header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Santa Clarita CA
Today in
S.C.V. History
June 7
1861 - Fort Tejon commander ordered to abandon fort (est. 1854) & transfer garrison to Los Angeles [story]
Fort Tejon

| Friday, Sep 20, 2013
Commentary by Carl Kanowsky, Esq.
Carl Kanowsky, Esq.

Carl Kanowsky, Esq.

As anyone with preteen daughters knows, Barbie, the iconic California doll that ruled the toy empire for years, has been vigorously challenged by Bratz, the line of saucy, spunky dolls, “The Girls With A Passion For Fashion.”

Bratz, led by Jade, Sasha and Cloe, ignited a war not unlike that between Bill Gates of Microsoft and Steve Jobs of Apple. The conflict has spread from the shelves at Toys “R” Us to the federal courts, with Mattel claiming that Bratz cost it $1 billion in sales. (I’ll bet you didn’t know mere toys were such big business.)

Mattel’s claim against Bratz is not that Bratz is major competition, which it obviously is, but rather that MGA Entertainment, the makers of the Bratz line, stole the concept and idea from Mattel.

You see, the person who dreamed up Bratz is Carter Bryant, who before making his fortune with Bratz, was a fashion and hair style designer for, you guessed it, Mattel.

While still working for Mattel, Bryant went to MGA with sketches and a fairly simple model of a Bratz-style doll, constructed of a head from Mattel’s inventory, a Barbie body and Ken’s boots. Less than three months later, Bryant had left Mattel and was working for MGA.

Mattel sued MGA, asserting that since Bryant designed the Bratz dolls while still working for Mattel, Mattel owned the concept and right to exploit the idea.

Basic law holds that generally if an employee creates something for his employer, the employer owns that development, not the employee.

Bratz_1To bolster this, Mattel had Bryant agreed in writing that he would communicate to Mattel all of his inventions, as well as assign to Mattel “all right, title and interest” in such inventions.

Inventions were defined as including things such as discoveries, improvements, designs, developments, etc.

Seems pretty comprehensive, doesn’t it? The trial court judge thought so and ruled, before the case was tried before a jury, that the term “inventions” included Bryant’s ideas, such as Bratz.

Mattel and MGA then proceeded to fight out the rest of the battle in district court, with Mattel claiming it should own the entire Bratz concept, and with MGA predictably saying MGA should own it.

The case went to the jury, which agreed that Barbie (that is, Mattel) had been harmed and that Jade (that is, MGA) owed her $10 million. That’s a lot of money, but it’s a far cry from the $1 billion that Mattel was demanding.

The judge ordered MGA to stop making Bratz dolls immediately, a devastating result for MGA.

MGA appealed, asking the Court of Appeals to set the Bratz free. Interestingly, the Court of Appeals agreed.

The appellate court decision hinged on several factors, but one of the main ones was that the term “inventions” does not necessarily include “ideas.”

The justices said designs and processes are “concrete,” while ideas are “ephemeral and often reflect bursts of inspiration that exist only in the mind.”

The Court of Appeals also ruled that the trial-court judge should have let the jury decide whether “inventions” include “ideas,” rather than taking that decision from them.

The jury, according to the appellate court, should have heard that contracts signed by other Mattel employees clearly stated that inventions did include ideas, whereas Bryant’s was silent on that topic.

Now, because of the lack of one word, the case goes back to the trial judge and is likely to go through the whole process again.

Mattel, which thought it had finally triumphed in the decade-long war, must continue the fight while MGA gets to begin marketing Bratz anew. What has already cost millions in attorneys fees will cost millions more, with no certain outcomes.

The morals of the story to employers: 1. Make sure all of your internal documents are consistent with each other. 2. Make sure your employees know you welcome their ideas and inventions, and that they will be well rewarded for sharing with you.

Maybe if Mattel had that type of policy, Carter Bryant would have gone to his employer and not to the competition.


Carl Kanowsky of Kanowsky & Associates is a Santa Clarita Valley attorney. He may be reached by email at cjk@kanowskylaw.com. Nothing contained herein shall be or is intended to be construed as providing legal advice.



Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment

Opinion Section Policy
All opinions and ideas are welcome. Factually inaccurate, libelous, defamatory, profane or hateful statements are not. Your words must be your own. All commentary is subject to editing for legibility. There is no length limit, but the shorter, the better the odds of people reading it. "Local" SCV-related topics are preferred. Send commentary to: LETTERS (at) SCVNEWS.COM. Author's full name, community name, phone number and e-mail address are required. Phone numbers and e-mail addresses are not published except at author's request. Acknowledgment of submission does not guarantee publication.
Read More From...
Monday, Jun 5, 2023
Last weekend marked the Fifth District's 25th annual Tribute to Veterans and Military Families, featuring the theme "A Family Tradition."
Friday, Jun 2, 2023
By now you have no doubt heard about the waste hauler transition coming to the city of Santa Clarita. Beginning July 1, all residents in our city will begin the process of switching over to Burrtec Waste Industries for their trash service.
Thursday, Jun 1, 2023
Can you believe it's already June? May was a whirlwind of excitement, laughter and a few mischievous moments.
Thursday, Jun 1, 2023
Tuesday, May 16, 2023
Since the days of Noah some people have been particularly drawn to owning exotic animals. While Noah was ordered to amass his collection to save animals from a flood, these days people obtain unusual pets for different reasons. Some are attracted to the animals’ appearances, others to the novelty and attention they receive for having them as pets.
Monday, May 15, 2023
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond has issued a statement in response to Gov. Gavin Newsom’s revised budget for fiscal year 2023–24.

