header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail


Today in
S.C.V. History
July 24
1864 - Walker/Reynier family patriarch Jean Joseph Reynier, then 15, arrives in Sand Canyon from France; eventually homesteads 1,200 acres [story]
Joseph Reynier

By Nicholas Iovino

SAN FRANCISCO – A federal judge in California must consider whether personal information is a form of currency and determine whether to advance a class action over a massive Facebook data breach.

Fighting litigation over a September 2018 hack that affected 29 million users, Facebook argues a liability-limiting clause in its terms of service is particularly strong and enforceable for a company that provides a free service, as the Ninth Circuit held last year in Darnaa LLC v. Google.

But five named plaintiffs say they pay for access to Facebook’s social network in the form of valuable personal data, which the company uses for targeted advertising and sells to third parties to make more than $40 billion in 2017 alone.

“Is it a cost to the consumer that they hand over all this personal information which is used by Facebook to sell to other people?” U.S. District Judge William Alsup asked in court Thursday.

Last year, hackers managed to infiltrate millions of Facebook accounts by exploiting a vulnerability in its “View As” feature for user profiles. Facebook initially said the breach affected 50 million users but has since downgraded that estimate to 29 million users, including 4 million in the U.S.

Hackers swiped the names and contact information – such as phone numbers or email addresses – of 2.7 million U.S. users, and infiltrated the profiles of an additional 1.2 million U.S. users, gaining access to usernames, birthdates, workplaces, hometowns, schools attended and other personal information, including places where they recently “checked in” or were “tagged.”

In a hearing Thursday at the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, lawyers for a proposed class of hacked Facebook users urged Alsup to take a long, hard look at the social network’s business model as he decides whether the service is actually free of charge.

“The notion that this is a free service is a little outdated,” plaintiffs’ attorney Douglas McNamara said. “The currency is your information.”

McNamara, of Cohen Milstein Sellers Toll in New York, insisted that Facebook’s limitation-of-liability clause should be deemed “unconscionable” and “unenforceable” because it directly contradicts pledges the company has made about protecting user privacy.

Quoting the “Privacy Principles” posted on Facebook’s website, McNamara cited representations that the company “work[s] hard to keep your information secure” and is “accountable.”

Alsup did not seem particularly persuaded that such comments can be interpreted as promises to protect private user data.

“It says, ‘We work hard to keep your information secure,’” Alsup said. “That’s not quite the same as saying, ‘We guarantee it will always be secure.’”

After pressing both sides to identify an “on-point” court ruling on whether personal information can count as a “cost” of service, Alsup concluded he is in uncharted territory.

The judge asked Facebook’s legal team to explain why there should not be “bone-crushing discovery” to determine how valuable Facebook users’ information is and whether its social network can truly be considered a “free service.”

Facebook lawyer Andrew Clubok, of Latham & Watkins in Washington, D.C., insisted that courts have not recognized the type of information taken in the 2018 data breach as particularly valuable. He further argued that users voluntarily add that data to their profiles. The only information required to open an account is a name, birth date, gender and phone number or email address.

Given the nature of the online social network, Aslup did not put much weight on the fact that users volunteer to post personal information there.

“What’s the point of opening account other than sharing private information?” Alsup asked.

The judge also acknowledged his own personal discomfort with the Menlo Park-based company’s business model.

“For me, I would not like the places I like going on vacation being spread across the country so people can send me ads about it,” Alsup said.

After 90 minutes of debate, Alsup took the arguments under submission.

He also ordered plaintiffs’ lawyers to make their five clients available for depositions by May 10, and he asked Facebook to file supplemental briefs on any evidence uncovered in those interviews.

Started in 2004 by Harvard dropout Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook remains the world’s largest online social network with 1.56 billion daily active users and nearly 2.4 billion monthly active users as of March 31, 2019.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.


