header image

[Sign Up Now] to Receive Our FREE Daily SCVTV-SCVNews Digest by E-Mail

Inside
Weather


 
Calendar
Today in
S.C.V. History
September 18
1962 - Articles of incorporation filed for Golden State Memorial Hospital on Lyons Avenue [story]
Golden State Hospital


In a unanimous decision Thursday, the California Supreme Court ruled that the William S. Hart Union High School District bears a measure of responsibility for alleged sexual molestation incidents involving a female guidance counselor and a male student at Golden Valley High School five years ago.

The case pertains to Roselyn Hubbell, a school counselor who was arrested in June 2008 in connection with the ongoing molestation of a 15-year-old boy from January to September 2007.

According to court papers filed by attorneys for the boy, Hubbell drove the victim home from school “and spent long hours with (him) on and off the high school premises. The guidance counselor performed a variety of sexual acts on (the victim) and required him to perform a number of sexual acts on her.”

Hubbell’s charges were ultimately reduced to one misdemeanor count of annoying or molesting a minor. In April 2009 she pleaded no contest to that charge and was placed on three year’s probation. A “no contest” plea cannot be used as an admission of guilt in a civil court.

Attorneys for the victim’s family filed a civil lawsuit against the school district, alleging the district knew Hubbell had a history of child molestation before it hired her and did nothing to warn people about it or prevent it from happening in the future.

The Hart District won at the trial court level and the Appeals Court upheld the decision. According to court documents, the appellate court ruled that even if the district knew about Hubbell’s history before it hired her, the district can’t be held laible if she did it again.

The question for the California Supreme Court was whether the appellate court decision was correct. It said no.

The specific issue for the high court was this:

“When a school district’s employees hire, retain or supervise a school guidance counselor they know or have reason to know has a history of child molestation, can the school district be vicariously liable for that negligent hiring, retention or supervision under Government Code section 820 if that counselor molests a student entrusted to her – or is the molested student unable to sue the school district because there is no separate statute imposing direct liability on the district for that conduct, as the Court of Appeal majority held in its published opinion in this case?”

Writing for the Supreme Court, Justice Kathryn Mickle Werdegar said, “We conclude plaintiff’s theory of vicarious liability for negligent hiring, retention and supervision is a legally viable one. Ample case authority establishes that school personnel owe students under their supervision a protective duty of ordinary care, for breach of which the school district may be held vicariously liable.”

In other words, yes, a school district can be sued for damages if it knew or should have known about an employee’s history of child molestation.

Which is well and good from a theoretical standpoint.

But the underlying question remains:

Before she was hired into the William S. Hart Union High School District, did Roselyn Hubbell have a history of child molestation that the district knew or should have known about?

The Supreme Court assumed she did.

But that “fact” has never been proved in a court of law.

When the plaintiffs initially sued the Hart District, the school district filed a demurrer, alleging the court lacked statutory authority to hear the case because the Hart District (thought it) couldn’t be held liable. The trial court agreed, and the facts of the case – Did Hubbell have a history or not? – were not argued.

Plaintiffs appealed the trial court’s decision to uphold the demurrer, meaning the appellate court only ruled on whether the Hart District could be sued. It didn’t delve into Hubbell’s history.

At the Supreme Court level, Hubbell’s history was not open to debate. The only question was whether a school district could be held liable IF it knew an employee had a history.

In a statement Thursday from the law firm handling the matter for the Hart District – whose costs were covered under the school district’s insurance policy – attorney Steve Harber of McCune & Harber said the case is in the “allegations stage. It is one thing to make allegations; it is another to establish facts.”

At this point, the idea that Hubbell had a history of child molestation is merely an allegation – as is the idea that she molested the boy at Golden Valley, from the court’s standpoint. Because Hubbell’s “no contest” plea in the criminal court can’t be used as an admission of guilt in a civil court, the “fact” that she molested the boy at Golden Valley hasn’t been established in the civil case against the Hart District.

Hubbell was a Hart District employee from August 2002 to June 2008. When she was hired, state law required school district employees to be fingerprinted for background checks. Hart District administrators were not immediately able to give details about Hubbell’s background check Thursday – and aren’t likely to do so because it’s a matter of pending litigation – but if she was cleared in the background check, she might not have had a criminal history.

“When the true facts come out, they will show that the (school) district appropriately screens its teachers and counselors,” Harber’s statement said. “The alleged perpetrator here was found out, arrested and prosecuted because of the district’s vigilance.”

The public is likely to find out whether Hubbell had a prior history of child molestation – and whether the Hart District knew or should have known about it. That’s because Thursday’s Supreme Court decision opens the door for the victim’s attorneys to bring the case back to the trial court and argue the facts for the first time.

Comment On This Story
COMMENT POLICY: We welcome comments from individuals and businesses. All comments are moderated. Comments are subject to rejection if they are vulgar, combative, or in poor taste.
REAL NAMES ONLY: All posters must use their real individual or business name. This applies equally to Twitter account holders who use a nickname.

No Comments

    Leave a Comment


    LOCAL SCHOOL LINKS
    Related Content
    LATEST SCHOOL NEWS
    Tuesday, Sep 17, 2024
    Six of the seven Foothill League Varsity football teams begin league play Friday night, Sept. 20.
    Monday, Sep 16, 2024
    The William S. Hart Union High School District has announced upcoming community information meetings about Learning Post Academy Independent Study School, Thursday, Sept. 18 and Friday, Sept. 19.
    Monday, Sep 16, 2024
    The regular meeting of the Saugus Union School District Governing Board will take place Tuesday, Sept. 17 beginning at 6:30 p.m.
    Monday, Sep 16, 2024
    West Ranch High School’s Studio A Jazz Band will be the opening act for the Huntertones, a Brooklyn-based sextet, who are coming to the Santa Clarita Valley for a one-night performance.
    Friday, Sep 13, 2024
    The William S. Hart Union High School District Governing Board unanimously approved the appointment of Valerie Van Oss as the new Director of Fiscal Services and Mark Overdevest as the new assistant principal at Valencia High School.