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1861 - Fort Tejon commander ordered to abandon fort (est. 1854) & transfer garrison to Los Angeles [story]
Fort Tejon
The school year is ending, which means the Santa Clarita Public Library is ramping up its summer programming. This includes the kickoff of the annual Summer Reading Program which begins June 12.
June 12: Kickoff to Santa Clarita’s Summer Reading Program
Micaiah Scott will continue her career with The Master's University track and field team, but this time as an assistant coach.
Micaiah Scott Returning to TMU as Assistant Coach
Perfect Tux, a Santa Clarita based provider of fashion-forward men's formal wear, celebrates its remarkable journey from a local startup to becoming a top 1% Shopify store.
SCV-Based Perfect Tux Skyrockets to Shopify’s Top 1%
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's detectives need the public's help in locating missing person Maeleen Nicole Canchola.
Update: Missing Saugus Teen Found
Twenty-one College of the Canyons fire technology students have received $1,000 scholarships from Edison International to cover tuition, books and school-related fees.
COC Fire Tech Students Awarded Edison Scholarships
California State Sen. Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, announced Tuesday his successful effort in protecting $40 million from being cut from California’s Court Appointed Special Advocates program.
Wilk Protects State’s Foster Youth Program Funding from Being Cut
Two new deans are at the helms of California State University, Northridge’s College of Humanities and College of Health and Human Development — Jeffrey Reeder and Mechelle Best.
CSUN’s Newest Deans Encourage Communication Throughout University
Easton Johnson was named the Golf Coaches Association of America Jack Nicklaus Award winner as the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics' top men's golfer for 2023.
TMU’s Easton Johnson Named Jack Nicklaus Award Recipient
SACRAMENTO — State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond announced that the California Department of Education is partnering with Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library, the preeminent early childhood book-gifting program in the world and the flagship program of the Dollywood Foundation.
State Education Department Partners with Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library
More than 15.8 million Californians now have a REAL ID – an increase of 172,036 from the previous month – according to California Department of Motor Vehicles data.
DMV Reminding Californians to Gear Up for Summer Travel with REAL ID
1824 - Mexican soldiers track runaway Chumash slaves through the Santa Clarita Valley [story]
Chumash revolt
Halfway to Home is hosting a special adoption event on Saturday, July 22, with @zoomroom_santaclarita from 12 p.m. to 2:30 p.m.
Halfway to Home Hosting SCV Dog Rescue Adoption, Fundraising Event
The Santa Clarita Water Agency recently released its newest sustainable landscape resource, Garden Smarter.
SCV Water Launches Sustainable Landscape Resource
The California Department of Transportation has scheduled full freeway closures on the northbound and southbound State Rout 14 / Antelope Valley Freeway between Technology Drive in Palmdale and Avenue A in Lancaster.
Caltrans Announces SR-14 Full Closures
The regular meeting of the Saugus Union School District Governing Board will take place Tuesday, June 6, beginning with closed session at 5:30 p.m., followed immediately by open session at 6:30 p.m.
June 6: SUSD Regular Meeting
The city of Santa Clarita’s Film Office released the nine productions currently filming in the Santa Clarita Valley for the week of Monday, June 5 - Sunday, June 11.
Nine Productions Currently Filming in Santa Clarita
Last weekend marked the Fifth District's 25th annual Tribute to Veterans and Military Families, featuring the theme "A Family Tradition."
Keeping Up With Kathryn Barger | Tribute to Veterans
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health cautions residents who are planning to visit L.A. County beaches to avoid swimming, surfing and playing in ocean waters.
Ocean Water Advisory Issued for L.A. County Beaches
Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department Missing Persons Unit investigators are asking for the public’s help locating Christy Lee Anderson.
Public’s Help Needed in Locating Missing Valencia Woman
On Saturday, the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department celebrated 78 young men and women who completed a 14-week “Scouts of America, Learning for Life,” Certified Sheriff’s Explorer Academy at S.T.A.R.S. Center in Whittier.
LASD Celebrates Explorer Academy Graduates
Shelter Animals Count, the most trusted and current source for animal sheltering data, spotlights a trend in dog euthanasia from the newly-released Intake and Outcome Data Analysis report for Q1 2023.
Study Shows Rise in Shelter Dog Admissions
1968 - Saugus resident Elizabeth Evans struck by bullet meant for Sen. Robert F. Kennedy [story]
Elizabeth Evans
1925 - Newhall Constable Jack Pilcher killed in the line of duty in handgun accident [story]
Jack Pilcher
%d bloggers like this: