ranking member of the Senate Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship, was among those who said he was “deeply troubled” by the preexisting relationship requirements being enforced by banks.

“Creating artificial barriers that block businesses from much-needed capital is redlining by another name,” Cardin said in a statement.

Senator Marco Rubio, R-Fla., was similarly displeased with the initial rollout.

“The requirement that a #SmallBusiness not just have a business account but also a loan or credit card is NOT in the law we wrote & passed or in the regulations,” Rubio tweeted April 3, noting the requirement at issue was from Bank of America, not the government. “They should drop it.”

But new criticism was lobbed this week by U.S. District Judge Stephanie Gallagher, despite her ruling Monday denying an injunction request to block Bank of America’s lending requirement.

The underlying class action, filed by Baltimore-based manufacturer Profiles Inc., accuses Bank of America of putting “discriminatory policies of corporate greed over the needs of America’s small businesses.”

“Nothing in the CARES Act authorizes or permits defendants to pick and choose who would gain access to or benefit from the federally backed lending program,” the 16-page complaint states. “There is no justification for requiring depository clients and other small businesses to go to the end of the line.”

But Gallagher, an appointee of President Donald Trump, found the stimulus law did not expressly create a private right of action allowing small businesses to sue lenders over provisions of the law, effectively tying the court’s hands.

“Plaintiffs’ experiences demonstrate a significant flaw, from their perspective and that of many other small businesses, in the implementation of the massive and complex PPP program,” the judge wrote in her 23-page opinion. “However, given the competing policy interests, the need to balance the desire to assist the widest swath of small businesses with the need to incentivize lender participation, and the overall fluidity of this epidemic, Congress is better positioned to remedy any defects in the CARES Act, and to pass the supplemental legislation it believes best aimed at ameliorating the effects of the COVID-19 crisis.”

Alan M. Rifkin — managing partner of the Bethesda-based firm Rifkin Weiner Livingston, which represents Profiles Inc. in its case against Bank of America — pointed to Gallagher’s criticism in a statement following the opinion’s release.

“The class action highlights serious shortcomings in Bank of America’s administering of the program,” Rifkin said. He promised to appeal the decision, but in the meantime asked Congress to “do what is right and open the PPP process to any small business that otherwise qualifies for federal funds under the PPP program.”

While Gallagher highlighted the program’s main flaw, she noted banks typically put their own customers first and declined to issue an order that could “undermine Congress’s goal to maximize relief for American small businesses.”

“If fewer lenders are incentivized to participate in PPP, because they are prohibited from prioritizing their own customers or other entities they believe worthy of expedited consideration, then fewer American small businesses will have access to the pool of readily available PPP funds, and Congress’s statutory scheme would be further frustrated,” she wrote.

In its response to Profiles Inc.’s injunction request, Bank of America pointed to the importance of prioritizing current lenders for that exact reason.

“BofA’s decision to prioritize lending to clients who do not have lending relationships with other banks is simply an effort to direct its resources quickly and efficiently,” wrote Kenneth Smurzynski with the DC-based Williams & Connolly LLP, who represents the bank in the dispute. “Because lenders already have information about their existing clients, prioritizing those clients streamlines the application process, meaning more loans are processed faster.”

Federal judges in Houston are also handling lawsuits from small businesses making similar complaints against Wells Fargo and a local financial institution, Frost Bank.

The complaints, filed over the weekend by Houston lawyer Salar Ali Ahmed, claim the preexisting relationship requirements at both banks violate the CARES Act.

“Defendant implemented a loan process that unlawfully prioritized its existing business clients at the expense of not only its own clients without business checking accounts, but also other small businesses from applying for funds from the governmental loan program,” according to the lawsuit against San Antonio-based Frost Bank.

But as these lawsuits roll in, some criticism of the program has been dialed back.

“Despite some challenges, the program has now had over 1 million small businesses approved for small business loans,” Senator Rubio said in a Twitter video posted Tuesday morning

The Florida Republican stressed early issues were the result of the all-new nature of the emergency lending program. He reversed course on earlier complaints, calling the program a success and claiming over $240 billion has been committed to small businesses with disbursements already underway.

“But there’s more work to be done,” Rubio added. He called on his fellow lawmakers to approve more funding for the program, after a dispute in the Senate last week that saw an additional $250 billion in PPP funding die on the floor.

In an emailed statement, Bank of America spokesperson William Halldin said the bank “remained focused” on the more than 300,000 applications it has received, totaling more than $45 billion since it opened the program.