    Latest Additions to SCVNews.com
    The Master's University cross-country teams continued their successful 2024 campaigns with strong finishes at the BIOLA Invitational on Friday, Sept. 13 at Craig Regional Park in Fullerton, Calif.
    TMU Women Win, Men Place Second at XC Invitational
    Sheriff’s Department Announces New Law Enforcement Gang Policy
    Sheriff’s Department Announces New Law Enforcement Gang Policy
    The biology department at California State University, Northridge has stayed committed to promoting STEM research carried out by K-12 students and teachers in the Los Angeles Unified School District.
    CSUN Student Research Journal Celebrates 28 Years of Inspiring Scientific Imagination
    Did you know the SCVEDC has an interactive, online tool that provides themed virtual tours of the amazing features the community has to offer? 
    Take a Virtual Tour of the Santa Clarita Valley
    California Institute of the Arts alum and visionary filmmaker Tim Burton (Film/Video 1979) was honored with the 2,788th star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.
    CalArts Alum Tim Burton Receives Star on Hollywood Walk of Fame
    1962 - Articles of incorporation filed for Golden State Memorial Hospital on Lyons Avenue [story]
    Golden State Hospital
    The Santa Clarita Valley Senior Center welcomes back Jim Curry for an evening concert celebrating the music of John Denver on Saturday, Oct. 5 at 5 p.m. in the Grand Ballroom at Bella Vida.
    Oct. 5: SCV Senior Center Welcomes Jim Curry ‘Take Me Home’
    As part of the Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency's ongoing commitment to ensuring local groundwater quality and reliability, the SCV Water recently began construction on a new treatment facility to remove perchlorate and volatile organic compounds at Well 205 in Valencia.
    SCV Water Begins New Water Treatment Project in Valencia
    Get ready to set sail at the Pirates SENSES Block Party, presented by the city of Santa Clarita, Thursday, Sept 19 from 7-10 p.m. on main street in Old Town Newhall.
    Sept. 19: SENSES Pirate Block Party
    No. 21 College of the Canyons football team knocked off No. 5 Fullerton College 29-13 on Saturday night behind a stifling defensive effort and five field goals from Luis Rodriguez.
    No. 21 Canyons Knocks Off No. 5 Fullerton 29-13
    Six of the seven Foothill League Varsity football teams begin league play Friday night, Sept. 20.
    Foothill League Football Begins for SCV Teams
    The California Institute of the Arts will present the "NAACP Santa Clarita Masquerade Ball", Friday, Oct. 4, 7-11 p.m. at 24700 McBean Parkway, Valencia, CA 91355.
    Oct. 4: NAACP Santa Clarita Masquerade Ball at Cal Arts
    The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health is investigating two human cases of a rare parasitic infection, Baylisascaris procyonis, also known as raccoon roundworm.
    Public Health Investigating Disease Spread from Animals to Humans
    1879 - First official Newhall School building erected near Walnut & Ninth streets [story]
    First Newhall School
    The city of Santa Clarita is hosting Make A Difference Day on Saturday, Oct. 26 and is looking for enthusiastic residents to volunteer for various projects that benefit local nonprofits, as well as the city.
    Oct. 26: Volunteers Needed for Make a Difference Day
    Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital and PathPoint announced the graduation of Aiden Land and Andrew Mendence from the Project SEARCH internship program.
    Henry Mayo Newhall Hospital, PathPoint Celebrate Grad Interns
    The William S. Hart Union High School District has announced upcoming community information meetings about Learning Post Academy Independent Study School, Thursday, Sept. 18 and Friday, Sept. 19.
    Sept. 18-19: Learning Post Academy Online Information Meetings
    The Santa Clarita Community College District Board of Trustees will hold a special meeting Wednesday, Sept. 18, 5 p.m. in open session to interview and appoint a new trustee for Area 5.
    Sept. 18: COC Board to Interview, Appoint Area 5 Trustee
    The city of Santa Clarita wants to remind residents that volunteer registration is open for the 29th Annual River Rally Cleanup and Environmental Expo scheduled for next Saturday, Sept. 21, from 8 to 11 a.m. at the William S. Hart Pony Baseball and Softball Complex, 23780 Auto Center Drive, Santa Clarita, CA 91355.
    Sept. 20: Last Chance to Register for the River Rally
    The California Highway Patrol is dedicating Sept. 15-21 to promoting child passenger safety across California, focusing on the protection of the state’s youngest road users.
    CHP Emphasizes Child Safety for National Child Passenger Safety Week
    The regular meeting of the Saugus Union School District Governing Board will take place Tuesday, Sept. 17 beginning at 6:30 p.m.
    Sept. 17: SUSD Regular Board Meeting
    West Ranch High School’s Studio A Jazz Band will be the opening act for the Huntertones, a Brooklyn-based sextet, who are coming to the Santa Clarita Valley for a one-night performance.
    Sept 30: West Ranch Jazz Band to Open for Huntertones
    An exclusive Ransomeware webinar "Ransomeware, Don't Be the Next Victim!" will be hosted Wednesday, Sept. 25, 11 a.m.- noon by Shield IT Networks, in partnership with Lucas Insurance Services. It will be free for VIA members.
    Sept. 25: Free Ransomeware Webinar for VIA Members
    As part of the Third Annual Business for Artists Conference on Saturday, Oct. 19, Judith Modrak will lead the Imaginary Fossils Sculpture Making Workshop.
    Oct.19: Business for Artists Fossils Sculpture Making Workshop
    SCVNews.com