You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Leave a Comment

Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
1864 - Walker/Reynier family patriarch Jean Joseph Reynier, then 15, arrives in Sand Canyon from France; eventually homesteads 1,200 acres [story]
Joseph Reynier
The SCV Food Pantry is in need of volunteers to help sort food, stock shelves, fill bags and distribute food to its residents in need Monday through Thursday and Saturday of each week.
SCV Food Pantry in Need of Volunteers
College of the Canyons graduating sophomore Jonah El-Farra has been named a California Community Colleges Men's Basketball Coaches Associations (CCCMBCA) student-athlete scholarship recipient for the 2023-24 season. 
El-Farra Earns Coaches Associations’ Student-Athlete Scholarship
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors unanimously approved Tuesday a motion introduced by Supervisor Kathryn Barger and co-authored by Chair Lindsey P. Horvath that directs the creation of an independent Ethics Commission and ethics reform measures to improve transparency and create greater oversight in County government.
Supes Unanimously Approve Creation of Ethics Commission, Reform
The city of Santa Clarita is inviting artists to submit artwork for consideration for its upcoming “Body & Presence” juried exhibition, which will be on view at the Canyon Country Community Center during the City's annual Business for Artists Conference.
Aug. 4: Call for Art ‘Body & Presence’ Exhibit Deadline
Zach Schroeder, the head coach for The Master’s University track and cross country programs, is stepping down to be closer to family.
After Historic Run, TMU Coach Zach Schroeder Steps Down
The community is invited to an SCV Senior Center Health and Wellness program lecture “Let’s Talk About Kidney Health” on Wednesday, July 24, from 1 p.m. to 2 p.m.
July 24: SCV Senior Center Wellness Program Lecture on Kidney Health
College of the Canyons baseball is sending five players to four-year universities to continue their academic journeys and athletic careers following the 2024 season.
Five Cougars Taking Skills to Next Level
The Master's University baseball has signed pitcher Mack Skeels to join the team for the 2025 season.
Pitcher Mack Skeels Commits to Mustangs Baseball
Drug-related overdose and poisoning deaths plateaued for the first time in ten years in 2023 in Los Angeles County, a new Los Angeles County Department of Public Health analysis of Los Angeles County Department of Medical Examiner data has found.
L.A. County’s Drug-Related Overdose Deaths Plateau for First Time in Decade
As temperatures soar in Los Angeles, so do the numbers of mosquitoes and their relentless, itchy bites.
Vector Control Launches Summer Safeguarding Campaign
1982 - Vic Morrow & two child actors killed in helicopter crash at Indian Dunes during filming of "Twilight Zone: The Movie" [story]
Twilight Zone Movie
Picture this…a cozy blanket laid out on the grass, the warm evening breeze and your favorite film playing on the big screen.
Ken Striplin | City Cinemas Brings Back Movies Under the Stars
The California State University, Los Angeles Golden Eagle volleyball team, which included middle blocker Shelby Grubbs from Newhall, was welcomed to the White House on Monday, alongside other national champions from the past academic year, to celebrate their accomplishments as part of NCAA Sports Day.
Former Hart High Standout Honored at White House’s NCAA Sports Day
The Friends of Hart Park - in partnership with the Natural History Museum and Los Angeles County Parks - is pleased to announce the return of their signature event “Silents Under the Stars” on Saturday, Sept. 7, starting at 6 p.m., at William S. Hart Park.
Sept. 7: ‘Silents Under the Stars’ Returns to Hart Park
To help students balance education with their diverse work and family responsibilities, College of the Canyons will offer a wide variety of flexible learning options during the fall 2024 semester.
COC Fall 2024 Offering Flexible Learning Options
Beginning Monday, July 29, crews will start the construction of traffic circulation modifications on two intersections, part of the federally-funded, Traffic and Pedestrian Circulation and Safety Improvements Project.
Santa Clarita Announces Upcoming Lane Closures
Circle of Hope's Annual Tea is one of Santa Clarita’s most anticipated fundraisers bringing awareness of breast cancer and raising funds to help those in our local community fighting this disease.
Oct. 19: Save the Date for Circle of Hope’s Annual Tea
The city of Santa Clarita’s Film Office has released the list of four productions currently filming in the Santa Clarita Valley for the week of Monday, July 22 - Sunday, July 28.
‘S.W.A.T.’ Among Four Productions Filming in Santa Clarita
The Santa Clarita Valley Special Education Local Plan Area (SCV SELPA) and its member districts actively seek out all individuals with exceptional needs, from birth to age 22, including infants and children parentally placed in private schools.
SCV SELPA Seeking Children with Disabilities
The California Department of Transportation announced the right lane of southbound Interstate 5 will be blocked overnight Monday, July 22 through Friday, July 26 from two miles north of Templin Highway (near the Whitaker Sand Shed) north of Castaic Lake Hughes Road for paving work.
Caltrans Announces Overnight Southbound I-5 Lane Closures in Castaic Area
The Superior Court of Los Angeles County will be closed Monday, July 22, as the Court works diligently to repair and reboot network systems that were severely impacted by a ransomware attack first detected the morning of Friday, July 19.
Ransomware Attack Closes L.A. County Superior Court
The Los Angeles County Health Officer has issued a heat advisory for the Santa Clarita Valley through Thursday as high temperatures have been forecast.
Heat Advisory Issued for SCV
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health has closed two beaches due to a recent sewage spill.
Sewage Spill Closes Two L.A. County Beaches