— By Brad Kutner, CNS

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

0 Comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment


Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted 4-0 on Tuesday, Nov. 26, to supporting a motion to evaluate the feasibility of instituting a new department to spearhead the county’s efforts to tackle homelessness.
Supes Vote to Explore Creation of New L.A. County Homelessness Department
The California Institute of the Arts boasts two artists with CalArts connections earning spots on the Recording Academy list of nominees for the 67th annual Grammy Awards.
Two CalArtians Nominated for 2025 Grammys
The Performing Arts Center will host America's Got Talent top 12 finalist comedian Don McMillan's show, 7 p.m. Saturday, Dec. 21 at 26455 Rockwell Canyon Road, Santa Clarita, CA 91355.
Dec. 21: PAC Presents America’s Got Talent’s Don McMillan Show
The California Department of Transportation advises motorists to be extra cautious as a record number of Southern California residents are expected to travel for the Thanksgiving holiday.
Caltrans Warns of Delays Due to Record Thanksgiving Holiday Travel
The Sierra Hillbillies Square and Round Dance club invites all to a Ugly Sweater themed Square Dance, Sunday, Dec. 8, 2-5 p.m. at Valencia United Methodist Church, 25718 McBean Parkway, Santa Clarita, CA.
Dec. 8: Sierra Hillbillies Present ‘Ugly Sweater Square Dance’
The Santa Clarita Volunteer Hub is a one-stop shop for promoting volunteerism in the community. It connects local non-profits and volunteers who want to offer their time, skills and talents to a good cause.
Volunteer Hub: Connecting Volunteers with Local Causes
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health is warning residents to avoid consuming voluntarily recalled raw milk due to a detection of H5 bird flu virus in a retail sample. Many retailers in Los Angeles may have sold recalled raw milk that may be contaminated with H5 bird flu virus.
Recalled Raw Milk Was Sold in L.A. County
In a three-set sweep, The Master's University women's volleyball team advanced out of the opening round of the NAIA Women's Volleyball National Championship Tournament over the Benedictine (KS) Ravens Saturday night, Nov. 23 in The MacArthur Center.
TMU Women’s Volleyball Wins NAIA Opening Round Match
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health will join in marking the 36th annual World AIDS Day on Dec. 1.
Dec. 1: County Landmarks Light Up in Red for World AIDS Day
Deputies and investigators with the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station are currently investigating a series of burglaries reported in the Stevenson's Ranch community over the span of one week.
SCV Sheriff’s Station Investigating Stevenson Ranch Burglaries
Join the city of Santa Clarita for the Fourth annual Holiday Tree Lighting Ceremony at The Cube – Ice and Entertainment Center, powered by FivePoint | Valencia, 27745 Smyth Drive, Valencia, CA 91355 on Friday, Dec. 6 at 7 p.m.
Dec.6: Skate Into the Holidays at Fourth Annual Holiday Tree Lighting Ceremony
As official Neighborhood Champions for the 6th year, the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce encourages everyone to embrace the spirit of the holiday season by supporting local small businesses on Small Business Saturday, an annual event founded by American Express, now celebrating its 15th anniversary. This year, the event takes place on Saturday, Nov. 30 (all day).
Nov. 30: Small Business Saturday Promotes ‘Shop Local’
College of the Canyons football closed out its 2024 campaign with an exciting 26-21 victory over Mt. San Jacinto College in the Southern California Football Association Jersey Mike's Valencia Bowl at Cougar Stadium on Sunday, Nov. 24.
Canyons Closes Season with 26-21 Bowl Game Victory over Mt. San Jacinto
1916 - A score of Wobblies bust up Newhall Jail after commandeering SP freight train [story]
Wobblies logo
As part of Santa Clarita’s ongoing commitment to public safety, small dividers will be installed on Orchard Village Road in the coming weeks.
City Emphasizes Pedestrian Safety on Orchard Village Road
The Campaign for College Opportunity has named College of the Canyons a 2024 Champion for Excellence in Placement in Black Math Success.
COC Named 2024 Champion for Excellence in Placement in Black Math Success
The city of Santa Clarita will host the grand opening of the Valencia Community Center on Monday, Dec. 9 at 10 a.m. at the center at 26147 McBean Parkway in Valencia.
Dec. 9: Valencia Community Center Grand Opening
Join a community discussion on retail theft Monday, Dec. 16 from 4-5:30 p.m. featuring California State Assemblywoman Pilar Schiavo, Assemblymember Rick Zbur and a panel of industry experts.
Dec. 16: Community Conversation on Retail Theft with Pilar Schiavo
All For Kids is seeking foster families and now offers two virtual ways for individuals and/or couples to learn how to help children in foster care while reunifying with birth families or how to provide legal permanency by adoption.
Dec. 19: All For Kids Virtual Orientations on Foster Care and Adoption
As millions of motorists gear up for travel, the California Highway Patrol is gearing up, too. Starting at 6:01 p.m. on Wednesday, Nov. 27, and running through 11:59 p.m. on Sunday, Dec. 1, the CHP will activate its annual Thanksgiving Maximum Enforcement Period.
Nov. 27-Dec. 1: CHP Maximum Enforcement Period
The 4th Annual Newhall Holiday Marketplace will take place 10 a.m.- 4 p.m. Sunday, Dec. 8 at the Newhall Community Center, 22421 Market St., Newhall CA, 91321.
Dec. 8:  Newhall Holiday Marketplace
College of the Canyons will enter the postseason as the No. 12 seed in the California Community College Athletic Association (3C2A) Women's Volleyball Southern California Regional Playoffs.
No. 12 Canyons Women’s Volleyball to Begin 3C2A SoCal Regionals
The Thanksgiving holiday is all about gratitude. Being thankful for what we have and all the blessings we have in our lives.
Ken Striplin | Thankful for Our Nonprofits
SCVNews.com